News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by woofie11 on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:09PM (#24190672)
This clearly and unambiguously crosses the line into abuse of market power. Apple's actions before? Maybe? Sort of? Apple needed that 30 percent cut to monitor for fraud and quality or something, going above-and-beyond other payment processors.

This? This has absolutely no basis in anything. It's simple retaliation designed to kneecap Epic from Apple's dominant control of a market. Apple can refuse to let Epic release games, without stopping Epic's Apple development dead in its tracks. That accomplishes all reasonable business purposes.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by TylerE on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:15PM (#24190730)
Companies shouldn't be allowed to fire customers that blatantly break rules the customer agreed to?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mantap on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:32PM (#24190944)
Usually when you fire a customer they can go to one of your competitors. This just proves Epic's argument. There is no competing App Store on iOS because it's not allowed. If Apple "fires" you then your users can no longer install the app onto their own phones.

Imagine if Microsoft "fired" Adobe and as a result nobody could install Photoshop on Windows anymore.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by giovannibajo1 on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:42PM (#24191081)
Fortnite is available on several different game consoles and platforms (most of which, by the way, have a 30% commission fee). It used to be the case that it wasn’t available on iOS, and it was a planetary success already. Customers that had a iOS device and absolutely wanted Fortnite had to resort to use another platform, eg. buy a PC or a PlayStation. Now we’re back on the situations where we were before: Fortnite won’t be available on the iOS platform (like it’s not available for others), and customers will have to play it in other platforms.

I’m not sure how this shows a monopoly. On the contrary, I think it will be hard for Epic to prove that Apple has a “monopolistic power” on Fortnite distribution when they got billionaires through it even before it was ported to iOS.

EDIT: downvotes on HN for stating an opinion?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by woofie11 on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:56PM (#24191278)
Antitrust doesn't require a monopoly.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:09PM (#24191419)
Okay, then since we've failed to argue that Apple is a monopoly, what's the next antitrust argument, and how does it apple to iPhones but not to game consoles (which have the same if not stricter restrictions to third-party software developers)?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gridlockd on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:22PM (#24191582)
Game consoles are toys, smartphones are an integral part of people's lives and livelihoods.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:36PM (#24191733)
That's a very flimsy definition of the difference. Game consoles are generally much more powerful general-purpose PCs that can do everything an iPhone can do (except connecting to cell networks). They tend to be full multimedia consumption devices and can also manage other electronics in your home (lights, security cameras, etc.). Any supposed benefit iPhone owners would gain from being able to run unsigned code would also apply to console owners.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by arcticbull on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:37PM (#24192484)
True, but your Tesla has a super-powerful general purpose computer in it that connects to cell networks, and is likely way more powerful. Nobody's going to argue a Tesla is a PC.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:40PM (#24192508)
I'm curious how someone could argue that Apple's App Store rules are anticompetitve and that they should be forced to change them, while also arguing that the same doesn't apply to Tesla's media computer(s). Is it just because there are more iPhones than Teslas?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by arcticbull on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:42PM (#24192534)
FWIW I personally don't.

However, I see the argument to be made that in selling a Mac or an iPhone, you're being sold a general-purpose computing device with explicit value added by third-party software vendors. Also, on macOS, you were sold the explicit ability to run whatever software you want. It's purpose is to run software from third-parties.

When you bought a Tesla, that wasn't how the car was represented to you. It's purpose is to drive, and yeah it's got a sweet big screen that happens to run apps, but that's ancillary.

Legally, I think that matters. From a free-software perspective, I agree, I would also like to run whatever I want on my car.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:13PM (#24192845)
> Also, on macOS, you were sold the explicit ability to run whatever software you want. It's purpose is to run software from third-parties.

I agree with that, and I think there would be a much stronger argument if Apple changed MacOS to remove this ability when it is a very well-established ability of the Mac platform. Of course, Apple almost certainly will not remove this ability, not because they want to be nice or they want to dodge antitrust allegations, but because they know that doing so would lose them customers.

But with iPhone, my argument is that this is absolutely not the expectation fostered by Apple's marketing or held by the vast majority of iPhone owners. Apple has always been very proud of its App Store and its (supposedly) strict vetting process to protect iPhone owners from malware, privacy violations, and other junk. Now, I personally think Apple should be much more restrictive about what apps it allows in the store, because there is a vast wasteland of abandoned apps and junk apps. If anything, the iPhone seems to have gotten less and less restrictive over time (the first iPhone didn't even support any third-party software, after all). I have a lot of trouble buying the argument that any significant number of iPhone owners expected to be able to run any third-party software they want to.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by arcticbull on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:30PM (#24193012)
> I have a lot of trouble buying the argument that any significant number of iPhone owners expected to be able to run any third-party software they want to.

While I agree with the overwhelming majority of your reply, I'd suggest that the significant majority of iPhone owners expect to be able to run "any third-party software they want" because they expect substantially any third-party software they would want to be available in the App Store. Removing Epic is violating that implicit understanding.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:57PM (#24193266)
I see your point, but surely it's not controversial that Epic very deliberately broke the rules in order to get its app removed from the App Store, right? Epic is probably just hoping that iPhone owners will take Epic's side and blame Apple for the removal (or even more likely, Epic only cares about the effects of the PR on the court case). I can't predict how every iPhone owner who plays Fortnite will react to this, but it seems like any slightly inquisitive person would look at the situation and think, hmm, it seems like Fortnite existed on the App Store for a long time, so what changed?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by misnome on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:11PM (#24192157)
What's preventing a console being used as a productivity platform? Isn't it just the artificial restriction on where you can get software for it from?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gridlockd on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:27PM (#24192366)
Its stated purpose. Sony once tried to get some tax advantages by classifying the PS3 as a general purpose computer, which they achieved through the "OtherOS" feature, which allowed you to run Linux.

They later removed that feature, causing a class action lawsuit, which they settled.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by hnick on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:45PM (#24194093)
Is it simple to find out what category Apple is importing iPhones under in various places? I had a quick search but not hitting anything relevant.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by YarickR2 on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:09PM (#24192135)
Games on smartphones are not integral part of people lives and livelihoods.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gridlockd on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:20PM (#24192274)
Perhaps, but the lawsuit isn't specifically about games either.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gamblor956 on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:36PM (#24192464)
You are free to make and sell games for the PlayStation and Xbox without going through Sony or MS...

However, in order to get a key that works with their DRM or console OSs, you do need a license.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ChrisLomont on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:38PM (#24194434)
>Antitrust doesn't require a monopoly.

Yes, it does.

https://www.justice.gov/atr/monopoly-power-and-market-power-...

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by woofie11 on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:59PM (#24194814)
Did you read the link you just posted? Seriously. It clearly states what I said, and contradicts what you said. As per YOUR LINK, you don't need a monopoly for antitrust; just "the ability to raise prices above those that would be charged in a competitive market."

Apple unambiguously has this with their app store.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by nodamage on Monday August 17, 2020 @11:22PM (#24194930)
Not all antitrust violations require monopoly power, that is true. For example, price fixing is illegal even if the companies involved do not have monopoly power.

However, several of the claims Epic made in their lawsuit do require proving that Apple has monopoly power, which is going to be a difficult argument with their current 46% market share.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by woofie11 on Monday August 17, 2020 @11:50PM (#24195068)
Which ones? I only skimmed the case, but it looked like market power would suffice.

In either case, the standard legal approach is to throw the kitchen sink of claims, to see which ones stick. Most claims get rejected by the courts, but if you have a few that work, it's enough.

It also helps settle. If I have a dozen $10 million dollar claims, with a 5% chance of success each, a rational opponent will throw me $6 million to go away. If the parties settle, the kitchen sink approach is not a bad one to get a better settlement.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by nodamage on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @12:07AM (#24195152)
The claims of "unlawful monopoly maintenance" in particular. But you're right, I think their best chance of success is the tying claim between "iOS App Distribution" and "iOS In-App Payment Processing" which only requires market power.

I don't think Epic cares to settle here though, they have more than enough money to keep this suit going for the next decade.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ChrisLomont on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @08:05AM (#24197643)
>As per YOUR LINK, you don't need a monopoly for antitrust; just "the ability to raise prices above those that would be charged in a competitive market."

Instead of picking one sentence out of context, why not quote the entire thing? Does it still support your claim?

Here is your sentence in context for those who care about truth:

"the Supreme Court, in other cases, seems to have articulated standards for 'monopoly power' and 'market power' that, at least linguistically, are incompatible. In NCAA v. Board of Regents, [FN33] the Court defined 'market power' as 'the ability to raise prices above those that would be charged in a competitive market.' [FN34] By contrast, the Supreme Court has consistently defined 'monopoly power,' at least for section two cases, in accordance with the definition articulated in United States v. E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. [FN35]-i.e., as 'the power to control prices or exclude competition.' [FN36] Strictly construed, the Court's language appears to require a higher burden of proof to establish 'market power' than to demonstrate 'monopoly power,' because proof of a defendant's ability to exclude competition would not suffice to demonstrate the existence of 'market power.' Moreover, even the price portion of the du Pont monopoly power definition is broader than the NCAA market power standard because the latter ignores the ability to prevent price decreases."

Did you ignore what is current case practice? Did you ignore that the article cited more cases supporting my position than yours? Your out of context quoting is intellectually dishonest.

Some more quotes you ignored - go ahead and post them in context if you like.

"Most antitrust rules require the plaintiff to show that the defendant has or is likely to obtain 'market power' or 'monopoly power.' The offense of monopolization requires, of course, proof that the defendant has monopoly power."

"According to the Supreme Court's latest formulation, a tying arrangement is not illegal unless the seller has 'market power' in the tying product."

> Seriously. It clearly states what I said,

Yes, indeed. It's so clearly stated you removed the context that clearly states the opposite of what you said.

I guess I should have found a clearer explanation, since you quote things out of context.

Here's an easier read [1], and here's some legal standards applied from there with case citations:

Under cartels and collusion: "if the enterprise (as an economic entity) has not acquired a monopoly position, or has significant market power, then no harm is done."

Two questions:

1) Why did you remove the context of your quote?

2) Can you cite a successful anti-trust case where monopoly power was not shown in the proceedings?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ForHackernews on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:57PM (#24191281)
Holy s* this is a surreal comment to read on Hacker News. Once upon a time we believed in general-purpose computing devices that allowed users -- their owners! -- to run whatever software they pleased.

Now you speak of "platforms" that charge a tax in return for preventing users from installing software -- on their own devices they actually literally own, mind.

Can you imagine if your car would only operate on roads approved by Ford?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by krrrh on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:03PM (#24191354)
I believe in general purpose computers, I see them every day and I know they exist.

I also believe in choice and experimentation when it comes to business models. If I want to buy some systems with trade offs and benefits that don’t always include being able to root and run Linux on them, who are you to prevent me?

Believing that all systems must be maximally flexible is a scarcity mindset that felt more reasonable when families had to save to be able to afford a desktop computer that would be in use for several years.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ForHackernews on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:23AM (#24196390)
> Believing that all systems must be maximally flexible is a scarcity mindset that felt more reasonable when families had to save to be able to afford a desktop computer that would be in use for several years.

This is a good insight and it's entirely possible that general purpose computing was a historical aberration.

You say you want to be able to choose between a real computer and a restricted appliance, but how long will the market allow you to make that choice?

Selling locked-down terminals with access to a pay-to-play "platform" is obviously very profitable. How much longer will MacOS and Windows allow you to install unverified software?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by giovannibajo1 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @05:30AM (#24196763)
I don't think there is a cogent risk that general computing open platforms will go away soon.

PCs can be self-assembled without buying them as an appliance from a specific vendor, and you can at the very least install Linux on them. If you care about Windows, Microsoft is adopting open source more and more, you can have install Ubuntu within Windows right now, I doubt they will change course on software installation.

I do have a Linux box in my home and successfully use it for many tasks. This doesn't mean that I feel that all devices that have a CPU in my home must absolutely run unsigned binaries compiled by me.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ForHackernews on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @05:56AM (#24196910)
But why shouldn't they? Why would anyone on a site called "Hacker News" be advocating for deliberately gimped devices?

I'm not saying manufacturers need to expend money and effort to support tinkers and hobbyists, but why deliberately go out of their way to block them?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ForHackernews on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @02:05PM (#24202017)
> PCs can be self-assembled without buying them as an appliance from a specific vendor

For now.

Every year, integrated SoCs become cheaper and more powerful. Self-building a PC is more and more niche.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by misnome on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:12PM (#24192167)
Or tunnels that only your tesla car can drive through?

I mean, per-car roads probably aren't a good business model, but if it's a privately owned road you can probably make up your own rules, and there would be nothing to stop you doing that, right? And nothing to stop car owners using different roads.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by buzzerbetrayed on Monday August 17, 2020 @11:13PM (#24194879)
So let's hear your argument on why Nintendo should allow you to run any software on their switch.

And even if you do think that, let's see some evidence of you arguing that case as passionately as you argue this one.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ForHackernews on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @02:03PM (#24201995)
> your argument on why Nintendo should allow you to run any software on their switch.

Begging the question. Why should the manufacturer have any say at all over what software I run on hardware I own?

To paraphrase your question: Let's hear your argument why General Electric should allow me to heat any food in their microwave?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Andrew_nenakhov on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @01:31PM (#24201559)
If a user wants Epic apps on his iPhone, and Epic wants said user to have those apps, Apple should not be asked for permission. That should not have control over the device after sale. It is no longer theirs.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by donarb on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:57PM (#24191287)
Microsoft can fire game developers from Xbox.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Maascamp on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:06PM (#24191386)
But doing so wouldn't make that developer's software unusable on Windows.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:08PM (#24191408)
Being banned from the iOS App Store also doesn't make your software unusable on Windows, or Mac, or any other non-iOS platform. The App Store's exclusivity is precisely the same as that of nearly every video game console.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by brmgb on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:25PM (#24191609)
> The App Store's exclusivity is precisely the same as that of nearly every video game console.

I don't understand why you keep bringing up video game consoles in this discussion.

1. You seem to believe people actually agree with the way console stores work. This is not the case.

2. The fact that the situation is also terrible somewhere else doesn't absolve Apple of anything. That's not how justice works.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:41PM (#24191784)
If you are consistent in your claims and believe that all computing devices, including smartphones, game consoles, e-book readers, GPS watches, car entertainment centers, etc. should be required to provide a way for owners to run unsigned code, then my accusations of inconsistency do not apply to you.

In fact, I see much much less vitriol aimed towards game console store policy than iOS App Store policy. That's why I mention it.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gtyras2mrs on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:50PM (#24193197)
They cannot fight all battles at once. They probably think they have a better chance of winning this battle and setting the precedent for the next battles for other "app store" issues.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m4rtink on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:45PM (#24193630)
And all these devices certainly should be able to run the code their owner wants them to run, full stop.

That this is often not possible is stupid but also incredibly dangerous. Not by the standards of the evil Apple just did, but what even more malicious actors can do to you is they can run code on your device & you can't do anything about it.

It could be state actors pressuring the company making the think & or exploiting vulnerabilities in the closed source firmware running on it.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ericflo on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:22PM (#24192298)
They're clearly picking their battles. If they are able to win this case against Apple, they can use it as precedent to (hopefully) pressure consoles to open up too.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by brmgb on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:20PM (#24192276)
You are intentionally muddying the water by bringing code signing (a technicality) and devices for which software distribution was never part of the economics. Nevertheless, yes, I think making ebook readers tied to a single store illegal would be a net positive from consumers. It would let stores compete on their merits as stores and readers as readers. More competition is always good.

Pointedly, my argument is simple: the modern concept of plateform, as has been pushed by management consulting firms for the past two decades and successfully been exploited by hightech companies, is a blatant attack against anti competition laws and I believe the whole thing only started because the US government decided it would only meekly enforce them. Rebranding barriers to entry moats shouldn't make artificially building them more acceptable.

As you rightfully pointed, plateforms seem to be popping everywhere nowadays from game consoles to cars. I don't find that surprising: reducing competition is like crack cocaine to companies. It both means less need to innovate and differentiate and a larger share of customers surplus (theorically all customer surplus but it might be too blatant then). Customers are the ones losing there.

As the whole thing strongly goes against one of the core tenant of modern capitalism, it seems obvious to me it is going to end with more regulations as soon as the political zeitgeist regarding economy will lean less towards extrem laissez-faire. Unless of course, we decide to go full-bore towards nineteenth century style capitalism...

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by matwood on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:15PM (#24193425)
TBH, the console makers are probably thinking 'shit, Apple is going to end up ruining it for all of us.'

Not that it matters, but the Amazon app store has the worst policies IME.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Hamuko on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:53PM (#24191935)
The fact that Apple is going to kill Epic Games' ability to notarize macOS apps does actually make their software unusable on Macs.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by peapicker on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:18PM (#24192902)
Nope. I personally run with this setting:

https://it.nmu.edu/docs/allowing-third-party-applications-in...

Amazingly it then lets me run all the open source I want that I download from the internet but am too lazy to build myself.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ntSean on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:28PM (#24193978)
This setting has been removed from recent macOS versions.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by waterhouse on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:26PM (#24194371)
Yup. In the Mac OS security settings window, for "Allow apps downloaded from:", you can only choose "App Store" or "App Store and identified developers". The workflow is now:

1. Try to open the application. Get a window that says "APPLICATION can’t be opened because it is from an unidentified developer.", and below that, in a smaller and non-bold font, "Your security preferences allow installation of only apps from the App Store and identified developers." The window only has an "OK" button. (There is also a small "?" button in the lower left, which is present in lots of notification windows and presumably points to a generic help page.)

2. Open Security & Privacy in System Preferences. There is now, magically, a line in it saying "APPLICATION was blocked from opening because it is not from an identified developer", and an "Open Anyway" button.

I only discovered that workaround by accident. Before that, I believed that Mac OS had completely removed the option to run such applications. (As I recall, back when "Allow apps downloaded from: Anywhere" existed, if you did choose it, it would show some kind of warning and also revert itself after 30 days; it seemed obvious they wanted to remove the option entirely.)

I'm tempted to bring out the word "gaslighting" to describe this. Because that line about "Your security preferences allow ..." is in a context where it should be an explanation of why "APPLICATION can't be opened because it is from an unidentified developer", yet your security preferences about apps have only two choices and neither one would permit opening the application; and because a System Preferences pane now shows different options depending on what unrelated user applications you've opened recently, which is insane.

... Turns out there is a second, faster workaround. Right-click (or control-click) on the application, and click "Open". Then, instead of getting the liar window with only the "OK" button, you get a window that has an "Open Anyway" button. This workaround is, in fact, documented in the generic help page that the liar window's "?" button points to. This is also insane because it makes "Open" in its different forms (double-click, command-O, command-line "open", and the right-click "Open" option) no longer a single, uniform operation.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by count on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:18PM (#24192903)
No, it doesn't. It just means it's users have to take extra steps. I use non-notarized software every day on a Mac.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by waterhouse on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:01PM (#24193302)
For the sake of argument, is there a limit to the number or kind of extra steps before you'd call it unusable? If "downloading VirtualBox and running a VM of an earlier MacOS version" became necessary at some point, would that be over the line?

I suspect there are corporate users who have policies that forbid running non-notarized software. That probably shouldn't apply to a game like Fortnite—most companies wouldn't consider it important, or perhaps even a positive, for their employees to be able to run Fortnite on their company laptops—but it would apply to other apps.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:13PM (#24193845)
> For the sake of argument, is there a limit to the number or kind of extra steps before you'd call it unusable?

Surely this comes down to what reasonable expectations are held by the customer. There are microcontrollers you can buy that require a soldering iron and USB breakout board in order to run your own software on them. I think that's pretty reasonable, but it would be a ridiculous requirement for a desktop PC purchased at Best Buy.

The question becomes: what are the reasonable expectations for installing third-party software on an iPhone. Personally, I think the overwhelming majority of iPhone owners expect and even highly value the fact that Apple (supposedly [0]) vets all third-party software on the iPhone, and it's generally more difficult to accidentally install malware or break your device than it is on other computing platforms.

[0] As I've said before, I think Apple actually needs to be more restrictive, because a lot of useless/broken/scammy stuff makes it into the App Store.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by waterhouse on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:46PM (#24194475)
Well, this subthread is about running non-notarized software on Macs. And my expectations on that, which I will proclaim to be reasonable, come from using Macs since before Apple notarization existed: i.e. I could run whatever I damn well wanted.

Apple changed behavior on that at least twice. (I skipped several Mac OS versions, so I may have missed intermediate changes.) First, it switched to requiring you to choose, in security preferences, an option to allow apps from anywhere—which, I think, would show a scary warning, and would also revert itself to the default after 30 days. Later, it switched to removing that "Anywhere" option, and instead shows a misleading "you can't open this because of your preferences" error, and provides a couple of insane hidden workarounds. I consider the first change reasonable, if unnecessarily annoying; I consider the second change unreasonable.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mantap on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:14PM (#24193411)
It's technically possible yes, but Epic's position is much much worse than that. They won't be able to legally build any app because the SDK is proprietary and only available to registered developers.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by count on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @02:43PM (#24202526)
The SDK for iOS, sure. The comment was about Mac apps though.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Avamander on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:15PM (#24193426)
"Oh you can install the software, you just have to do a handstand and say 'I love Apple' in front of your computer, no biggie"
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by oblio on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:26PM (#24191631)
We actually have Nintendo to blame for this whole thing. They started the walled garden situation, and people seem oblivious to it and love them as a company.

https://www.filfre.net/2016/04/generation-nintendo/ ->

> In a landmark ruling against Tengen in March of 1991, Judge Fern Smith stated that Nintendo had the right to “exclude others” from the NES if they so chose, thus providing the legal soil on which many more walled gardens would be tilled in the years to come.

All walled gardens suck.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by jonny_eh on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:19PM (#24193453)
> people seem oblivious to it and love them as a company

In the same way people love Apple.

[dead]
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by dang on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:26PM (#24194663)
Would you please stop posting flamebait and/or unsubstantive comments? You've done it a ton in this thread and it's not what HN is for.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting here, we'd be grateful.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mantap on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:35PM (#24191717)
Epic's developer account will be suspended, meaning they can no longer use Xcode (!) or sign/notarize apps to run on the Mac.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by tapoxi on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:58PM (#24192001)
Xbox isn't central to modern life like a smartphone is. Also, the game consoles use a razor/blades model, they're sold at a loss and make money through the sale of games. Smartphones are not sold at a loss.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by PeterisP on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:31PM (#24194002)
There are many factors that are relevant to the question whether Apple has a dominant market position and these actions would/should be limited by antitrust laws, or if their competitive actions are within the bounds of fair play. These two factors are not.

The rights and legal limitations of Apple (regarding App Store) and Microsoft (regarding Xbox) are exactly the same no matter if iPhone or Xbox is considered "central to modern life" or not; and whether the hardware was sold at a loss. These aspects are simply not relevant for the antitrust case, they should not and would not change the decision.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by montagg on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:06PM (#24194237)
You might be correct, from an ethical perspective, but this isn’t the way US antitrust law works today.

If different rules should be applied to companies that are essential to modern life, such as classifying them as essential services, that should be a new law that’s explicit about the qualifications, gets debated, and has to reconcile the tradeoffs inherent in that classification. It should definitely not be something defined by a court of law (and it’s unlikely to be in this case).

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m4rtink on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:48PM (#24193656)
IIRC most modern consoles are no longer sold at a loss, though the margins are not very high.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by kingnothing on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:08PM (#24192126)
Fortnite isn't central to modern life.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gruez on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:44PM (#24192548)
A cheap source of entertainment for kids that are locked down because of a pandemic isn't central to modern life?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by nouveaux on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:56PM (#24194158)
It's a bit of a stretch. There are plenty of alternatives.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by WindyLakeReturn on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:37PM (#24193071)
The outcome of this case may change that possibility.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:06PM (#24191395)
Arguments of this form always rely on nebulous definitions of what counts as a "choice." Sure, if you're banned from a specific app store, you cannot use that specific app store, because that's just what is means to be banned. You can, of course, still access any other app store.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mantap on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:48PM (#24191864)
Imagine if Google decided tomorrow to ban App Stores other than Google Play Store on Android.

This would mean that there's only two app stores: Apple's and Google's.

Google doesn't do that because that would be an abuse of their market position and they would get rinsed in the courts. Since the same laws apply to Google as Apple, and Apple clearly has significant market power in smartphone and tablet computers, it stands to reason that Apple should be prohibited from doing the same thing.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:58PM (#24192006)
> Google doesn't do that because that would be an abuse of their market position and they would get rinsed in the courts.

Are you sure that Google doesn't do that because the Android platform is an extremely viable and lucrative alternative to iPhones, and that people who value the ability to sideload software on their smartphones flock to Android for precisely this reason?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mantap on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:57PM (#24193712)
Whether they want to or not is beside the point, which is to consider whether it would be anticompetitive for Google to ban other app stores from Android.

As far as I can see, what distinguishes Apple from Google is status quo. Apple never did allow app distribution other than through the Apple App Store. i.e. "We've always been doing it"

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:18PM (#24193884)
> which is to consider whether it would be anticompetitive for Google to ban other app stores from Android

That's what I'm getting at. Is it anticompetitive to deliberately make your product worse by removing a key differentiator between your product and its closest competitor?

Or come at it from another angle: would it be "anticompetitive" for Apple to (in new iPhones) completely remove the App Store and thus all reasonable expectation to be able to run third-party software? Is it anticompetitive to sell a handheld computer than can do email, play music and videos, etc., but not run third-party software?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by heavyset_go on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:34PM (#24193046)
Google is abusing their market position as well, because they purposely hinder third party app stores by putting restrictions in Android that prevent them from implementing features that the Play Store has had for years.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m4rtink on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:50PM (#24193665)
A simple litmus test:

Is F-Droid in Google Play ?

It is not.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by boring_twenties on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @11:28PM (#24206864)
Not only is it not in Google Play, but it can't update apps in the background the way Google can.

For every update, times every app you have to click through a stupid screen "Are you sure you want to install this update? It requires no special permissions."

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m4rtink on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:37PM (#24229833)
Ironically this onewould be super helful for the recent Firefox update disaster where they switched from the bit outdated Fennec to the new and faster but totally unfinishec Fenix.

With auto updates this was quite a wakeup call...

Another nice thing is F-Droid listing multiple versions, another thing sorely lacking in Google Play.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by danudey on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:22PM (#24191577)
If Epic thinks that Apple's and Google's store conditions are onerous, just wait until they find out what it's like to ship a game on PS4 or XBox.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Hamuko on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:34PM (#24191709)
If only Epic had ever published a game on PS4 or the Xbox…

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_games_by_Epic_Games

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by nightski on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:27PM (#24191644)
Actually shipping on Xbox one is quite simple and mostly free with the ID@Xbox program or the Creators program.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by theshrike79 on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:02PM (#24192058)
And if you slip stuff that’s against the rules on Xbox and sue Microsoft, they’ll just let you keep your accounts open and keep selling your applications?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gamblor956 on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:31PM (#24192417)
Depends on what rules you break, but yes generally they will.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by danudey on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:30PM (#24203978)
The ID@Xbox program is for indie developers, not multibillion-dollar corporations.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mcintyre1994 on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:24PM (#24192334)
This whole thing is about Fortnite which is already on both of those platforms.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by montagg on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:09PM (#24194266)
That’s pretty core to any anti-trust argument that is built on monopoly: is the iOS market distinct from the smartphone and tablet markets?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Shivetya on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:00PM (#24191316)
They are trying here to separate iOS from Apple devices which is being deceitful. There is nothing Apple is doing that prevents them from running on an Android phone.

That is the key here, Epic and some others are trying to change how Apple has implemented their device. iOS and the hardware are part and parcel. You don't get to choose which OS you run as it was never designed to support such action.

iOS was never an open OS, you cannot legally install it on other devices either.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by chrisacky on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:24PM (#24190822)
Of course they should. But, market dominance means agreement to such terms are not 'fair'.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by TylerE on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:25PM (#24190837)
Yes, total market dominance with 10% market share.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by dstaley on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:38PM (#24191022)
Epic very specifically defined the "market" as iOS devices. Their argument is based on the assertion that Android is not an alternative to the App Store since it's a completely different operating system. So, Apple actually has 100% market share of the iOS market.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by goodlifeodyssey on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:39PM (#24194437)
> Epic very specifically defined the "market" as iOS devices.

That is true, but I think it is debatable whether that is a reasonable way to define "market".

It would be as if a vendor wanted to sell their goods in a grocery store. The grocery store says no for some reason. The vendor disagrees and sues them, saying they have a monopoly on all grocery store sales on that particular corner.

"Wait, but there is a grocery store across the street?"

Well, in their law suite they defined market to be just that corner---they excluded the other corner where the Android grocery store is selling things.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by dstaley on Monday August 17, 2020 @11:06PM (#24194845)
That is not an apt analogy because the switching costs for grocery stores is no where near as high with iOS. If you want the full argument I highly recommend reading the full legal filing.[1]

[1] https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/apple-complaint-734589783.pdf

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by bryanlarsen on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:29PM (#24190905)
60% market share by revenue in 2019.

https://www.businessofapps.com/data/app-revenues/

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:10PM (#24191437)
Isn't that just because Apple's customers are more willing to spend money on apps than other customers?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ayoisaiah on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:40PM (#24191779)
Willing is not the right word. They generally have a greater means to do so.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:43PM (#24191818)
Of course. My point is that this doesn't seem to be related to any anticompetitive behavior on Apple's part. If Apple was using market power to force smartphone competitors out of the market to increase Apple's own market share, that would be one thing. But to accuse Apple of anticompetitive behavior because their small smartphone market share spends more money on apps than other smartphone owners does not seem reasonable.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by bryanlarsen on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:16PM (#24192224)
Epic is not suing Apple because Apple used nefarious means to achieve dominance. You, I and Epic would probably all agree they earned that dominance fair and square.

But once you have dominance different rules apply.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:39PM (#24192499)
That's fair enough. I'm actually pretty sympathetic to the subjective argument "Apple is really big and profitable now, and I don't like their App Store rules, so let's try to get them to change it." I find it less ridiculous than arguments that attempt to construct some supposedly objective principle like "iPhone are general-purpose devices and therefore they must allow running unsigned code."

Ideally, I'd prefer that this kind of back-and-forth between developers and Apple would happen strictly through negotiation, rather than invoking the court system, but I realize that not all markets are functioning well enough for this to be practical.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by PeterisP on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:34PM (#24194025)
Antitrust laws start applying long before total market dominance, and one of their goals is to proactively ensure that total market dominance is never reached.

It certainly can be argued that they have a dominant position in a particular narrow market, and the court will look at these arguments and determine whether they do or not.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m-p-3 on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:21PM (#24191569)
You don't need a monopoly to be struck with an antitrust lawsuit.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by jpalomaki on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:37PM (#24191011)
One could argue that they still have monopoly for the iOS part of the market. A bit like retail store having monopoly on certain geographic area.

Not sure what's the business model behind Apple Arcade, but it looks Apple is in a way also competing on the gaming market. From this point of view their 30% cut from competitors' sales looks a bit worse.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by uncoder0 on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:27PM (#24190868)
In the US?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m-p-3 on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:19PM (#24191549)
A company that have a dominant position in a large ecosystem and can make or break an entire business model?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by throwaw4y-plate on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:24PM (#24190824)
If the rules are possibly illegal, yes, a question which will soon be litigated.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by kentonv on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:41PM (#24192519)
When the rules themselves are illegal? No, no they should not.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by pjc50 on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:52PM (#24191221)
The thing is, this starts the taxi meter running; every dollar that Epic would have expected to make will get added to their demand for damages.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by sushid on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:20PM (#24192275)
Source? They specifically state that they're not suing for damages and I doubt they have changed their case in the last few days...

> Apple’s conduct has caused and continues to cause Epic financial harm, but as noted above, Epic is not bringing this case to recover these damages; Epic is not seeking any monetary damages.

https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/apple-complaint-734589783.pdf

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by pjc50 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @05:20AM (#24196697)
That's in the middle of the document, but at the end:

> C.Awarding any other equitable relief necessary to prevent and remedy Apple’s anti-competitive conduct;and

> D.Granting such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper

It's also totally normal for a course of action that was deemed unlawful and resulted in losses for one party to be compensated. Anyway, we have a decade or so to find out; these cases are not quick.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @05:35AM (#24196790)
Only D is arguably on point, and probably wouldn't reverse a statement in the same filing that they are specifically not seeking a specified class of damages, instead it basically keeps open anything not specifically excluded tomwhich they might be entitled; equitable relief as mentioned in C is a legal term of art that does not overlap with money damages, so that certainly cannot be read as a claim for money damages.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by elicash on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:25PM (#24190844)
I personally thought they were already in abuse of market power.

But on this latest development, I want to hear Apple's argument first. That said, I didn't find their argument on the first action compelling so not optimistic. But maybe they discovered some abuse, for one random, made-up example -- my point isn't to trust Apple but just to see what the reasoning is first. This tweet doesn't say if they were given any reasoning for the latest action.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mrgordon on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:27PM (#24190870)
Yeah to be honest while I think Apple clearly has monopoly power here that should be reined in, I also get the feeling that Epic will have a pretty weak argument for why they purposely violated the Terms of Service and then expect to continue using the SDK tools.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by hrktb on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:39PM (#24191037)
If you argue a company doesn’t allow behavior X, doing it and getting punished is the best course of action to prove the point.

To your point, they have a whole lawsuit filling explaining why they think X should be allowed.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mrgordon on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:16PM (#24193433)
According to the law, the best course of action is not to break the law to prove you don't like the law. While the Terms of Service are not the law, you agree to follow them when signing up and the terms didn't change after Epic signed up.

Practically, you may be correct that this is the most expedient way to try to fix the problem but you can get burned as Epic has in the short term with a sharp drop in revenue as Apple & Google have both booted them and may refuse to work with them in the future.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by hrktb on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @02:45AM (#24195893)
I'd draw a parralel with civil desobediance.

I'm aware this case is between two behemoth, the point to them is not civil rights but future revenue and there's a lot to say about each side's behavior, but on the principle it's the same I think.

The important point here I think is they are bearing the consequences of their act (not that they have a choice either), so it's not like it's unfair to Apple or Google. On a scale of "breaking the rules", it's closer to sitting on a forbidden bus bench than looting stores.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mcintyre1994 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @02:31AM (#24195851)
I’m unconvinced that there should be repercussions beyond the App Store tbh. While Apple get to set the App Store rules fine you get taken off there, but then what’s the actual criteria for this all out permanent ban? Just not reinstating your app in a compliant form? What if you decide the deal sucks and don’t want to go back on their store? Then you just get permanently banned forever? Presumably it doesn’t work like this if you try to upload an app that breaks the rules and they catch it at app review - sorry, you broke rule xyz and if you don’t have a compliant app up within 30 days we’re permanently banning you from developing for any of our platforms. I don’t get why breaking App Store rules matters beyond the App Store at all.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mrgordon on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @07:52PM (#24205702)
Its a matter of intent. If I've caught you trying to subvert the rules, then I have no reason to think you won't abuse them again. It is reasonable someone wouldn't want a frequent abuser to be able to submit new apps via their SDK. In the extreme case, I could submit a new app every minute just to waste their reviewers' time.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Keyframe on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:19PM (#24191538)
Apple’s argument was what was in their TOS and acting on it. I don’t know what they would say apart from that? Open question now is whether their TOS violates any law, since law > TOS.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Razengan on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:28PM (#24190894)
> Apple needed that 30 percent cut to monitor for fraud and quality or something, going above-and-beyond other payment processors.

How much do Microsoft, Sony, Nintendo, Steam, Gog and etc. take from publishers on their stores?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by coldpie on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:40PM (#24191052)
It's all private, of course, but they're all generally in the 30% ballpark. There may be lower rates for big clients, but there's no way for us to know that. https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/08/as-epic-attacks-apple...
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by danudey on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:24PM (#24191605)
In other words, Apple and Google are bad for taking a 30% cut, but Sony and Microsoft are not bad for taking a 30% cut plus having a (reportedly) vastly more onerous set of policies than Apple has.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by glangdale on Monday August 17, 2020 @11:47PM (#24195048)
When console makers start making the same profit margin on their devices as Apple does, as opposed to selling them at or even below cost, this argument will begin to make sense.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by manquer on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:14AM (#24196333)
It is not fixed , depending on how large you are MS or Sony will pay you to launch on their store . There is volume discounts , AAA does not pay indie rates
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by josephcsible on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:51PM (#24191202)
That's a misleading question, because on other platforms you can choose to avoid the store. A better question would be "what's the lowest cut you need to give up to distribute to users of these other platforms?". And the answer to that is zero on basically all of them except iOS.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by urda on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:34PM (#24193554)
Since when? You cannot side load apps onto modern consoles, to the extent of manufactures like even Nintendo releasing updated hardware revisions to block homebrew exploits.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:13PM (#24191472)
> That's a misleading question, because on other platforms you can choose to avoid the store.

That's definitely not true. You cannot run unsigned code on most video game consoles.

And for PC game marketplaces, those platforms still have market power. Surely there's a big difference between being banned from Steam and being banned from the Discord Store.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by grishka on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:39PM (#24191763)
Video game consoles are specialized hardware. They do one thing and they do it well. It's kind of understandable that these companies want to review anything released for those. They want to ensure that games are of high quality so as to not hurt the reputation of the platform itself. They want games to help sell consoles. And that's how video game consoles always worked.

iPhones, on the other hand, are not specialized. They're general-purpose devices at this point — both by design and by how Apple markets them. The problem is, both developers and users see the app store and its policies as a nuisance.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Razengan on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:19PM (#24192271)
> Video game consoles are specialized hardware.

No.

> They do one thing and they do it well.

Look up console jailbreaks and home-brew.

> The problem is, both developers and users see the app store and its policies as a nuisance.

Apple does a lot to protect users from unscrupulous practices. Look up the App Store policies and see for yourself.

See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24154647 and similar comments:

> the magnitude of this is not immediately apparent unless you’ve worked in an agency / freelanced building iOS applications. You have no idea how many user-hostile and abusive things I’ve seen blown completely out of the water with the golden phrase "Apple won’t allow that". It wins arguments in favour of the user instantly and permanently.

> I’ve run up against Apple’s capricious review process more times than I can count, so I’ve got more reason than most to complain about it. But it’s impossible for me to argue that these rules don’t help the user when I’ve personally seen it happen so many times. It’s a double-edged sword to be sure, and I believe the best way of balancing things in favour of the end-user is to be more open than Apple is, but there are undeniable benefits to the user with the current system.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by grishka on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:34PM (#24192448)
> No.

You and I know that they're locked-down computers with hardware DRM and a bit of custom silicon, but most users don't see them like that. To them, it's a device that is only capable of running games.

> You have no idea how many user-hostile and abusive things I’ve seen blown completely out of the water with the golden phrase "Apple won’t allow that".

I'm an Android developer myself but I've seen iOS apps released, and I'm friends with many iOS developers. You're going through this bureaucracy lottery every time you release an update. You can never be sure of its outcome, and you can never know how long it would take. Even most governments are more predictable.

Sure there exist rules that are genuinely in the interest of the user. But then there are rules that are in the interest of Apple as a business (the 30% cut for digital goods). There also are rules that are following US laws, and they're stringently enforced regardless of your target market because Apple happens to be a US company.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:56PM (#24192667)
> To them, it's a device that is only capable of running games.

And Spotify, YouTube, Netflix, live TV, Plex, home automation, web browsing, Skype, etc. In other words, nearly everything an iPhone can do and probably very near 100% overlap with how iPhones are actually used.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:57PM (#24191985)
> They want to ensure that games are of high quality so as to not hurt the reputation of the platform itself. They want games to help sell consoles. And that's how video game consoles always worked.

And my argument is that an overall better (according to each individual buyer's preference) software experience is a major (perhaps the single largest) differentiator of iPhones over competing smartphones. This has always been a major part of Apple's marketing and indeed is the primary reason I use an iPhone. Yes, on the iPhone it's "games and other apps" instead of just games, but I don't see that being a major difference (particularly since game consoles can serve other purposes too, like media consumption and home automation).

My argument is that iPhones are and have always been essentially "the game console of smartphones" or "the appliance of smartphones." In fact, that type of description is often used both pejoratively by iPhone haters and lovingly by iPhone fans. They're simply not made for or marketed to people who want a general-purpose Unix PC with a cell phone antenna built in, even though technically they are essentially that (note, of course, that iPhones and game consoles are technically general purpose computers, but that's not really relevant).

> They're general-purpose devices at this point — both by design and by how Apple markets them. The problem is, both developers and users see the app store and its policies as a nuisance.

I strongly disagree with your impression here. My impression has been that complaints about App Store rules have overwhelmingly come from a small number of extremely large developers (unsurprisingly, developers that are big enough that they want to make a play to shift some of Apple's market power toward themselves). I don't see iPhone owners complaining about App Store rules, and I suspect one reason is that anyone who values being able to sideload any software on their smartphone has many very nice Android options.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by grishka on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:16PM (#24192216)
> I don't see iPhone owners complaining about App Store rules

Well, as someone outside of US and its culture, I see every now and then how people dislike Apple enforcing its morals on apps. Example: even if your app is rated 18+ and contains UGC, you still can't have any porn in it. Even if it's censored by default but there's a setting to show it. They demand that you completely obliterate any content that is even slightly erotical, let alone overtly pornographic, or have your app banished from the app store.

And don't even get me started on "illegal file sharing".

I've seen this from both sides. As a user, you blame Apple for seeing a placeholder when trying to view a VK group that contains suggestive imagery in one of its photo albums. As a developer, you roll your eyes when your bug fix update gets rejected an umpteenth time with the reason being "we turned safe search off, typed 'porn' into the search box and naked people came up". It just feels like a dictatorship state, and a very prude one.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by misnome on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:22PM (#24192308)
By this definition, surely as long as Apple didn't market it free from the App Store, it doesn't qualify as a general purpose device?

If I could install a web browser and libreoffice on an xbox, would that meet your definition of a general purpose device? And isn't that an artificial, monopolising restriction that I can't?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by nodamage on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:20PM (#24194340)
Even if that were true (which is highly debatable given than an Xbox is basically a rebranded PC), there is no provision in US antitrust law that treats "general purpose devices" as different than "specialized hardware".
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by dwild on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:24PM (#24191600)
> That's definitely not true. You cannot run unsigned code on most video game consoles.

And I'm pretty sure many people would be quite against this practice and believe this is an harmful monopolistic practice. The thing is though, no one had the balls and/or the cash to defends this like Epic does right now against Apple.

Let's hope this will bring a more open future on video game consoles too.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:33PM (#24191704)
Most people I've seen commenting on this Epic vs. Apple debate seem to think that it's okay on game consoles but not okay on iPhones, which is just preposterous. At least you're consistent. But what about e-readers, GPS devices, car entertainment systems, etc.? Should all Turing-complete computing devices be forced to provide a way for the owner to run unsigned code?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by PeterisP on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:37PM (#24194046)
IMHO that would be a really good thing. We are not there yet, but that seems like a laudable goal to me.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ayoisaiah on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:47PM (#24191850)
The difference is that those other devices have a specific use. Smartphones are general purpose devices, so it's not the same at all
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by baddox on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:59PM (#24192023)
That's a bizarre argument. It seems to imply that Apple could avoid these allegations by either increasing or decreasing the restrictions they place on third-party developers.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by misnome on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:15PM (#24192200)
Isn't that specific use mostly artificial by restricting your ability to install things though?

If it's a CPU in a box, then it's purely a matter of what software you are allowed to install on it, right?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ayoisaiah on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:14PM (#24192196)
How does it imply that? Which of those devices you mentioned (e-readers, GPS devices, car entertainment systems) have a store for downloading apps? If they do, then yes I would like to be able to put whatever I want on there without the approval of some corporation.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Razengan on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:17PM (#24192238)
> because on other platforms you can choose to avoid the store.

> And the answer to that is zero on basically all of them except iOS

That is a lie: Microsoft's Xbox Marketplace, Sony's PlayStation Network, Nintendo's eShop.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by immigrantsheep on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:46PM (#24191132)
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by donarb on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:00PM (#24191322)
Except games and Xbox:

"The new fee structure excludes all games and any purchases on Xbox consoles."

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by joshstrange on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:59PM (#24193732)
This is misleading, it doesn't apply to games and it's only if you link your customer directly into the app store (not if they go to the store and search for your app or find it some other way).
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by tsieling on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:31PM (#24190929)
Roughly the same, I think the variance is about 10% with Steam being an outlier working in tiers tied to revenue. At least one allows developers to name the cut (including 0%) but 30% is the most common number.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ghostpepper on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:33PM (#24190950)
This is a valid question - if the answer is a fraction of what Apple charges then it strengthens the case against Apple.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Razengan on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:18PM (#24192260)
> if the answer is a fraction of what Apple charges then it strengthens the case against Apple.

The answer is the same. What now? Will you put down the pitchforks?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by ghostpepper on Monday August 24, 2020 @04:46PM (#24265318)
My comment was actually intended to play a bit of devil's advocate - I'm not convinced that Apple has a monopoly, and I kind of don't mind living in the walled garden.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by objclxt on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:45PM (#24191126)
It’s the same. Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo all charge 30%.

https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/10/07/report-steams-30-cut...

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by pwinnski on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:42PM (#24191069)
They all take 30% of IAP.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Bud on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:27PM (#24190863)
On the contrary, there is a very solid basis. Epic has access to Apple's platform and dev tools because it has (or had) an agreement with Apple whereby it paid a percentage of profits earned in exchange for said access.

Epic, btw, has the exact same kind of agreement with Sony, Microsoft, and Google, for access to their gaming platforms. All three of those companies are extracting the same 30% fee that Apple is.

But now Epic has decided to grandstand and pretend that Apple has a "monopoly" and protest paying Apple, while still happily paying the exact same fees to its other gaming partners, including to Sony (for PlayStation), which just invested $250M in Epic.

So to say that there is "absolutely no basis" for Apple's action just isn't true.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Hamuko on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:44PM (#24191822)
>Epic, btw, has the exact same kind of agreement with Sony, Microsoft, and Google, for access to their gaming platforms. All three of those companies are extracting the same 30% fee that Apple is.

Tim Sweeney has stated in the past that he feels like there's a better argument for game console makers taking a 30% fee.

>"There's a rationale for this on console where there's enormous investment in hardware, often sold below cost, and marketing campaigns in broad partnership with publishers. But on open platforms, 30 per cent is disproportionate to the cost of the services these stores perform, such as payment processing, download bandwidth, and customer service.

Basically, he feels that these platforms might actually be doing enough work to earn a 30%. It's not that crazy to criticise one company taking a big slice and approve another company taking a same slice if they are bringing different value.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by threatofrain on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:56PM (#24192669)
My problem with this is it's a very ad hoc argument without a brightline standard to anchor your judgments. It's not really clear why anyone who can get a slice of your work deserves any slice, and society has conventionally allowed the market to determine this.

You appeared to have carved out a convenient exception for the Playstations and Switches of the world because your intuition tells you that the industry isn't healthy, and that wobbling it a little could kill company interest. But we still have nothing to anchor the belief that 30% is right for gaming consoles but not elsewhere.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by odshoifsdhfs on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:18PM (#24192256)
And the iPhone doesn't have an enormous investment in hardware/R&D/marketing? The only point would be the sold below cost, but I even thought this was illegal (dumping) no?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by thedz on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:28PM (#24190892)
> Epic, btw, has the exact same kind of agreement with Sony, Microsoft, and Google, for access to their gaming platforms. All three of those companies are extracting the same 30% fee that Apple is.

You don't have to agree to Epic's terms to access the platforms from Sony, MS and Google. You do, however, have to agree to Apple's terms to access their Platform.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by Bud on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:35PM (#24190983)
Nitpicking, and I'm not even sure that's correct. Regardless, it's not relevant. What Epic is griping about here is the 30% fee, but they're not acting or speaking in good faith about that. They're pretending that fee is somehow onerous, but they pay that exact same fee to every other platform, too.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m-p-3 on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:33PM (#24191702)
The Epic Games Store takes a 12% commission on all games sales though.

https://variety.com/2019/gaming/news/tim-sweeney-epic-games-...

And I'm sure they're not happy about the fees on other platforms, but they can't fight everyone at once.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by sushid on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:22PM (#24192306)
They can believe that many actors are injust but can be simply choosing their battles. And phones > consoles in terms of impact. They're also less arbitrary about which purchases take a 30% cut or not compared to phones.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by pwinnski on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:43PM (#24191095)
Epic had to agree to Sony's, Microsoft's, and Google's terms, however, which seems more relevant.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by PeterStuer on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:12PM (#24191467)
Isn't that extremely coincidental that they all just stumbled upon that same 30%? I'm sure there is no collusion whatsoever.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by m-p-3 on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:24PM (#24191591)
It's the status quo, the first one to make it lower will force everyone to go lower, and none of them want that.

There is no incentive to stay competitive by cutting down on your slice of the pie.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by quotha on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:10PM (#24192150)
So, Epic should get special treatment? They don't have to pay the fees? Just everyone else? How is apple supposed to run the app store? They kinda know what they are doing or why else would so many people buy their iphones?
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by mcintyre1994 on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:15PM (#24192206)
Their app isn't on the store, so no they shouldn't pay fees beyond whatever Apple charge for the privelege of being a developer on their platform. Not sure why not paying App Store fees (because of not having an app on the store) would justify removing access to all developer accounts and tools.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by quotha on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:16PM (#24192230)
Well it used to be dude, that is the whole situation here.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by gruez on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:42PM (#24192520)
> They kinda know what they are doing or why else would so many people buy their iphones?

Or maybe it's something that people merely tolerate. Kind of like how ISPs are almost universally derided in the US for crappy service and high prices, yet everyone seems to be paying for their serivece. If you asked people when they're buying an iphone whether they want 30% of app and in-app purchases to go to apple, with no way around it, how much % of them would say yes?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by quotha on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:11PM (#24194279)
Yes I see that, and you can apply that to all sorts of things in our lives. It’s still arbitrary where the line is that keeps everyone happy, I guess Epic thinks it’s < 30% but I am just not with them on this fight
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by smilekzs on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:32PM (#24192440)
No one should have to pay 30% as long as Apple also competes in the same "marketplace".
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by tonyedgecombe on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:14PM (#24190725)
This clearly and unambiguously crosses the line into abuse of market power.

Epic is taking them to court. What did they expect, a nice thank you and a pat on the head.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by serioussecurity on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:27PM (#24190864)
You don't get to use retaliatory behavior to discourage lawsuits, in this form, especially as a service provider.

If they wanted to sue Epic back over frivolous patent violations, they're allowed, but if you're going to engage in retaliatory behavior you can't do it in a way that violates your own ToS.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by danudey on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:32PM (#24191694)
Apple has terms and conditions for developer accounts, which, if broken, result in account termination.

Epic agreed to, and then broke, those terms and conditions. This results in account termination.

I'm not sure how this is retaliatory behavior. If I had an app and snuck violations into my app to get past review, then had my app removed, then instantly released a PR campaign and filed a lawsuit, I think it would be pretty clear to most people that:

1. I broke the rules and having my account terminated is the obvious result.

2. I didn't break the rules accidentally, but instead broke them very deliberately.

3. I am not interested in discussing this through normal channels, and instead broke the rules to get my app removed as a PR power play so that I would look like the good guy.

That's what happened here. Epic sneaking the IAP workaround into their app shows they broke the rules; Epic filing a lawsuit and launching a PR campaign instantaneously shows that they broke the rules deliberately, knowing the consequences, and are not interested in following the App Store T&C. Doing anything other than closing their developer accounts would be preferential treatment that other developers are unlikely to get in the same situation.

Whether you agree with the rules or not (Epic obviously doesn't), according to the terms and conditions Apple is doing the correct and obvious thing.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by dade_ on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:54PM (#24193236)
Terms and conditions can say whatever they want, but illegal terms in a contract are not binding. The problem is that this type of dispute usually takes years to litigate, so I have to think there is much more to this strategy.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by spzb on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:57PM (#24191291)
It's not retaliation although that's how Epic are trying to portray it. It's a straightforward breach of contract on Epic's part and Apple are invoking the termination clause.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by kmeisthax on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:36PM (#24193063)
The thing is, Apple probably isn't the only one to do this. Apple is actually very graceful by the standards of platforms. Note that Epic did not attempt to surreptitiously introduce a "direct payment" feature into Microsoft, Sony, or Nintendo platforms. That's because you don't even get developer documentation without signing an NDA. Had Epic even thought about doing this on console, the question wouldn't be "will the console manufacturers retaliate", as much as it would be "how many months until the console manufacturers start banning new game submissions that use Unreal Engine"?

Apple did this before, BTW. Remember "Thoughts on Flash"? That wasn't Jobs railing against an aging browser plugin. Adobe had figured out how to get Flash to export iOS apps, and that really pissed off Jobs. So it was really Jobs attacking a strawman (the buggy Flash Player) in order to justify banning all third-party development tools. The FTC threatened to sue and the rule was removed about 3 months later.