The on-going Phase 2/3 trials in the UK, South Africa and Brazil are designed to establish the efficacy of the vaccine under viral challenge. The idea is that you vaccinate a bunch of people (and an equally-sized control group) and wait around until a subset of them test positive for the virus. Then you unblind the groups and make sure that the people who got sick were in the control group. You also check for ADE (antibody dependent enhancement) to make sure the vaccine doesn't amplify the strength of the virus.
All your questions are valid, but this study doesn't claim to answer them. Those results are still forthcoming. Additionally, the risk of ADE is well understood and carefully considered in the design of these trials.
(Disclaimer - I'm a participant in the UK Phase 2/3 trial)
The OP did not claim that the study sought to answer the questions posed. The article does answer the question 'Is it safe?' with the word 'Yes' so I believe you are actually in agreement with the OP and the OP did understand that it is really early to say that, hence the critique.
Sure reads to me like the OP is attacking the idea of developing a vaccine, not the media coverage.
I have always thought those medical trials are conducted under an NDA against the patient, meaning you do not only not know what group you are in, you are not even allowed to tell you are being observed in such a study (to prevent accidental unblinding).
The one thing we agreed to do was not to get an antibody test as that would unblind ourselves.
They never asked that or made us sign anything to that effect.
In this Phase 3 trial, they are measuring prevention of disease across ~10,000 people. They just want to see who tests positive for COVID and how sick they get. In this Phase, they aren't asking most groups about side effects or any subjective questions about symptom severity or anything like that where reading that someone was in a study would influence our opinion.
I think your perception of the numbers are a little off here. In the UK, we were loosing 1100 people a day entirely through covid (https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/) That was most from a few hot spots like london. (less than 10% of the population.) We were very close to overwhelming hospitals. when a hospital system is overwhelmed you get a very large spike in deaths, because stuff that's treatable isn't treated
without lockdown, those deaths would have grown exponentially. Something like 200-400k preventable deaths.
so, if we want to get out of lockdown, we need to have something to reduce the spread of the virus. One way is heard immunity (thats what the US is doing, and its not going very well) another is vaccine.
Now, given the UK example, if the vaccine causes 10 deaths, and 1000 severe reactions(ie hospitalised) thats still better than the 200k deaths and close to a million cases with complications
Deaths arn't the whole picture, its the people that recover with life altering injuries as well.
>COVID-19 associated UK deaths
>Deaths of people who have had a positive test result
These are people who died who tested positive for the the virus not people who died as a result of having the virus. Not very useful numbers since the virus spreads in hospitals.
Under this definition COVID-19 is a terminal disease from which nobody ever recovers. If it hadn't been noticed, the English death toll would eventually have matched the case count.
Matt Hancock was apparently furious when he found out, now a review of PHE has been triggered as they've been serving the UK with bogus stats for months. Notethe coviddata site says PHE wasn't even deduplicating tests until 2nd July. So "case count" before then was also misleading. 30,000 positive cases vanished overnight and that assumes they did the deduplication correctly, but the government is so bad at data handling that at this point it's unclear if any stats can be trusted.
This stuff is really important and it's clear a lot of people on HN are in denial about it, because each time it gets brought up a torrent of downvotes follows. The COVID stats are wrong. They're not even just useless, they're actively misleading. They lead to beliefs like this one:
In the UK, we were loosing 1100 people a day entirely through covid
which is not true and has never been true. It's a belief based on assuming the stats are measuring what actually matters/what people want to know. In reality the stats are measuring what's easy to measure. It leads to huge over-reaction to what is in reality an extremely mild virus.
I am referencing the ONS when I say 1100 people a day, why? because the ONS stats can be compared to many years previous. PHE ones are collected by some consultancy company and are trash.
The average daily death rate is found here: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsde...
> In reality the stats are measuring what's easy to measure. It leads to huge over-reaction to what is in reality an extremely mild virus.
The stats are measuring how many deaths are occurring above the normal average death rate for that period. _something_ caused an extra 1100 deaths a day.
Sure you can say covid is a _very_ mild virus. It might be for some, but out of my friends that have had it (as in tested positive) 1 desaturated to 88% every night. 1 had a fever for 14 days(as in bedbound) 3 had a week long fever, 5 were asymptomatic 3 had epic shits for a weeks. All of these people are < 40. of the people that were > 40 and tested positive, all 3 died. However that's because at the time they were only testing inpatients.
So, with the greatest of respect, you can take your "mild virus" and "its really not 1100 extra deaths a day" and shove it up your arse.
Excess deaths is an entirely different statistic. We can assume total mortality is correct, but that says nothing about what causes it. For example, many excess deaths are clearly not caused by COVID because COVID isn't mentioned on the death certificate, but rather some other problem, even with the ultra-lax reporting and suddenly changed death certificate standards that the UK has introduced.
In reality lock down has caused some deaths. The virus has caused some - or slightly accelerated some, it's not really clear how much life-years reduction has really taken place given the absolutely on-average mortality profile.
I'm very sorry to hear about your friends, but bear in mind "epic shits" aren't even a recognised symptom of COVID. It's a respiratory disease. There's a lot of conflation going on where people are reporting things that aren't COVID as if it was some new but hitherto unknown side effect of the virus. In reality, other kinds of illness didn't stop because a new virus turned up and people can still get sick with the flu or many other diseases - as they do every year - even though COVID is more well known by this point.
http://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2020/04/stomach-compla...
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7172493/
And thats just two, there are many more. Bear in mind they were _all_ covid positive. It wasn't someone saying "I had the snuffles". Lab confirmed covid cases. They are also medical, either nurses or doctors.
> In reality lock down has caused some deaths. The virus has caused some - or slightly accelerated some, it's not really clear how much life-years reduction has really taken place given the absolutely on-average mortality profile.
excess mortality in april was ~880(with smoothing) people a day. but sure, its all just a conspiracy.
Given that the normal causes of excess death have been significantly truncated: driving, drinking and sports, its fairly reasonable to assume that standard causes of death have dropped. We can expect significant spike in deaths from chronic conditions such as cancer, diabetes and copd, but that takes time.
> ultra-lax reporting and suddenly changed death certificate standards that the UK has introduced.
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
actually its been tightened up, and been told to be more specific. Normally an old person dying in a home is put down to "old age", or, if they fall down the stairs: "terminal event" (falls are a massive killer) before you start talking about attending doctors, none of that happens in practice. Its whoever needs the ash cash that certifies the death.(it depends on the consultant. I know of one who managed to buy a porche with the ash cash. Although I think the payments have stopped now) Or if its outside hospital, who ever answers the phone.
Look, I'm never going to change your mind, but just look at those stats. Something caused a huge spike. That spike started dropping before lockdown ended. That looks like a standard epidemic curve to me. I don't see how it can be reasonably read differently
Gosh, where did you get this idea from? Is this a new talking point from somewhere?
Taking the UK again as an example, road deaths are rare and stable at about 1700 per year or about 32 per week:
https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/reported-road-casua...
Overall weekly deaths are 10,000 or so (outside of spike times). Even if the roads became totally empty tomorrow you wouldn't be able to see the difference, it'd be lost in the noise. And obviously lockdown doesn't lead to empty roads: people must still drive to deliver goods, engage in urgent business and so on, so reduction in weekly deaths due to less driving would in reality be less than 32.
As for drink - do you really think people drink less when locked up on their own for months on end? They don't, they drink far more:
https://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/bored-br...
Finally, deaths due to sport?! In an average year in the UK between 15-25 people "die accidentally in athletic/sporting areas" according to the ONS. Deaths due to sport aren't relevant on the scales we're talking about.
Look, I'm never going to change your mind, but just look at those stats. Something caused a huge spike
I am looking at the stats. That's why I consider COVID to be mass hysteria.
Yes, there's a spike in some countries. It's not in any way describable as huge. UK spike matches the famous plague years of 1998/1999/2000. I don't remember any particular special disease in those years:
https://swprs.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/uk-flu-comparison....
In other countries like Switzerland literally nothing happened different to previous years:
https://swprs.files.wordpress.com/2020/07/schweiz-todesfaell...
Staggeringly, in Germany this supposedly deadly disease killed nobody at all when measured using excess deaths:
https://swprs.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/sterbefallzahlen-d...
Yet according to the official stats 10,000 people died of COVID. Clearly this claim can't be true. Where are all these excess deaths?
What's happening here is a highly infectious but virtually harmless virus has been labelling an ever increasing segment of the population as COVID positive. A tiny number of these people really do get hurt by the virus, but that's not important in the grand scheme of things: apparently even the common cold can kill 8% of the elderly. With basically any virus, and especially flu, you can get alarming stories of battles with death by people who were apparently healthy - just search for them and you'll find them. It doesn't by itself mean the virus is dangerous, which is always a relative term.
What happens if you randomly label a huge and ever-increasing section of the population, then measure their health? You get "COVID associated deaths" (which means nothing, it's just a statistical artifact) and you get an ever-widening array of "associated symptoms", because you're measuring normal health activity but re-assigning the cause. So I admit defeat on the "epic shits" point - I should know by now not to say COVID is a respiratory disease and thus can't cause $RANDOM_SYMPTOM, because public health has lost its mind and is publishing papers on random correlations all over the place. The fact that correlation doesn't imply causation has been totally lost.
How can you convert a not very dangerous virus into an excess death spike? Well, it'd cause a small spike by itself anyway, but if you want to make it bigger doing things that increase the spread of every virus sounds good to me: things like flushing all the sick people out of hospitals into care homes, creating panic in said care homes that leads to abandonment (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-52014023), locking people indoors where they're coughing all over each other, putting people into depressions etc.
In about 60 years or so.
>> In the UK, we were loosing 1100 people a day entirely through covid
> which is not true and has never been true.
Excess death stats (all cause deaths over and above the average for the time of year) are available[1] and peak at 12000 in a week or about 1700 a day. I'd say you deserve your downvotes in this case.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/htgq14/oc_...
Excess deaths is not the same thing as "deaths caused by COVID". This conflation relies on the assumption that you can virtually empty hospitals out and have no effect on mortality at all, which is absurd. What are all those surgeons doing, exactly?
If COVID is so deadly, why do some countries show no difference in excess deaths vs previous years?
I know that excess deaths aren't the same as deaths caused by COVID. The idea that you can lockdown in week 13 and have 12,000 excess deaths per week 3 weeks later because hospitals were "virtually empty" also seems absurd. Emergency healthcare remained available and the messaging was that people should still go to hospital if they were ill. I do expect deaths because routine healthcare was limited during lockdown, including people who died during the period of lockdown because they couldn't get hospital treatment (https://www.theguardian.com/society/2020/may/08/more-people-...), but without further evidence, I'd be sceptical that this was the dominant effect.
I'm not sure what you're claiming here: are you saying that deaths because people couldn't access healthcare are almost entirely the cause of the UK's excess death peak? What is your evidence for that claim?
> If COVID is so deadly, why do some countries show no difference in excess deaths vs previous years?
https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/07/15/tracking... has Germany's recorded COVID-19 deaths and excess deaths as 8,538 and 7,549 respectively, and Switzerland's at 1,668 and 1,567. Your question seems to boil down to "why did some countries do so much better at containing the epidemic than others?" I don't know, although Germany and Switzerland seem better organised than the UK so that might have something to do with it.
The problem is lots of things that sound absurd related to COVID end up being true. Our intuitions are not a good guide to an event that's never happened before. So we rely on data, but it's hard to interpret and can be wildly misleading.
For instance, here you express an intuition that people would have continued going to the hospital because "the messaging was people should still go". In the UK? Definitely that wasn't the case. People were told they had to "save the NHS" and that there was a massive programme of field hospital construction because the government was certain they were going to run out of beds. They were told there was a deadly virus and they shouldn't leave their homes. The government ran advertising campaigns that looked like a promo for a zombie movie.
This slaughtered hospital admissions:
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
Total attendance dropped from about 18,000 a day to more like 9,000 per day. It halved overnight. Your intuition about what people did was quite wrong. Even today admissions have not fully recovered.
We don't know how many of those people really needed to be there or else they'd die. But it seems the halving was independent of people's medical needs: cardiac admissions also halved. They went from around 500 per day to more like 250 per day. So that's 1750 missing cardiac ER admissions per week. Some of those people certainly will have died.
And hospitals not only emptied themselves, flushing sick people (with many viruses) into care homes where they then spread them around. But they also refused to take sick people from care homes, so deaths in care homes tripled but deaths linked to the virus only account for half of the increase (and "linked to" is very vague, there are many incorrect classifications there):
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/04/27/care-homes-see-r...
We agree that there's absolutely a critical question about why some countries saw an increase in excess deaths and others saw nothing happen. Clearly if this is genuinely the same virus, and it's the same tests that are detecting it so it must be, then the differences are likely be explained by differing actions taken by governments.
When put in context, Germany didn't actually see any excess deaths, look at the graphs:
https://www.destatis.de/EN/Themes/Cross-Section/Corona/Socie...
If you showed the top three lines to someone who didn't read the news and asked them to pick the year with the scary epidemic, they'd say 2018. There's just no evidence of anything happening in these graphs - the slightly elevated above average number during the "epidemic" is identical in size to the slightly under-average death rates before it started. Sadly you do see people cite figures like "deaths were elevated by X% compared to the same week last year", which is misleading. We'd expect these numbers to wander up and down around the average over time. Yet they supposedly have 200,000 confirmed cases. The most reasonable explanation is that COVID is essentially re-labelling people, and when they die they're labelled as COVID deaths instead of other causes.
In Switzerland excess mortality looked pretty much the same as in 2017 (e.g. peaked at the same levels):
https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/statistics/health/state...
Again, there's just no evidence of anything unusual happening here. If you showed the graphs to someone who didn't know about COVID they'd never imagine anything was happening. The "spike" is relative only to a smoothed rolling average, but such "spikes" are common and happen in many years, so it's not unusual when compared in a more granular way. If COVID had never been discovered we'd have seen these excess death rates and simply assigned them to the flu, as happens every year.
In the UK the excess death rate was higher, but still no cause for alarm. It matches the famously deadly winters of 1998/1999/2000. Hmm, I don't remember any such deadly winters. People were saying the world would end because of the millennium bug, not any other kind of bug :) Clearly there's a loss of proportion here. When I pointed this fact out to a friend, he was confused for a moment and then tried to argue that maybe we are just much more caring than people were in 1999, so death rates and reactions are incomparable! How silly!
The question is not whether people died because of COVID induced panic. There is abundant evidence they did, especially in care homes:
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-52014023
https://swprs.org/covid-19-a-report-from-italy/
https://samnytt.se/aldreboendets-personal-kan-inte-svenska-a...
The question is merely what proportion of it was due to that.
> Again, there's just no evidence of anything unusual happening here.
In Switzerland, something unusual certainly happened compared to 2017, namely a peak outside winter flu season (https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/statistics/health/state...). What caused that, in your view?
In Sweden, where the government stopped short of a full lockdown but messed up care homes by refusing to hospitalise people with COVID19 symptoms (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-52704836), excess deaths also peaked (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_in_Sweden#Ex...). Were the Swedes also panicked into not going to hospital? What did the care home deaths die of?
To return to the question which started the thread, the PHE stats in the UK overestimate by including people who died for other reasons after a positive test, but this effect cannot have caused anything like the error in the statistics that you claim: a back of the envelope calculation based on typical lifespans (http://julesandjames.blogspot.com/2020/07/mountains-and-mole...) gives 20 wrongly-counted deaths per day. If you're claiming that the panic lessened that life expactancy by keeping people out of hospitals, I'd note that even if every single missing cardiac case dropped dead, that's 250 people per day, no where near the 1700 we were seeing at the peak. If PHE continues to count old positive tests now, it will matter, because there are many fewer deaths in total.
The anti vaccination optics, of a vaccine killing people, would be so bad the resulting vaccination resistance could lead to millions of deaths.
Yes, statistics maybe say that it would be a good deal now. But if you assume it fuels the antivac fire and decreases measles vaccination by 10% for the next 10 years, then we are looking at a death toll 10-100 times larger than COVID in the future, from that disease alone.
Measles also only infects a person once. Preliminary data is pointing toward covid immunity lasting for only a few months.
Other coronaviruses typically do have reinfection about a year after first infection: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.05.11.20086439v... - with antibody reduction occurring after about six months.
I know there have been a few people who appeared to clear the virus but subsequently tested positive again - I don't know enough about the details here. Vox article with more links: https://www.vox.com/2020/7/12/21321653/getting-covid-19-twic...
I hope that reinfection with this virus is less likely, but I don't think we yet have any data to suggest that it is much different than existing coronaviruses.
As far as I know, that's not true at all.
A King's College study has shown that the level of B cells in former patients blood declinened quickly after a few months. Still there has yet to be a study on T cells level and T cells seem to play a more important role than B cells in covid immunity.
That doesn't counter your point, but we'll need up to phase 3, to have enough coverage to make sure your statistics hold. But indeed, the risk seems to be balanced against 5 years waiting for any long term symptoms to show.
Without a vaccine - wouldn't herd immunity just be letting the virus spread and then let Darwin take over, more or less?
It was the approach taken initially by the UK, and it is the one currently being taken by sweden.
Good thing this isn't a retrovirus.
>But I do have concerns on trying to push out any novel vaccine in less than two years without adequate testing.
They started on this vaccine about 9 years ago, originally for the first SARS/MERS. They just gave it to 1,077 people and all 100% produced the desired effect, and the worst symptom reported was fatigue/headache that resolved on its own within 24 hours, or sooner if taken Tylenol/paracetamol. We're losing ~150,000 people worldwide EVERY MONTH to this virus, how many more months/deaths should we wait until we're sufficiently satisfied that it's safe?
That's a good start. But for example, how many of them were pregnant, and at what stages? I would guess none. That would be the most famous way to get this wrong.
I hope they are thinking hard about the optimal roll-out strategy, though. It should surely be faster than in normal times. It might well be that you should run very very large not-quite-trials as the first stage of general distribution, and watch their evidence in real-time.
Of course we're gonna test this on the healthiest, least-likely-to-accidentally-die humans, what's the point?
They explicitly did a pregnancy test on everyone who can be pregnant to preclude the possibility, just in case.
But there are quite a few more steps from there to treating the population.
I don't understand anything about biology/vaccines or anything else relevant - but there have been several stories in history of medicine that was thought to have no side effect, that ended up being taken off the shelves because it was more dangerous than first thought.
If we're going to inject a few hundred million (if not a few billion) people with something, we need to be really really sure it won't harm then, and considering the fact that COVID has a mortality rate of 1%-ish, the vaccine has a huge burden of proof.
And more importantly to anything that I say as a non-expert - most experts on these issues seem to think you need at least ~10 months of human trials, if not more.
That’s the entire point of a Phase one trial. Vaccine studies may be a little different in their numbering, but the intent of a phase one trial is to figure out if the treatment is safe. The effectiveness is a separate question.
https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/parents/infographics/journey-of...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandemrix
No one knows if this vaccine has similar side effects, what if it causes elevated risk of lung cancer?
Drugs are comparatively safer, given the time frame of the pandemic.
Before vaccinating 7 billion people with a vaccine done in a year we should think at least twice, Darwin Award in global scale and all. Let them vaccinate 80+ year olds or people with one foot already in the grave, but be very careful before doing it in a massive scale.
However we're going to try dozens of vaccines on probably 500k-1m people in total globally before deploying them in an increasingly broad way. The next stage of the Pfizer-BioNTech trial is going to be 30,000 in July/August.
We need to ensure that the vaccine is extraordinarily safe. "But it saves more people than it kills" is not an argument people accept, unfortunately. If this vaccine kills anyone, the antivax fallout could be worse in the long run than just letting the virus run its course.
Come on now, we gotta start somewhere
For context: That is 0.0002% of the world's population.
per capita numbers are useful context but sometimes the total number is also important context that is worth worrying about. In this case a tiny percentage of a very large number results in a large enough number to cause concern.
0.0002% per month is still just 0.0024% per year. Don't forget that more than 1% of the population die each year to begin with.
Traditionally many things used to take an awful lot longer than it does now (e.g. gene sequencing). Technology advances.
Also, this vaccine was based on an earlier one developed for MERS so they weren't starting from scratch.
> We still don't have vaccines for retroviruses like HIV/Herpes
That's completely irrelevant because they're very different viruses. Vaccination for a coronavirus should be a lot easier.
> But I do have concerns on trying to push out any novel vaccine in less than two years without adequate testing
It is undergoing extensive testing. Tens of thousands of people are currently being given the vaccine. The timeline is not really relevant; what counts is the testing that is carried out.
I'm sure the Oxford University team has given proper consideration to safety.
This may be true with chips and gene sequencing, but is not true for vaccines. The waiting period for vaccines is mainly for safety and efficacy, not waiting on technology like the other two.
We may become more certain some vaccines are safer given intrinsic properties, but that probably won't result in any statistically noticeable difference because it's very hard to tell how a vaccine will behave without actually trying it as far as I understand it.
Why is that? Uneducated guess: because of the rapid mutations of those viruses and the way they go dormant and hide?
The trouble with HIV is during the infection process, it has an reverse transcriptase enzyme and an integrase enzyme, the two of which allow it to build DNA sequences and alter the host DNA. It permanently alters the host, allowing the virus to continue reproducing.
There are some people for which this modification does nothing (long term non-progressives), but the for the majority of human beings, their immune system collapses within a few months or years (without treatment).
To get back on topic, I'd really like someone to explain in some way that makes sense to me (because I've heard none--maybe I'm just incorrigible, thought) how a mandatory vaccine is justifiable for a disease with an extremely high survival rate that elderly people who've already exceeded the average life expectancy are disproportionately at risk for.
Lastly, consider all of the people who have "recovered" but haven't really recovered, this includes the young 20-30 yr old crowds. There's hundreds of support groups now focused on post-corona-syndrome where people are 100+ days into the recovery but still have symptoms, including brain damage, neurological issues, strokes, kidney failures, shortness of breath, etc. It seems as if the older people are dying, and the younger patients are surviving, but with long-term damage.
0.66% of NYC residents have been hospitalized (https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page). Antibody tests show that at least 20% of NYC was infected, and that's likely an underestimate (antibodies take weeks to show up and may soon drop to undetectable levels). So the hospitalization rate is at most around 3%.
Once we run out of hospital resources, the death rate will jump 5-10x. If that happens, you're talking 20+ million deaths in the U.S
That's just not going to happen. There was essentially uncontrolled spread in NYC, and the hospitals were strained but not overwhelmed. The hospitalization and death rates in currently hard-hit states are much lower than peak NYC, and may already be at a plateau.
It seems as if the older people are dying, and the younger patients are surviving, but with long-term damage.
This is a real concern, but I'd like data rather than anecdotes.
“I am trying to keep my weekly covid journal going. We are still in about month 4 post infection.
Some good news is my breathing is slightly better. When everything is bad all small improvements are noticed. Could be from OTC blood thinners or that my lungs are getting better. Still have a super hard time breathing, but it is just a bit less difficult. I am also in a near constant state of fatigue, but am unable to easily sleep because of the other symptoms. My MRI revealed no vessel or tissue damage to my brain from the stroke, so maybe not a stroke or just not sever enough to cause damage. It did reveal a small cyst on the brain, but that seems to be common in covid recovery patients and no one knows why yet. The stroke like symptoms maybe related more to the hypoxia and not a stroke. I see a nuerologist this week and they will decide the next steps. The symptoms are still there though - dizzy, off balance, difficulty with sentence formation, difficulty getting facts from brain to mouth or hands to type, memory issues. Super frustrating.
My cardiologist has sent me for a new test that takes highly detailed xrays of the heart. After deciding what/how much damage is in my heart valve they will decide the next course of treatment. Other than the damage, he says my heart is healthy.
Passed my breathing test, so capacity is OK and volume/flow is good. The worry and science now is saying the breathing troubles I am experiencing may be related to tons of micro-clots in the lungs. They have been discovering these during autopsy of covid deceased (hopefully deceased) patients. My next steps of healthcare relate to all these specialist working together. I can not start blood thinners for my stroke prevention until I am sure I will not need heart surgery. I can not go down the path of heart surgery until there were sure I can both breath effectively and not have a stroke. I am fortunate for good doctors that are at the front edge of treatment for covid patients. Some of the care is "we just have to wait", that is OK but frustrating because in the mean time I am at the mercy of me neighbors to do the right things and not re-infect me and I have to stay socially isolated. The latest science is showing that antibodies are not retained in over 85-90% of cases of infection, meaning there is no natural immunity. This includes me, I showed no antibody after 10 weeks. This is worrisome since I am sure I would NOT be able to survive another round, since I barely survived the first one. "
The thought of dealing with permanent lung and brain damage for the rest of my life is pretty terrifying, and seems disturbingly common even in age groups with a low fatality rate.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jul/20/coronavirus-...
There will be a law suit over how CFS patients are currently treated: https://www.virology.ws/2020/07/15/trial-by-error-nice-on-ex...
You might want to follow it. I will be.
She's been avoiding fats has she's had both reflux and is trying to eat an anti inflammatory diet. Will see if she fancies a change of tactics.
Current dietary recommendations are the same for everyone and implicitly assume you are slightly overweight and sedentary, consuming a caloric excess. In America many people die of obesity related diseases and dietary recommendations based on the epidemiological data reflect this. When you are weak and frail in bed it amazes me that Doctors still recommend the same diet based on this data. It took me so long to realise why salads and lean protein were making things worse. I needed more calories! More protein, fat, sugar, all the 'bad' stuff to build myself back up. Of course I'm assuming your wife has lost weight while ill as I did and this doesn't apply otherwise.
I have no idea if there are 'hundreds' of support groups - my wife is on a couple that largest of which has approaching 10000 members. Every time I post about her progress to Facebook I find more friends or friends of friends who know of people that haven't yet made a connection to a group of or who are only newly considering themselves 'long term ill'. Given what we know now, and the large wave of cases, there are many more people who will be suffering long term symptoms in the months to come.
I really hope there is no long term damage - but I think you have to admit it is too early to say that with any confidence. The impacts or Ebola and SARs are well understood, so I'm not sure why people find it so hard to believe in the issues covid causes.
Article: ‘I feel helpless’: three people on their grueling Covid-19 recoveries
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jul/20/coronavirus-...
This shows clear counter evidence to the claim of hospitalization rate being ~20% for all age groups. This CDC data shows a steep increase in the hospitalization rate as age increases.
Not sure where you are getting your information.
That's what happens when between 4k and 5k people die per day over 50 days.
Why not build more hospitals?
> there's a good chance this virus will burn out in our population long before a truly safe vaccine comes to market.
That's the reason for the down-votes, and for once I think it's actually appropriate. The rest of the post was fine, but those are some wildly controversial - if not completely incorrect and reckless - assumptions to make. For one, it's too early to make definitive statements like these. As far as I know, public health experts have made it well known the risk factor is enormously high and so it's worth being proactive than reactive. Clearly there's an enormous amount of effort in getting an emergency vaccine out and I would think for good reason. Nobody on HN is qualified to make statements on this, especially if they're not actively studying this disease or they're not a public health expert.
Where did the "mandatory" come from?
If a vaccine is promising but unproven, the sensible thing is to make it available to those who want to take the risk.
I agree that for a mandatory vaccine, you want a high level of certainty.
(What is possible is that schools and even workplaces require proof of vaccination once one is widely available if there is still a widespread virus risk. That could arguably be fairly coercive but it's important to distinguish from being "mandatory.")
> elderly people who've already exceeded the average life expectancy
Letting hundreds of thousands of people (in the US alone) with easily a decade left to live die of a preventable disease is not ethical. What you're writing sounds extremely callous.
Also the numbers of Covid-19 are mainly following a Gompertz model - like a seasonal virus that starts big and then fizzles. The high R-Values people talked about in the beginning aren't a real thing.
Michael Levitt in the beginning already calculated the outbreak in China perfectly. He made good Videos to explain the basic math. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCgPf1SuPNY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uw2ZTaiN97k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aHrx68IT7o
Maybe take a look at some f'/f in a logchart... It's easy to do - just look at death per day/total.
Some countries are easy to model (e.g. Germany) - US is difficult with policies and outbreaks coming from different sides, ... - but some states are not that difficult to understand)
If you're living in an area where the virus is circulating, you are likely to eventually be exposed many times. Getting lucky once is not enough.
> like a seasonal virus that starts big and then fizzles. The high R-Values people talked about in the beginning aren't a real thing.
They're absolutely real. Seasonal viruses come back every year, so if this is like the flu, then we have to worry about another major wave in the fall.
Epidemics can slow down for two reasons:
* Increasing immunity. Herd immunity is a long way off in most places in the world. Even places that had some of the worst outbreaks, like NY city, have only had ~20% infection rates.
* People change their behavior, causing R to decrease. Social distancing, mask-wearing, enforced lockdowns, quarantining of infected people, quarantining of exposed people - these can all lead to slower spread of the virus.
> Michael Levitt in the beginning already calculated the outbreak in China perfectly.
The epidemic was suppressed in China through a massive government and societal response. It would have been far worse if there had been no reaction. Because of the reaction, most of the country was spared the experience that Wuhan had. If all containment measures were to end today, the epidemic would flare up again and millions of people would die over the next several months.
The only way to permanently dampen the outbreak is to achieve a high level of immunity. That can either be through a vaccine, in which case almost nobody will die, or it can be through herd immunity, in which case many millions of people will die worldwide.
It's not about how often you're exposed to the virus but about how long and how intensely. Living with someone is pretty much the worst case.
According to Johns Hopkins in the UK more than 15% of those who get it die, for the US it is 3.7%. The link says those numbers were updated this morning so they are current.
>How can you still push lies like that?
Still? that is the first time I have posted that, so I not sure what you mean by still.
HIV is so fundamentally different that it doesn't make sense to include it as a comparison here.
> there's a good chance this virus will burn out in our population long before a truly safe vaccine comes to market.
The virus isn't just going to "burn out" anytime soon. 143k deaths in the US already, and we likely haven't even hit 10% of the population being infected yet.
Treatments will help pull the death rate downwards, but without a vaccine we're likely looking at multiple hundreds of thousands more deaths.
Coronaviruses are very different. We've rarely had any this deadly before. All vaccines are different; they're not one blanket thing. Smallpox vaccines are attenuated virus (a virus that has mutated to be benign in humans; in the case of Smallpox, the first vaccine by Jenner was injecting people with Horsepox).
Most Influenza vaccines are heat treated/inactivated virus.
In all cases, vaccines try to produce antibodies and force our immune systems to develop a memory for a virus we haven't actually been exposed to. As shown in the links above, this might not work at all for coronavirus.
To some extent, the actual interactions of vaccines, are somewhat opaque. This In A Nutshell video shows a very small part of the adaptive immune system, greatly simplified:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BSypUV6QUNw
> The virus isn't just going to "burn out" anytime soon
Exponential growth doesn't go on forever. It has to hit an inflection point:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kas0tIxDvrg
The more deadly a virus is, the faster it does burn out. It runs out of hosts to infect or everyone develops an immunity. SARS/MERS may have had lower outbreaks because of how much more dangerous they were.
If you graph fatalities on a logarithmic scale, you'll see we're already well past the inflection point in the US:
https://aatishb.com/covidtrends/?data=deaths
The cases are going up, but the fatalities are not, indicating there may be a lot of over-counting. Keep in mind people who test positive but die of a car wreck are counted as COVID19. All these people getting surgery after 3 months are required to get tested just for their surgery, and a positive antibody test counts as an active case, even if they're not sick or have the virus at all.
It's so bad in the UK they've stopped reporting fatality numbers due to issues with the data.
> The more deadly a virus is, the faster it does burn out. It runs out of hosts to infect or everyone develops an immunity. SARS/MERS may have had lower outbreaks because of how much more dangerous they were.
At what point is the virus going to "run out of hosts to infect" or reach a point where "everyone develops an immunity"? Everything I've read from epidemiologists seems to indicate we're a long ways away from that. We're not going to get a free pass from herd immunity anytime soon (https://covid19-projections.com/us estimates that the US is at 8.4% total infection so far), and we can't count on it just burning itself out. It's a bad combination, where it's not deadly enough to quickly burn itself out like SARS/MERS, but has a death rate higher than something like the flu, and is very transmissible.
> The cases are going up, but the fatalities are not, indicating there may be a lot of over-counting
I'm very skeptical of the over-counting claim, without evidence. And I don't think it's quite true to claim that fatalities are not going up. The 7-day rolling average of deaths in the US has been climbing since around July 5th.
SARS and MERS.
> Keep in mind people who test positive but die of a car wreck are counted as COVID19.
I'd like to see evidence that this has happened, that's it's not some freak outlier, and that it has any meaningful impact on the reported death toll. Looking at excess mortality, it looks like deaths have been under-reported, if anything. It's getting tiresome to see people trotting out the anecdote about someone getting in a car wreck and being counted as a CoVID-19 death.
In Colorado there was lawsuit over this, because there was a case of a college age man dying of alcohol poisoning but he tested positive for Covid-19 so was counted as a Covid-19 death per CDC regulations. So the Colorado Health Department now tracks two numbers: people that died with Covid-19 and people that died because of Covid-19. As of right now the first is 1,752 deaths and the second is 1,615 deaths. Statistically it's not a huge difference, you can see the numbers here:
8.5% isn’t significant?
Then there are the stats from the ONS where they have actually verified that covid is the cause. The numbers are not very different.
See https://www.ft.com/content/a26fbf7e-48f8-11ea-aeb3-955839e06... for excess mortality in a few countries. Many victims are not counted.
You cant lump all excess mortality into the Covid bucket.
If the UK where really serious about the actual covid death toll they should address the huge discrepancy between the reported covid deaths and the excess mortality during the pandemic. Not a good look for the UK.
Interestingly enough the weekly UK excess death figures went negative at the end of June, meaning less people died that week than in previous years. Presumably this is due to the huge number of deaths in care homes in previous weeks.
The Oxford/AZ (https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/07/20/ne...) and the Pfizer team (https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/07/20/mo...) have both reported T Cell responses induced by their vaccines.
Robus T Cell responses should be protective, but we are still mapping that out for SARS-CoV-2 (https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/07/15/ne...).
They were reported again today. They weren't stopped because they were bad but because there were descrepencies between the counting for each nation of the UK.
This simply isn't true.
I don't think we can wait until the risk is zero, after all the risk of allowing the virus to continue is far from zero. You talk about unknowns, we don't know the long-term impact of the disease either. Damage to the heart and lungs, oxygen deprivation of the brain, the impact extends beyond a boolean live or die.
> There are also calls to perform "challenge trials"[1] in which vaccinated people are deliberately infected with coronavirus. However, there are ethical concerns due to a lack of treatments.
There might be a benefit in pushing it out to over 75s who are at severe risk from the virus (IFR 19%), or even over 65s (3%). Agree that it's not worth the risk of a barely understood vaccine on kids.
[1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
[2] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.05.13.093195v1
Herpes is not retrovirus. It just have a latent phase where inactive viral DNA is in the cytoplasm of infected neurons.
This sounds like how you get zombies. I’ve seen this movie before.
I strongly disagree with this sentiment. In the ideal world we would have both a treatment and a vaccine, but a vaccine is much preferable: even if it grants immunity for only a year it still allows for better logistics than a treatment. A treatment is also an unknown cost while the cost of producing a vaccine is fairly well know. Also there are loads of people who are at high risk and cannot survive COVID if they got it. Herd immunity and actual immunity from a vaccine is their only option for staying alive. Lastly, your comment makes it sound like steps are being skipped here. They are not. This vaccine along with others is undergoing the same three phase study approach as any other candidate for any other virus. The difference is that sometimes phase 1 and 2 are combined which puts the people in those trials at risk, but based on your comment I don’t see that as being one of your concerns (based on the part about how well yeah a lot of people died but it doesn’t warrant an emergency vaccine). It does not cause risk to anyone else and for successful phase 1 & 2 trials you can assume the vaccine is safe for the populations tested in phase 3. Once all three are cleared, the vaccine is just as safe as any other.
I know to a lot of people it may feel like corners are being cut but I have seen zero evidence for that. We are saving time by doing things like combining phase 1 & 2, expediting review and paperwork by prioritizing these candidates over other drugs, and in this particular case by manufacturing the vaccine while it’s still in trials, gambling that it will actually work. So far the Oxford vaccine looks to be the most promising of all so I would say it’s a good gamble, but then again only a small portion of that $1.2b is mine (coming from US tax dollars and AstraZenica coffers).
A true emergency vaccine is the only one that’s currently approved for use: it’s been approved as an experimental vaccine by the Chinese military for use by the military for one year. That particular vaccine doesn’t have phase 2 or 3 results actually published and the preliminary data from phase 2 doesn’t look as good as the Oxford one. That is the kind of thing I would personally hold off on, but not something that’s gone through all three phases and been independently reviewed.
For me, the things being developed are not 'vaccines' but are a different thing entirely with a similar intended purpose.
>It's really really to early to say yes or no, and the fact that the article tries to make a claim either way, is worrying.
This is exactly what the phase 1 trial (the result which were just released) tries to establish -
>Phase I trials were formerly referred to as “first-in-man studies” but the field generally moved to the gender-neutral language phrase "first-in-humans" in the 1990s;[5] these trials are the first stage of testing in human subjects.[6] They are designed to test the safety, side effects, best dose, and formulation method for the drug.[7] Phase I trials are not randomized, and thus are vulnerable to selection bias.[8]
It's important to remember that vaccines for previous coronaviruses (SARS/MERS) had reports of generating anitbodies, but also causing immunopathic responses or immune enhancement syndrome:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3335060/
https://www.pnas.org/content/117/15/8218
>Is it safe?
It's really really to early to say yes or no, and the fact that the article tries to make a claim either way, is worrying. Vaccines for new families of viruses traditionally take years or decades to develop. We still don't have vaccines for retroviruses like HIV/Herpes (and it may not be possible due to the nature of those viruses).
I've had all my vaccinations; I'm not an anti-vaxer. But I do have concerns on trying to push out any novel vaccine in less than two years without adequate testing.
Although this virus has killed many, the risk factor for it is nowhere near high enough to warrant an emergency vaccine. There are trials underway for inhaled steroids that look very promising, and there's a good chance this virus will burn out in our population long before a truly safe vaccine comes to market.
Having a viable treatment option seems much more valuable and safer than vaccinations in this particular case.