Lastly, consider all of the people who have "recovered" but haven't really recovered, this includes the young 20-30 yr old crowds. There's hundreds of support groups now focused on post-corona-syndrome where people are 100+ days into the recovery but still have symptoms, including brain damage, neurological issues, strokes, kidney failures, shortness of breath, etc. It seems as if the older people are dying, and the younger patients are surviving, but with long-term damage.
0.66% of NYC residents have been hospitalized (https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page). Antibody tests show that at least 20% of NYC was infected, and that's likely an underestimate (antibodies take weeks to show up and may soon drop to undetectable levels). So the hospitalization rate is at most around 3%.
Once we run out of hospital resources, the death rate will jump 5-10x. If that happens, you're talking 20+ million deaths in the U.S
That's just not going to happen. There was essentially uncontrolled spread in NYC, and the hospitals were strained but not overwhelmed. The hospitalization and death rates in currently hard-hit states are much lower than peak NYC, and may already be at a plateau.
It seems as if the older people are dying, and the younger patients are surviving, but with long-term damage.
This is a real concern, but I'd like data rather than anecdotes.
“I am trying to keep my weekly covid journal going. We are still in about month 4 post infection.
Some good news is my breathing is slightly better. When everything is bad all small improvements are noticed. Could be from OTC blood thinners or that my lungs are getting better. Still have a super hard time breathing, but it is just a bit less difficult. I am also in a near constant state of fatigue, but am unable to easily sleep because of the other symptoms. My MRI revealed no vessel or tissue damage to my brain from the stroke, so maybe not a stroke or just not sever enough to cause damage. It did reveal a small cyst on the brain, but that seems to be common in covid recovery patients and no one knows why yet. The stroke like symptoms maybe related more to the hypoxia and not a stroke. I see a nuerologist this week and they will decide the next steps. The symptoms are still there though - dizzy, off balance, difficulty with sentence formation, difficulty getting facts from brain to mouth or hands to type, memory issues. Super frustrating.
My cardiologist has sent me for a new test that takes highly detailed xrays of the heart. After deciding what/how much damage is in my heart valve they will decide the next course of treatment. Other than the damage, he says my heart is healthy.
Passed my breathing test, so capacity is OK and volume/flow is good. The worry and science now is saying the breathing troubles I am experiencing may be related to tons of micro-clots in the lungs. They have been discovering these during autopsy of covid deceased (hopefully deceased) patients. My next steps of healthcare relate to all these specialist working together. I can not start blood thinners for my stroke prevention until I am sure I will not need heart surgery. I can not go down the path of heart surgery until there were sure I can both breath effectively and not have a stroke. I am fortunate for good doctors that are at the front edge of treatment for covid patients. Some of the care is "we just have to wait", that is OK but frustrating because in the mean time I am at the mercy of me neighbors to do the right things and not re-infect me and I have to stay socially isolated. The latest science is showing that antibodies are not retained in over 85-90% of cases of infection, meaning there is no natural immunity. This includes me, I showed no antibody after 10 weeks. This is worrisome since I am sure I would NOT be able to survive another round, since I barely survived the first one. "
The thought of dealing with permanent lung and brain damage for the rest of my life is pretty terrifying, and seems disturbingly common even in age groups with a low fatality rate.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jul/20/coronavirus-...
There will be a law suit over how CFS patients are currently treated: https://www.virology.ws/2020/07/15/trial-by-error-nice-on-ex...
You might want to follow it. I will be.
She's been avoiding fats has she's had both reflux and is trying to eat an anti inflammatory diet. Will see if she fancies a change of tactics.
Current dietary recommendations are the same for everyone and implicitly assume you are slightly overweight and sedentary, consuming a caloric excess. In America many people die of obesity related diseases and dietary recommendations based on the epidemiological data reflect this. When you are weak and frail in bed it amazes me that Doctors still recommend the same diet based on this data. It took me so long to realise why salads and lean protein were making things worse. I needed more calories! More protein, fat, sugar, all the 'bad' stuff to build myself back up. Of course I'm assuming your wife has lost weight while ill as I did and this doesn't apply otherwise.
I have no idea if there are 'hundreds' of support groups - my wife is on a couple that largest of which has approaching 10000 members. Every time I post about her progress to Facebook I find more friends or friends of friends who know of people that haven't yet made a connection to a group of or who are only newly considering themselves 'long term ill'. Given what we know now, and the large wave of cases, there are many more people who will be suffering long term symptoms in the months to come.
I really hope there is no long term damage - but I think you have to admit it is too early to say that with any confidence. The impacts or Ebola and SARs are well understood, so I'm not sure why people find it so hard to believe in the issues covid causes.
Article: ‘I feel helpless’: three people on their grueling Covid-19 recoveries
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jul/20/coronavirus-...
This shows clear counter evidence to the claim of hospitalization rate being ~20% for all age groups. This CDC data shows a steep increase in the hospitalization rate as age increases.
Not sure where you are getting your information.
That's what happens when between 4k and 5k people die per day over 50 days.
Why not build more hospitals?
> there's a good chance this virus will burn out in our population long before a truly safe vaccine comes to market.
That's the reason for the down-votes, and for once I think it's actually appropriate. The rest of the post was fine, but those are some wildly controversial - if not completely incorrect and reckless - assumptions to make. For one, it's too early to make definitive statements like these. As far as I know, public health experts have made it well known the risk factor is enormously high and so it's worth being proactive than reactive. Clearly there's an enormous amount of effort in getting an emergency vaccine out and I would think for good reason. Nobody on HN is qualified to make statements on this, especially if they're not actively studying this disease or they're not a public health expert.
Where did the "mandatory" come from?
If a vaccine is promising but unproven, the sensible thing is to make it available to those who want to take the risk.
I agree that for a mandatory vaccine, you want a high level of certainty.
(What is possible is that schools and even workplaces require proof of vaccination once one is widely available if there is still a widespread virus risk. That could arguably be fairly coercive but it's important to distinguish from being "mandatory.")
> elderly people who've already exceeded the average life expectancy
Letting hundreds of thousands of people (in the US alone) with easily a decade left to live die of a preventable disease is not ethical. What you're writing sounds extremely callous.
Also the numbers of Covid-19 are mainly following a Gompertz model - like a seasonal virus that starts big and then fizzles. The high R-Values people talked about in the beginning aren't a real thing.
Michael Levitt in the beginning already calculated the outbreak in China perfectly. He made good Videos to explain the basic math. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCgPf1SuPNY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uw2ZTaiN97k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aHrx68IT7o
Maybe take a look at some f'/f in a logchart... It's easy to do - just look at death per day/total.
Some countries are easy to model (e.g. Germany) - US is difficult with policies and outbreaks coming from different sides, ... - but some states are not that difficult to understand)
If you're living in an area where the virus is circulating, you are likely to eventually be exposed many times. Getting lucky once is not enough.
> like a seasonal virus that starts big and then fizzles. The high R-Values people talked about in the beginning aren't a real thing.
They're absolutely real. Seasonal viruses come back every year, so if this is like the flu, then we have to worry about another major wave in the fall.
Epidemics can slow down for two reasons:
* Increasing immunity. Herd immunity is a long way off in most places in the world. Even places that had some of the worst outbreaks, like NY city, have only had ~20% infection rates.
* People change their behavior, causing R to decrease. Social distancing, mask-wearing, enforced lockdowns, quarantining of infected people, quarantining of exposed people - these can all lead to slower spread of the virus.
> Michael Levitt in the beginning already calculated the outbreak in China perfectly.
The epidemic was suppressed in China through a massive government and societal response. It would have been far worse if there had been no reaction. Because of the reaction, most of the country was spared the experience that Wuhan had. If all containment measures were to end today, the epidemic would flare up again and millions of people would die over the next several months.
The only way to permanently dampen the outbreak is to achieve a high level of immunity. That can either be through a vaccine, in which case almost nobody will die, or it can be through herd immunity, in which case many millions of people will die worldwide.
It's not about how often you're exposed to the virus but about how long and how intensely. Living with someone is pretty much the worst case.
According to Johns Hopkins in the UK more than 15% of those who get it die, for the US it is 3.7%. The link says those numbers were updated this morning so they are current.
>How can you still push lies like that?
Still? that is the first time I have posted that, so I not sure what you mean by still.
To get back on topic, I'd really like someone to explain in some way that makes sense to me (because I've heard none--maybe I'm just incorrigible, thought) how a mandatory vaccine is justifiable for a disease with an extremely high survival rate that elderly people who've already exceeded the average life expectancy are disproportionately at risk for.