40% of the Fortune 500 companies are founded by immigrant families [2][3], so the U.S. is really shooting itself in the foot (again).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America_First_(policy)
[2] F500 2010: http://research.newamericaneconomy.org/wp-content/uploads/20... (pdf)
[3] F500 2017: https://startupsusa.org/fortune500/
A real America-first policy would encourage and fight for high skill immigration, since that builds the economy of the US and depletes talent from other countries.
Lots of valuable brains are outside the country, but doesn't mean we should traffic in somewhat misleading statistics.
Does it change my view on immigration? Of course not, but it does indicate that if immigration was stopped entirely then it is not true to say that that 40% slice of fortune 500 companies would simply never have been founded.
That is not the same as saying that 40% of the founders of Fortune 500 companies were immigrants (which I believe is bruceb's point).
To your point: Let's say there were 5 founders. Let's say one was an immigrant. Would the company still have been founded by the other 4, if the immigrant were not there? That's unknown, but one would expect that at least some of the time the answer is "no". Or if it were founded, would it have grown as large as it did? Again, unknown, but in at least some cases the answer is probably "no".
To argue otherwise is to say that founders are replaceable parts - that they have nothing unique to add. That seems... questionable.
My comment should be read as: I have seen the 40% figure given very often on HN and I did interpret it as 40% of Fortune 500 companies being founded only by first-generation immigrants.
To me someone who was born in a country and has citizenship in that particular country is not an immigrant.
But, to your actual point (I hope): I'm inclined to agree with your definition of immigrants. And yet, if we didn't accept the parents, we wouldn't have the children either.
The problem with that argument is, where do you draw the line? One generation? Two? A few decades? A few centuries? If you follow that argument too far, only businesses founded by Native Americans weren't founded by families of immigrants.
I think that categorizing people as immigrants, (first generation) children of immigrants, and non-immigrants makes sense for this discussion. And if "founded by families of immigrants" means first-generation children, that's still to some degree an argument that we want immigrants because of the effect they have on the economy. Not as direct an argument as if they were founded by immigrants, but still something of an argument.
The claim as stated here, "40% of the Fortune 500 companies are founded by immigrant families", is very straightforward.
Now a more precise statement: 40% of Fortune 500 companies had at least one immigrant or American with at least 1 immigrant parent on found team. Changes the image in one's mind a lot. Why not actually be straightforward instead of misleading?
Your formulation is fine too, although immigrants are Americans, so I don't love that distinction. Regardless, these all conjure up the same idea for me. For the purposes of this discussion, I don't even see much difference between founder and cofounder. Typically if someone is called a cofounder then the business probably wouldn't exist without them.
To settle the argument, why don't we agree to stick with this sentence from the original study: "43 percent of these companies were founded or co-founded by an immigrant or the child of an immigrant."
Alternatively, that role would have been filled By someone else.
If your hypothesis were true, then the rate of Fortune 500 companies being founded by immigrant families (40%) would be representative of the % of immigrant families in the U.S. population (24%), which it's not.
Made up numbers follow. If the average number of Cofounders was 4, at 25% population rate the number would be around 66% immigrant founded by that stat.
If ability is normally distributed, and immigration is a filter for A players, their descendants will regress to the mean to become B players. B players want their C player American kids to have jobs over the A player non-American immigrant. America first.
Instead of investing in our domestic population with job training and scholarships, corporations are importing labor from overseas. Those people getting imported have degrees (sometimes of dubious quality) paid for by socialist states, often work for 'staffing agencies' to circumvent benefits and PTO of the real company, have very little job mobility, are most often paid below-market rates.
It's basic economics. More labor means cheaper labor.
Why are Blacks and Hispanics underrepresented in Software development [1]? If you compare the overall employment figures to the overall demographics of the country, they're almost identical, but way, way off for software development. It's because the most vulnerable people in the US don't have access to jobs and education, and corporations have no incentive to train entry level workers when they can just import them.
> so the U.S. is really shooting itself in the foot (again).
In what manner? The US doesn't need every genius walking on planet earth to reside in the US.
EDIT: reference
This is the lump of labour fallacy[0], and is erroneously used to argue against immigration.
The US population has grown from ~150 million in 1950 to ~350 million now.
The only thing that got more expensive relatively speaking is housing. Which kind of make sense because land area don't tend to change.
Look around at your house and answer if you could get the same stuff (or even, poor replacement of the same stuff) if you're at the same percentile of income in 1950s.
1950 to 2020 looks good on paper, until you realize that the bulk of the wage growth happened prior to 1990. Since 1990, the S&P 500 has gone up approximately 10x. Meanwhile, wages have approximately doubled. That means in the last 30 years, the wealth gap has increased. If you consider only minorities, the picture is even worse.
It's almost like, US workers are losing their bargaining power for some reason. If you consider outsourcing, various trade agreements, and white collar immigration, those are all net-negative on US labor. Some demographics have been disproportionately impacted than others, just as predicted.
The brain drain effect is almost always linked to poor economic performance. And the rules are so ham fisted now. Bipartisan H1B reform goes nowhere (prioritize US masters degrees, block H1B dependent employers from more H1Bs etc). Stupid stuff is everywhere.
Immigrants bringing in revenue (plenty) support US jobs in the US.
It's going to be a rude shock to the less skilled american worker to find a lot of jobs going remote overseas (Canada even) and their middle management / entry level office jobs vanishing.
This historic effect here, where another country educates someone, and then they come to the US, is INSANELY profitable for the US. Seriously, in a ruthless way folks who are not successful in school, have health issues, have criminal backgrounds, are disabled etc don't come in on these visas.
Instead its ambitious folks ANOTHER COUNTRY has invested a lot into coming to the US. How does that hurt the US?
This has always been a huge advantage the US has had. Crazy to see the US throwing it away.
In fact, preventing immigration reduces jobs. Companies will happily offshore any position they can.
Jobs don't just exist in a vacuum. They're the result of a relatively complex economy, but growth generally creates jobs. So we should grow.
Bringing in uniquely talented individuals who can distribute expert knowledge accomplishes that.
Bringing an IT worker who does a good JAVA/.Net programming does not accomplish that... right?
Here's some of the high-level effects of bringing international talent of all sorts to the US of year:
1) more talent in the US
2) less talent in other nations
3) the US can ignore pre-university education and opportunity problems
1 and 2 are great for the US government and the top of the US economy, but bad for pretty much everybody else.
3 is pretty awful for a huge number of actual US citizens. Especially given the current state of our nation, this seems like a problem.
I don't believe in "talent". It's all about nurture. If you need more talented people in huge fields for generations, yet half of your nation doesn't have college degrees, the problem is that you are not investing in your people successfully. If we invested more in education and resources for kids, parents, and families from before conception through early childhood and education, we would not have a shortage for fields like... computer science and engineering. These aren't fields that just popped up, they've been a big deal for a century.
Yes - this is active, but not irrational, because this is a reversion to mercantilism of the earlier centuries (it is not a conservative position, but a regressive one).
The only people welcome to this country are "growing things in the ground".
Because if the only thing that you consider to be productive is farming (as in production == farming), then the whole social requirements of education, research or specialization is irrelevant. And in fact, those people are a drain on the food security and profitability of the extractive industry of farming.
Maybe because it is fresh, I was struck by a bit of the lyrics from Hamilton as being a direct reference to this thought that the rest of America is just "moving money around" in the service industries (even the industry, where every stage is just making something from somebody else's raw material, till you get to the Appalachian coal mines).
Don't tax the South 'cause we got it made in the shade /
In Virginia, we plant seeds in the ground /
We create, you just wanna move our money around /
This financial plan is an outrageous demand[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/111th_United_States_Congress#M...
[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/05/22/trump-wan...
Wouldn't lock-downs have resulted in the consulates being required to close in much of the world?
And how much reciprocity is there? Are Americans even allowed to travel to most of the world today? There are stories about schools in places like UK having to charter planes to bring students since it's impossible to get there otherwise. Making this all into a narrative about xenophobic americans seems near-sighted.
H1B was being abused and needed to be reigned in.
There are still plenty of people coming into the country through various means, the US is still extremely generous with immigration.
There are plenty of qualified citizens here and in the zero sum game that is hiring national immigration policy should put their needs first before anyone else's.
Everything I read about it convinces me it's a byzantine and capricious process, and largely down to chance.
My process of gaining permanent residence in the Netherlands is a cakewalk by comparison. University MSc, then free access to the job market for a year, then after some years of employment and passing a relatively simple integration exam, I have long-term European residence. At no point was this up to the arbitrary whims of some immigration officer or a far-fetched lottery chance.
To me the idea that immigration is zero sum is repugnant and wrong.
US is the WORST country on earth for immigration. I came to US >10 years ago, still NOWHERE near getting a Green Card. Will probably won't get well into my 30s or 40s. It's practically impossible to get it in the next 5 years.
The same time I started undergrad in US, my friend started undergrad in Germany. He was already a German citizen by the time we were working. I was still on F visa. This was like half a decade ago.
My biggest regret EVER was doing this in the US. If I got a PhD in Europe instead of US, I wouldn't be a person who doesn't have a country.
I understand that American people don't want immigrants. But let's not pretend immigration into US is easy. I've been trying my entire life to live here without getting kicked out and it's pure luck. One mistake and you need to wrap your entire life, leave loved ones and go back home. Again, I'm NOT saying I'm entitled to living in the US, I'm saying this is an extremely long, and complex process.
This exact sort of anti-competitive nationalism has been tried before, and over and over again it has been abandoned. It's a failed policy that gives other countries a competitive advantage over your own.
It's better to learn from others' mistakes than to repeat them yourself.
Nothing has been reigned in. H1B quota got full early on this year and H1bs were allotted through a lottery of qualified candidates. Transfers are still being allowed. If your argument is that H1B gets abused then right way is to pass a reasonable bill and not blanket ban everything.
Yet again, F1 visa already prohibit students a 100% online school from entering the country. So your impression of immigration being "reigned in" is pretty misguided.
It's going to be good to vote this cycle.
Even if you are anti-immigration, your biggest issue should be tourist visas which is how illegal immigrants stay in the US, and those are unlimited and in the millions. H1B quotas are stupid by design.
(1) F1 visas have been effectively banned in much of the world since COVID started - the required interviews could only be done in now-closed centers. (2) H1B, L1, H4, and J1 visas have been suspended until the end of the year, leaving OPT transfers, H1B lottery winners (already a 1 in 3 shot), H1B transfers, and others in the lurch. (3) RFEs (a first step to visa denials) have been on a steep rise.
As a result, not only are we kicking people out, but international applications to US schools have absolutely collapsed; fewer people are even trying. The US is actively abandoning its goal of being the land of opportunity, and it makes me sad.