News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Int. students may need to leave US if classes are 100% Re... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @01:37PM (#23761794)
Well... 40% of the Fortune 500 had at least one founder that was from an immigrant family. I think that's the precise statement, but I might misunderstand.

That is not the same as saying that 40% of the founders of Fortune 500 companies were immigrants (which I believe is bruceb's point).

To your point: Let's say there were 5 founders. Let's say one was an immigrant. Would the company still have been founded by the other 4, if the immigrant were not there? That's unknown, but one would expect that at least some of the time the answer is "no". Or if it were founded, would it have grown as large as it did? Again, unknown, but in at least some cases the answer is probably "no".

To argue otherwise is to say that founders are replaceable parts - that they have nothing unique to add. That seems... questionable.

Re:Int. students may need to leave US if classes are 100% Re... by belval on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:42PM (#23762584)
I think you are building a straw man from my comment instead of addressing the actual claim, my point is absolutely not about questioning whether the co-founders were relevant to the companies success.

My comment should be read as: I have seen the 40% figure given very often on HN and I did interpret it as 40% of Fortune 500 companies being founded only by first-generation immigrants.

To me someone who was born in a country and has citizenship in that particular country is not an immigrant.

Re:Int. students may need to leave US if classes are 100% Re... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @04:25PM (#23763599)
If that was a strawman, it was unintentional.

But, to your actual point (I hope): I'm inclined to agree with your definition of immigrants. And yet, if we didn't accept the parents, we wouldn't have the children either.

The problem with that argument is, where do you draw the line? One generation? Two? A few decades? A few centuries? If you follow that argument too far, only businesses founded by Native Americans weren't founded by families of immigrants.

I think that categorizing people as immigrants, (first generation) children of immigrants, and non-immigrants makes sense for this discussion. And if "founded by families of immigrants" means first-generation children, that's still to some degree an argument that we want immigrants because of the effect they have on the economy. Not as direct an argument as if they were founded by immigrants, but still something of an argument.