Or maybe the real answer was a coordinated national response.
Why wasn't the NYC cluster confined to NYC or NY state? If the initial lockdown succeeded in killing community transmission in Oregon, how did it start growing again? Most likely from external sources.
Only a national strategy could have made these individual state-level lockdowns worthwhile. Since we didn't have that, the states implemented a haphazard, patchwork of lockdowns that weren't coordinated.
> I doubt anyone will give a shit what the Governor says. Goodwill has been burned through and then some.
Unfortunately you're right about that.
I'm not an expert, but that doesn't seem to be the case.[1]
> interstate commerce clause
I thought that just gave Congress the power to regulate interstate commerce. Again, I'm not a legal expert.
1. https://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2020/03/18/29607...
I am probably wrong about the law used. IANAL.
So if you gave them relief preemptively they'd be OK, right?
In any case, you don't need border closures. Even things like suspending or massively reducing domestic air travel, introducing compulsory self-quarantine upon arrival in a new state etc. might be better than doing nothing. I'm not an expert, but it seems like we never even tried.
The viable model is the Swedish model, schools are open, restaurants are open, nobody wears a mask. What they do is voluntarily keep more distance between people. That's it. that will do it.
The sky has not fallen, they are exactly on the same track as the US.
Sweden and Czech Republic has about the same population, there were strict lockdown measures in the Czech Republic and not much at all in Sweden.
So far 336 people have died in the Czech Republic due to Covid-19, daily cases are ~50. For comaparison Sweden has 5053 dead with daily cases about 500-600.
That does not look like something viable & I'm not sure how are they gonna get out of this with some many daily case & how many more people will have to needlessly die.
If you want to protect old people (and everyone of us will get old eventually) is to make sure they won't get infected, simple as that.
To achieve that, many care homes here locked down much earlier than the state wide lockdown (and in some cases were already in annual flu related lockdown, same thing for many hospitals). In quite a few cases, the care personnel even volunteered to basically camp out at the site to eliminate any possibility of getting the infection in from their homes.
This has been quite effective. The few cases where the infection did get in were pretty brutal, which validates the rather drastic steps taken.
Sweden's seen way more deaths than its neighbors, and being on the same track as the US should be an embarrassment here.
Also, no, that will not do it. That will see a huge fraction of the population infected. Adding masks would help a lot, though.
Maybe the ability to control people coming in and out is more of a commonality than their responses? That is considering their responses looked _nothing alike_. NZ and Japan are basically as opposite as you can get in regards to a response.
How did they do it? All borders closed. Quarantine at home? Well, we’ll post someone to keep an eye on you. Not following the rules? We have a quarantine camp that will work better.
Someone infected on the same floor of your apartment building? Everyone is locked down for 24 hrs (can’t leave your unit). Floor is disinfected and everyone tested.
Vietnam just basically went full throttle using every public health measure they could.
It is only a matter of time before we see community spread a second time, and as in Oregon nothing has materially changed since November. We still have no vaccine or immunity, and we can reasonably expect to see a second outbreak before either appears. The only difference is that Kiwis are unwilling to tolerate a second shut down, and Kiwi businesses don't have the funds to weather another financial hit. Neither does the NZ government, realistically.
Locking down the country was an understandable response, but it does not appear to have achieved anything valuable unless a vaccine becomes available before the next outbreak.
NZ somehow always comes up...
HK never locked up as hard as NZ or Spain or Italy even thou it's a city almost double the size of the country NZ with 420 times the density.
I think the OP’s point is that your goal is immunity and Sweden will get there before NZ will (absent a vaccine). Sweden’s economy will be humming while NZ stays isolated.
Give it a year and we’ll see who did best
Or India? 4x the population, 1/5 the deaths so far. Although they'll catch up eventually - this disease is simply too contagious. But they have a national strategy, everybody is making plays from the same playbook.
> nobody wears a mask
Why not though? If it's been proven to reduce transmission, it seems stupid to not do it.
> that will do it.
All that's done is take the US to the top in lives lost to this disease. If that's where we wanted to end up then mission accomplished, I guess.
> The sky has not fallen, they are exactly on the same track as the US.
See above.
Hoisted by our own petard.
Only 1 death attributed to COVID, making Burundi the country with the fewest deaths per population.
The US is at the top for two reasons, huge and extremely varied country, lots of testing and accountability.
China most likely has had more deaths than the US, they just simply chose not report it, ergo they are all good (and that's what Trump wishes the US could do).
I said they've had a plan and they've tried to fight. Exhibit A: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/may/14/the-coronaviru... It'll ultimately overcome India, but it won't be because they waved the white flag like the US appears to have done.
> China most likely has had more deaths than the US,
China would have to underreport deaths by 20x to approach the American death toll. Covering up that many deaths doesn't seem possible. It makes me feel like you're just arguing in bad faith.
And even if China had exactly as many deaths as the US, they'd still be 3.5x better on a per capita basis. Despite being more densely populated, poorer, and likely having a population with more pre-existing respiratory issues due to more pollution. That's how poorly the US has performed in this whole affair.
Deaths on this scale is hard to hide, even in a state controlled environment. Large cities outside of Wuhan have no seen this. I have colleagues and friends in the big cities and I haven’t heard of anyone catching let alone dying of covid.
Since we "crushed the curve" we've learned what masks are good for, and how they should be used. We've developed a lifesaving protocol for the most sick patients. We've gotten into the summer which plays somewhat in our favor.
In fact, it looks like universal masking and a bit of care is sufficient to get R0<1. Problem solved, eventually. Unfortunately... leadership matters.
How many people died from other, preventable things, while we learned that masks work? Something we knew then, by the way. Just ask any country that dealt with SARS Ver. 1.0
Because they shut down. They observed community spread and they acted appropriately. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/05/04/seattles-leade...
Scientific knowledge is slow and hard to come by, and we didn't know that in February. What we knew was this: Masks don't work for every disease. They don't even work for all coronaviruses. Cloth masks worn by the public can increase transmission of some diseases. SARS-COV2 is not the same as SARS-COV1.
'If it looks like you're overreacting, you're probably doing the right thing' -Fauci https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/03/17/overreacti...
Yep, this right here is the problem. Unfortunately, social media and the 24/7 news cycle (that magnified 100x by social media) has meant that people react strongly to events that have no effect on them, and then go and do things which have no effect on the underlying cause, just because they saw people doing is thousands of miles away.
This is what happened with the COVID lock downs. People panicked when they saw NYC, but there was no reason for most place to lock down (when they did). Far better to wait for a more effective time. But no, you had people slamming governors for doing nothing in states that had very few cases.
This extends to a ton of other causes and problems. See the BLM movement. You have people protesting in countries that have nothing to do with George Floyd and a very different police force, risking their lives and others by spreading covid, because they saw people on the news in another country protesting. Utterly absurd.
Seems to have worked fine, as the average number of cases has been around 50 daily for a couple of weeks, all that while most of the restrictions have been lifted.
So where is the difference ? I think in two aspects: - all the neighboring countries did similar strict lockdown and achieved similar levels of success - we closed our borders to everyone, including preventing residents from going out - the Prague international airport was deserted for month and a half, all international bus and train connections have been shut down & border crossing were guarded by police with army helping out, letting only trucks through
I think this really helped as each country could apply their lockdown separately for a limited period, without worrying about international travel bringing it right back in.
While from what I've read and even been told by people in the US - even is a single US state did a very strict lockdown with potentially huge economical cost - the neighboring state (or in some cases even the next city!) will do hardly anything at all. Combined with no state border lockdown, the strict state will get infections back in from the less responsible areas.
The Czech Republic border is no longer closed, buses and trains go over the borders again & local flights have been reestablished. Still, a version of the border lockdown is still going on, with the Czech Ministry of health maintaining a list of "red" countries, such as for example Sweden or Portugal, that you should not visit but if you do you should go to quarantine and get tested.
I tend to agree with your point, though. Many many areas could likely have been just fine by only restricting large gatherings (concerts, etc), requiring masks, strongly encouraging WFH, and so on. But keep open hair salons, local shops, restaurants (with precautions), etc.
Even in the Bay Area, I can't help but think we shut too much down.
Now that it is raining in the Atacama, we have no political will to do anything.
Edit: I was sassy before I saw your edit :D. High-five on agreeing in principle!
This is tough and it's a bit of a lose-lose situation. Like you said, there's not enough patience or personal savings to stay like this for another 8 months, and any course of action will be highly criticized, regardless of outcome.
If it had, it would have had about half the deaths it eventually did.
Also, NY is about as dense as the US gets, and has way more shared, multi-generational housing than the rest of the US. Also NYC has way more transit usage than any other area in the USA, which was one important vector.
Everyone keeps pretending like the lockdown is the only variable. It isn't!
How many people had covid, self quarantined, and never spread it ... unbeknownst to anyone?
The way exponentials work maybe nobody was saved, or maybe a whole nursing home or a city of old people.
I recall the y2k problem and the hysteria. In the end, nothing happened. But... was it an overreaction, or was it an appropriate reaction seeing that all these companies didn't meltdown financially?
Looking back, it would have made more sense to do the lockdown in phases. Ask every company who can have their employees work from to do so. Track the numbers!
Ok, is it still spreading quickly? Well identify the next round of business that should shutter.
We basically did it all at once and like Oregon, CA was pretty adherent, but I just went for a walk this afternoon and it looks no different than per-Covid.
We basically went from on, to off, to on again.
It was never going to work and people were screaming that at the top of their lungs in March. We were called ghouls or accused of supporting genocide. I am not kidding.
It seems fairly successful so far in China/Korea/Australia etc. Maybe it was never possible with a fractured America filled with selfish idiots. I've completely lost hope in my country for the first time in my life I don't have confidence we can our system can fix itself
The US is not like that at all.
What is appalling that the CDC seemed to be completely clueless to these basic observations, as if it weren't their job to make sane recommendations beyond the "everyone everywhere immediately shut yourself indoors for a few months" (a recommendation imported from China FWIW)
In my state, Oregon, we locked down when there were only a handful of cases, and not much community spread. Most spread was either in long-term care or familial. But we locked down _hard_ and had pretty good compliance. I am talking, standing in the middle of I-5 at noon compliance. Sure you'd have to keep an eye out for trucks from time to time. But still.
We set up surge capacity. Hospitals in Portland set up triage tents and cleared out other beds for a surge...... that never came. A few weeks in, the tents were taken down, the staff was laid off. We sat in our cocoon waiting for something, not sure what. Eventually the pain of being closed started to tick away, and we started reopening...
But nothing materially _changed_ between then and now. We just stopped community spread of an infection nobody really had. We've had less than 6k infections in Oregon. Now we are opening up and guess what? Cases are increasing! We didn't flatten the curve we crushed the curve. So there was no controlled spread, it was just us all feeling proud of ourselves for three months while the poor suffered.
The sneaky lie was that, in a country as big as the US, a flatten the curve strategy was never going to work at a national level. We need community level response.
We locked down Oregon over what was happening in NYC. That is akin to Northern Ireland locking down because of Moscow. That isn't an exaggeration. If anything, it is an understatement.
All of the European countries that we are saying "why can't we be more like them?" all had orders of magnitude more cases than Oregon. So if Oregon quadruples in cases over the next month we are still better off than a lot of nations.
To flatten the curve, there needs to be a damn curve to flatten. Had we waited until there was known, uncontrolled community spread and _then_ shut down, we would have a lot more political will. Now if it gets to that point after three months of being shut down, I doubt anyone will give a shit what the Governor says. Goodwill has been burned through and then some.