News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by glofish on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:04PM (#23621501)
you cannot eradicate this disease unless you turn the nation into China.

The viable model is the Swedish model, schools are open, restaurants are open, nobody wears a mask. What they do is voluntarily keep more distance between people. That's it. that will do it.

The sky has not fallen, they are exactly on the same track as the US.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by m4rtink on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:36PM (#23621834)
The Swedish model is only viable as long as you don't mind killing 4700 extra people.

Sweden and Czech Republic has about the same population, there were strict lockdown measures in the Czech Republic and not much at all in Sweden.

So far 336 people have died in the Czech Republic due to Covid-19, daily cases are ~50. For comaparison Sweden has 5053 dead with daily cases about 500-600.

That does not look like something viable & I'm not sure how are they gonna get out of this with some many daily case & how many more people will have to needlessly die.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by zucker42 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:42PM (#23623391)
I think the point of people advocating the Swedish model is that it's not fair to compare Sweden now with the Czech Republic now. If a country implements strict lockdown measures for three months and then no lockdown measures it might well be it has equal or more deaths a year from now. This will only become a fair comparison at the end of the pandemic.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by mixmastamyk on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @11:41PM (#23623787)
Yes, almost everyone will get it regardless. Sweden simply moved its deaths forward. Whether it was the right thing to do is left as an exercise for next year.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by mnm1 on Thursday June 25, 2020 @03:28AM (#23637824)
Except we already have an effective treatment, dexamethasone. So all those Swedish deaths could have potentially been pushed to now when the mortality rate is lower due to new treatments like dexamethasone. Instead, they were not pushed so they all died. Had they been pushed, a third likely would have survived. So already we know Sweden's strategy is total shit that lead to avoidable deaths.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by mixmastamyk on Friday June 26, 2020 @01:50PM (#23654839)
It's a bit early to assert that given the drug was noted to help just days ago.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by mnm1 on Friday June 26, 2020 @02:19PM (#23655186)
A randomized clinical study involving thousands of patients is not good enough to assert this?
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by virmundi on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:23PM (#23622815)
The Swedish model was exacerbated for the same reason the NYC was. You can’t put old people with the disease in lock down with other old people. You’ll quickly kill them.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by m4rtink on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @08:39AM (#23627172)
Of course you can't do that - anyone infected needs to be isolated and people who were in contact with them as well.

If you want to protect old people (and everyone of us will get old eventually) is to make sure they won't get infected, simple as that.

To achieve that, many care homes here locked down much earlier than the state wide lockdown (and in some cases were already in annual flu related lockdown, same thing for many hospitals). In quite a few cases, the care personnel even volunteered to basically camp out at the site to eliminate any possibility of getting the infection in from their homes.

This has been quite effective. The few cases where the infection did get in were pretty brutal, which validates the rather drastic steps taken.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by dehrmann on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:08AM (#23624966)
When people criticize Sweden, they usually quote the top-line number, leaving out that Sweden's admitted failures were in protecting the elderly and outreach to at-risk immigrant communities.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by austhrow743 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:06PM (#23622692)
Why are you comparing them to the Czech Republic when the commenter was comparing them to the US and saying the US should model them? They're not saying the Czech Republic should model them.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by MengerSponge on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:12PM (#23621577)
This is not true. New Zealand has done an exemplary job. Taiwan has done a fine job. Hong Kong? Japan? South Korea? All democracies. All competent.

Sweden's seen way more deaths than its neighbors, and being on the same track as the US should be an embarrassment here.

Also, no, that will not do it. That will see a huge fraction of the population infected. Adding masks would help a lot, though.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by salmon30salmon on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:20PM (#23621667)
NZ is an island with two big cities, doesn't count. Taiwan is also an island. So is Japan. HK is one technically, I guess. But not really. South Korea is basically an island, since they have a completely closed border with their only land neighbor.

Maybe the ability to control people coming in and out is more of a commonality than their responses? That is considering their responses looked _nothing alike_. NZ and Japan are basically as opposite as you can get in regards to a response.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by refurb on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:37PM (#23621848)
Vietnam has 90M people, a massive land border and only 350 cases (no community spread for 6 weeks now). They are testing like crazy, so it’s not because they aren’t catching them.

How did they do it? All borders closed. Quarantine at home? Well, we’ll post someone to keep an eye on you. Not following the rules? We have a quarantine camp that will work better.

Someone infected on the same floor of your apartment building? Everyone is locked down for 24 hrs (can’t leave your unit). Floor is disinfected and everyone tested.

Vietnam just basically went full throttle using every public health measure they could.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by virmundi on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:41PM (#23622946)
This shows the power of an authoritarian system. Unfortunately we’ve seen other examples of authoritarian systems killing millions more than this disease ever would.
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by m4x on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:21PM (#23622806)
NZ has made a similar mistake to Oregon as described above. We shut down early and hard, practically wiping the disease out with less than 1200 total infections, and totally burning through all the good will required to tolerate a second shut down. Now that we have re-opened, we are seeing new cases appear as Kiwis who were trapped overseas return home, and foreigners visit for "essential" business.

It is only a matter of time before we see community spread a second time, and as in Oregon nothing has materially changed since November. We still have no vaccine or immunity, and we can reasonably expect to see a second outbreak before either appears. The only difference is that Kiwis are unwilling to tolerate a second shut down, and Kiwi businesses don't have the funds to weather another financial hit. Neither does the NZ government, realistically.

Locking down the country was an understandable response, but it does not appear to have achieved anything valuable unless a vaccine becomes available before the next outbreak.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by kmlx on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:39PM (#23621878)
new zealand's total population is less than nyc. also an island 5h flight from australia.

NZ somehow always comes up...

HK never locked up as hard as NZ or Spain or Italy even thou it's a city almost double the size of the country NZ with 420 times the density.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by kalleboo on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:04AM (#23624296)
Japan's response was not competent at all. Basically every news article about how Japan managed to deal with the virus is "dunno, they must have gotten lucky?"
Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by refurb on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:34PM (#23621815)
NZ has the benefit of having 1,000 miles of ocean between them and everyone else. Very easy to isolate.

I think the OP’s point is that your goal is immunity and Sweden will get there before NZ will (absent a vaccine). Sweden’s economy will be humming while NZ stays isolated.

Give it a year and we’ll see who did best

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by triceratops on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:09PM (#23621551)
> you cannot eradicate this disease unless you turn the nation into China.

Or India? 4x the population, 1/5 the deaths so far. Although they'll catch up eventually - this disease is simply too contagious. But they have a national strategy, everybody is making plays from the same playbook.

> nobody wears a mask

Why not though? If it's been proven to reduce transmission, it seems stupid to not do it.

> that will do it.

All that's done is take the US to the top in lives lost to this disease. If that's where we wanted to end up then mission accomplished, I guess.

> The sky has not fallen, they are exactly on the same track as the US.

See above.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by salmon30salmon on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @07:29PM (#23621768)
We also have a much higher life expectancy than India. One of the theories as to why Africa has not been hit is that they have far fewer old people.

Hoisted by our own petard.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by glofish on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:41PM (#23622476)
Yeah like Burundi. They ran 300 test.

Only 1 death attributed to COVID, making Burundi the country with the fewest deaths per population.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by glofish on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:37PM (#23622433)
India? You think they have the disease under control?

The US is at the top for two reasons, huge and extremely varied country, lots of testing and accountability.

China most likely has had more deaths than the US, they just simply chose not report it, ergo they are all good (and that's what Trump wishes the US could do).

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by triceratops on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:34PM (#23623333)
> India? You think they have the disease under control?

I said they've had a plan and they've tried to fight. Exhibit A: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/may/14/the-coronaviru... It'll ultimately overcome India, but it won't be because they waved the white flag like the US appears to have done.

> China most likely has had more deaths than the US,

China would have to underreport deaths by 20x to approach the American death toll. Covering up that many deaths doesn't seem possible. It makes me feel like you're just arguing in bad faith.

And even if China had exactly as many deaths as the US, they'd still be 3.5x better on a per capita basis. Despite being more densely populated, poorer, and likely having a population with more pre-existing respiratory issues due to more pollution. That's how poorly the US has performed in this whole affair.

Re:California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulativ... by yibg on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:25PM (#23622834)
There maybe some merit to the claim that China is under reporting, but I haven’t seen any claim that they are under reporting by that much.

Deaths on this scale is hard to hide, even in a state controlled environment. Large cities outside of Wuhan have no seen this. I have colleagues and friends in the big cities and I haven’t heard of anyone catching let alone dying of covid.