Compound this with the total lack of quality control in garment manufacture and you begin to see why shopping is such an ordeal. The same brand and fit (model?) of pants from Dockers, Levis or the Gap will fit you differently, depending on the color of the fabric. Typically, the darker the color of the garment, the more snug the fit. Sounds ridiculous, right? Lighter fabrics tend to relax out more. It's all about the fabric content. Raise your hand if you've ever washed something and had it either get smaller or bigger, or become completely misshapen. Quality control is done on the first hundred or so garments that come out of the factory. After that, it's a free-for-all.
People don't know what suits them because there is a very real learning curve to the whole process of getting yourself dressed. This is why most women shop and dress in groups. Institutional knowledge is hugely valuable. So is a cloth tape measure.
I watch What Not To Wear. They make it look easy. Then they make it look hard (the "victim" almost always cries). Because drama sells. But behind the scenes is an entire staff of people who follow fashion trends, understand a great deal about ready to wear garments and know where to go and what it costs. That's a full time job. Nobody has that kind of time, and it's a barrier to entry.
Not caring about what kind of statement our clothes make is a learned behavior. The fashion industry does not care about the happiness of the customer. If you don't believe me, find a girl who won't slap you for it and ask her about her bra. So if they don't care, why should we?
This saves me time in the store and also makes the decision less agonizing since I can make it over a few days.
So, yeah, you're probably dead on about how 'wrong fit' can be interpreted.
IRL, you get people who miss their measurement unit (cm or inches seem to be complicated). Or they misunderstand instructions and thus just enter 10 cm while they should enter 10.5 cm.
However, there are online stores for custom made shirts (with lots of measurements) and it sometimes works, depending on the dedication on the user's side.
Also, try doing the first few shirts individually (typically there are discounts for buying 4-5 at a time). You may need to have 1-2 great-but-not-perfect shirts first. But once you nail the measurement, it's easy from there on out.
Believe this: tailors aren't just for fancy clothes and they aren't expensive. I take all of my jeans to my tailor and have them hemmed to the exact length of my legs because not a single clothing manufacturer makes clothing that fits my length!
http://www.esquire.com/blogs/mens-fashion/pants-size-chart-0...
So it doesn't surprise me that there's "vanity sizing" in men's trousers. Not even a little bit. This, too, makes for a tough call when it comes to getting dressed. Camel toe or saggy butt? Hm.
(eta: sorry for devolving this discussion into a rant on ready to wear clothing)
Anecdotal point, I bought a pair of black jeans from the Gap (4 months ago), having tried on several other colors of the same model (size/cut), each fitting different. Since I could not find an identical fitting pair in another color, I decided to get a second pair of black jeans (exact same).
Being paranoid, I decided to try on the second pair before purchasing, and it fit differently than the first.
I decided to try on the first pair again to make sure I was not going crazy. Exact same pants, exact same UPC, different fit.
If I can find a good piece of clothing that fits me well, I tend to purchase several of them at once (in the same exact color/style).
You have a "style expert" who you meet with over Skype video. They send you a box of clothes to try on and review with your expert over Skype video. Any items you don't like or don't fit you put back in the box and send back. They include the return shipping label in the box so you just have to put the label on tape up the box and have FedEx pick it up. You only pay for the items you keep (no shipping charges or extra fees). They try to make the process as painless as possible.
Over time as you meet with your style expert, it's always the same person, and get to know each other they get a better sense for what you like and don't like as well as keeping track of things such as sizes and fits. They also recommend what things work well together so you know what things to wear together, etc. They have definitely pushed me out of my t-shirt and jeans comfort zone, without going to fashionista or anything.
The primary drawback is my clothes budget is definitely higher than it use to be, as most of the clothes are significantly more expensive (no $20 dollar jeans) as they tend to come from more boutique and small manufacturers.
While that probably sounds an awful lot like an advertisement I have no connection with Hendricks Park other than as a happy customer.
Two things that stand out and (deliberately) separate this site from the casual online shop experience:
"Hendricks Park is a _luxury clothing_ service for men who have better things to do with their time than shop for clothing."
"Men who enjoy and value our service the most, tend to buy at least $1,250 in clothing per season."
Specifically, should a man using this service budget $5,000 a year for clothing?
Seems like others might be drawn to this if they didn't have to shell out $200 for a pair of jeans each time. I definitely get the desire for premiere clothing/shopping just wondering if it can scale down the price line and still work.
Thanks for the rad feedback. I appreciate it. It'll make my product a lot better.
You're right, shopping online is different. But despite this, shopping online is a billion dollar industry that doesn't show any signs of being slowed down simply because it isn't taking place in person. I think if women (who, arguably, are more obsessed with fit/feel/etc. than guys) can shop online then there's definitely a way to make it work for men. That's what I plan on doing.
Also, great point about clothing serving as a symbol or a form of self-expression. I think you're spot-on about programmer types making the statement, "I don't really care about clothes," but a) it assumes everyone is making the same statement, which is problematic (we can't ALL have the same message to express since we have such a diversity of experiences in how we perceive the world) and b) it eliminates the possibility that a typical geeky dude never wants to look good, which I would argue isn't the case.
Nevertheless, great points and I appreciate them all.
Buying something online really lacks any information on how the clothes will fit. There's basically that old saying and I don't see how it can be solved when buying online "wear the suit, don't let the suit wear you." If you could get the site set up to find locations near the user where these suggested clothes can be tried on/purchased then I think the site could be very useful.
As it is I was already interested enough to try to go to dress.me and sign up (only to find out it doesn't exist yet), however I wouldn't be willing to pay for it. If I could get a discount on the clothes the site suggested by being a paying member, then I may be willing to pay for it (but then it comes back to the conundrum I've already mentioned).
I only have one piece of constructive feedback, which I hope you will pay some heed: Men have fragile egos. You should be wary of saying "Because guys hate shopping" or suggesting in any way that men do not have a sense of style. Yes, many (maybe even most) guys do not have any sense of style, or might hate the whole shopping experience. But I guarantee that using this sort of language as your tag-line (or 30-second elevator pitch) will turn away just as many guys from your site as it catches.
My suggestion is that you simply tout the benefits of this suggestion-based shopping. It's an obviously great idea, which I am backing 100%. Sell them on the benefits without making claims which will hurt their egos.
You'd say the same thing about jewelry (BlueNile.com: 58M quarterly revenue) and shoes (Zappos.com: bought by Amazon for ~$1B).
(note: I edited this to say "jewelry" instead of "diamonds")- I agree loose diamonds are a commodity. An wedding ring you're going to wear the rest of your life is something I'd imagine people would want to see/wear before buying)
I don't think that's the barrier for clothes.
Shoes are a closer analogy. I would be very interested in seeing an answer to this question to those who buy/bought from Zappos:
When you buy shoes from Zappos, are you buying a style or shoe that you've previously tried on or bought?
Also, I think women's shoes are a different market to men's shoes. Women I think almost take it for granted that shoes, particularly dress/fashionable shoes, will be uncomfortable.
Again I take a utilitarian view to shoes. I have a hard time finding a pair that fits nicely. I'll buy lightweight runners/sneakers/joggers (depending on your lexicon) and then wear them virtually every day until they fall apart and I buy a new pair.
I imagine I am not alone in this.
In particular, it cannot be overstated how important a good return policy is. It's also bizarre how many companies get it wrong.
Example: I bought some stuff from Bed, Bath and Beyond a month or two ago. I realized I'd gotten the wrong thing. By this time I'd misplaced the receipt. I was expecting a hassle when I went back to the store. I walk up to the service counter and ask what the return policy is. The women behind the counter says they have a no hassle return policy.
She said she could give me store credit no problem or, if I preferred, she could look up the receipt on the system with my credit card. If she could find it, she'd give me a refund instead. She did in fact find it. I didn't have to produce any annoying pieces of paper nor justify why I was returning the item.
After that incident I went and spent another $150 in comfort knowing that if what I bought didn't work out I could return it.
So my advice for anyone dealing with physical goods: make it as easy as possible to return goods and customers will spend more. Make them love your store/website/whatever.
Online clothing stores need an innovation like this.
My girlfriend (and me to a certain extent) generally returns around 50% of her ASOS purchases after trying them on at home. You can return them in the same bag, have them picked up or drop them to any Collect Plus (http://www.collectplus.co.uk) location.
The delivery is fast. The prices are ok. So far I have never returned my shoes. They all fit perfectly and customer service is great!
But you need an expert, I don't think this is solvable on line.
[1] http://www.truthaboutdiamonds.com/truth-about/james-allen-bl...
"Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond?" is also interesting reading. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/print/1982/02/have-you-e...
Shoes are slightly different than clothes. While fits do vary slightly, it's not even remotely close to the variations in clothing. Online shoe shopping also produces better results than clothing. Things like feel aren't are varied either and the details are not nearly as important. I wouldn't buy expensive shoes online, but for most types of shoes, I much prefer online vs. b&m. Partially because of variety and partly because of my size (13 US).
Contrast this to my online clothes shopping habits, where probably at least 50% of my purchases are returned.
However, this can and should be bundled with a more assertive counseling activity: "we're not going to force anything down your throat; however, if you're not satisfied with the way you're perceived, and you think your clothing style is part of the problem, we might have some suggestion to offer".
Counselling should itself be structured in two levels:
* generic help for free ("If you have $PHYSICAL_FEATURE and want to be perceived as more $QUALITY, you should chose clothes which have $CRITERION. Beware that $CONTRAINDICATION". Could be raw text with a couple of diagrams, could be something more interactive)
* referral to one-to-one counselors, with a commission on their fee.
However, it sounds like a real problem, with real solutions to be provided, to people willing to pay for it (nobody expects to get clothes for free, no freemium competitor will undercut you), and with enough diversification possibilities to find one successful way to grow. As always, and especially for very personal services, flawless execution matters much more than the initial idea.
Most online clothes shops I've seen have a really good return policy and free postage. They encourage you to order more then you need, and as well different sizes. So you effectively get sent a whole bunch of stuff to try. You try it on, keep what you like and send the rest back for a refund. It's even better when you're ordering online from shops that have a physical presence as you can just take it back to the store and get a refund instantly.
They were able to base their successful decisions on that assumption. Like using same-day shipping. Sending multiple clothes for the price of one to allow them to use the one that fits both them and the occasion. And more recently, including any accessories that can go with their choices.
I think some of these ideas can be generalized. As a shopping service, you can overcome all three barriers by sending multiple clothes based on the "this or that" questions. Or current trends. Or a both. This allows the buyer to make their final decisions within the comfort of their own homes. They can then send back all but the clothes they keep, if any.
I'm pretty certain men won't use this service for renting (though what do I know, I haven't tested this assumption), but treating it as such, you anticipate returns to be normal. The service can possibly learn what works for recurring customers (what fits, what general style they keep, etc), and lower the return rate. Furthermore, it can find trends in the "this or that" questions vs return rate to better predict as to what will be kept. It can even make fashion suggestions and educate on the subject via email/blog. I think us geeks would be more open to fashion advice if there were theory and stats to back it up (well, I would anyway; there's mountains of theory behind design, why not fashion?). Translate the emotional into the technical. Base suggestions on what both visually pleases the crowd and feels good to the indifferent individual.
Does this sound any more feasible?
Nothing to try, nothing to see, just buy and wear.
Oh, and Hanes tagless white t-shirts XL
Oh, and Nike slippers 10'
That's my basic outfit 24/7 and I can buy it all online.
Also, by asking the user to choose something he knows he's comfortable in, the website can get really interesting metrics to help determine the good size.
Finally, I guess it's always possible to give more detailed metrics of you (how much you weight, height, arms length, etc.). So, basically, it could be optional but if you're willing to spend a little time measuring it, it could be of a tremendous help. In fact, if I knew I could avoid big stores by taking a few measure of me, I'd do it right now.
People who are models generally fall within a certain range of sizes, but it's still impossible to predict perfectly what will fit them, and you might not even have all the sizes available.
What I would like to see is specific measurements of the garment. The distance from the collar to the bottom of the shirt, the width at the bottom of the shirt, the width of the arms, etc. The few standard measurements that are usually provided with a dress shirt or a pair of pants are a good start, but they aren't nearly enough to judge fit. I've had shirts custom made (via the internet) that use the reverse of this process, where I provide them all sorts of different measurements and they make the garment to fit. They all fit very well, so I have hope that making this information available could help with the fit problem.
The real question is whether there is a correlation between clothes and programming language choice. Do lisp users wear highly functional clothing that's really ugly to look at? :)
And they are simply always stylish, fit perfectly and you can hardly go wrong in them. Right? RIGHT???
Hence:
1 suit
3 proper shirts
3 pairs of jeans
10 black t-shirts
1. Looking at photos is not the same as looking at the real thing;
2. Clothes are more than just the look. How they feel is also important;
3. You obviously can't try clothes on online. You can (and really need to) in a store. I have clothes that fit ranging from M to XL depending on the brand and style.
So there are those barriers to overcome. There are additional issues.
First, I read the dress.me blurb and it says that when you signup it asks you several "this or that" questions. A theoretically reasonable approach but one doomed to failure.
The reason is that people (men in particular) don't know what suits them. When someone says they like something, it means they're accustomed to it. This is a key point service providers like this need to understand.
It's why you see people seemingly trapped 10, 20, 30+ years ago with their haircuts, shoes and clothes. Typically this is how they looked and what they wore when they were teenagers and in their 20s. That sort of thing sticks because it's what they knew growing up (much like musical tastes tend to be) or even it's just the nostalgic angle: that style takes them back to probably what were more easygoing days.
Second, there are an awful lot of men--we geeks are particularly guilty of this--who have a completely utilitarian view to pretty much everything, including clothes. There's a reason the programmer stereotype is t-shirts and jeans. These clothes are comfortable, require very little maintenance, are cheap and require very little thought.
Clothes, like many things, are a statement about who you are as a person. Pretty much everything we do is some form of expression of who we are. This is even true of things like programming language choice.
So the problem we geeks have in particular is that we don't generally care about what kind of statement our clothes make, which in and of itself is a statement.
Anyway, watch any of the makeover shows that are on TV. Whether they be for men or women you will see the first thing the self-appointed style gurus will do is beat them out of their old habits into things that actually suit them. Asking them what they like would get you nowhere.
This is also why the cliche exists of women shopping for men. I think women are probably more naturally inclined to the "group" aspect of pretty much all forms of self-expression, clothes being just one. Just watch a woman--particularly a young woman--get dressed for anything and you'll quickly realize it's a group not a solo activity deciding what to wear.
Sites like this I think are seductive to those who start them, much like dating sites are. It seems like it should be easy, right? I think the reality has proven and will continue to prove otherwise, at least until these fundamental problems are somehow addressed.
The true meaning of "I hate shopping" is more likely to be "I hate making decisions about things I don't know about, care about or both." The "knowing" part can probably be fixed. The "caring" part is a much bigger problem.