In particular, it cannot be overstated how important a good return policy is. It's also bizarre how many companies get it wrong.
Example: I bought some stuff from Bed, Bath and Beyond a month or two ago. I realized I'd gotten the wrong thing. By this time I'd misplaced the receipt. I was expecting a hassle when I went back to the store. I walk up to the service counter and ask what the return policy is. The women behind the counter says they have a no hassle return policy.
She said she could give me store credit no problem or, if I preferred, she could look up the receipt on the system with my credit card. If she could find it, she'd give me a refund instead. She did in fact find it. I didn't have to produce any annoying pieces of paper nor justify why I was returning the item.
After that incident I went and spent another $150 in comfort knowing that if what I bought didn't work out I could return it.
So my advice for anyone dealing with physical goods: make it as easy as possible to return goods and customers will spend more. Make them love your store/website/whatever.
Online clothing stores need an innovation like this.
My girlfriend (and me to a certain extent) generally returns around 50% of her ASOS purchases after trying them on at home. You can return them in the same bag, have them picked up or drop them to any Collect Plus (http://www.collectplus.co.uk) location.
The delivery is fast. The prices are ok. So far I have never returned my shoes. They all fit perfectly and customer service is great!
Shoes are a closer analogy. I would be very interested in seeing an answer to this question to those who buy/bought from Zappos:
When you buy shoes from Zappos, are you buying a style or shoe that you've previously tried on or bought?
Also, I think women's shoes are a different market to men's shoes. Women I think almost take it for granted that shoes, particularly dress/fashionable shoes, will be uncomfortable.
Again I take a utilitarian view to shoes. I have a hard time finding a pair that fits nicely. I'll buy lightweight runners/sneakers/joggers (depending on your lexicon) and then wear them virtually every day until they fall apart and I buy a new pair.
I imagine I am not alone in this.