Shoes are a closer analogy. I would be very interested in seeing an answer to this question to those who buy/bought from Zappos:
When you buy shoes from Zappos, are you buying a style or shoe that you've previously tried on or bought?
Also, I think women's shoes are a different market to men's shoes. Women I think almost take it for granted that shoes, particularly dress/fashionable shoes, will be uncomfortable.
Again I take a utilitarian view to shoes. I have a hard time finding a pair that fits nicely. I'll buy lightweight runners/sneakers/joggers (depending on your lexicon) and then wear them virtually every day until they fall apart and I buy a new pair.
I imagine I am not alone in this.
In particular, it cannot be overstated how important a good return policy is. It's also bizarre how many companies get it wrong.
Example: I bought some stuff from Bed, Bath and Beyond a month or two ago. I realized I'd gotten the wrong thing. By this time I'd misplaced the receipt. I was expecting a hassle when I went back to the store. I walk up to the service counter and ask what the return policy is. The women behind the counter says they have a no hassle return policy.
She said she could give me store credit no problem or, if I preferred, she could look up the receipt on the system with my credit card. If she could find it, she'd give me a refund instead. She did in fact find it. I didn't have to produce any annoying pieces of paper nor justify why I was returning the item.
After that incident I went and spent another $150 in comfort knowing that if what I bought didn't work out I could return it.
So my advice for anyone dealing with physical goods: make it as easy as possible to return goods and customers will spend more. Make them love your store/website/whatever.
Online clothing stores need an innovation like this.
My girlfriend (and me to a certain extent) generally returns around 50% of her ASOS purchases after trying them on at home. You can return them in the same bag, have them picked up or drop them to any Collect Plus (http://www.collectplus.co.uk) location.
The delivery is fast. The prices are ok. So far I have never returned my shoes. They all fit perfectly and customer service is great!
But you need an expert, I don't think this is solvable on line.
[1] http://www.truthaboutdiamonds.com/truth-about/james-allen-bl...
"Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond?" is also interesting reading. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/print/1982/02/have-you-e...
Shoes are slightly different than clothes. While fits do vary slightly, it's not even remotely close to the variations in clothing. Online shoe shopping also produces better results than clothing. Things like feel aren't are varied either and the details are not nearly as important. I wouldn't buy expensive shoes online, but for most types of shoes, I much prefer online vs. b&m. Partially because of variety and partly because of my size (13 US).
Contrast this to my online clothes shopping habits, where probably at least 50% of my purchases are returned.
You'd say the same thing about jewelry (BlueNile.com: 58M quarterly revenue) and shoes (Zappos.com: bought by Amazon for ~$1B).
(note: I edited this to say "jewelry" instead of "diamonds")- I agree loose diamonds are a commodity. An wedding ring you're going to wear the rest of your life is something I'd imagine people would want to see/wear before buying)
I don't think that's the barrier for clothes.