News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by ksec on Thursday June 11, 2020 @05:41PM (#23493574)
Every time I criticise Intel, Or more like pointing out facts , supporters will always use Jim Keller as the excuse, as if he was the silver bullet.

Intel's struggle has nothing to do with is processors' design. Sunny Cove and Willow Cove ( aka Icelake and TigerLake ) were close to design complete before Jim Keller joined. Intel's problem is with their manufacturing, both technical and economical. And Jim Keller is not a Fab guy, nothing he could do to fix this.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by wmf on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:29PM (#23493948)
The great man theory of chip design. In a few months we'll get a ton of the "Xe sucks because Raja's GPUs are always too hot" theory.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by CoolGuySteve on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:47AM (#23496694)
He lovingly lays each atom and then kisses each box gently before it heads out the door.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by tw04 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:29PM (#23493949)
Process didn’t cause all the security holes implemented as performance hacks, architecture did. AMD caught up through architecture, process was just icing on the cake.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by etaioinshrdlu on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:21AM (#23496570)
No one thought of speculative execution and hypertheading as performance hacks until the last few years. They were brilliant techniques. They still are, they just were found to have a cost. They are still used now but more carefully.

Intel Management Engine and SGX on the other hand, are basically user-hostile parts of the hardware, with some bugs mixed in.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by wolfgke on Friday June 12, 2020 @03:49AM (#23497032)
> No one thought of speculative execution and hypertheading as performance hacks until the last few years.

"Everybody" who has some knowledge in security (espcially with respect to side channels) knew from beginning that these CPU features were a ticking time bomb in terms of potential side channels.

What was unclear was how this (at this time played down by CPU vendors) potential threat could be used to create real attacks.

Going from potential threat (that "everybody" knew about) to real attack is the central achievement of the authors of the Spectre and Meltdown attacks (and their successors).

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by legulere on Saturday June 13, 2020 @05:05PM (#23512726)
That’s not the impression that I got. Research on side channels were basically limited to timing side channels in cryptography. Everything else was not seen as practically exploitable.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by wolfgke on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:46AM (#23525948)
> Everything else was not seen as practically exploitable.

For a concrete blog post, see https://cyber.wtf/2017/07/28/negative-result-reading-kernel-...

Note that according to https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Spectre_(security... Spectre was published January 2018, i.e. this blog post is indeed older.

As I wrote: It was unclear how this potential threat could be used to create real attacks.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by majewsky on Friday June 12, 2020 @03:40AM (#23497000)
ME is exactly what Intel's data center customers want. It's only present in consumer CPUs because it doesn't scale to have separate ME and non-ME SKUs.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by jimbob45 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:17PM (#23493857)
Why do you say their problem is based in manufacturing?
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by The_Colonel on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:22PM (#23493891)
They have been working on the 10nm manufacturing process for ages and it's still not completely finished. That gave AMD huge opportunity to catch up (which it did).
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by londons_explore on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:53PM (#23494080)
Nothing stops Intel manufacturing their designs with third parties. Yet they don't.

Either it isn't worth it (too much coupling between fab and designs - not the right abstractions), or institutional inertia stops them doing it.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by jabl on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:41AM (#23496674)
IIRC most of Intel's expenses are related to the fabs and semiconductor R&D. The chip designs (the computer architecture part that gets computer people excited) is almost a rounding error on top of that. From that perspective Intel designs chips so that they can sell the silicon real estate they manufacture, not the other way around (that they have fabs so they can realize their chip design ambitions).

So if they would fab their chips somewhere else, they would be sitting on a huge expensive asset producing nothing. If they couldn't find a productive use for their fabs it would likely mean the end of the company. And if they can't produce their own chips in their own fabs, why would anyone else want to use Intel fabs?

Further, the vertical integration of fab process and chip design is something Intel regards as a competitive advantage. For a long time this was very much true, but it seems the hard work by TSMC and others have made it possible to make top-end chip designs on a merchant foundry process nowadays.

Intel at some point tried to play the merchant foundry game, but it seems it wasn't successful and they shut it down. Which perhaps isn't that unsurprising, considering TSMC, and to a lesser extent Globalfoundries, have been at that game for decades and they're good at it.

So all in all, I don't think fabbing their chips at some third party is a viable approach for Intel. Either they fix their process or they go under. "Go under" not necessarily meaning bankruptcy, it could also mean a massively, hugely downsized company doing chip designs to be fabbed at some third party. I think they're still far away from such a drastic step.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by theevilsharpie on Thursday June 11, 2020 @08:40PM (#23494784)
> Nothing stops Intel manufacturing their designs with third parties. Yet they don't.

It wouldn't surprise me if the reason Keller left is because he wanted to outsource manufacturing to a competitive third party fab, and got denied.

Keller is an a computer architect, but architecture doesn't matter if you can't physically build the thing.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by olliej on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:27AM (#23496597)
I'm not a hardware engineer/cpu designer/electrical engineer, but my understanding is that designing high end cpus requires engineering and designing towards the specific manufacturing process of the fabs you're using. Even if intel did decide to, I don't think they could just send their designs to tsmc/global foundries or what have you.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by jabl on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:48AM (#23496697)
Not my expertise either, but it seems that the advantages of vertical integrations between fabbing and chip design being large was the "common wisdom" in the industry for a long time. But it seems that lately AMD/NVIDIA/TSMC and others have demonstrated that fabless chip companies and merchant foundries is a model capable of producing the highest end chips as well.

And yes, if for some reason Intel would want to fab their chips at some merchant foundry (see my sibling answer to yours why I think that's unlikely, but just for the sake of argument), I'm quite sure they couldn't just email the RTL's to the foundry and get chips back. It would take a lot of work to adapt the chips to the merchant foundry's process.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by ksec on Friday June 12, 2020 @05:15AM (#23497459)
They cant, they will need to redesign the whole thing with new rules, mask and testing. Not to mention using tools that likely Intel is extremely unfamiliar with. ( At least their CPU teams.)

It is more of a cost/ economical issues, which jabl above provides a decent explanation.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by fomine3 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:40PM (#23495460)
Ice Lake outperforms Zen2 in IPC but it can't run on higher clock speed (on efficiently) and can't ship many chips. Many of it is due to 10nm manufacturing.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by ReticentVole on Friday June 12, 2020 @01:47AM (#23496409)
Intel's problem is that they fired expensive, older American workers and replaced them with H1B contractors.

There's a video on AdoredTV about the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agxSclh27uo

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by markus_zhang on Friday June 12, 2020 @07:54AM (#23498302)
But, but it's good for the stock price!
[dead]
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by KKKKkkkk1 on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:37AM (#23496652)
As someone who used to hold an H-1B visa I can confirm that they are one of the dominant factors that brought Silicon Valley to where it is today. Workers on H-1B visas are fearful and obedient. Despotic managers who love to cut corners without being held to account thrive on such a workforce.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by harichinnan on Friday June 12, 2020 @12:05PM (#23500574)
It might be your personal anecdote. I know many H1B employees who are well paid and not fearful or obedient.

Different cultures have different ways of being courteous and showing respect to others(elderly). You must've had some misunderstandings based on your own. Silicon Valley has been a dominant force. Many H1B employees contributed to the valley's success.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by jsf01 on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:19AM (#23496561)
It’s not about race—it’s about a shitty corporate culture. Within Intel there are full-time employees (blue badges) and contractors (green badges). Intel has shifted towards hiring more green badges while paying them less, offering them fewer benefits, and in general treating them worse in comparison to the full-time blue badges. And yes, many green badges are working for Intel under H1B visas. Because of the poor working conditions, there isn’t a great incentive for green badges to be doing their best work. Meanwhile, blue badges become proportionally fewer in number within the company.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by harichinnan on Friday June 12, 2020 @12:00PM (#23500531)
I agree it's shitty culture to color code employee badges and subject a set of people to humiliation. I've worked as an employee and a contractor. We all will at some point in our career. You can't judge someone's integrity to work or competence by the color of the badge they are wearing. H1B employees do compete for IT jobs and win them over Americans. But that's because of interview performance and skills. There's enough data for anyone who wants to find out on how H1B employees are paid.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by ashtonkem on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:04AM (#23496485)
Often the problem isn’t nation of origin, it’s the nature of the training given from one generation to the next and knowledge transfer.

My father used to work in Hughes in some areas that required American citizens by US law; he regularly told stories of someone in a department retiring before replacements had been hired for knowledge transfer, causing lost time and knowledge.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by arein2 on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:10AM (#23496510)
The mood of the country is racist propaganda

I mean a lot of things are obvious, why pretend they are not

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by harichinnan on Friday June 12, 2020 @12:10PM (#23500634)
Police killing black men is no longer racist propaganda. It's a reality of life for black people.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by specialist on Friday June 12, 2020 @10:41AM (#23499679)
25+ years ago in Redmond, most of the H1B were Europeans.

The criticisms haven't changed. Just the available sources of cheapest labor.

Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by harichinnan on Friday June 12, 2020 @12:08PM (#23500610)
If you worked in Microsoft, you would know the H1B employees never came cheap. If you were dreaming of reaching Wall Street salaries in Redmond, then that's a mismatch in expectations. Microsoft was always making software for around the world. If American didn't have H1B program, they would've simply expanded the dev centers in Asia and Europe rather than pay Wall Street salaries in Redmond.
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by specialist on Friday June 12, 2020 @12:27PM (#23500822)
How does this relate to your statement that criticism of H1B is racist propaganda?
Re:Jim Keller to Depart Intel by deathgrips on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:46AM (#23496688)
If this statement didn't have racist intent, how would you know?