News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by zw123456 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @12:26PM (#23440289)
This is actually a pretty good explanation of why mm-wave is safe. An inside joke in the industry is that mm-wave can't propagate it's way out of a wet paper bag. Which is quite literally true. One might wonder then, what is the attraction of using a band that has such limited propagation properties ? The answer is that wireless technology is reaching the Shannon limit, that is to say 4G/LTE is approaching the physical limit of how much information can be packed into a Mhz of spectrum. The solution is to use beam forming. If you can dedicate the entire spectrum to a single user by forming a highly directional beam between the user and the tower then you can dramatically increase the capacity (hence throughput). But to do that you would need an enormous antenna. The laws of physics say that the beam width is inversely proportional to the size of the antenna for a given wavelength. If one were to try to create a 1 degree beam width using sub 6Ghz you would need a 12ft diameter (or square) antenna. Obviously that is not practical. But if you use a smaller wavelength then you can focus a tiny beam to a single user with a 1ft antenna. The trade off is short wavelength such as mm-wave have very little penetrating ability. So you have to place a lot of base stations all over the place. Expensive yes, but you get whopping through puts. But.. the signal could not penetrate it's way out of a wet paper bag, or through walls, or skin, or anything just about.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by 0xDEEPFAC on Saturday June 06, 2020 @12:43PM (#23440420)
Ignoring the potential health concerns. 5G antennas need to be placed on every single city block low and close to people to be effective - so it is hopeless for a majority of the US not directly in a city unless we litter the entire suburbs and small towns in addition to our cities with Huawai equipment.

And again, what is all of this for? Faster downloads of instagram photos? I don't get it. How about starting with infrastructure projects that matter like fiber - some people in the US only have DSL as an option...

Following the Chinese WHO debacle and how much faith I have in the phone industry I, personally, don't believe the hype and the studies they produce even if they deem it "safe."

Re:5G is perfectly fine by zw123456 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:38PM (#23440869)
Actually, because of the low propagation properties, mm-wave 5G network is mostly fiber. The signal can only travel a few hundred feet, the rest is fiber. Why ? The most expensive part of fiber is the last few hundred feet. Also, the antennas being so small, don't necessarily have to be on a large pole. Also they use phased array antennas that electronically steer the signal so they can be mounted on light poles that might sway a little but it can be compensated for. BTW, Huawei equipment is not being used by any of the major carriers in the US (or any that I am aware of). The mm-wave signal is safer than wifi. Remember, you microwave oven using 2.4Ghz to cook your food, same band as wifi.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by gsich on Saturday June 06, 2020 @08:25PM (#23443583)
>Remember, you microwave oven using 2.4Ghz to cook your food, same band as wifi.

Which was chosen because of the size factor. Other frequencies would also be able to cook food.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Raphael_Amiard on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:31PM (#23441294)
So, what you're saying is that 5g is basically an improved wifi? (Shortish range so uses another transport, very good throughput)
Re:5G is perfectly fine by DoofusOfDeath on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:52PM (#23441776)
Could someone explain why the sibling comment is flagged and dead? I don't have any background in this area, so it's not obvious to me what's wrong with the comment.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by akvadrako on Sunday June 07, 2020 @04:29AM (#23445764)
It looks like just a list of papers, almost definitely either irrelevant or bad science. This kind of thing is very common and it’s not worth the time to investigate it.

If someone wants to show that 5g is dangerous they need to first demonstrate they understand why those claims aren’t taken seriously.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by GregoryVPerry on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:59PM (#23441833)
>The mm-wave signal is safer than wifi.

This is completely not true, and the foregoing article ignores numerous aspects of the potential health concerns of millimeter wave radiation in the 95Ghz area of the spectrum.

1) 95Ghz millimeter wave provably and without question has the potential for adverse affects on human tissue. Active Denial Systems (https://jnlwp.defense.gov/About/Frequently-Asked-Questions/A... for example) use 95Mhz directed energy for so-called Non Lethal Weapons technology. This is not complex.

2) Based on poor signal propagation and inability to permeate through common materials used in most building construction, 95Ghz picocells are being deployed every couple hundred feet in areas with large buildings and superstructures. This is not something that can be opted out of, especially in densely populated urban areas.

3) The adverse effects of electromagnetic fields on biological tissue was extensively researched by Dr. Robert Becker and documented in his published scientific research as well as his book The Body Electric. All of this information was suppressed by academia and big pharma, he proved exponentially increased cellular mitosis rates, damage to DNA, and a host of other ill effects from EM fields at powers significantly less than today's mobile telephones and WiFi access points. There is a massive profit motive associated with mobile telephony, the Federal Communication Commission is one of the only, if not the only, self-funded government agencies in the U.S. and if you've ever consulted for them it shows. Armani suits, 7 Series in the parking lot, the FCC has loads of cash from spectrum allocation auctions where they receive billions of dollars for each chunk of the spectrum they auction off for use by mobile carriers.

Millimeter wave 5G should be completely stopped in its tracks until conclusive studies have been conducted. Hundreds if not thousands of scientists at this point have signed public letters to this effect, I am really surprised this is even a 5G positive topic of discussion on YC.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @04:10PM (#23441895)
> 1) 95Ghz millimeter wave provably and without question has the potential for adverse affects on human tissue. Active Denial Systems (https://jnlwp.defense.gov/About/Frequently-Asked-Questions/A.... for example) use 95Mhz directed energy for so-called Non Lethal Weapons technology. This is not complex.

At what energy levels?

You can use a really bright light as a denial system, but that doesn't mean a flashlight can harm someone.

Any system that relies purely on heat to cause problems does not demonstrate that the frequencies are unsafe.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by GregoryVPerry on Saturday June 06, 2020 @05:38PM (#23442436)
Again, as mentioned in my previous comment Becker's scientific work with The Body Electric documented numerous instances of cellular mitosis being accelerated and other ill effects from electromagnetic fields much less powerful than what we are holding up to our ears these days.

These 5G picocells are phased antenna arrays that can perform beamforming with pinpoint directed energy. And they are coupled with Software Defined Radios that can be remotely upgraded with firmware updates.

Hitler almost took over the world, and we have significantly more advanced technology available to us these days since World War II. Depending on the RF front end of these picocells, what's to stop some potential next world dictator from turning all of these picocells into a global active denial system to prevent riots and civil unrest - because provably 95Ghz is already being used for ADS - especially if the picocell output power can be controlled via firmware update?

So here's your question back to you: how much output power are these picocells actually capable of?

And with active beamforming capability, what's to stop a government from turning these picocells into highly directional ADS nodes to prevent riots and protests?

These things are popping up next to tunnels and public transit ingress/egress in NYC, and public officials are refusing to comment on what they are being used for other than "it's something to do with Homeland Security":

https://newyork.cbslocal.com/2017/09/27/mysterious-metal-tow...

All of this SDR-enabled 5G picocell gear from all vendors need to go through extensive teardown analysis from the technical community, to determine what amplifier components are being used. China wouldn't think for two seconds about rolling out that type of capability in their country to prevent civil unrest, and having remotely-upgradable amplifiers on every light pole that provably can interact with human tissue doesn't sound like a fun future to me.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:08PM (#23442675)
They'd have to be massively overbuilt to provide enough power for ADS. If there's any evidence of that, I'll be worried.

Just like I could be worried that street lights are going to be used like spotlights, but I'm not.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by dragonwriter on Saturday June 06, 2020 @12:48PM (#23440463)
> so it is hopeless for a majority of the US not directly in a city

~80% of the US population is urban, ~70% in large urbanized areas and ~10% in smaller urban clusters, per the census bureau. A majority of the US is not in a city only by empty land area, not people.

Which isn't to say that it isn't important to also have solutions that work for the other 20%, but things that are only valuable for the urban 80% remain quite valuable.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by zw123456 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:05PM (#23441076)
I don't think 5G will be restricted to cities at all. There are some carriers who are already providing pretty good service to rural areas using sub6 fixed wireless. The N77 auction (3.7 - 4.2Ghz) I think will open up some very good competitive rural options. mm-wave will probably be too expensive in most cases but not necessarily always. The reason is because mm-wave being so fiber intensive. There is often a misconception that fiber is more expensive to deploy in rural areas but often the opposite is the case. Rural areas tend to have fewer regulations and restrictions that make deploying fiber a lot less expensive on a per mile basis that in cities. It's just that cities have more potential customers so it is the obvious first place to deploy. Although it will take longer to get there, I believe that fiber will work its way to more rural areas over time.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:30PM (#23441652)
> I don't think 5G will be restricted to cities at all. There are some carriers who are already providing pretty good service to rural areas using sub6 fixed wireless.

That's a true statement but most uses of "5G" are talking about mm-wave. There's no question that lower frequencies, already in use for 4G or adjacent to those, will get the evolutionary bump to 5G.

And don't forget to consider the need/benefit side. If your 2-7GHz towers won't be saturated, even a free pile of mm-wave antennas isn't worth the maintenance costs.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by __s on Saturday June 06, 2020 @12:59PM (#23440559)
The person you're responding to wasn't saying that the majority of the US is not directly in a city, but that 5G won't be useful for the majority of that subset

A third of the population isn't something to disregard. Their suggestion is that a holistic approach could be taken. But maybe this isn't too much an issue of resource allocation (ie 5G deployment may not be zero sum with fiber deployment, particularly if the considered regions are disjoint)

Oh well, hopefully Starlink or something can help raise the floor on rural internet access quality

Re:5G is perfectly fine by mcguire on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:46PM (#23441401)
It's fortunate that those who live in urban areas never leave those urban areas.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Nokinside on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:28PM (#23441633)
You might slightly misunderstand what 5G is because all everybody talks is mm Waves.

5G spectrum covers low-band and-mid band spectrum from 1G through 4G LTE frequencies. Then there is this new high-band. First 5G installations are deployed into new high-band.

5G installations in countryside will be low band that is more efficient than 4G/LTE. You can have _less_ base stations than LTE, not more in the low-band. 5G NR is more efficient radio interface in all bandwidths.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by GregoryVPerry on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:15PM (#23442737)
Completely not true. 5G is picocell deployment due to 95Ghz millimeter wave. There will be thousands of these things in each town, everywhere.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Yetanfou on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:31PM (#23442884)
There won't be many picocell stations deployed in the countryside I'd guess? The first tree would eat the signal and we have a lot of trees here. No, it'll be using the same bands as 3G/4G with a different protocol. Those picocells are for use in densely built areas with lots of people and not that many trees but also lots of walls.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by zackees on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:21PM (#23441218)
This. Once people realize that 5G needs to be INSTALLED EVERYWHERE they are going ask why we are building all of this... especially when 4G was fast enough for nearly everything.

It seems that the most cost effective method is to use direct line of sight wireless transceiver using whatever which then does the last mile to 4G.

This whole 5G push is a solution looking for a problem.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by 1231asra on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:54PM (#23441787)
5G is a protocol upgrade.

You can upgrade 2G bands to 5G: massive coverage but without the shitty 2G protocols.

You can use 4G bands for 5G, and for 4G smartphones it will still look like 4G.

And finally, there's the possibility for low-range cells at very high frequencies. One possibility of many.

There is no need to re-build all the infrastructure. In many cases, you push a firmware update.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by pjc50 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:08PM (#23440627)
The obvious use case is stations, stadiums, and plazas, where there's a huge number of people in a single 4g cell who get terrible service.

I don't imagine the network as a whole will upgrade to 5g-only.

As for radio safety: anyone talking about the towers is underinformed. If there is a risk it's from the high power TX next to your head - see EU "SAR" limits.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by zw123456 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:44PM (#23440908)
The wireless companies will most definitely go to all 5G, but not necessarily mm-wave. 5Gnr will be used for sub6 and will have a lot of benefits over 4G primarily lower latency due to the 100us TTI.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by half-kh-hacker on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:10PM (#23440650)
> I don't imagine the network as a whole will upgrade to 5g-only.

5G only is fine, as it encompasses more modes of operation than just the millimetre-wave model.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by 0xDEEPFAC on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:11PM (#23440661)
I see your point, personally if I go to a conference, stadium, or concert I am not there to look at my phone or answer email though xD
Re:5G is perfectly fine by pjc50 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:54PM (#23440982)
Lots of conferences regard WiFi as a basic, critical technology to provide to the attendees, on the level of catering and toilets.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by sokoloff on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:47PM (#23440926)
When attending a tech conference, I’m frequently on my phone or laptop, either to follow along with a specific topic being discussed or to do some other work in the downtime.

That can often be accommodated quite well by conference WiFi though.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by aphextron on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:45PM (#23441733)
>"And again, what is all of this for? Faster downloads of instagram photos? I don't get it. How about starting with infrastructure projects that matter like fiber - some people in the US only have DSL as an option..."

It's all about latency. Current 4G tech is ~50ms at best. 5G is <5ms. That opens up a whole new class of real time applications for mobile devices. Not to mention that omnipresent 5G would obliviate the need for residential fiber and be much cheaper/easier to deploy at scale.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by gsich on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:40PM (#23443341)
The latency advertisement in 5G is only the latency between your device and the base station you are connected to.

LTE is already in the <10ms area, so expect a real world latency improvement of about ~5ms.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by VHRanger on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:54PM (#23441794)
Talk to me when my mobile plan has unlimited data.

Until then I can only see 5G hype as pure marketing from the telecom industry.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by LargoLasskhyfv on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:56PM (#23440998)
While mostly not caring about anything wireless/mobile at all:

Do you see street lights as "littering", too? Or the countless satellite dishes?

Now for something really evil, just use traffic signs as beamforming antenna arrays :-)

Re:5G is perfectly fine by citruscomputing on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#23441308)
> Do you see street lights as "littering", too?

Yes, actually. Light pollution is a real problem. Have you seen as many fireflies lately?

Re:5G is perfectly fine by LargoLasskhyfv on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:20PM (#23441590)
That's not what I meant to ask, just the visibilty of those artificial poles all around.

Regarding the fireflies. Not sure, think about 5 to 6 years ago maybe, and in about the same interval in the times before that. They are uncommon here, or have been on their path to extinction back from my early childhood.

Back to your question: There are ways to make them less polluting, by ensuring they only illuminate what should be illuminated, by using the right spectrum, by switching them on demand only, and so on.

I'm very aware of that aspect. But again, that's not what i meant to ask.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by baddox on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#23441303)
Why is this less reasonable than having wifi in nearly every home? Mentioning Instagram photos is not a strong argument for fast internet access not being a valuable component of infrastructure.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by nbaksalyar on Saturday June 06, 2020 @04:39PM (#23442057)
> what is all of this for? Faster downloads of instagram photos?

It’s almost like saying “640kb of memory will be enough for everyone”. :) Instagram, YouTube, and a wealth of other apps which are a large part of our lives now were enabled largely by 3G/4G — speed of data transfer over GPRS/EDGE was just abysmal. And I can’t even imagine what kind of apps we’ll have with lower latencies and higher data transfer rates of 5G.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by catalogia on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:18PM (#23442769)
> And again, what is all of this for?

The "crowded stadium" justification is BS, it's all about IoT.

Companies want to put a cell radio in every appliance you own, so they can collect telemetry and possibly send you ads. Some high value consumer products, particularly cars, are already doing this. And of course many other products are already using wifi, but in that case the user can simply choose to not enter their wifi password, denying their "smart" TV the ability to spy on them. Using cell radios takes this control away from the user, but getting that many more devices connected to cell networks will require new infrastructure that can handle the scale. Enter 5G.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by gambiting on Saturday June 06, 2020 @04:00PM (#23441837)
I mean, I'm literally sitting about 0.5m away from my WiFi router which supposedly can transmit at like 1.9Gbps, and that has never been any discussion. Like the author said - these waves are just so weak they aren't doing anything to your body, not now, not in a 100 years. It's not exactly rocket science.

Edit: I do agree that I literally don't see any point at all. 4G is fast enough for absolutely everything even including 4K streaming, and doesn't require a tower built on top of my house

Re:5G is perfectly fine by mistermann on Saturday June 06, 2020 @05:52PM (#23442546)
> I mean, I'm literally sitting about 0.5m away from my WiFi router which supposedly can transmit at like 1.9Gbps, and that has never been any discussion.

Did you have any say in whether you installed a Wifi router in your home?

> Like the author said - these waves are just so weak they aren't doing anything to your body, not now, not in a 100 years.

People say lots of things, but sometimes the things people say are not true. This, combined with various other variables, seems to leave many people with suspicious feelings about some societal initiatives, not just 5G.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Spooky23 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:22PM (#23440748)
That’s easy — they are going to put cable out of business. You’ll have fixed wireless internet and tv. Most of the consumer protections remaining for internet don’t apply to wireless service.

Unlike cable companies, the “national emergency” and need to “catch up” to the Chinese allows the telcos to drop poles anywhere and avoid pole rent, etc.

It’s probably one of the grossest examples of corruption at the federal level, which is a high bar.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by zw123456 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:46PM (#23440924)
A telco can not "drop a pole" anywhere for free. There is a fee paid to either co-locate on existing or to place a new pole. All cities and counties have right of way fees that all carriers pay to use the right of way.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Spooky23 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:21PM (#23443230)
Obviously it isn’t free, but it’s helluva a lot cheaper than renting pole space for the 5G equipment.

In my city, 90% of the 5G poles are new, some feet away from existing poles. Federal rules give the locality no power to deny placement, only to make limited cosmetic changes, and only in a period of 30 days or less.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by gsich on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:34PM (#23443303)
Depends on the frequency used.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by CyberDildonics on Saturday June 06, 2020 @12:53PM (#23440512)
Why are you putting your energy into deciding who to trust instead of understanding how it works?
Re:5G is perfectly fine by pretendscholar on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:27PM (#23440787)
Depending on the subject it could take years to understand everything that goes into an explanation to make sure you didn't miss anything. At some point you have to assume certain things are true for the sake of argument.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by 0xDEEPFAC on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:08PM (#23440630)
Isn't that how research is done? If a tobacco company publishes research explaining how tobacco promotes lung health and people start reporting their "research" as fact wouldn't that be a problem?

There is opposing research with different conclusions that 5G may not be so safe, which I am sure many people choose to ignore since they contradict the WHO, and TV media reports.

Its about sources and authority. Finding the truth is difficult.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by CyberDildonics on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:26PM (#23440777)
> Its about sources and authority.

This is a simplistic and lazy when it comes to something that is built on well understood scientific principles. This line of thinking is what gives us flocks of people believing in easily debunked conspiracy theories. People who don't understand gas compression leading to condensation believe in chemtrails because a false authority tells them to and people who don't understand electromagnetic radiation search for an authority to tell them what conclusion to come to and reject in depth explanations.

Much of medicine ends up being built on statistics because of the difficulty of drilling down to the underlying mechanics of what happens inside a living body. Statistics can be easily abused since most of the flaws end up being about what is not said and not measured.

Electromagnetic radiation comes out of light bulbs at even higher frequencies. No one seems to worry about halogen lights and heat lamps.

5G is a broad spectrum of frequencies, what specific frequency and amplitude are you worried about?

Re:5G is perfectly fine by mistermann on Saturday June 06, 2020 @05:57PM (#23442582)
> This line of thinking is what gives us flocks of people believing in easily debunked conspiracy theories.

I suggest you consider the possibility that language like this may do more to increase the magnitude of "conspiracy theorists" than your claim. The actual answer to the question is not known, and I suspect there's a decent chance that you don't actually know much about the people you're criticizing.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by schoen on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:38PM (#23441340)
> The answer is that wireless technology is reaching the Shannon limit, that is to say 4G/LTE is approaching the physical limit of how much information can be packed into a Mhz of spectrum.

My understanding of the Shannon limit is that it depends not only on the bandwidth but also on the signal-to-noise ratio. If you had no noise at all (including infinite control over the modulation and demodulation process), you could modulate an unlimited number of bits per symbol within an arbitrary finite bandwidth. Like a QAM constellation with 2⁵⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰ points or something, all of which could in principle be accurately distinguished from one another in the absence of any noise.

If the signal-to-noise ratio isn't a fixed thing for RF communications in different times and places, in what way is cellular communication newly reaching the limit now? I mean I understand that some digital coding methods are considered to be fairly near optimal for a given RF environment; is the idea that they previously weren't and now they are, so there's no longer much benefit to be had from engineering improvements in that area?

Re:5G is perfectly fine by zw123456 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:21PM (#23441599)
Yes, exactly, I simplified it a bit for the limited space here. Basically C ~ B * SINR where B is the amount of spectrum and C is capacity. The reason mm-wave yields such whopping throughputs is 1. space diversity, that is, each user gets a beam 2. the dedicated beam means that one site is not interfering with it's neighbor (co-channel interference) . So if you can control the RF into a tight beam, the SINR is greatly improved. So it boosts both B because not you are not sharing B you get all the B available to the carrier in your beam and SINR is greatly improved because your beam is not being interfered with by other cell sites.

You can not, unfortunately, modulate an infinite number of bits in practical implementations. The more QAM point require higher SINR to resolve. You can't have infinite SINR or Infinite Spectrum. Say you have 100Mhz of spectrum, in low band you are sharing it with others but also getting interfered by neighboring sites particularly at the cell edge.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by cuspy on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:01PM (#23442622)
The 5G scare is to some extent part of an exploitative, manipulative health-concern industry. However, people are generally right to be afraid of the potential health effects of new technologies and substances that are released into their environments.

It is extremely unethical and dangerous in my opinion to attempt to shame and censor people or pathologize their "paranoia". In most cases, despite being cynically exploited, what we're talking about is a healthy and sensible self-protective instinct. I feel safer in my society when people are free to discuss these fears without shame

When talking to a skeptic, if you are certain that a particular fear is illegitimate, be specific as to why and don't use shame to seek compliance. In many cases you'll probably find that you yourself lack the ability to clearly explain why you think their skepticism is unfounded. We all know from countless examples, even in recent history, that there are many people and organizations willing to physically harm the public's health in various ways for profit.

What I wish we would all be concerned with is not the health effects, but instead the potential for dramatically increased surveillance and control that comes with access to so much more bandwidth. Carelessly normalizing and naturalizing progress for progress's sake undermines the credibility of science and technology as tools for the greater good. More and more people are turning against us.

Second, it's also my opinion we should be concerned that certain crucial decisions about our urban environments are exempt from even the pretense of local democratic control. I for one do not want to live in a city where critical infrastructure is governed by a large top-down international private corporate consensus, but it seems that's where we are headed.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by wazoox on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:06PM (#23441087)
Why 5G is dangerous : because mm-wave can't get out of a paper bag, we'll need a tremendous number of antennas everywhere, consuming a tremendous amount of resources and burning a tremendous amount of energy. For what benefit exactly? I don't want 5G. I'm very certain we have really urgent problems of climate, pollution, biodiversity, resources to tackle, and we certainly don't need any new planned-obsolescence systems. No to 5G. And of course, no to 8K TV.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by baddox on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:27PM (#23441262)
I don’t think that’s a very useful way to think about resource allocation. It’s not practical to only focus on what is deemed the single most important problem facing the world. Even if it could be done, it’s likely not even the most efficient way to solve problems, due to competitive advantage.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by looneytunes6651 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#23441307)
MM-waves used for 5C also work via VGCC activation. 5C is designed to carry extraordinarily high amounts of information per second and is, therefore, extraordinarily highly pulsed. The electrical parts of these MM-waves do not penetrate well into buildings, such that millions of 5C antennae are planned in close proximity to our home, schools, churches, businesses, etc, such that it will be nearly impossible to avoid exposures. Given the high pulsation level for 5C radiation, even short exposures may well produce severe biological effects. In addition to this, the finding that 5C systems involve output power sometimes like 30 times higher output than did previous systems, we have an strong argument for disaster (Human exposure to RF fields in 5G downlinI Nasim, S Kim - arXiv preprintarXiv:1711.03683, 2017 - arxiv.org)
Re:5G is perfectly fine by jzebedee on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:36PM (#23441331)
It looks like your link is broken. Is this the preprint you're referring to?

"Human Exposure to RF Fields in 5G Downlink" Imtiaz Nasim, Seungmo Kim https://arxiv.org/abs/1711.03683

[dead]
Re:5G is perfectly fine by jzebedee on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:48PM (#23441421)
Humor me for applying some heuristics here. You're bringing up 43 year old studies and two decade out CIA reports as justification for the health risks of _extremely-widely used_ technology. Should I assume that this is the best we have on offer in studies of a systemic risk, or just cherry picking?

Also, why create a throwaway to post this stuff if you're stating an earnest and sincere belief? Surely credible views like these deserve to be held openly.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by antepodius on Sunday June 07, 2020 @01:57AM (#23445122)
That second part's not really fair, is it? 5G conspiracy theorists are an internet laughing stock. I certainly wouldn't want to have my real name attached if I was expressing a view I knew was fringe and would carry social consequences if it were related back to me. Anonymity is a defense against punishment.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Havoc on Saturday June 06, 2020 @04:46PM (#23442092)
>I don't want 5G

Better switch back to 2G by that logic then cause 3/4G also requires higher density of towers

Re:5G is perfectly fine by falcor84 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:09PM (#23441119)
I for one am excited about the opportunities for team meetings over AR, which to do right would require these higher bandwidths
Re:5G is perfectly fine by mcguire on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:49PM (#23441431)
I would prefer to be able to listen to podcasts while driving in the vast, empty wastelands outside urban areas.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by stinos on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:30PM (#23441653)
This sort of has been solved for 50 (wild guess) years with portable music players. Sure it is not exactly the same, and sure there's the extra recording step, but once that is done (which for downloadable stuff nowadays takes a fraction of the playback time) you have something which is better in some ways because it's offline. Don't get me wrong here: I'm not acvocating to go back, but in some ways it's strange to see new technology being used so widely yet people suffering to get things done which were actually better with older technology. Battery life is another one. The 2 of them combined in an example: I have a rather old portable player which takes micro SD cards. Even without swapping that's a huge amount of music. 2 AA batteries and the thing lasts for hundreds of hours. So purely for playing audio that solution really owns anything newer. Then again, it's of course also the only thing it does.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:52PM (#23441782)
It's also a problem that's solved by podcast apps, and in an even better way because they self-update your content.

Definitely a shame that they make so many phones without microSD slots, though.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Yetanfou on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:37PM (#23442915)
> Definitely a shame that they make so many phones without microSD slots, though.

Just don't buy those phones and that problem is solved.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @08:42PM (#23443665)
Which is fine if that's your only requirement. I also want the ability to root my phone (and update it once the manufacturer support runs out in two years), and since I use T-mobile I want full support for their network (including 600MHz 5G). All achievable individually, but no phone supports all three.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by CharlesW on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:39PM (#23441705)
> I for one am excited about the opportunities for team meetings over AR, which to do right would require these higher bandwidths

Setting aside whether that assumption is true, you don't have Wi-Fi?

Re:5G is perfectly fine by kiba on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#23441306)
Pretty sure that's not going to happen due to the sheer expense.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by 11235813213455 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:21PM (#23440742)
There's also the fact that this will trigger a lot of new smartphone sales, compatible with 5G. This represent a future massive amount of pollution, for something not really necessary
Re:5G is perfectly fine by ratsmack on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:32PM (#23440832)
We are burying ourselves in piles of obsolete gadgets. I buy very few computers or phones, but I look at the pile of stuff I've collected over the last 15 years and wonder how big the pile would be if I always bought the latest trendy items when they became available.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @04:01PM (#23441843)
Are you sure it will trigger a lot of new sales?

The average person keeps their phone for 3 years or less anyway, and 5G is being deployed over a much longer timescale.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by oh_sigh on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:27PM (#23441261)
This isn't 5Gs fault - this is an argument against anything new and better than the the previous version. The real problem is that consumers are not charged the true cost of cleanup for their phones.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @04:05PM (#23441864)
What would you estimate that is? Is it the kind of thing that could be paid for with an extra $50 a phone? Ideally along with some human rights enforcement.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by mrfusion on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:26PM (#23440782)
I’d guess most old smart phones get resold to third world countries. Not a bad thing.

Or do you have evidence that they’re a pollution problem?

Re:5G is perfectly fine by GaryNumanVevo on Saturday June 06, 2020 @01:53PM (#23440966)
I think OP is referring to the pollution created refining rare metals, plastics, etc, that go into modern phones. Reuse is great, but reducing initial consumption is better.
Re:5G is perfectly fine by 11235813213455 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:38PM (#23441344)
yes and freight
Re:5G is perfectly fine by hootbootscoot on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:54PM (#23441789)
Nice, but I would have started in with explaining the electromagnetic spectrum, what photons are, what frequency is, where the visible light spectrum starts, how it's bounded by infrared at the bottom and uv above it, what "ionizing" radiation is, where on the frequency band it starts, what else starts around that band (photosynthesis) as a result of photon quanta finally being able to alter electron valences being at specific quanta, why etc, how ionizing radiation damages molecules, radiosynthesis and melanin-containing-fungi that grow on reactor walls, etc.

basically, reassuring those prone towards conspiracy cult beliefs due to insufficient science education and a general bent towards such theories will tend to backfire. just saying "it's ok" won't work.

break it down and immunize them to future silly beliefs due to understanding the electromagnetic spectrum, etc.

once they understand that everything below visible light just makes molecules wiggle, spin, hop, MOVE around, and doesn't structurally alter them then when some random youtuber says "absorbtion band oxygen water bla bla" you can understand that it's a low-efficiency microwave oven at best, lol

the other thing is: a tendency for those without a basic science education to presume that all of humanity is equally ignorant of this stuff. one can show them photos of how we learned this stuff the hard way, ranging from Mdm Curie to the hapless armed services assistants to various Manhattan project tests etc. not to mention the denizens of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, etc. We learned about the high absorption band around 60ghz back in submarine communications 101 as that range won't work for long range comm...

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Gnarl on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:36PM (#23443317)
Ionizing RF not required for DNA damage. Think biology, not oldschool physics & see here: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279863242_Oxidative...

TLDR; "Analysis of the currently available peer-reviewed scientific literature reveals molecular effects induced by low-intensity RFR in living cells; this includes significant activation of key pathways generating reactive oxygen species (ROS), activation of peroxidation, oxidative damage of DNA and changes in the activity of antioxidant enzymes. It indicates that among 100 currently available peer-reviewed studies dealing with oxidative effects of low-intensity RFR, in general, 93 confirmed that RFR induces oxidative effects in biological systems."

Re:5G is perfectly fine by yumraj on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:54PM (#23441458)
> The bottom line is, short of swallowing or embedding a 5G mmWave transmitter into your body and letting it run for a long time, you’re safe.

But isn't the cellphone, which will have a 5G transmitter, be effectively next to your body all the time? In all of these discussions why do we always ignore the 5G mobile devices?

And, what about when you're outside, standing below a 5G small cell, as you're taking a walk or kids are playing in the neighborhood, is it safe then? There is no wall between you and the antenna, just a few meters of air.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by yongjik on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:13PM (#23441554)
The world is already soaked every day with a vastly more lethal form of radiation, called sunlight. Ever took a nap in the beach without sunscreen? Compared to that, 5G is a non-issue.

If your kid wants to stand right below an 5G transmitter for hours, for some reason, make sure that they use sunscreen, because otherwise they may get uncomfortable radiation burns from the sun.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Gnarl on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:28PM (#23443269)
Methinks you need to see this: https://www.nature.com/articles/srep14914/

Biologically, there's big difference between man-made and natural EMR.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by bildung on Sunday June 07, 2020 @04:46AM (#23445846)
Mobile devices are ignored because they are regulated to only emit at most 0.2W.

Compare that to visible light, which is the same thing, EM radiation, but because of the way higher frequency has 100.000 times higher energy density per Watt emitted.

In general, there are only two way EM radiation can cause harm: Number one is ionizing radiation. That is, a photon contains so much energy that it can, upon hitting an electron e.g. in your skin, hurling it out to become a free radical. For radiation to be ionizing, it has to have much higher energy per photon than the 5G frequencies. Radiation starts to become ionizing at wavelengsth of about 300nm (i.e. UV light).

The only other known way is through overheating tissue until it becomes damaged. As these frequencies are absorbed by water, which is part of practically every cell, this already happens in the skin - and if your skin warms up into damaging territory, you would definitely feel that.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Pick-A-Hill2019 on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:34PM (#23442902)
Firstly, Congrats on making it to the front page of HN, I guess you finally managed to work out the algorithms (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23417975). In closing all I would add is this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23439437
Re:5G is perfectly fine by jrockway on Saturday June 06, 2020 @03:24PM (#23441618)
Someone posted: "why do we need this?" By the time I was done writing my reply, they deleted their comment and HN wouldn't let me reply. But here is my reply:

The demand comes from the fact that the vast majority of the world uses a cell phone as their primary computer. Paying for the Internet twice is a luxury they cannot afford. So it makes sense that the phone companies want to serve them. There is a fixed amount of spectrum available at lower frequencies that can travel longer distances, and we've used all that. So now the idea is to exploit higher frequencies where more bandwidth is available, but the trade-off is that the signals don't travel as far (attenuation by building surfaces, and even the air itself). So access points have to be closer together.

The reality is that WiFi has never worked very well. Bandwidth is allocated poorly, mostly by accident. (Claiming there are 11 channels at 2.4GHz was a big lie that cost us dearly. Bad defaults at 5GHz led people to believe it was attenuated by walls, which it really isn't -- APs just chose channels that they were only allowed to use at lower power than the 2.4GHz channels.) Any time you've seen WiFi working well involves careful site surveys and complicated software that coordinates access over a backhaul (usually wired for the ones that work, but dual radio APs that use wireless backhaul appear to work in the lab -- nobody that I know of is selling them though). 5G is basically that, but owned by the incumbent carriers instead of individuals. They can coordinate access and steer devices to the right AP, which is the #1 thing that makes short-haul radio links reliable. I agree that the circumstances suck, but funding hardware R&D has to be paid for by someone. If you want to start a company to make a peer-to-peer radio network, I say go for it. People are interested. The hardware exists. But I think you'll find that to make money, you're going to have to charge people for access, and probably provide some sort of fallback to 4G/3G for people that are out of your service area. Guess who can provide that? The incumbents. So that's why they're doing it.

It's not all bad, though. Someone has to provide backhaul for the APs, and they're often fiber. So fiber is not going away, and the technology will not stop being developed. It is likely that the fiber ISP that sells service to the cell phone companies will also be happy to sell it to you. It really comes down to how easy it is to lay the fiber to your location. In some cities, they built subways under every street for power and Internet (Manhattan has a huge network). In environments like that, it's easy for anyone to sell you a connection. I worked for an ISP that did exactly that, and it was great. The biggest barrier we had was buildings wanting to charge the ISP to provide service to the building. That isn't profitable for the ISP, so they simply say they can't serve you.

My TL;DR is: encourage your municipality to make it easy to provide fiber to your location, and someone will. You can buy the necessary equipment to start a fiber ISP with a credit card. I say go for it.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by Gnarl on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:30PM (#23443279)
"You can buy the necessary equipment to start a fiber ISP with a credit card"

That sounds really interesting. Care to list stuff needed to bootstrap a fiber ISP?

Re:5G is perfectly fine by jrockway on Saturday June 06, 2020 @11:57PM (#23444642)
Get an OLT: https://www.ui.com/ufiber/ufiber-olt/

And some ONTs: https://www.ui.com/ufiber/ufiber-nano-g/

(I have not used these, but the price is right.)

Obviously the hard part is stringing a fiber between your datacenter and the customer.

Re:5G is perfectly fine by joyj2nd on Saturday June 06, 2020 @02:10PM (#23441128)
So you are telling us that Corona is not caused by 5G?