News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by nostromo on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @12:17AM (#23387389)
This is more interesting than all the other layoff stories in that they're axing 1,400 California jobs but adding 2,000 in lower-cost locations like Dallas, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Minneapolis and Austin.

It's like offshoring -- but off-Californiaing.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by Spooky23 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @09:52AM (#23390981)
It makes sense. If you're not looking for super high-end tech talent, there is no magical advantage to paying California salaries so that people can spend every dime on housing.

I skeptical of most of the tech stuff too -- fewer tech roles require the skillsets/social connections only found a big tech hub than in the past. For many years, IBM was able to run successful tech operations in places like Minneapolis, Austin, Binghamton NY, Hudson Valley NY, North Carolina, Tampa, etc.

The median home price is Pittsburgh is literally 90% less than many California locales. Even with a 40% pay cut, in many professions moving to one of these places will be a neutral in terms of money and probably a positive impact on the employee's quality of life.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by halflings on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @11:11AM (#23391846)
> The median home price is Pittsburgh is literally 90% less than many California locales.

Can you give some data around this? 90% seems like a hyperbole. Or are you comparing the most expensive zipcode in the bay area (e.g Atherton) with the cheapest in Pittsburgh?

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by Spooky23 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @12:42PM (#23393010)
I didn't do a study of real estate valuation. I googled "real estate palo alto" and "real estate pittsburgh" and grabbed the number from the first Google results. (realtor.com)

I can tell you that I live in a small northeastern city, and a 3 or 4 bedroom mid 20th century, single family house is around $130/sqft in a nice neighborhood. In the burbs, it's about $150/sqft. When your mortgage+taxes is <$15k/year, you don't need to make crazy salaries.

I don't know bay area real estate, so looking at Gilroy, CA, which would be a hella commute to SFO, you're looking at $400-450/sqft for 3/4br single family. That's alot of cash.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by dodo6502 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @11:41AM (#23392224)
My friends just moved to Pittsburgh and bought a great house for 108k. This is literally 95% less than a comparable home in Silicon Valley.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by thorwasdfasdf on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:18PM (#23393477)
and he probably got a backyard with it too. In CA, you don't even get that. Why pay 1 to 2 million dollars in CA for a house when you can't even have a backyard?
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by david38 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @12:59PM (#23393235)
I moved to Cali from Illinois. These numbers look correct. A similar, but smaller property was MORE than 10x greater in California.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @05:07AM (#23389141)
>It's like offshoring -- but off-Californiaing.

This is what "Going full remote" post-covid is going to look like for a lot of companies.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by nvr219 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @09:13AM (#23390616)
Good!
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by onemoresoop on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @12:32AM (#23387475)
I wonder if they gave the employees the option to relocate with out of calofornia salary. Not sure if that’s legal but it would have been worth giving them an option, some might as well take it, everything’s too expensive in cali, one cannot easily start a family there
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by mc32 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @12:36AM (#23387493)
They gave them the option to stay on if they relocate. Doesn’t say they keep their CA salary though.

>“ Most of the layoffs will take place in September and those affected will have the opportunity to relocate and stay with the San Francisco-based company.”

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by klenwell on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:51AM (#23387925)
The two Stitch Fix stylists that I've known both worked remotely and I got the impression that most of them did.

Is that not true? If it is true, how do you relocate a remote worker?

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by paxys on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:55AM (#23387960)
"We are going to cut your salary in half. You should move to a cheaper city to make up for it."
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by Melting_Harps on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @03:39AM (#23388639)
> "We are going to cut your salary in half. You should move to a cheaper city to make up for it."

To think that less than 4 months ago People were ridiculing Andrew Yang and other proponents of UBI. I admit having it be, initially anyway, State sanctioned bothers me a great deal; but the fact is gainful employment is no longer a reliable aspect of modern Life for many in Society. This will continue to cut deeper and deeper, and for anyone not paying attention these protests and riots in the US have a much deeper sense of resentment than just Police Brutality against black males. And it's felt throughout the spectrum of underemployed, highly indebted underclass. Its like the bottled and pent up anger from the Occupy movement coming back.

In many ways this reminds me of the London Riots of 2011, when London police killed a young black male named Mark Duggan [1] and it exposed a myriad of sociological, and socio-economic issues that quite frankly still remain to this day.

1: https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/three-riot-lesson...

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by koolba on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @06:44AM (#23389596)
Context matters. The current economic climate is in no way representative of normalcy as we just shut down a large chunk of it indefinitely.

That aside, the idea that you can finance life in the highest cost living areas of the USA as a “stylist” (picking items for a clothing subscription) is lunacy. Clearly that work can be done anywhere and it’s only a matter of time till it’s pushed to the lowest cost areas. I wouldn’t be surprised if the cost of such labor goes to near zero as they attempt to start “paying” people with publicity instead.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @10:01AM (#23391062)
Putting someone’s job title in quotes like that is super condescending. It’s bad taste, especially when you make more and you’re commenting on a post where 1,400 of them got laid off.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by koolba on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:08PM (#23393326)
> Putting someone’s job title in quotes like that is super condescending. It’s bad taste, especially when you make more and you’re commenting on a post where 1,400 of them got laid off.

It's in quotes with an inline description because, while it's the actual job title for the positions in question, it's also a common English word that in most circles would refer to a "hair stylist".

Ascribing negative intentions to minor punctuation and making up biographies about your fellow commentators says more about your bad taste and biases than mine.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by godzillabrennus on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @07:49AM (#23390008)
The job of a stylist will largely be automated away with AI. There will be a few needed to keep training the machines but it’s a career path akin to the horse and buggy maker.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by dlkf on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:19AM (#23390182)
I'm not convinced of this. We could easily have used software to procedurally generate outfits from a selection of components since the 1980s. Why hasn't this already happened?
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by greedo on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @10:19AM (#23391282)
The same reason that Jobs (and Ive) were the arbiters of what Apple shipped for many years; you can't program taste or style.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by cschmidt on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:11AM (#23390129)
Actually Stitchfix is an interesting example of “human in the loop” AI. The AI makes recommendations to the stylist, who assembles outfits. Presumably the stylist is still adding value or they wouldn’t have them.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by koolba on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:21AM (#23390199)
Either way, if people can be scammed^Wconvinced into using their own car to make deliveries for a few bucks that barely covers depreciation, then you can definitely find someone to sit on their computer and click through pictures of clothing for less than an SF city livable salary.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by david38 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:07PM (#23393318)
You clearly don’t know much about how style jobs work. Sometimes it can be done anywhere, but there is a difference. Like most of the nicer things in life, if you can’t tell the difference, then it’s not for you.

I suppose you think it’s lunacy that hair dressers think they can live in the city as well.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by dhimes on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @11:14AM (#23391877)
UBI = "universal basic income" here
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by babesh on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:28AM (#23388197)
Lower minimum wage floor in those areas.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by tyingq on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:48AM (#23390398)
The requirement to relocate makes me wonder if the true reason is to avoid some current, or likely future California labor law.

Why not just offer a straight salary cut, since they are already, as you say...remote?

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by onemoresoop on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:55AM (#23387957)
In this case perhaps rehire with slashed salary. Some people in need would take it
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by toyg on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:25AM (#23388178)
And resent you forever, as well as likely to leave very soon. It would be a liability.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by dividedbyzero on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @07:04AM (#23389734)
That isn't a problem at all in a lot of industries; sure, you may have to coddle tech workers for now, treat them like actual human beings and all that nonsense, but imagine a future where you can treat just like your warehouse staff. Wouldn't that be neat? /s

On a more serious note, I know a few companies who do treat their tech people like disposable inventory, on par with the lower-prestige roles, and it works out just fine for them. They don't get highly motivated world-class talent, but they don't need that sort of talent; just someone to take care of their relatively modest IT/dev needs. It's not very efficient across a lot of metrics, but low salaries probably compensate for that.

This seems to be a trend across all sorts of industries, less and less jobs that pay well, less employees that get coddled and treated well, commoditize the hell out of every last role etc. – just because it's not a big thing in much of tech yet probably doesn't mean it's an impossibility.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by geodel on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @10:36AM (#23391450)
> but imagine a future where you can treat just like your warehouse staff. Wouldn't that be neat?

I think that day is closer than many imagine. If I take out well paying / no physical labor part I am as a Jira slave and daily standup chump are lot closer to warehouse worker than silicon valley type pampered engineer.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by granshaw on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:22AM (#23390204)
It’s already happening IMO. Tech wage growth has been pretty slow esp outside of the FAANGs, and many agreed upon “best practices” are commonplace in the industry now, leaving less room for differentiation among workers
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by matz1 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @09:35AM (#23390816)
Thats normal, in most industry, the worker resent their employer. They come and leave all the time.

A company purpose is to make money, not to take care of its employees.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by subsaharancoder on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @03:09PM (#23394898)
What are the implications of this in terms of taxes? My understanding is that the CFTB https://www.ftb.ca.gov/ will continue to tax you as a CA resident as long as your employer is based in CA. The laundry list for determining residency is long and in many cases you would end up paying taxes even if you don't live in CA.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwood/2019/10/22/now-calif...

https://moskowitzllp.com/leaving-california-and-the-franchis...

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by GhettoChild on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @12:49AM (#23387570)
The article I read said that they were going to give their current employees the opportunity to relocate. It did not specify if there was going to be a change in their income though.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by barcadad on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:04AM (#23387641)
It doesn't make sense to do it if they don't cut their pay.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by ashtonkem on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:13AM (#23387683)
Apparently they’re not engineers, but stylists. Can the difference in pay for stylists be very large across states?
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by klipt on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:22AM (#23387737)
If there were no difference, what would be the motivation to fire in CA and hire elsewhere? I guess office rent is a factor, but that's probably small compared to salaries.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by ashtonkem on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:25AM (#23387754)
Nothing compared to salaries for engineers. Office space averages $17k a year a head, and it’s probably higher in area like CA and NYC where land is expensive.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by onemoresoop on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:56AM (#23387968)
Wow, 17k per head outside the valley and nyc? Seems exceasive, its the first time i har of this figure. Any idea how much that would be in california/nyc?
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by ashtonkem on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:04AM (#23390094)
Office space is both cheap and shockingly expensive. It’s cheap because it’s usually a few dollars a square foot, often as low as $1-2. It’s expensive because you need a lot of square feet, plus room for expansion. Your average employee needs 100-150ft in order to not feel cramped, including personal and communal space.

Here’s an article from 5 years ago that showed a $10k per employee per year cost difference between NYC and Dallas. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/heres-how-much-your-compan...

Keep in mind that office prices are going to vary wildly based on location. High rises in the downtown with good access to public transit are going to cost a lot more than an office park that’s just barely within city limits. So these averages per city are going to hide huge standards of deviation.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by klipt on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @11:46AM (#23392299)
> Your average employee needs 100-150ft in order to not feel cramped

Haha, tech companies in the Bay Area use open office designs that pack people like sardines. Each employee probably gets closer to 30-50sqft.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by mikekchar on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @03:42AM (#23388654)
When I was doing some budgeting in London, England several years ago, I found that the monthly rent for a small apartment was similar to the the cost of a desk in the office, so 17k per head sounds about right to me in large urban areas.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by wott on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @07:12AM (#23389774)
> 17k per head sounds about right to me in large urban areas.

I don't know about the US, but in France, in large urban areas like Lyon or Toulouse, you can easily find office space for 100 to 200 €/m²/year. Which means, translated in $, that $17k per year would grant you 75 to 150 m² (800 to 1600 sq. ft.).

That would be a very very nice office, far from the shoulder-to-shoulder openspace model, even if you add other expenses than pure rent :-)

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by ashtonkem on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:11AM (#23390126)
There are some American cities where prices are similar. The data is old, but Dallas was about $10k cheaper per head than NYC was in 2015.

Of course, in America rents in NYC and SF are going to drive up the averages by a lot, with companies like FB and Google willing to pay huge amounts for prime real estate and luxury build outs.

So the interesting question for you is: how much are rents in Paris, and how does that affect the averages of France as a whole?

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by GhettoChild on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:24AM (#23387745)
they can cut their pay and their employees could still be better off since they are going to be expaning in Austin where there is not state income tax.

Also, the company will be able to save more money since everything is cheaper from taxes to real estate in other states compared to California.

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by michaelbuckbee on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:26AM (#23387762)
It might be worth it to keep them at their current salary and just not pay SF real estate costs.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by driverdan on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @09:30AM (#23390778)
> Not sure if that’s legal

Why wouldn't it be legal?

Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by paulcole on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @10:11AM (#23391184)
You don't need to wonder. It literally says that in the article. Even above the paywall.
Re:Stitch Fix to Lay off About 1,400 Employees in California by hinkley on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:10AM (#23387669)
I was curious about that. They keep popping up with job openings lately and I was t sure what’s going on there.