News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by mullingitover on Thursday May 28, 2020 @11:49PM (#23346090)
Eradicating harmful insect species using CRISPR gene drives is so tempting. We could wipe out Medflies with it (without spilling a single drop of pesticide), and even more importantly, we could drive the mosquitoes that cause malaria/yellow fever/dengue/etc to extinction. There are a lot of worries about the side effects, but I'm equally worried about the consequences of failing to use it. There's a lot of attention paid to the 100k coronavirus deaths, and not to minimize those, but they pale in comparison to the equally tragic and preventable malaria deaths which go practically unnoticed.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by ISL on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:37AM (#23346304)
Early in the days when nuclear physics found application, it promised to bring great benefit to society in addition to its tremendous utility in warfare. There are lots of opinions about this sort of thing, but it is a fact that our society has great difficulty dealing with nuclear waste. Furthermore, while accidents are rare, they have enduring impact in the locations where they occur.

Today, of all days, we all feel the impact of an uncontrolled and exponentially-spreading biological disaster. Gene drive can have a similar impact, if it goes awry.

To wield a weapon of extinction that we barely understand is folly. There are as many opportunities for loss of control through mutation as there are mosquitoes. While the biomechanics probably don't work out, it seems like a bad idea to attempt such an extinction when each of our tiny adversaries are equipped with hypodermic needles and a penchant for mammalian blood.

Your point regarding the consequence of not acting is very well-taken. It only takes a day or two in a country with tropical disease to understand how crippling it is, not just to individuals, but to entire continents of people. The happiness of billions of lives does hang in the balance. Before going with the "nuclear" (or should I write "CRISPR"?) option, one should explore every other avenue to its end.

I'm a physicist -- I see in CRISPR all the good and bad that physicists encountered at the dawn of the nuclear age. Be real, real careful with it.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by Gravityloss on Friday May 29, 2020 @05:58AM (#23348144)
There are also other issues. Technology has advanced and information is more easily available. Nuclear technology has proliferated - even small countries can nowadays use it, and probably many large companies also could.

Biotech could be harmful in a massive way, done by a much smaller operator.

So "we" don't really get to say. Someone will just use these technologies. This is what Bill Joy wrote of in 2000, in the essay "Why the future doesn't need us". How do we organize society around this different harm dynamic?

EDIT: In some sense, nuclear technology is a great success story. Not used in anger since the second world war. Countries like Italy and Sweden had nuclear programs, but they didn't end up there. (Ariane and Vega solid boosters are Italian for that reason.) Political ways were found to contain it.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by awakeasleep on Friday May 29, 2020 @09:26AM (#23349706)
I hadn't imagined a large, energy intense company running their own reactor before reading your comment. What an idea to start the morning!
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by jojobas on Friday May 29, 2020 @09:55AM (#23349996)
Even factoring in the rare accidents, nuclear energy kills less people per GW and per GW*h than coal (by a factor of 2000) and rooftop solar (by a factor of 10).

The death toll of not using nuclear is higher than that of using it.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by mrtksn on Saturday May 30, 2020 @02:19AM (#23358956)
The concern is not only about the number of people die.

Large areas become uninhabitable practically forever and people are uprooted, becoming refugees overnight with no chance to go back ever. Suffering also increases through cancers, inability to breed, and/or deformed babies.

Death per kW doesn't capture that picture, I don't know why anyone would optimize for death per kW alone.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by jojobas on Saturday May 30, 2020 @08:48AM (#23360789)
The above figures hold true for disabilty-adjusted life years.

Coal does all that too, it's just spread across wider areas and longer time. Japan is somewhat unique in how little flat land there is, typically there would be miles and miles of uninhabited space around a nuke power plant.

Screening thousands of Chernobyl cleanup workers didn't discover elevated cancer risks, as far as I remember the only group that was measurably affected was the people who refused to relocate.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by mrtksn on Saturday May 30, 2020 @11:25AM (#23361782)
My argument is that you can’t look at dead bodies per kW/h and claim one is better than the other.

It doesn’t incorporate the relocation of potentially tens of millions of people on a single incident. It doesn’t incorporate the political complexities and so on.

People don’t simply look at the probability of getting killed and be fine with being uprooted if something happens. People don’t want to risk being relocated overnight. The death thing isn’t even a concern, most people don’t even believe that it would happen to them.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by jojobas on Saturday May 30, 2020 @11:39AM (#23361882)
People are afraid of being relocated but not afraid of being killed? Well then, check how many people were relocated due to hydro and coal quarries.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by mrtksn on Saturday May 30, 2020 @11:52AM (#23361986)
And they are not happy about it many of the times. Protests are widespread when such facilities are to be built. It’s not happening overnight, they usually get compensated handsomely but people still don’t want it. On nuclear, it’s much more hardcore, you leave overnight to never come back and it’s very unlikely to get fair compensation.

What is hard to understand that people don’t want this to happen to them?

Death? Big deal, people face death through the entire history to preserve their way of life. There are professions where death is an occupational hazard. Nobody cares about death. What's scary is to lose your life in a sense of losing everything that you worked for, some people commit suicide when they lose something that they cared and build through the years.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by jon_elbrook on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:01AM (#23348162)
>Furthermore, while accidents are rare, they have enduring impact in the locations where they occur.

And coal emission, gas spill, oil spill, dam burst, dam construction dont?

>but it is a fact that our society has great difficulty dealing with nuclear waste.

France has no problem.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by michaelcampbell on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:03AM (#23348542)
> >but it is a fact that our society has great difficulty dealing with nuclear waste.

> France has no problem.

France is part of the world, and thus has part of the problem. Maybe France isn't contributing to it, but we as humans own it now.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by korantu on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:27AM (#23348694)
This is not very practical answer.

France got waste reprocessing to the extent where decades of electricity provided to Paris only leave several glass slabs of waste behind [1].

France has solution to the problem [2], where the rest of the world choses to ignore it while championing solutions that are not really helping.

So, France got the answer.

[1] https://www.heritage.org/environment/commentary/recycling-nu...

[2] Decarbonization in 10 years: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EYp2uVFVcAEWAoW?format=jpg&name=...

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by C4stor on Friday May 29, 2020 @09:23AM (#23349671)
To be fair, France still don't fully know what to do with radioactive waste.

We're kinda good at recycling it (so, indeed not the horrifying process your [1] describes), but the final non reusable waste is in fact just stored where it's produced, waiting for better ideas on what to do with it, so it's not exactly ideal. There are a dozen of publicly funded current research projets on that, so let's cross fingers. Overall, I'd say that our policies are pretty solid to get us towards a good solution in the best possible shape, but I wouldn't say that France got the answer yet.

(Also, old plants deconstruction is a planned problem with currently no planned solutions.)

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by saulrh on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:19PM (#23352743)
You have to store high-level waste for hundreds or thousands of years before it's safe.

Heavy metal wastes never become safe. A dump site for cadmium or chromium or lead or arsenic waste will be exactly as hostile to life around it in ten thousand years as it is today. The only way for it to "become safe" over time is for it to leak into the environment and distribute the damage over time. In practice, the "solution" for heavy metal industrial waste is to store it where it's produced and ignore it. Usually in huge open pits, which are just great for the environment around them /s.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by taneq on Friday May 29, 2020 @09:35AM (#23349800)
I just look at it from a systems engineering perspective and think a whole bunch of nearly-identical systems sharing the same physical layer with no separation between them is terrifyingly vulnerable no matter what you do.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by deathgrips on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:37AM (#23346589)
The problem with this sort of thinking is that we don't live in a bubble. Even if we don't study nuclear weapons or biological engineering, our enemies will.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by mrunkel on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:24AM (#23346817)
There is also a problem with thinking that everyone that isn't you is an enemy.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by 42_ on Friday May 29, 2020 @05:57AM (#23348140)
At the scale of nations, this line of thinking is very much necessary.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by ChristianBundy on Friday May 29, 2020 @10:07AM (#23350095)
Are you a nation?
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by deathgrips on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:25PM (#23353654)
No, but he lives in one.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by ChristianBundy on Saturday May 30, 2020 @12:13AM (#23358410)
He?
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by deathgrips on Saturday May 30, 2020 @01:23PM (#23362814)
Integers identify as male :)
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by deathgrips on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:54AM (#23346982)
It's better to have weapons but never need to use them than to need weapons but not have them.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by saagarjha on Friday May 29, 2020 @03:25AM (#23347163)
Do note that having weapons makes you infinitely more likely to use them.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by antepodius on Friday May 29, 2020 @11:09AM (#23350825)
And not having them, when someone else has them, makes it infinitely more likely they'll waggle their eyebrows at you and have you quietly comply with their every demand.

Europe doesn't have large militaries, which is fine as long as they're satellite states of the U.S.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by antepodius on Friday May 29, 2020 @11:09AM (#23350832)
And not having them, when someone else has them, makes it infinitely more likely they'll waggle their eyebrows at you and have you quietly comply with their every demand.

European nations don't have large militaries, which is fine as long as they're satellite states of the U.S.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by kortilla on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:28AM (#23347626)
> our society has great difficulty dealing with nuclear waste.

Emotionally, not physically. We let ignorance take over and fear drive decisions.

Your comparison of CRISPR to nuclear bombs and meltdowns just puts it into the irrational fear category.

You said yourself that you’re a physicist. Why do you think that qualifies you to talk about the risks of gene editing with CRISPR?

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by michaelcampbell on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:04AM (#23348553)
> You said yourself that you’re a physicist. Why do you think that qualifies you to talk about the risks of gene editing with CRISPR?

He says, on a site devoted to people talking about things about which 99% of them know nothing.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by rubidium on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:15AM (#23349038)
It’s already been shown to not result in what was expected in the trial that was done in Brazil. A total Jurassic park moment. Nature “found a way”.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-49660-6

I feel like everyone missed this news?

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by arcticfox on Friday May 29, 2020 @11:23AM (#23351019)
> Evidently, rare viable hybrid offspring between the release strain and the Jacobina population are sufficiently robust to be able to reproduce in nature. ... Thus, Jacobina Ae. aegypti are now a mix of three populations. It is unclear how this may affect disease transmission or affect other efforts to control these dangerous vectors.

Uh-oh moment.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by 1propionyl on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:02AM (#23346149)
A genetic modification designed to spread through a population at higher-than-normal rates of inheritance, spread through a massive population of insects that act as carriers for many rapidly mutating viruses, and that feed on the blood of many different species?

What could go wrong?

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by mullingitover on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:24AM (#23346239)
Anopheles mosquitoes have killed more people than all the wars in human history combined, so to me the 'what could go wrong' is that we don't do anything to permanently wipe them out.

I'm not saying we shouldn't be careful, but that we should carefully, deliberately drive them to extinction.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by Someone on Friday May 29, 2020 @03:57AM (#23347418)
The goal should not be to eradicate the mosquitos, but to eradicate Plasmodium, and then even just the ones (most) responsible (if you can call an unicellular organism responsible) for malaria.

Also, ‘only’ about 40 of 460 Anopheles species commonly transmit malaria (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anopheles). We should target those, leaving the others around.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by runeks on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:43AM (#23348412)
> Anopheles mosquitoes have killed more people than all the wars in human history combined […]

What makes you sure that CRISPR-gone-wrong couldn’t kill even more people?

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:37AM (#23346301)
Could possibly vs the lives already lost and the lives yet to be lost.

I know where my opinion firmly lands: definitely worth considering the options.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by ip26 on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:32AM (#23346281)
Engineering mosquitoes to be unsuitable carriers for malaria (and others) could be a less perilous path.

It would be something like this option:

https://www.bbc.com/news/amp/health-52530828

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by Retric on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:46AM (#23348427)
That’s 100k deaths in the US globally it’s over 350k. The US has effectively eradicated Malaria locally, which is why the 100k deaths are getting so much attention. You need to go much further down the list of US killers to find something we don’t pay much attention to.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by tsimionescu on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:57AM (#23349371)
> There's a lot of attention paid to the 100k coronavirus deaths, and not to minimize those, but they pale in comparison to the equally tragic and preventable malaria deaths which go practically unnoticed.

Actually, Covid19 has already killed almost as many people this year to date as malaria in 2018, at least according to Wikipedia (400k died of malaria, 360k of Covid19). And this is only after a shutdown of large number regions or countries.

I know this is somewhat besides your original point, but I feel that it is important to bring up, given the trend to downplay Covid19 in some circles.

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by S_A_P on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:44AM (#23349282)
This response pretty much encapsulates your user name 100%. That said, haven't they already started releasing "GMO" mosquitoes in Brazil?

Just googled it and looks like they did:https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/09/study-dna-spread-gen...

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by lvs on Saturday May 30, 2020 @03:42AM (#23359281)
You've just read an article about bioterrorism and concluded that human engineering of ecology is not only safe but obligatory?

What if I told you that, if there were ever a working and effective gene drive -- instead of just people self-promoting on the basis of such things -- that it could be used as much for evil as it could be used for good?

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by jon_elbrook on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:11AM (#23348225)
>we could drive the mosquitoes that cause malaria/yellow fever/dengue/etc to extinction.

How?

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by Jyaif on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:28AM (#23349154)
"Debug is a group of scientists and engineers developing technology to raise and release sterile mosquitoes to eliminate the ones that carry disease."

And it's used in the real world:

"Today, our scientific paper reporting near-elimination of Aedes aegypti from three neighborhoods in Fresno County"

https://blog.debug.com/2020/04/nature-biotechnology-features...

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by jon_elbrook on Friday May 29, 2020 @09:17AM (#23349603)
Releasing sterile mosquitoes wouldn't eliminate the ones that carry disease. that's basically the opposite of natural selection.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by ses1984 on Friday May 29, 2020 @09:37AM (#23349828)
"sterile" is an over simplification, with something called gene drive, you can actually introduce sterility into the gene pool in such a way that spreads through the entire population driving it to extinction. Crazy.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by jon_elbrook on Saturday May 30, 2020 @04:46AM (#23359586)
I don't see how that could work. Clearly some mosquitoes are going to be resistant to the modification and will survive.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by ses1984 on Saturday May 30, 2020 @01:46PM (#23363039)
I could explain it but not as well as if you just search for crispr gene drive.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by kingkawn on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:36AM (#23348374)
If you wipe out entire species of insects you will decimate life throughout the food chain
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by throwaway0a5e on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:53AM (#23348477)
Depends on your choice of insect. The world would mostly be fine without mosquitoes. Losing ants would be a big problem. This is one of the big problems with using pesticides on crops, you kill the good stuff too.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by kingkawn on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:01AM (#23348528)
We have not lived in a mosquito-less world, you cannot say with justifiable certainty that wiping them out would not devastate birds and other wildlife that have intricate relationships to them in the food web
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by dfsegoat on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:21AM (#23346226)
Devils advocate: mosquitoes and their diseases have been with us since we were rodents.

I would express great concern at this idea, but can understand the temptation.

Why not just use CRISPR to confer malaria etc. immunity in humans?

Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by mullingitover on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:26AM (#23346252)
Genetically modifying all humans with no side effects is far more difficult and ethically dubious than genetically modifying mosquitoes.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by masonic on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:25AM (#23346824)

  since we were rodents
Humans (well, most, anyway) were never rodents. You have to go back almost to the K-T event even to find a common ancestor.
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:48AM (#23346357)
If that’s your opinion, how do you reconcile it with being ok that Africans suffer mosquitoes and their diseases, but us Westerners don’t?
Re:1989 California Medfly Attack by smabie on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:06AM (#23346727)
Gene drive the entire human population? Are you serious? Moreover, that doesn't really help the people today.