News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by munificent on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:00PM (#23316337)
The fundamental flaw is this:

The primary content no user wants to see any every user agent would filter out is ads. Since ads are the primary way sites stay in business, they are obligated to fight against user agents or other intermediary systems.

The ultimate problem is that Facebook doesn't want to show you good, enriching content from your friends and family. They want to show you ads. The good content is just a necessary evil to make you tolerate looking at ads. Every time you upload some adorable photo of your baby for your friends to ooh and aah over, you're giving Facebook free bait that they then use to trap your friends into looking at ads.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by stonogo on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:14PM (#23318040)
I sure am tired of hearing about "the fundamental flaw" in empowering people. What you describe is not a flaw in empowerment, it's a flaw in their business model, and it's one that can that be fixed (i.e. "innovate a better business model"). Can we stop propagating the idea that people who do not want to use their limited bandwidth and processing power to rasterize someone else's advertising are somehow "flawed"?

The only thing more insane than blaming users for having self-interest are the people who pretend that Facebook et al. are somehow owed the business model they have, painting ad-blockers as some kind of dangerous society-destabilizing technology instead of the commonsense response to shitty business practices it clearly is.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by solveit on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:37PM (#23318178)
The point is that fighting Facebook on Facebook is a losing game and "innovate a better business model" has been tried, is being tried, and is not working because it is hard. A plan that does not work is indeed "flawed", no matter how noble and natural the intentions.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by stonogo on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:58PM (#23318295)
"Users don't care about your ad network" is not a "plan," it is a reality, and calling it "flawed" is just corporate propaganda. I'm sure you're arguing in good faith but the very foundation of this assessment is fundamentally incompatible with reality.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bobthepanda on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:01PM (#23318304)
Well, no, today's model is "users tolerate your ad network in return for free content". Which is clearly true given that Facebook is making profits despite everyone and their mother grumbling about ads.

Something has to pay the bills.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by stonogo on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:04PM (#23318320)
Yes, tolerating the ad network definitely falls under "users don't care"... until they do, and they start taking measures to counteract it, and then we're back to "something has to pay the bills," which is where I'm suggesting some R&D investment might be wise.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by solveit on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:30PM (#23318484)
> until they do, and they start taking measures to counteract it,

When? Adblock has been free and easy for years now

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by true_religion on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:50PM (#23318590)
Adblock usage has been creeping upwards every year. It’s only the fact that most people use mobile devices, that slowed its growth.

Now, extensions to block ads are mature on mobile.

On some sites I run, I see 60% blocking on desktop, 10% on mobile. If it hits 60% on mobile as well, then the ads would cease to be profitable.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by esperent on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:41PM (#23318843)
Do you have a source for those numbers? By your argument, advertising should already be unprofitable on desktop, which seems unlikely.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by x0 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:26AM (#23320363)
It's a site that they run, they are the source for those numbers.

A quick google says somewhere from 20%-40% use adblockers. 60% sounds high, but depending on the website, I can see it. For example, I bet at least 60% of visitors to gnu.org are blocking ads and/or trackers.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bradlys on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:16PM (#23318379)
If not ads then what would pay the bills? We all know users won’t pay for a subscription service.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by egypturnash on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:47PM (#23318572)
We all know users won’t pay enough for a subscription service to make a huge profit that makes the VC happy, makes the founder one of the ten richest people in the country, and supports a ton of offices and salaries in some of the priciest places to live and work.

But the tiny Mastodon server I run for myself, with a total user count in the low triple digits, costs about fifty bucks a month, and the users who are willing to pay cover half of that. I could probably get more of them to cover it if I was more aggressive about asking, but I prefer to keep it super low-key. I could also lower those costs if I felt like putting some work into optimizing it.

It’s not my job, it’s a thing I run on the side and put a few hours of technical work into every few months. I ain’t gonna get rich from it but it gives my friends a nice place to chat on the Internet.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bhupy on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:10PM (#23318689)
Yeah but the vast majority of Facebook users don't care enough to learn how to use Mastodon. Try asking the average Social Security recipient to use IRC.

I reject the notion that "We all know users won’t pay enough for a subscription service to make a huge profit that makes the VC happy, makes the founder one of the ten richest people in the country etc" because...if you can figure out how to get Grandma to use a federated Mastodon-like service, then you would do just that.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by egypturnash on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @01:08AM (#23319562)
“Hi Mom! We’ve decided to leave Facebook. Jane’s set up our own little substitute. It’s where we’ll be posting all the pictures of the kids from now on. I’ve written up the basics in this letter; if you have any questions we can talk about it when I see you next week.

— Suzy <3”

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by true_religion on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:52PM (#23318597)
I don’t think what you describe is a good experience. You provide a benefit for hundreds of people, but can’t even get 25 dollars a month in return.

Contrast this with real life hobby groups, and service groups, where you can more easily raise money to cover costs.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by egypturnash on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:57AM (#23319509)
I’m giving something to my friends. This makes them happy, and it makes me happy to see them happy. I’ve made a few new friends because of this, I’ve gotten to know some acquaintances better too. I am richer in my connections.

There’s a low-key buzz of occasional thanks and favors in my life that I wouldn’t get if I wasn’t doing this, either. And occasionally this connection lets one of my friends help out another who needs it, financially or emotionally, when they wouldn’t even necessarily be contact with each other, much less interested in helping out, without the shared space I’ve created.

I think this is a great experience.

(Total active user count is more like a few dozen, btw.)

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by enneff on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:35PM (#23318516)
Perhaps if people aren’t willing to pay for it the service isn’t that valuable after all.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by thayne on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:30AM (#23319406)
I see two problems with this. First of all, the service Facebook provides isn't valuable at all unless all your friends and family are also using it and posting content. So unless you can get a critical mass of users to switch to a new platform with a different business model, it won't succeed. Secondly, we've become accustomed to not having to pay for social media, and asking to pay for a social media platform is a little like asking to pay for air. Sure, yours might not have as much pollution, but I can get something almost as good for free.

I've actually experienced the latter, as I looked for an alternative to Gmail. I just found it hard to justify paying for an email provider, where the only real value add to me is the absence of ads, and not being Gmail. And really, the price is mostly irrelevant. For me to be willing to pay _anything_, it would have to have a really compelling reason to move. The value of not seeing ads is just not that high for me. And I don't think you would say there isn't value in an email provider.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by enneff on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @05:34PM (#23330330)
I use Fastmail for my important email because I want to be paying a company to take me seriously as a customer. They’re not going to just lock me out of my account because of some random abuse trigger elsewhere in their system. You’re probably not seeing the value because the bad thing hasn’t happened to you yet, but it might and when it does there’s not much recourse.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bhupy on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:55PM (#23318614)
Perhaps if people don't find a service valuable, then we should everyone to stop using it.

If that argument sounded absurd to you, it's probably because it is. The services are valuable because people ultimately do use them — a lot of them, even. They pay for them indirectly by agreeing to look at ads.

There are loads of services we do not directly pay for, like the fire department and the public library — and yet they are immensely valuable.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by enneff on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @05:36PM (#23330352)
The argument sounds nonsensical because it’s missing a verb.

I don’t agree that just because people will use a free thing that means it has a lot of value. Note I didn’t say that FB has no value, just that it might not be as valuable as one might think.

Considering most of their value is their messenger platform I don’t think FB is really worth much at all beyond their social graph.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bhupy on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @07:14PM (#23331332)
> The argument sounds nonsensical because it’s missing a verb.

That's a typo on my part — it doesn't change the veracity of the argument.

> I don’t agree that just because people will use a free thing that means it has a lot of value. Note I didn’t say that FB has no value, just that it might not be as valuable as one might think.

Sure, but how do you measure the "true" value? If you can answer that question, you will probably become a billionaire.

> Considering most of their value is their messenger platform I don’t think FB is really worth much at all beyond their social graph.

What are you basing this on? You may only find the messenger platform to be valuable, but how do you know how others perceive the FB platform/product?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by enneff on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @08:39PM (#23331993)
I’m going on what I’ve observed in FB users around the world. Their most dedicated users are people in developing countries whom they have convinced that Facebook is the internet.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bobthepanda on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:31PM (#23318798)
People do pay for Facebook, by being exposed to ads.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by esperent on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:39PM (#23318833)
Facebook is only 16 years old. The idea of social networks is only a few years older than that. Surely we can't have tried and failed at every possible alternative already?
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by redwall_hp on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:52PM (#23318910)
I can buy web hosting for less than a coffee per month that can sling thousands of static HTTP requests per second. In a world where something like Mastodon/GNU Social was the norm, any hobbyist could opt to run one fraction of a grand federated social network out of the goodness of their hearts, for spare change, or for a small fee to their users.

Centralized, siloed social networks are only expensive to run because they're centralized. Things were better when the norm was to start a blog instead of using someone else's walled garden.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by coffeecat on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:04PM (#23318319)
It appears to me that the parent post was criticizing the ad-based business model - not endorsing it.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by stonogo on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:05PM (#23318328)
I'm complaining about the structure of the dialog around this issue, not casting aspersions on the parent post's argument itself. It's impossible to have a reasonable discussion when the terminology in use is strongly prejudiced against one of the key parties in the relationship.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bhupy on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:20PM (#23318410)
Reality is strongly prejudiced against one of the key parties in the relationship. Users, today, tolerate ads in exchange for free content. Any reasonable discussion — where continued delivery of content is a desired end goal — needs to come up with an answer for how we pay for it. Calling out "fundamental flaws" is one such way of doing that.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by coffeecat on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @11:30PM (#23319098)
Stating things nakedly, using the assumptions and perspective of the big guy, can be a powerful rhetorical style when advocating for the little guy. See any of Chomsky's political writing as an example.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by munificent on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:30PM (#23325749)
> I sure am tired of hearing about "the fundamental flaw" in empowering people.

I'm all for empowering people. But adding personally controlled user agents to Facebook is a fundamentally flawed solution. There is no path for that to succeed because the primary content users will want to filter is ads, and the primary content Facebook needs people to see is ads. Thus user agents are an existential threat to Facebook and since Facebook controls all the content, they will ensure user agents are not allowed.

The core business model does not align Facebook's incentives with user's incentives. You can't fix that at the content level.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by brigandish on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:46PM (#23318571)
> it's a flaw in their business model, and it's one that can that be fixed (i.e. "innovate a better business model")

Doesn't that assume that there is a better business model?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by inetknght on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:53PM (#23318605)
Yes. They're based on users voluntarily giving payment for services rendered and, importantly, being satisfied with the transaction.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by brigandish on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @11:29PM (#23319096)
Which company uses that business model and has a size comparable to Facebook?
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by tomrod on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @11:50PM (#23319213)
Apple.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by brigandish on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:07AM (#23320220)
I thought it was obvious I meant from the sector in question. My mistake, I'll try again.

Do you know of a social media company (or ad company using a product to garner the data, if that helps) that uses that model with a comparable size to Facebook? If not, are there any that are making ground?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:46PM (#23316811)
"The ultimate problem is that Facebook doesn't want to show you good, enrishing content from your friends and family."

Well, it is someone else's website. What do you expect Zuckerberg has his own interests in mind.

In 2020, it is still too difficult for everyone to set up their own website, so they settle for a page on someone else's.

If exchanging content with friends and family (not swaths of the public who visit Facebook - hello advertisers) is the ultimate goal, then there are more efficient ways to to do that without using Zuckerberg's website.

The challenge is to make those easier to set up.

For example, if each group of friends and family were on the same small overlay network they set up themselves, connecting to each other peer-to-peer, it would be much more difficult for advertisers to reach them. Every group of friends and family on a different network instead of every group of friends and family all using the same third party, public website on the same network, the internet.

Naysayers will point to the difficulty setting up such networks. No one outside of salaried programmers paid to do it wants to even attempt to write "user agents" today because the "standard", a ridiculously large set of "features", most of which benefit advertisers not users, is far too complex. What happens when we simplify the "standard"? As an analogy, look at how much easier is is to set up Wireguard, software written more or less by one person, than it is to set up OpenVPN.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ggggtez on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:12PM (#23317041)
I don't think that "user-agents" are the hard part either. At this point, I think any grad student would happily write a NN implementation that took various posts as input, and returned to you a sorted list based on your preferences (with input layers like: bag of words, author, links, time, etc, that the user could put more or less weight into just by simple upvote/downvote).

The problem is that no one has the incentive to host such a service for free, and users wants the content to be available 24/7. So it's not as simple as just setting up a peer-to-peer network. Users who just use a phone as their primary computer will still want to be able to publish to their millions of followers, and so it wouldn't work to have those millions of people connect directly to this person's device. Maybe you can solve that with a bit-torrent like approach, but the problem gets harder when you include the ability to send messages privately.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:47PM (#23317357)
"Users who just use a phone as their primary computer will still want to able to publich to their millions of followers, and so it wouldn't work to have these millions of people connect directly to this person's device."

You have shifted the discussion from small overlay network for friends and family to large overlay network for "millions of followers".

Those methods of sharing content with "millions of followers" are already available and will no doubt continue to be available.

A small private network is a different idea, with a different purpose. People will always have the choice of using a public network however a small overlay can avoid sending traffic through third party servers, like Facebook's.

There is no requirement that a service has to be "free", or supported by ads. This is something else you injected in the discussion. I use free software to set up overlays, but I have to pay for internet service and hosting. The cost of the "service" is not the setup it is the internet access and hosting.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ggggtez on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:06PM (#23317498)
Your idea doesn't sound particularly tenable. A pay social network that limits you to only your close friends and family, that will have no network effects, have less features, and be more difficult to set up...

It's easy for people to point what they don't like about Facebook, but I don't think you are really comprehending why they dominated the social network space to begin with. It's not as easy as making a product that doesn't advertise, if it costs money to use instead.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:02PM (#23317937)
Tenable for what? You are injecting your own ideas. Why would I care about the reasons Facebook is popular. The idea I submitted was to make the process of setting up overlay networks easier, not to try to start a web-based business. Making software easier to use is a tenable idea. The ideas you are introducing might not be tenable. However, they are not my ideas. The pattern I see is you introduce some idea, attribute it to me, then shoot it down.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by mycall on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:00PM (#23317915)
> The problem is that no one has the incentive to host such a service for free

matrix.org is approaching this

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by lordlic on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:05PM (#23317497)
I guess it's worth clarifying what exactly you're talking about. If you want to share images and text with a small group of people, okay, that might be useful in some cases. But that's not the use case that Facebook users have in mind - you're setting the bar almost comically low and the impact on the actual landscape of the web will be exactly zero.

If you mean something that can make a splash in the social media space to address the "user agents on Facebook" problem, color me skeptical about the prospect of competing on useful features with the Facebook behemoth while fighting the complexity up and down the stack of making everything decentralized and trying to make it friction-free for casual users to run, with no funding from ads, and starting out at square one on network effects. Yes, Mastodon is a possible counter to this line of argument, but Twitter is so stagnant and their product is so simple that I feel like it's almost a unique case. And for most people the Facebook use case includes being able to find all their real-life contacts; by that measure even Mastodon would fail.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:49PM (#23317811)
You can be as skeptical as you want to be. Even assuming this idea was intended to "make a splash" (it isn't), these sort of comments make no difference whatsoever. We have all seen how HN commenters have criticised ideas that, rightly or wrongly, later went on to become successful businesses. The thing is, this is definitely not intended to be a business. It is just some software that exists and that works. If it works for me, then it is "successful". There is no budding "founder" to shoot down. Just a user with some software that works. The assumptions of "make a splash in the social media space" and "competing with Facebook" are all wrong.

The business of Facebook is not the "comically low" bar of sharing text and images with friends and family. An overlay solution that avoids sending traffic to a third party server is not "competing with Facebook". However it could be used to avoid Facebook which is the point we are discussing here. The fact that only a small number of people actually use a solution does not mean it is a "failure". If the software is relatively small, compiles fast, runs on different OS and architectures, stays available for download and reliably works as intended, then to me it is "successful". The way I evaluate "success" and "failure" of a software is probably different from many commenters/readers.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by scarmig on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:17PM (#23318067)
And, secondarily to your main point, the idea that "sharing images and text with a small group of people" is some weird niche case that Facebook users don't care about is... pretty off-base. I'd say it's the main use case for the majority of Facebook users.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by baq on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:57PM (#23316910)
i have a fundamental issue calling a content-curating, psychological-experiment-running platform visited by hundreds of millions of people daily 'someone else's website'. the fact that it is privately owned doesn't matter if nation states use it to wage information wars against other nation states' citizens. to make matters worse, the 'someone else' in question knows about it perfectly well and is fine with it because it means he's showing more ads.

this is plain and simple fucked up.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:20PM (#23317119)
Well, that is what it is. No one knew a single website could grow so large, but it did. Even though there are thousands of people working for its owner, when reading articles like the OP we are reminded how much control he still has over it. No doubt he still thinks of it as his personal creation. Of course, "99.99999%" of the content is not his. Perhaps most of the people who sign up on Facebook are not employed by nation states but just ordinary people who want an easy way to stay connected to friends and family. Maybe these people should have a better way to stay connected than using a public website.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by baq on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:08AM (#23324498)
indeed this happened but that's hardly a reason to let it continue to be.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by seph-reed on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:22PM (#23317599)
Why are you defending Zuckerberg for being a dick? If you have power, you have responsibility: full fucking stop.

The idea that it's okay to be a selfish child with power is tantamount to allowing driving while drunk. Power is deadly, you can just as easily crush a persons life as you could their legs with a car. Don't drive drunk, don't be in power if you can't be a responsible citizen about it.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by CompSciPunk on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:47PM (#23317801)
Power does not imply responsibility, nor visa versa, there is definitely a venn diagram here. Dictators - all power, no responsibility. Manager of a homeless shelter - lots of responsibility, little power.

I believe, with nothing to back this up, that social media would be improved with a better educated population. One that knows and values the basic tenets of critical thinking and debate. No amount of policing will make people smarter or more courteous. People have to choose to be more civil and be more interested in views counter to their own.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by matz1 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:46PM (#23318233)
The poster doesn't defending Zuckerberg, merely trying to explain why Zuckerberg did what he did.

>If you have power, you have responsibility: full fucking stop.

No, if you have power you get to decide the rule.

Same as drunk driving, the reason we are not allowing driving while drunk is because the people who are against drunk driving has more power than the people who are pro drunk driving. The side that has more power get to decide what the law is.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by seph-reed on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:36PM (#23325882)
You're confusing legal responsibility with responsibility proper.

Dictators are responsible for the death of millions, even if they make laws that say otherwise.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by matz1 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @02:46PM (#23327938)
Responsibility proper is subjective.

>Dictators are responsible for the death of millions.

The Dictators very well may believe that their action is the proper responsibility (According to him).

My point is you can't simply ask them to stop by telling them they have responsibility. Both side may view responsibility differently.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by StandardFuture on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:29PM (#23317197)
Excuse my ignorance, but isn't the overlay network setup problem one that has problems at almost every level of the stack? If there is not any definitive technical problems to overcome, why is it not possible to create a mobile app that friends and family could use as their own private network?

Isn't the internet supposed to be every node acting as it's own server and client simultaneously anyways? Is the problem just the inability to truly decentralize discovery, registry, and identity authentication of nodes in the network? Or is the problem that most ISPs don't want people operating services out of their homes or off of their phones?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:06PM (#23317503)
"Excuse my ignorance, but isn't the overlay network setup problem one that has problems at almost every level of the stack?"

It works for me and has worked for others. The keyword here that distinguishes this idea from almost every other "peer-to-peer overlay network" project that you can read about is "small". If you limit the size of the network, you can avoid some problems. Most projects you read about aim at the ability to create a single, large network that potentially everyone can join. Open to the public. However using a different approach it is possible to create only small networks that are only open to people you know, e.g., friends, family, co-workers. There are still problems, but there are always going to be some problems. The internet you are using right now has problems. The question is does it work well enough. The small overlay network idea has worked well enough for me that I consider it one of the better ones. It is really impossible to debate these ideas on the internet. Opinions are strong and negativity is even stronger. If you want an answer you need to try things out yourself and draw your own conslusions. No peer-to-peer solution is "perfect" and if you are always looking for the solution with zero negatives and zero limitations, you will never find it. Worse is if you never actually try these solutions, you just read about them. After you try many of them and learn what you like and do not like about the design/implementation, it is easier to chose one idea that works for your use case. Everytime someone starts promoting a peer-to-peer project you can quickly evaluate it, based on what types of designs/implementations have worked for you and which ones didn't. Well, that's my opinion, anyway.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by gmax on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:40PM (#23317274)
It may not be that hard to set up things for yourself, have been toying with something like that for messaging https://cweb.gitlab.io/StoneAge.html. The deeper question is how to sustain this kind of products and make them competitive without comparable funding.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bobthepanda on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:37PM (#23318824)
Email exists. Wordpress has free site hosting. SMS is ad free. If people wanted to create a free webpage for friends and family to see there are loads of options. The problem is that, generally speaking, most people do not find the value proposition as a Facebook replacement compelling.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @11:50PM (#23319208)
Where are you getting this idea of "Facebook replacement"?

You introduce your own idea, then shoot it down.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

Facebook does not provide software to set up small overlay networks.

Nor is the business of Facebook to provide messaging or free web pages. That is just bait. The business of Facebook is providing a way to advertise to targeted audiences within the billions of people who visit Facebook. That is what people pay for. It is a website with billions of daily visitors.

Unless you have a webite with billions of visitors then you are not competing with Facebook.

A small overlay network is not a website, it is a computer network. It does not have a large audience because the number of nodes is small. It is an interface you see when you type ifconfig or ip addr, not an email server, a blog website or an SMS provider. You could could use it for those things or you could use it for other things, anything you can do on a LAN.

It makes zero difference what you think people want. This is not a popularity contest of any sort. If you want to argue against the premise of my comment then you need to argue that small, personally-managed overlay networks and peer to peer connections are less efficient for sharing content with friends and family than using a public website, subject to "curation" and "censorship".

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by bobthepanda on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:05PM (#23328267)
> In 2020, it is still too difficult for everyone to set up their own website, so they settle for a page on someone else's [for] exchanging content with friends and family

This is patently not true. People were using email for this prior to Facebook's existence, which worked well enough ("Share photos via email! Share videos via email! Here's a funny story from grandma! RSVP to my birthday!") and was painless to set up; in fact, all the people who have Facebooks also have emails! But very few people are doing this anymore as their main mode of communication with friends and family; this kind of activity is now happening on Facebook, where people are happy with the ease that it facilitates. Small networks works fine, but nobody's interested, hence why Facebook is worth billions and billions of dollars and is a large website.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:40PM (#23353861)
You say "nobody's interested". That of course is "patently false". For one, pwdisswordfish2 is apparently interested. The author and other users of the software he/she says she uses are obviously interested. There are numerous projects that aim to use overlays. The overlay idea was used by one company that sold multiple times, ultimately to Microsoft for billions of dollars. The HN readers who upvoted the comment describing small overlays are presumably interested in seeing the idea presented in a comment.

The stated purpose of this forum is intellectual curiosity. There is nothing in bobthepanda's comments that is directed at that stated purpose. Why is he/she arguing about email usage when the quoted sentence refers to setting up websites? This looks like more of the "straw man" argument technique. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by int_19h on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:52PM (#23318911)
That's because the real value of Facebook is in the social graph, and it's locked in there.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by gdilla on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:12PM (#23318021)
Some families already have their own slack. chat, post articles, share pics, and even put content in appropriate channels that you're free to join or leave! I already do this with my friends group of about 20 cuz it's more than good enough.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by justapassenger on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:29PM (#23317649)
> The primary content no user wants to see any every user agent would filter out is ads

"no user"? Nope. People buy magazines, that are 90% ads. Subscribe to newsletters. Hunt for coupons. Watch home shopping channels. Etc, etc.

There's large part of population that wants to see ads. Scammy and bad ads? No. Good and relevant ads? A LOT of people do want them. Even tech-folks, who claim that ads are worst thing for humanity. Don't you want to learn about sale for new tech gadgets? Discounts for AWS? Good rent deals?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by kelnos on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:19PM (#23318078)
> Don't you want to learn about sale for new tech gadgets? Discounts for AWS? Good rent deals?

No, not at all. Ads don't just inform about deals, they also incite you to buy. I don't want to buy just because some random company got the chance to put some psychological manipulation in front of my eyeballs. If I want or need something, I will specifically seek it out. If I don't specifically seek it out, then I probably don't really need it.

If the price (heh) of that is that I miss out on some better deals for stuff that I would otherwise seek out, I'm fully happy eating that cost.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by josho on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:26PM (#23318448)
> If I want or need something, I will specifically seek it out

Sometimes we don't know that we have a problem that is easily solvable. As an example, I had no idea that there was an industry to reduce aws spending. One day a marketer made it past my filters and made me aware of an industry that I benefit from today. Just one example of many where marketing is win-win.

On the other hand I agree that there is too much psychological manipulation, unfortunately it exists because it works. Maybe this is where we need to disrupt the industry through a different approach. Just brainstorming, what if we regulated advertising to prohibit emotional/manipulative messages and rely instead on advertising facts?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by toddmclaughlin on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:07PM (#23318677)
> Ads don't just inform about deals, they also incite you to buy. I don't want to buy just because some random company got the chance to put some psychological manipulation in front of my eyeballs.

I'm curious why you don't want to encounter these "manipulations". Is it because of the brainpower it uses to identify them as such? Are you particularly susceptible to giving in to them? Something else? I'm genuinely curious.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by thejynxed on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @02:32PM (#23327714)
Not sure about him, but from my point of view ads mostly leave a slimy, oily, nauseating feel in my brain and make me want to gouge my eyes out.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by dannyw on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:41PM (#23318545)
I purposefully read a site called OzBargain, which is basically a compilation of ads. Sometimes I buy stuff I don’t need. Nonetheless, I like OzBargain.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pixl97 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:50PM (#23318252)
>I don't want to buy just because some random company got the chance to put some psychological manipulation in front of my eyeballs

Lots of people say this online, I just don't believe them. Visual psychological manipulation works well enough on most people.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ccktlmazeltov on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:25PM (#23318441)
That makes no sense to me, I bought a lot of cool stuff just because I saw an ads on instagram :|
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by latexr on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:29PM (#23318140)
> Don't you want to learn about sale for new tech gadgets? Discounts for AWS? Good rent deals?

No. I want less intrusions on my senses, not more. I buy few things, and ads are irrelevant for the central ones: groceries and utilities are dependent on my place of residence.

If given the choice, I’d welcome with open arms the chance to never see an ad again anywhere, including offline. I’ve never seen an ad with a deal as good as that one, and I doubt I ever will.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @04:27AM (#23320750)
There's a fundamental mismatch between how consumers value ads shown to them and how advertising platforms value the ads.

Suppose there is a $100 product that produces $110 worth of value for a specific person and costs $50 to produce and deliver to them. To use economics terms, there's a $10 consumer surplus here, and a $50 producer surplus. The consumer willingness to see the ad is proportional to the consumer surplus, while the producer's willingness to pay for ad placement is proportional to producer surplus.

This is a fundamental divergence in interests; because the ad networks are paid by producers, they'll serve the ads that tend to make ad buyers the most money, not the ads that best enrich the viewers' lives.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by K0SM0S on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:46PM (#23317787)
Honestly a truly well-made ad targeting on me, something that really ticked all the right boxes... gosh I'd spend 3-4× more, easily. Because ordinarily I just don't lose time on shopping websites, but I'm kinda of a spender when I do find things that I like. And I'm a sucker for good deals, I'm a patient prey hunter, I can wait months in ambush for the right deal.

Anecdotally of course, as one of those tech-folks who's got nothing against good and relevant ads.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by save_ferris on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:27PM (#23318123)
> Anecdotally of course, as one of those tech-folks who's got nothing against good and relevant ads.

Be careful what you wish for. This TED talk[0] on persuasion architectures brings up some interesting moral arguments against this idea. If we generally accept that ad conversion is a metric of an ad's success, how do we handle the situation where people that are susceptible to addictive behaviors like gambling and compulsive shopping are exposed to ads that exploit their condition? Data-driven advertising systems are built particularly well to find and exploit these kinds of people. We already see this a lot in the scam call/email world. Once you fall for one, the amount of inbound traffic you receive from scammers increases dramatically.

0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFTWM7HV2UI&t=872s

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by Izkata on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:13PM (#23318357)
> how do we handle the situation where people that are susceptible to addictive behaviors like gambling and compulsive shopping are exposed to ads that exploit their condition?

Ads like that used to be common. By your description, it sounds like they died out on their own.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by save_ferris on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @07:17PM (#23331351)
How? Data-driven ad systems are built specifically to target people who have a high probability of conversion. The perfect person for such a system is one that would constantly (i.e. impulsively) buy or convert.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by microcolonel on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:13PM (#23318027)
I guess I just don't buy enough things to want to see any ads at all. I don't have any particular issue selecting products either.

A well targeted ad doesn't need to serve you well, it just needs to convince you to buy; I have a lot of faith in myself and I'd say those are often the same thing, but experiences may differ.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by taurath on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:46PM (#23318232)
The “ads just aren’t good enough yet” poster while right doesn’t really take into account the terrifying things companies would ask to know about you in order to properly target those ads
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by birdyrooster on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:32PM (#23318492)
Marketing is typically about getting to the customer before the customer does any homework. The more informed the customer is, the less conversions the marketing heavy company will get. This is because they spend their budget on marketing (thus you seeing their ad as opposed to the competition). That means they don’t have the same resources dedicated to their product.

Sure at some scale, marketing becomes a requirement to build your brand for many other purposes and I will also concede that in some cases, like with services that hinge on network effect, marketing is required for the product to even become viable. But most things are not social networks and we would be better served to learn of the product in context with its competition in a less biased setting.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by matheusmoreira on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @11:11PM (#23319014)
> Don't you want to learn about sale for new tech gadgets? Discounts for AWS? Good rent deals?

Sure. The thing is: when people are interested in something, they look for it. When I want to buy some games, I open my PS4's store. Any advertising I get there is absolutely fine because I asked for it. I told the software to show me the stuff that's available for me to buy.

The problem is when I open a link to some web page and 80% of my phone's screen turns into advertising noise I didn't ask for and couldn't care less about. I make it a point to delete this noise.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by egypturnash on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:36PM (#23318522)
Honestly I think the only way to make an ethical social network is to make a non-profit one. Fund it alongside other public goods like PBS, public education, highways, rail networks, healthcare, etc.

And yes, I know: good luck getting THAT to happen in the US given how badly funded everything else in my list is. If you’re in another country that actually funds public goods maybe this is a thing you could talk to some of your fellow techies about and make a proposal, especially if your country is getting increasingly tired of Facebook?

Alternatively, ground-up local funding of federated social networks might be workable; I run a Mastodon server for myself and a small group of my friends and acquaintances, with the costs pretty much evenly split between myself and the users who have money to spare. It is not without its flaws and problems but it is a thing I can generally keep going with a small investment of my spare time every few months.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by giardini on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:15AM (#23319336)
The solution is to nationalize FaceBook (and any site that proves to be similar) and allow everyone free access to it w/o censorship. Give Zuckerberg a $1 for his time and effort.

Meahwhile, Google must be split up: e.g., Alphabet can go do AI work as a private corporation but Google Search needs to be nationalized (or split into at least 3 entities - i prefer nationalization).

Amazon must be broken up and parts nationalized, but this is a more complex case for later discussion.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by thejynxed on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @02:52PM (#23328032)
A) These companies are American, and outside of certain, very specific, industries explicitly mentioned in the War Powers Act, the American government has no authority to nationalize them at any time for any reason.

B) Companies like Facebook in particular can never be nationalized due to the First & Fourth Amendments, and government being barred from competing with private entities in the private sector.

C) I do agree that Google and Amazon should be tried for anti-trust violations and that Google in particular should be split for violating anti-trust laws against vertical integration across markets.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by berdario on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:24AM (#23319379)
Ok, but which country would Google Search have to be nationalized into?

The brits won't be happy if Google is nationalized into a french public service

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by a1369209993 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:14PM (#23316473)
> The primary content no user wants to see any every user agent would filter out is ads.

Not that you're wrong, but: that's the fucking point!

Advertising delenda est.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by arihant on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:17PM (#23316515)
Pay for Facebook then. 1.5% of total YouTube users subscribe for YT Premium. I love how the smartest minds will ignore the most primitive economics. Ads work. For everyone. Except deluded.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by Calamity on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:44PM (#23316793)
You know the worst part? I do pay for YT Premium and yet Google still finds a way to throw ads at me on Youtube videos through videos it suggests via Google Feeds (the leftmost screen on a Pixel). I bloody pay for the service and yet I am still getting ads on any youtube video I play when clicking any youtube suggested video on that feed. How annoying do you think that is? When you give in and pay, yet you are still getting harassed.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by nsriv on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:04PM (#23316958)
I had this issue as well and logging out (in my case, switching accounts) wiping Google app cache, and I think rebooting to make Pixel Launcher refresh, then logging back into the YT Premium subscribed account fixed it for me. Convoluted I know, but I think the issue was it wasn't picking up some profile variable or token denoting me as a subscriber. Hope that helps!
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by Calamity on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:39PM (#23317734)
Hey, thanks for this, just did this. Will now just have to wait and see until Google suggests me a new youtube video to see if it worked.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by dkn775 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:17PM (#23318068)
I knew that google feed was advertising, any reading about google news and google feed that talks about this? I have a pixel, same findings.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by comawhite on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:38PM (#23316721)
To be honest, I'd happily pay for YT Premium if Google didn't use my data to personalise other results and content on the internet. I personally stop using products/services that dictate what content is deemed "suitable" for my consumption. I'll happily be served adverts so long as I'm not getting manipulated.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pessimizer on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:39PM (#23317271)
If everybody paid for facebook, it would have as many ads, if not more. That companies would leave money on the table with no incentive to do so is a bizarre self-justifying myth that people who live off advertising tell themselves.

You pay for cable. Paying customers are a better audience for ads than deadbeats.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by themacguffinman on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:25PM (#23317623)
But everybody doesn't pay for Facebook, and the reason they don't do so is because Facebook is funded by ads and no one has paid for a Facebook without ads. But sure, Facebook might hypothetically still have ads if users paid, and my grandmother might hypothetically be a bicycle if she had wheels.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by throwaway2048 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:01PM (#23318303)
Facebook's purpose of existence isn't for somebody to "pay for it".

Facebook's purpose of existence is to make money.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by themacguffinman on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @01:35AM (#23319676)
And the way they make money is by someone paying for it. Some sites collect payments from users directly. Facebook collects payments from advertisers because most users wouldn't use Facebook if they had to pay for it.

Do you have a point? This reads like an unfinished thought.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by throwaway2048 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @02:25AM (#23319962)
there is absolutely no reason that they cant do both at the same time, there is a mental short circuit going on when people think paying for a website means no ads. Its never meant that in pretty much any other media.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by themacguffinman on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @02:46PM (#23327944)
Yes there is a reason, users often don't expect to pay for services that show ads, and users who pay for services often don't expect to see ads. That's why most popular online services don't mix the two, eg. Facebook, Spotify, YouTube, Netflix, Crunchyroll, Google, etc.

"mental short circuit" better describes your argument that jumps from "it's possible to both show ads and charge user fees" to "they always will".

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by creato on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:19PM (#23316529)
Where did you get that number? That's actually far, far higher than I would have thought and quite encouraging...
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by jjjensen90 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:23PM (#23316572)
On Feb 4th, Google said there were 20 million Youtube Premium users, and I believe the latest estimates put Youtube at 2 billion users, which would be a 1% subscription rate.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by mikenew on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:50PM (#23316847)
It would be interesting to see how they count a "user" too. If a good portion of those 2 billion people don't use YouTube very much then the % of users who are using it regularly and subscribing might be a lot higher.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by schuyler2d on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:29PM (#23317646)
The irony is that there's a disincentive to skip ads on 'paid' users even more -- because people willing to pay for things are even more valuable to advertisers -- so if you make a paid option with no ads, you're also gutting the value of the freemium-ads option (beyond the average user loss)
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by nicoburns on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:37PM (#23316712)
Paid-for Facebook would be a viable business if it wasn't competing with free-facebook. It's not ignoring economics to think that Facebook is causing significant negative externalities that ought to be priced or regulated to allow more ethical alternatives to thrive.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by baq on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:00PM (#23316931)
free facebook should be regulated out of existence. what else is free that is good for you? in big cities you have to pay for clean air to breathe already.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by pwdisswordfish2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:04PM (#23316957)
That does not tell us much. Where can we look at YouTube's balnce sheet? There is likely more to YouTube as a business than selling ads on YouTube. For one, YouTube under Google is like AC Nielson on steroids. The combination easily rivals any "smart" TV.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by Abekkus on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:53PM (#23316873)
I paid for youtube for a while, but I did not get a different algorithm. It was the same feed of addictive, stressful content. I stopped paying once I noticed this.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by freeone3000 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:35PM (#23317240)
I already don't get ads on youtube, so I don't see why I should pay for this when I can get all of the benefit with none of the expense.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by nabla9 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:22PM (#23316558)
> Pay for Facebook

You can do that?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by monadic2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:34PM (#23316690)
Compare how much money google can make off ads in a month to $15. You’re paying for way, way, way more than just removing ads and it’s obvious
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by trisiak on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:54PM (#23316876)
That's why you get other benefits that are much harder to price in.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by monadic2 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @01:06AM (#23319552)
....and most don’t use or want.

Of course they conveniently only bundle these features so they can pretend it’s what customers want—hell downloading and playing when the screen is off should be a part of youtube. Just another step in the long saga of companies intentionally crippling their own services to bilk customers.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by a1369209993 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:45PM (#23316806)
I don't use Facebook, and I want it to die. Facebook is one of the many, many reasons why advertising must be destroyed.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by egypturnash on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:54PM (#23318609)
How? AFAIK you can’t pay for Facebook. There’s no “Facebook Premium”. There’s only Ad Spigot Facebook.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ggggtez on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:18PM (#23317100)
Let's imagine for a moment that a decentralized social network actually took off.

How long until those ads crop back up anyway? Instagram should give us some idea on how sponsored content might look in such a system. According to some random site, the average price for a "sponsored" instagram post is $300. You think your friends are above showing you an ad when real money is on the line? Maybe they won't be making that kind of money with very few followers, but when Pizzahut asks you to post an ad in exchange for a free pizza, I think you'll see plenty of takers. Now, granted, at least the people being paid are your friends, instead of Zuck.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by CuriousSkeptic on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:09PM (#23318342)
But the kind of people who get $300 for a post should have a very large group of followers. Which should imply that there should be a reasonably large group of people prepared to part with some money in support of their work.

And for the small group of people it seems to me that it should be easily self correcting by normal social cues since there’s no network effect to offset it.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by int_19h on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:54PM (#23318925)
This played out in LiveJournal, and the outcome, generally speaking, was that paid promotions were too blatant to be effective outside of influencers proper (where it's part of the explicit contract between them and their audience).
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by monadic2 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:31PM (#23316645)
> Since ads are the primary way sites stay in business

Flaw? It seems that the point would be to force FB to transact with currency rather than a bait-and-switch tactic. The site would also be more usable if they were forced to change business model.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by manquer on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:28PM (#23316608)
That is how it is today. But does it have to be like that ? What is the minimum revenue per user required for service like FB to run.

While everyone is sceptical on whether such a service can reach critical mass to make financial sense, a brand new FB replacement may not be able to do it, However FB itself can certainly give that as an option without hurting their revenues substantially.

I was sceptical on the value prop for Youtube Premium, I am constantly surprised how many people pay for it, if google can afford to loose ad money with YT premium, I am sure FB can build a financial model around a freemium offering if they wanted to.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by marcinzm on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:37PM (#23316716)
Minimum doesn't matter, the only question is if it's more profitable than the current approach. Facebook makes $9/user/quarter. That's every user no matter how little they use the site.

The issue however is that the users advertisers care about are the ones with disposable income. The users most likely to opt out of ads are the ones with disposable income. Thus the marginal cost to Facebook from such users is significantly more than $9/quarter.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ardy42 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:06PM (#23316978)
>>> The ultimate problem is that Facebook doesn't want to show you good, enriching content from your friends and family. They want to show you ads. The good content is just a necessary evil to make you tolerate looking at ads.

>> That is how it is today. But does it have to be like that ? What is the minimum revenue per user required for service like FB to run.

> Minimum doesn't matter, the only question is if it's more profitable than the current approach.

Only if you think strictly inside the box.

The real problem here is one is a misalignment of incentives: Zuckerberg is managing Facebook to maximize the metric he's being evaluated on (profit and wealth), not the value provided to society.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by marcinzm on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:18PM (#23317105)
Value to society is subjective and many horrors of the past (and current) were caused by trying to optimize specific definitions of that term.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:43PM (#23317314)
And many horrors of the past and present were and are caused by optimizing for profits. So it's not like we get to side-step horror-avoidance.

I'd start with treating users as partners, and not cattle.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by marcinzm on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:59PM (#23317450)
>So it's not like we get to side-step horror-avoidance.

Which is my point. It's easy to say "just force them to optimize for value to society" and then ignore what that really entails in practice. And what giving someone the power to do that tends to cause.

Actually solving the related problems and making things actually better is probably possible but it's messy and hard and complicated.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by int_19h on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @10:56PM (#23318935)
"force them to optimize" doesn't mean putting a gun to somebody's head. But it's clear that the existing socioeconomic arrangements overall incentivize companies, including Facebook, to do a lot of harm while chasing profits. Forcing them to not do so can also mean changing the arrangements to remove the incentives.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ardy42 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:46PM (#23317794)
> It's easy to say "just force them to optimize for value to society" and then ignore what that really entails in practice. And what giving someone the power to do that tends to cause.

> Actually solving the related problems and making things actually better is probably possible but it's messy and hard and complicated.

What you describe is politics, and it's inescapable.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by solveit on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:40PM (#23318200)
> I'd start with treating users as partners, and not cattle.

What does this mean in practice? How do you treat 2.6 billion people as partners?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by henriquemaia on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:38PM (#23316719)
> I am sure FB can build a financial model around a freemium offering if they wanted to.

They probably could. As they could also charge you a premium and then profit two times on top of you — with your fee and then by selling your data to third parties. Why? Because who would know that was happening? Corporations have no moral compass dictating their actions. The bottom line being what's best for investors.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by manquer on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:50AM (#23325079)
Google uses my watching data in YouTube premium paying or not. They only claim not to show ads , that’s what most users care about . Even if FB sells / uses the data , as long as you don’t see ads and promoted content there are enough people who will pay for it

20 million for YT @ 5$/month is more than 1 billion in revenue per year. Given that 20M is just 1% of the user base , there is probably not a lot impact on the ad revenue either.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by CuriousSkeptic on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:17PM (#23318392)
In don’t see Facebook surviving such a transition. Without the manipulation and data mining for engagement you’re just left with a few features that is probably easily subsumed by other services in some federated fashion. It would provably look as exciting as hosted e-mail from the business side.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by manquer on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:54AM (#23325138)
Only a minority of users would pay for it. <1% of the users going by YT numbers .

It is not either free or paid , it can be both . It satisfies a need for the people willing to pay for the privilege of not seeing ads and gives additional revenue even.

No radical business changes required only a ideological change to treat their users as humans in required from FB

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by panopticon on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:54PM (#23317413)
I think another tangential but related issue is with how these companies measure success. They measure success by engagement, and things that drive the most user engagement aren't usually the best for the user.

YouTube has been getting a lot of flack for this recently.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by KorematsuFred on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:53PM (#23317399)
I am happy to pay $10 bucks a month for a facebook like service that suggests me engaging, high quality content without any promotional content.

I am already getting such service in the form of Android's newsfeed feature on pixel. Its google but its pretty good.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by dkn775 on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:06PM (#23317971)
You mean the screen to the left of the home screen? I have noticed a lot of low quality information and some advertising masquerading as articles.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by rockinghigh on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:56PM (#23317435)
> The good content is just a necessary evil to make you tolerate looking at ads.

You could make the same argument for Google or other online web sites relying on ads as the primary source of revenue.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by tomaskafka on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:59PM (#23317445)
You can, and if you look at Google's actions long term, they do.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by naravara on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @05:40PM (#23316741)
>Since ads are the primary way sites stay in business, they are obligated to fight against user agents or other intermediary systems.

Not all users hate ads in principle, just in practice. In theory, you'd be making the users select ads for relevance and not being annoying. But obviously, the site wants to show ads based on how much they're paying and "not being annoying" only factors in if pushes people off the site entirely.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by hallambaker on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @07:59PM (#23317908)
How are the user agents funded? Probably through ads.

The problem is actually how to fund the timeline publication services. But systems like Medium etc seem to work OK.

I am now spending several hundred dollars a year on content subscriptions. Plus subscriptions for Gmail, Zoom and a few other things where I have outgrown the free service. A freemium model for the timeline publication services would probably work.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by TwoBit on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:04PM (#23316956)
Facebook would be perfectly happy to eliminate all ads if instead you paid a small or even tiny monthly fee. But you won't pay it.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:44PM (#23317331)
No, they wouldn't, unless advertising gets banned. They'd instead accept your payment and find a way to shove ads in anyway, in a covert or overt way, just as many paid services do, because why leave money on the table?
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by rockinghigh on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:53PM (#23317405)
YouTube and Spotify went that subscription route and it works well. There are no ads.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by CuriousSkeptic on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:26PM (#23318452)
Spotify is reliant on copyright exclusions to keep competing free services at bay. So aren’t really providing any value.

YouTube is still reliant on ads, and ad-funded content creators, and will continue serving you manipulative content wether you pay or not. So can’t really count that as a success either.

The thing is when you remove the ugly side of those business what remains can bee done better for free using p2p networks or federation over open protocols.

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by solveit on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:34PM (#23318513)
> The thing is when you remove the ugly side of those business what remains can be done better for free using p2p networks or federation over open protocols.

Then why hasn't it happened?

Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @01:29AM (#23319644)
Because the ugly side of those businesses remains.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by adrianN on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:27AM (#23319398)
If you don't count "influencers" as ads.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by flippyhead on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:51PM (#23318258)
I don't know about that. I buy a lot of things. I wish something would help me buy what I need and didn't know I needed so I didn't have to spend time shopping and researching.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by vinniejames on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:53PM (#23318273)
According to this research, it isn't even good content. It's divisive content intended to force you to pick a "side" then fight for it
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ccktlmazeltov on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @09:24PM (#23318434)
Not true, I want to see good ads, ads that relate to what I actually want to buy.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by lucio on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @11:10PM (#23319009)
maybe you're interested in hearing about X tech, or you can tell your "Agent" that you want to buy Y thing, or travel to Z. That's where ads and reviews get thru.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by ngold on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @06:31PM (#23317219)
Still waiting for that ublock origin web browser.
Re:Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site le... by DanHulton on Tuesday May 26, 2020 @08:58PM (#23318293)
This feels like saying "the fundamental flaw about email spam blocking is won't somebody think of the spammers?"