News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by marcell on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:33PM (#22981205)
I've been tracking the antibody study results in a spreadsheet, and they are suggesting a 10-20x undercount of cases in the official "confirmed" numbers. You can see the data I've collected here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16onEUBWIV5IqN1RCvTla...
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by cies on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:47PM (#22981330)
I did similar calculations, and found the institutions in charge give us very unreliable data. The term "corona case" is very, very, ambiguous and cannot the understood as such without a detailed explanation on how the counting was done.

Thanks for sharing.

I found the peek in all-case mortality also very interesting, because that way counting is much more unambiguous: dead is dead.

They showed a clear diversion from the "average" in recent weeks, but... they did not show the stdev for the averages. Finally I found a chart that shows that "outliers" are not uncommon.

https://imgur.com/IPNiXRe

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by GuB-42 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:30PM (#22983436)
Here is for Europe if you are interested. There are charts for excess morality by country, by age, and by year.

https://www.euromomo.eu/

There is a very noticeable spike in the worst hit countries: Italy, Spain, France, Belgium, Netherlands and the UK. The cumulative excess deaths for all Europe in the last two months matches the COVID-19 reported deaths (around 100000).

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by usr1106 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:27AM (#22984745)
> The cumulative excess deaths for all Europe in the last two months matches the COVID-19 reported deaths

This article claims that most Covid-19 hotspots have significantly more excess deaths than reported covid deaths. Suggesting that there is a lot of underreporting. NYC being a notable exception. I think several countries count only corona deaths in hospitals, but systematically miss all deaths in care facilities. https://www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/corona-todesfaelle-wie-v... (charts should be readable despite any language barrier)

(I don't defend either view. As the old joke goes, don't trust any statistics you haven't manipulated yourself :) Statistics and causality have always been difficult, even more so in exceptional time with imperfect short-term data only.)

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by GuB-42 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @09:50AM (#22987116)
There is under-reporting that's for sure, but there is also a delay in all-cause mortality. In some cases, the same country both over and under reports. To be honest, I am surprised to see such a close match. I expected similar numbers, but this is within ~10%, which I suspect is a coincidence. But still, that's interesting.

Another coincidence is that the country that is most suspected of under-reporting, Germany, is also the least represented in EuroMOMO. There is data for only 2 regions.

Italy, Spain and France, the most significant contributors both in COVID-19 related deaths and excess mortality in general, all count deaths in care facilities now. I don't know about the UK though. Deaths at home are probably not counted, but according to the authorities, they are a minority: COVID-19 does not happen suddenly and people normally have time to go to the hospital. Still significant though.

My gut feeling is that there are actually ~50% more deaths than reported. But we'll have to wait for at least a few months to get proper statistics.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by djsumdog on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:41AM (#22985338)
It's nice to have another source on this. I saw a similar comparison from an Italian site:

https://www.corriere.it/politica/20_marzo_26/the-real-death-...

New York has been criticized for retroactively adding older cases. The Johns Hopkins data just tacks it on to the end of their time series, creating a weird spike and screwing up what the data represents:

https://battlepenguin.com/tech/fighting-with-the-data/

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by pacala on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:05AM (#22984622)
The spike has all but receded. Maybe be we're just having 3 flues in one year. Reason enough to stop the world?
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by barbegal on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:31AM (#22984770)
The spike receding is due to incomplete data rather than a reduction in deaths. Deaths (especially in the current circumstances) can take a couple of weeks to get registered properly.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by dpau on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:31AM (#22985031)
also need to take into account the decline in deaths from other factors due to quarantines, social distancing, and improved hygiene. less driving, less spread of other infectious diseases, etc.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by igravious on Sunday April 26, 2020 @04:09AM (#22985465)
> The cumulative excess deaths for all Europe in the last two months matches the COVID-19 reported deaths (around 100000).

Where's the noticeable spike for Ireland? Where's the spike for Portugal? Where's the spike for Luxembourg? Where's the data for the rest of Germany outside of Hesse and Berlin? Where's the spike for Austria? (And this is not a criticism of them, but they only track Western Europe by the looks of things.)

Don't know where Euromomo is getting its data from but I suggest to you that it's incomplete.

This NYT article[0] (other publications like The Economist[1] have arrived at similar numbers) show that the cumulative excess deaths for France, Netherlands, Switzerland, Spain, and England & Wales sometimes far exceeds reported Covid-19 deaths.

Of the countries you mention only Belgium is actually reporting accurately. (As is Sweden btw, a country you do not mention.) Note that both are smallish countries.

As of 14 hours ago Chris Giles (FT economics editor) tweeted[2] "A cautious estimate of the total number of UK excess deaths linked to coronavirus stands today at 42,700" (He updates this most days.) Worldometer[3] currently has the UK on 20,319 deaths. Quite a difference.

In fact, the numbers show that in Europe actual deaths are between 1.4 [Swiss] and 2.1 [British] times higher than the reported numbers for countries that are under-reporting.

Btw, you say that there are 100,000 deaths? EU 27 has 96,533 deaths as of this moment. EU+UK has 116,852 deaths as of this moment. And Europe in its entirety[4][5] has 122,568. (Am tracking these figures using a spreadsheet.)

Let's say that the adjustment we have to make is between 1.4 and 2.1 and let's ignore population size and pick 1.75 and then lower that to take into account that some countries are accurately reporting and let's err on the conservative side so let's choose 1.66… repeating as our adjustment rate, agreed? This gives us an estimated excess # of deaths for Europe of 204,280. Twice the figure you've given.

[0] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronav...

[1] https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/04/16/tracking...

[2] https://twitter.com/ChrisGiles_/status/1254105061745098752?s...

[3] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europe [5] https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/new/

(Europe is generally taken to extend from the Atlantic states of Ireland, Portugal, and Iceland in the West to the Ural and Caucasus Mountains in the east, from Scandinavia in the north to Italy and Greece in the south.)

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by thu2111 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @06:50AM (#22986179)
There's a simple reason for that: the lockdowns are killing lots of people and will kill even more. That's not under-reporting but rather an obvious outcome of clearing the health system in expectation of a surge that never came. Probably the UK will see an extreme form of this effect as people are encouraged to see the NHS as a sort of public park that everyone has to take care of rather than a large mechanical system, as in countries with private/insurance based healthcare.

Admissions at hospitals have collapsed: in the UK they halved. Admissions due to respiratory illnesses however didn't really go up, not surprising when you consider the small absolute numbers. There is now a massive backlog of operations and diagnostics for cancer that health systems will struggle to clear in time.

There's a story with some analysis of that problem here:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/04/26/what-second-coro...

In the past the recommendations of epidemiologists have ended up killing a lot more than they saved, with the 2001 foot and mouth epidemic in the UK being a classic example. It's likely it will be true again this time.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by nradov on Sunday April 26, 2020 @09:08AM (#22986867)
Malta is also considered part of Europe, south of Italy.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by igravious on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:14AM (#22995488)
Of course yes, sorry. I should have said the Mediterranean Islands Malta/Cyprus in the the south. Thanks!
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by marcell on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:53PM (#22981385)
Yea, I agree that the case counts are very different between regions. I think the more interesting column is the IFR estimate based on the antibody study results, since dead is dead as you say.

It is interesting though that the median undercount is converging to ~10-20x. Perhaps the protocols across regions are similar enough that the confirmed case counts are somewhat comparable.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday April 25, 2020 @07:44PM (#22982689)
It seems possible to me that there are variations, mutations, in different regions that might account for some of the variance in apparent R value and such?
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by amscanne on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:46AM (#22984836)
That chart is funny. The title is “unprecedented spike”, but it just shows that such outliers have occurred regularly.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by blago on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:48AM (#22985376)
Not at this time of the year if I am reading the chart right.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by thu2111 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @06:54AM (#22986204)
Time of year doesn't matter for his point though. What we care about is mortality, not whether it happens at the start or end of a winter.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by blago on Monday April 27, 2020 @01:02PM (#22997645)
Not all months are the same. It's clearly unprecedented for this time of the year.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by bobongo on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:16PM (#22981575)
> because that way counting is much more unambiguous: dead is dead

Unrealistically low death stats coming from Turkey compared to cases easily refute that argument.

Dead is dead, unless the state finds a way to claim that it was not a COVID19 dead.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by krisoft on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:37PM (#22982232)
No. Not unless. You misunderstand what all cause mortality means. The state can count COVID19 deaths as all bungee-jumping related the number still shows up in the total death rate. If you know what is the usual statistic you can show if there is an effect.

This is what “dead is dead” mean. One can argue what should count as a COVID19 case, and how exactly we are counting. There is a lot less argument over who is dead and who is not.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by bobongo on Saturday April 25, 2020 @07:28PM (#22982591)
> You misunderstand what all cause mortality means.

It seems I actually missed the mention of "all-cause" while reading the comment.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by autokad on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:13AM (#22984670)
a family member who is a doctor at a hospital told me that any patient that dies of a respiratory illness is being marked as covid19 even if they were never tested for it. dead truly means dead. dead by covid19 does not.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by gaius_baltar on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:31PM (#22981702)
> Dead is dead, unless the state finds a way to claim that it was not a COVID19 dead.

It's just a matter of demanding tests to declare as a COVID death and do not providing enough tests.

Brazil, for example, has an artificially low count of cases due to the lack of tests and a similarly low number of deaths. However, cases of death by "pneumonia", generic types of SARS and "unexplained respiratory diseases" skyrocketed: https://oglobo.globo.com/sociedade/coronavirus/alem-da-covid...

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by lostlogin on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:40PM (#22981778)
This has occurred in many countries and will presumably be part of way the final impact is finally measured. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronav...
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by asveikau on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:32PM (#22981715)
I would add that it doesn't have to be a malicious government purposefully undercounting. It's very easy to undercount or misdiagnose even with competent and well meaning people. Specifically every pneumonia death, heart attack, stroke is a potential undercount, and people aren't "bad people" or evil for making the wrong conclusion about the ultimate cause, especially when testing is less available and frequent than it should be. Also I have heard that there are a significant number of people dying of COVID19 in their homes and that those are more likely to be undercounted vs. a death in a hospital.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by cies on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:19PM (#22982082)
I said "dead is dead" in relation to all cause (not "only covid") mortality figures.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by bobongo on Saturday April 25, 2020 @07:29PM (#22982594)
I saw it just now. My apologies.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by snovv_crash on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:32PM (#22981711)
Or the other way around, someone who dies in a car crash but tests positive could count as a COVID death.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by rjtavares on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:35PM (#22981734)
Outliers such as this one are not uncommon in the winter. They are in April. According to that chart there isn't a single point outside of winter months as high as this year.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by cies on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:16PM (#22982061)
Maybe because its new and hit late winter?
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by FrojoS on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:41PM (#22981801)
Is this for the US? Do you have a link for the source?
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by cies on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:20PM (#22982096)
the chart is from ft.com, the news paper
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by Drdrdrq on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:36AM (#22985054)
Red line, nearly transparent old data, no link to source data... What's not to like? :) /s
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by joe_the_user on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:58PM (#22981432)
Your sheet is interesting. Looking at it, the IFR varies from 1.66% down to .11% and the 0.11% is for the Santa Clara, which many considered rather suspect.

The 1.66%, otoh, seems reasonably in line or at least compatible with what's been observed in Korea and elsewhere.

Given age is going to skew things a good deal, it seems like a picture is emerging but not that new a picture. An IFR of even 1% is pretty bad, especially given these statistics show how infectious this virus is.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by gst on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:26PM (#22981663)
The numbers that are quoted for Austria (which has the listed IFR of 1.66% in the document) weren't obtained via antibody tests, but via PCR tests. Here's a better source than the one linked in the document: https://www.sora.at/uploads/media/Austria_COVID-19_Prevalenc...

Most of those tests were done on April 4th and 5th which was 3 weeks after Austria started relatively strict lockdown measures, which also impacts that number, as this will result in the test to find an even lower number of positive people.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by newacct583 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:25PM (#22982135)
> An IFR of even 1% is pretty bad

To be clear: it would be the most dangerous general epidemic disease since the advent of vaccination, and by a significant amount. You need to go back to measles and polio to find general population outbreaks that were more lethal.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by rubber_duck on Saturday April 25, 2020 @07:22PM (#22982558)
A very important thing is that % is concentrated among old and people with preexisting health conditions.

Not every death is the same - a 80 year old with weak immune system could have lived 5 years longer without corona, but a healthy 20 year-old dying from cytokine storm caused by influenza has lost potentially 60 years of healthy life - the loss is much worse.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by Symmetry on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:48PM (#22983156)
I agree we should consider years of life lost but the figures are a bit higher than they ones you're using. 14 years on average for men and 12 for women. Not 60 years but more than 5. https://wellcomeopenresearch.org/articles/5-75
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by rubber_duck on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:19PM (#22983362)
Thank you for this link - this is the reason I come here :)

Seeing those numbers makes me more supportive of the isolation measures.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by joe_the_user on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:10PM (#22983297)
Not every death is the same - a 80 year old with weak immune system could have lived 5 years longer without corona, but a healthy 20 year-old dying from cytokine storm caused by influenza has lost potentially 60 years of healthy life - the loss is much worse.

In a triage situation, where you have to decide between different people dying, such choices are unavoidable or necessary. But I want highlight that you are talking about this stuff to say that it's OK to plan for the death of "a 80 year old with weak immune system could have lived 5 years longer" versus no death at all. And that's not OK.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by rubber_duck on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:23PM (#22983394)
But those discussions happen all the time. If there is a drug that can extend the life of this person for 5 years but it costs X - should it be covered by society ? At what X does it become unacceptable ? The highest numbers I've seen argued are in the 200k/year but realistically it's much lower depending on the country.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by joe_the_user on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:07PM (#22984007)
Well, there are two kinds of choices that are generally considered radically different.

One choice is providing some opportunity for further life beyond what's expected. That's generally considered something society likes but isn't obligated to provide. Society doesn't obligate it's member to spend money developing some miracle-extend that gives someone five more years.

The other choice is taking life that would normally be expected. That is something that society very much frowns on. If you could protect someone and you don't do it 'cause it would cost you money, you may wind-up in jail for murder.

Very quantitatively oriented people seem to have a hard time grasping why there's a difference here. But I think it's very rational in an evolutionary game-theoretic compact kind of way. Everyone is a member of society and values everyone else's life highly, more highly than immediate material things though maybe not more highly than other people's lives. This gives member of society basic security - you are thinking my insulin might worth just stealing and selling on the open market, me murdering you first might be my best strategy. You can see where things break down? The "social contract" is kind of the way around this.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by rubber_duck on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:37PM (#22984185)
You can self isolate without quarantine measures in effect so your point isn't that strong to me and you are ignoring that one of the biggest destabilising forces in history is economic downturn. US-China relations have been bad for a while now and both sides are throwing blame at each other as a populist policy (China has a US origin story allegedly). If this pushes the economy in to a global depression who knows what will happen s few years down the road. Taiwan, Korea, plenty of places that could erupt if things become politically unstable - both in the US and China.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by greedo on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:13AM (#22984672)
Self-isolating vulnerable populations is almost impossible. You're talking over 100M in the US.

And not doing anything (pretend it's just the flu) will result in 50M dead world wide. Everyone worried about a new depression should realize one is going to happen no matter what we do now. The only thing we can do is act in a humane fashion.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by jfnixon on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:15AM (#22985231)
Your number is highly suspect. About 16% of the US is 65+, or roughly 50M.

Where do you get your 50M worldwide figure? When a new flu appears, Neil Ferguson claims his 3K lies of undocumented C code forecast 200M will die. These numbers are all speculation and worse predictors than throwing darts at a board behind your back.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by greedo on Sunday April 26, 2020 @11:33AM (#22987848)
One third of the US population is considered at risk due to comorbidities. With over 328M people in the US, that's roughly 100M.

If you look worldwide, there are 7.8B people. If herd immunity takes 60% of the population becoming infected, that's 4.6B infections. With an IFR of 1%, that's 46.8M deaths. 460M hospitalizations (where possible).

Even say the IFR is overstated as some like. Say it's a magnitude less, comparable to the flu at .1% Now you are down to 4.7M deaths, but still the 460M hospitalizations. Still one of the most serious crises in the last 100 years.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by newacct583 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @07:59PM (#22982794)
> Not every death is the same

OK, so how many "influenza death equivalents" are we looking at? What's your metric for how bad this is? I mean, I think that's a little ghoulish, obviously, but if people really want to make this argument I'd really like to see the kinds of well-founded numbers that the experts are producing. Medical ethics is hardly a new field, after all. You'd think someone would have pulled some analysis off the shelf.

Instead, the people pushing "these people would have died anyway" seem to be almost exclusively political actors (or their proxies on social media sites like this one) with a goal of either defending the inaction of the current administration or pushing a policy goal that necessarily sets the virus loose on the public.

But if you really want to make a numerate case for not trying to save the old and sick, I'd genuinely and carefully read it.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by rubber_duck on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:33PM (#22983030)
I think there are already such calculations for approving drugs on public health programs - cost of treatment vs years of quality life provided.

So you would need to estimate the number of years lost vs the economic damage. This is impossible to get right on both sides but at least it gives you a framework.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by wonnage on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:47PM (#22983527)
Roughly 25% of males in the US 35-44 had hypertension in 2010, and this grows to over 50% by 55-64, an age I don't think anyone would consider especially old: https://www.heart.org/idc/groups/heart-public/@wcm/@sop/@smd...

Basically everyone who dies from this has a preexisting condition, but basically everyone in the US will develop at least one of the big three (hypertension, diabetes, or obesity) at some point.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by nradov on Saturday April 25, 2020 @10:09PM (#22983677)
Fortunately those conditions are preventable in the majority of cases.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by kitotik on Sunday April 26, 2020 @12:30AM (#22984428)
You are correct, it is possible to prevent some of those conditions in some (but not all) future cases.

Kinda sucks if you have any of those conditions right now though.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by whb07 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:49PM (#22988756)
We don’t cry about the millions of heart attacks that are easily prevented. We definitely don’t Give a damn about some person dying of cancer when they are smokers. Why are we drawing a distinction here?

You chose to eat X and not exercise for years/decades. A middle class American has enough education and purchasing power to know and behave accordingly.

Does it suck? Yes, but i find it incredibly unfair and hypocritical towards the rest of the world by ruining their lives based on the extremely old and or fat/unhealthy population.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by greedo on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:11AM (#22984662)
You do realize that at least in the US, 30% of the population has comorbidities?

And your comment comes across as extremely crass and insensitive.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday April 25, 2020 @07:49PM (#22982719)
How does that compare, with other high IFR diseases, didn't they also have deaths skewed towards older people?
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by rootusrootus on Saturday April 25, 2020 @10:14PM (#22983719)
The 1918 flu was notable for having a high fatality rate for young children. That does not seem to be the case for flu in general.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by newacct583 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:02PM (#22982818)
To be perfectly fair (and for the record I'm very much not among the "sacrifice the old and weak" set!): not as much as covid.

The elderly and immunocompromised obviously die more to almost every illness. But the effect is really pronounced with covid. And most other viral infections tend to kill children at higher rates too, and covid very notably does not. It's definitely an interesting aspect of the disease, though it's produce a kind of horrifying calculus among a lot of the right wing in the US.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by AlexCoventry on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:49AM (#22984855)
> since the advent of vaccination

What do you mean? There were vaccines in 1918.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by autokad on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:16AM (#22984687)
or the 1957 Flu pandemic but I suppose that was not long after the polio vaccine.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by analog31 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:50PM (#22984245)
It's interesting that this jibes with conventional wisdom. Since nearly the very beginning of when people started looking at graphs of case counts, my colleagues and acquaintances (mostly scientists) assumed a ratio of roughly 10x. Folks would look at any graph and automatically bump it up by an order of magnitude.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by bb2018 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:38PM (#22981251)
I think antibody tests will soon become more useful for tracking disease progression in a population than the viral tests. The collection methods may skew things but they still are much more close to a random sample than the viral tests which have lots of issues with test shortages and people unable to get tested (or not wanting to go to the hospital with mild symptoms).
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by garmaine on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:42PM (#22981287)
They have huge false positive rates though.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by ptrincr on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:56PM (#22981418)
Not sure why you are being downvoted:

https://www.oxfordbiosystems.com/COVID-19-Rapid-test

"In order to test the detection sensitivity and specificity of the COVID-19 IgG-IgM combined antibody test, blood samples were collected from COVID-19 patients from multiple hospitals and Chinese CDC laboratories. The tests were done separately at each site. A total of 525 cases were tested: 397 (positive) clinically confirmed (including PCR test) SARS-CoV-2-infected patients and 128 non- SARS-CoV-2-infected patients (128 negative). The testing results of vein blood without viral inactivation were summarized in the Table 1. Of the 397 blood samples from SARS-CoV-2-infected patients, 352 tested positive, resulting in a sensitivity of 88.66%. Twelve of the blood samples from the 128 non-SARS-CoV-2 infection patients tested positive, generating a specificity of 90.63%."

That gives us 62% false positive ratio according to (where a study finds the prevalence to be 6% of subjects using the test):

http://vassarstats.net/clin2.html

In some cases we have research being carried out with such low positive results that they can entirely be accounted for by the low specificity. So for example if you took samples from 100 people, based on 90% specificity, even if everyone had never had corona, 10 could be found positive.

Credit to this post:

https://old.reddit.com/r/COVID19/comments/g7f373/second_roun...

However it should be noted the article in question for this submission does not mention the type of test used.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by raverbashing on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:38PM (#22981763)
I wonder what's the process through which false positives happen in this case. Previous infection by milder Coronaviruses?

Edit: I'm looking at the reddit post but I have a lot of reservations with the "prevalence 0.06", unless we'll use the test to test absolutely everybody and not only people who are suspect. Has that calculator been validated as well?

If the test was 12 false positives in 128 negatives, how come they can claim the false positive rate is 60%?

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by ptrincr on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:52PM (#22981883)
Apologies for the way this was linked to. The 6% is from this study:

https://www.miamidade.gov/releases/2020-04-24-sample-testing...

"Our data from this week and last tell a very similar story. In both weeks, 6% of participants tested positive for COVID-19 antibodies, which equates to 165,000 Miami-Dade County residents"

That is what the commentator is referring to in the linked post.

So if you plug their own figures into the calculator:

Sensitivity .8866 Specificity .9063

and a Prevalence of .06 based on the study, you get the 62% false positive rate.

As the prevalence increases, as with the NYC study which found the positive rate to be 21% (prevalence), the false positive rate decreases, down to 28% of the NYC study.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by Symmetry on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:51PM (#22983175)
The password you need to Google for why it happens is "antibody cross reactivity." Not necessarily other coronaviruses but I imagine they're disproportionately more likely to cause it.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by suzzer99 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @03:18AM (#22985246)
This is from ARCPoint Labs, where I took my antibody test:

The Antibody test is a serology test which measures the amount of antibodies or proteins present in the blood when the body is responding to a specific infection. This test hasn’t been reviewed by the FDA. Negative results don’t rule out SARS-CoV-2 infection, particularly in those who have been in contact with the virus. Follow-up testing with a molecular diagnostic lab should be considered to rule out infection in these individuals. Results from antibody testing shouldn’t be used as the sole basis to diagnose or exclude SARS-CoV-2 infection. Positive results may be due to past or present infection with non-SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus strains, such as coronavirus HKU1, NL63, OC43, or 229E.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by FrojoS on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:00PM (#22981947)
Yes. That’s one possible explanation. Interestingly quite a lot of people might be somewhat immune to the new Corona virus due to anti bodies from previous Corona cold infections. More than 30% showed such antibodies in a recent study. https://www.finanzen.net/nachricht/aktien/drosten-hinweis-au... (Sorry that the only source I have ready right now)
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by nodamage on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:01PM (#22981961)
60% is the probability that a particular positive test result is actually a false positive. It's not the overall the false positive rate.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by brm on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:50PM (#22981357)
Only until the point that they don't. Unfortunately that requires a lot more people to have had covid...
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by timr on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:00PM (#22981446)
There are many different tests, from different manufacturers. Some of the tests have higher false-positive rates than others. Some have higher false-negative rates. Even a survey with an imperfect test can be designed to yield reliable data.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by danielfoster on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:50PM (#22981356)
And false negatives.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by pedrosorio on Sunday April 26, 2020 @11:41AM (#22987910)
If the rate of false positives and false negatives is the same but the true prevalence is << 0.5, then you will overestimate the number of positives.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by taeric on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:47PM (#22981332)
Do we know the rates already?
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by amluto on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:05PM (#22981482)
There’s preliminary data: https://covidtestingproject.org/
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by skybrian on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:41PM (#22981277)
I wonder which tests they used? A recent study is finding that some antibody tests are much better than others when it comes to false positives:

https://tildes.net/~health.coronavirus/o6a/coronavirus_antib...

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by marcell on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:50PM (#22981353)
I know that the California studies used the same test kit. It had 2 false positives out of 371 samples of pre-covid19 cases, and has a 10-20% false negative rate. Because the case numbers are so small, the false positives can skew things quite a bit. I took the midpoints of their 95% confidence intervals in the spreadsheet.

I don't know what tests the other studies used.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by jMyles on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:44PM (#22981827)
Here's a similar spreadsheet, with less detail but more studies:

https://www.reddit.com/r/LockdownSkepticism/comments/g6eqtt/...

It may be helpful to you.

Thank you for tracking these metrics.

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by DanBC on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:42PM (#22981294)
What numbers are you using for sensitivity and specificity?
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by marcell on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:51PM (#22981365)
It depends on the study, I've been using their reported confidence intervals. The two California studies (Santa Clara and Los Angeles) used the same kit, which has 2 false positives of 371 tests, and 10-20% false negative rate.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by nodamage on Saturday April 25, 2020 @05:30PM (#22981695)
It's worth noting that is the manufacturer claim but has not held up to independent validation.

Specifically, the Premier Biotech/Hangzhou Biotest Biotech test was validated by a Chinese provincial CDC and found 4 false positives out of 150. [1]

It was also validated by the COVID-19 Testing project and found 3 false positives out of 108. [2]

The Biomedomics test used in the Miami Dade study was also validated by the COVID-19 Testing Project and found 14 false positives out of 107. [2]

Hence I would recommend taking the results of the California and Florida studies with a huge grain of salt as the prevalence rates they found were within the false positive rates of the tests used.

[1] https://imgcdn.mckesson.com/CumulusWeb/Click_and_learn/COVID...

[2] https://covidtestingproject.org/

Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by bagacrap on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:16PM (#22982909)
you have the prevalence for NY state but the row is called NY city. The NYC prevalence was 21.2
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by buboard on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:40PM (#22981270)
i don't understand the value of this multiplier. Case statistics are not an official census, it's incidental , depending on the criteria with which each region makes tests. Case numbers are unimportant, it's the total infections and consequent deaths that matter
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday April 25, 2020 @04:45PM (#22981318)
You're probably right that they shouldn't be, but case statistics are regularly treated as an official census. I've seen many news articles in the vein that suchandsuch country is handling it better or worse because of their case numbers, or statistics like CFR that are computed from official case numbers.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by buboard on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:01PM (#22981960)
while the absolute value doesn't matter, its time course is mostly representative , because countries rarely change strategies wrt testing.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:05PM (#22981993)
That just doesn't seem true. In the US testing strategies are rapidly changing, since health officials indicate this will be essential to safely removing restrictions.
Re:In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% w... by analog31 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:54PM (#22984259)
One reason is that early on when the curves looked pretty much exponential, folks were trying to pin down how bad it could get, and when. This was when the worst case scenario was for nearly the entire population to get it. I'm not quite sure we're completely out of that woods yet.