Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by jasoneckert on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:20AM
(#22977884)
I seriously doubt that Apple would release an ARM-based laptop that would "destroy" the massive low/mid-tier Chromebook and Windows laptop market for three reasons:
a) They'd have to release it at the same price point or less than those products (that's not The Apple Way)
b) Chromebooks have a huge market share in the educational space, and Windows low-end laptops have a massive market share everywhere else (and in general, the first person to a market usually maintains their lead for a long time, even given other factors - just like Apple with the iPhone)
c) This would require users to switch from one app ecosystem to another on a different platform that attracts developers that want to monetize directly compared to the app ecosystem on most Chromebooks and low-end Windows laptops (which are still x86_64-based and have a plethora of free/FOSS productivity apps)
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by newacct583 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @10:12AM
(#22978210)
Point a) need to be elaborated a bit: the reason they can't release it at a very low price point is that, while sure, it might "destroy" the chromebook and low-end windows laptop market, it would also destroy much of the MacBook and iPad market for the same reason.
Who's going to buy the $1k macbook when a $300 one works just as well? This isn't going to happen. Apple is a company built on high margin products, they aren't going to change that.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by mgh2 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @01:08PM
(#22979483)
Worried about cannibalization? Of course, like the iPhone SE, there are some sacrifices compared to the premium devices, because these are non essentials for the target demographic: commoners.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by pentae on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:27AM
(#22977932)
a) Absolutely agreed. Considering the previous Macbook 12" was priced almost twice the price of the Macbook Air and marketed as a premium ultracompact, why would they do things differently?
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ghaff on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:58AM
(#22978142)
The Macbook 12" was pretty clearly targeted at someone like me, who during normal times was traveling something like 1/3 of the time and really isn't very price sensitive. To be honest, I'm not sure why there isn't a bigger market for a premium 11" to 12" laptop. A 2 pound 13" laptop like the Pixelbook Go isn't bad for travel but I'd still probably go with something a bit smaller if a good option were available.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by pentae on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:15AM
(#22978725)
Gripping on to my i7 Macbook 12" for dear life, I would jump on one with an apple chip if it ran cooler and had 3x the performance. Apple really need to focus on these things not being leg warmers though.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ghaff on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:21AM
(#22978776)
I was all ready to buy one when Apple refreshed it but then they discontinued it instead. And the refurb prices were pretty rich for a relatively old system.
If they do an update with an Apple chip, I would almost certainly get one.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ylee on Saturday April 25, 2020 @02:19PM
(#22980022)
>I seriously doubt that Apple would release an ARM-based laptop that would "destroy" the massive low/mid-tier Chromebook and Windows laptop market for three reasons:
>a) They'd have to release it at the same price point or less than those products (that's not The Apple Way)
When I covered IT hardware companies on Wall Street, I heard Apple's CFO say that his company could release a $799 computer "but we don't want to".
Around the same time, at an investor dinner with the Dell CFO, an attendee asked how sales were of a $299 computer on Dell's print catalog cover. The CFO replied, "the problem with advertising a $299 computer is that people want to buy it".
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by mgh2 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @12:45PM
(#22979331)
BUSINESS concepts behind the scenes:
a) What people don't understand about the SE strategy, besides economies of scale and a smaller, more powerful phone, is that the device was made to offer extreme value targeting a demographic using a specific strategy called "Price skimming": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_skimming
The iPhone SE was designed to lower consumer's (Android users) barrier to entry (price) into the brand, to quickly gain market share, then sell them services or premium devices in the future. This is possible because of Apple's established reputation as a premium brand (as opposed to penetration pricing): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penetration_pricing
b) The "1st mover advantage" is a myth. Consider Facebook or Google, they gained near monopoly market share because they were first in their technology/approach, not market.
The 'Apple way' is to wait for competitors to test new markets and get consumer validation, lowering risks by learning from early competitor errors, then grab market share with a product that delivers a better UX due to its superior combination of technologies. Look at Fitbit's demise with the Apple Watch - Google is now trying to replicate its Android success by acquiring Fitbit- "2nd mover advantage" works if done right.
c) If a and b work, this will make no difference to users, considering that Apple's strategy will not be focused on apps (this is a strength in phones, not laptops), but rather to sell a value performance device for the general public.
The Macbook failed not because it targeted the wrong demographic (business users) vs Air (students and commoners) and Pro (other professionals), but because it failed to provide value as an 'entry level' device: low specs, highly priced - they (partly) wrongly assumed business users' willingness to pay a premium for portability (inelastic demand) without regard for the value.
Nevertheless, the Macbook offer (a 1st gen. test product) did serve its purpose by anchoring users to see the next better offer at hand- the Air. This strategy called "bundling" in 3 options: good (price), better (quality), best (both) often serves to guide users to avoid extremes by choosing the middle option (usually most profitable), also called the "center stage effect": https://kenthendricks.com/center-stage-effect/
In short, if they can offer a value laptop (priced below ~$700, best deal ultrabooks at this range) in an old body design (12 inch) and best tech specs (A14 or ARM), then this could be Apple's 'Macbook SE' offer. Heck, even test a 1st generation with cheaper AMD's chipset.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by jrockway on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:45AM
(#22977677)
Apple's chips are really impressive. I would love to see them in a general purpose computer so that developers can really take advantage of the power. Whatever is in my iPad Pro would make a great development workstation if I could connect two monitors to it and ... run Linux. It is power-efficient, very lightweight, and has built-in 4G. In those categories, it beats the pants off of any Intel-based laptop I've ever had. But I still have to SSH to a real computer to work, which is an artifact of Apple's OS policies, not what sort of workload the chips they put in there are capable of.
The unfortunate reality with all of these stripped-down computers, though, is that nobody is writing software for them. While the CPUs are powerful enough to run pretty much anything, nobody is porting their AAA games or CAD software or video editors. Maybe Apple's ability to dynamically recompile Mac Store apps to ARM will help, but I still think MacOS is seriously lacking compared to Windows. So the best Apple can hope for is a "budget Mac" which power users won't buy (and power users write all the software), and they'll just be an expensive Chromebook. (ChromeOS doesn't have a lot of native software either, but at least you can run a normal Linux environment in a container and write software on the device. And, I don't think any person goes out to buy a Chromebook... they just get them for "free" from their school or company. It is an interesting segment of the market that can be profitable, but I really want to see these chips in something I can sink my teeth into. Set up a development environment, write software, and run the same software in production on those chips too.)
My takeaway is that it's a shame that this amazing CPU-design division exists inside a company that is all about dumbed-down user experiences. They could probably kill Intel overnight if you could just buy the chips on their own, but instead they insist on putting these chips in devices that are hamstrung by arbitrary policy. Obviously they are playing a long game, but as someone who just wants the best possible equipment... I can't afford to wait. (And I don't think the end result of the game -- Apple makes the CPU, laptop, OS, and software -- is very good for anyone.)
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by tpush on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:13AM
(#22977837)
The whole point of these rumors is that Apple's putting these chips in MacBooks, running macOS. So I don't get this kvetching about "stripped-down computers" and "dumbed-down user experiences".
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluescrn on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:30AM
(#22977955)
We've had a divide for over a decade now, where serious computing is done mostly on x86, and mobile mostly on ARM.
ARM devices have become associated with App Stores, touchscreens, locked-down and dumbed-down systems. And there's a very real risk that Apple will take this as the opportunity to completely lock out any software that's not been censored and taxed by their App Store.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by api on Saturday April 25, 2020 @10:12AM
(#22978211)
If they are going to lock down macOS totally they might as well kill it and exit the pro market entirely. If I can't run whatever I want on it, it is not a real computer.
I personally doubt they will do that. If anything I could see them making iPadOS more capable, moving more of the consumer market there, and making the Mac line even more suited to pro users with more compute power and more OS capability.
BTW the ARM move could fit into this. I wonder how a 32 or 64 core A series ARM64 chip in a laptop form factor would perform? Our company runs some infrastructure stuff on Cavium ThunderX chips with 96 ARM cores and the performance is comparable to high end Xeons for very parallelizable load. The Apple A series core is far superior. I'd take 64 of those in a laptop.
It would be so fast I'm sure it would have no issue running transpiled X64 code at perfectly adequate speeds. Could probably even run X64 VMs in emulation at speeds that were at least quite usable for testing and dev.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by arkanciscan on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:53AM
(#22977716)
Do you really suspect that Linux would run as well as iOS? Isn't iOS optimized for the A17 and vice versa? It's out of my wheelhouse, but I suspect that this synergy is the only reason they seem so fast.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by danpeddle on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:17AM
(#22977868)
From recent experience using the Pinebook Pro and manjaro, the answer is a resounding yes.
From the start, it was clear that a decent arm chip in a laptop is very usable. Paired with an SSD, and more ram, it would be killer.
MacOS would need some care to make it less heavy in terms of background consumption, but I don’t see that as being beyond Apple’s reach. Windows is a different matter, not sure what MS can bring to the table there.. The work being done right now in porting iOS applications to work on macOS clearly points to a strategy being developed.
Think it’s going to be an interesting couple of years.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluescrn on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:12AM
(#22977833)
It's about input devices and UI features much more than RAM.
iPad apps are expected to have massive buttons for big fat fingers. Pro software requires a mouse and a keyboard, a much more precise and flexible combination.
(Yes, you can get the Apple Pencil and an iPad keyboard. But it's a bit chicken-and-egg, people don't have the accessories because there's little software that uses them. And there's no software as few people have the accessories...)
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by jrockway on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:21AM
(#22977889)
Everyone I know with an iPad Pro has the keyboard case. I hate the keyboard... but I can put up with it while travelling. I don't think the keyboard availability is an underlying issue, but I do think that people will balk at a $700/year license for something that runs on an iPad, because they feel like it's a toy, not a tool. However, the CPU is not what causes that; the CPU has more raw compute power than many Intel laptops that people do run expensive software on.
I want my iPad Pro to be a good workstation, but the reality is that will probably never happen. However, if Apple uses the same hardware to run MacOS, then it could happen. Yes, they would need to tack on some more I/O (or at least release a first-party dock) and RAM, but they could still make a very thin and fast device that would blow Intel laptops out of the water. I would not buy one of these because I don't really care for MacOS. (I use the iPad as my "laptop" because it doesn't really require any customization or maintenance. I have my SSH key on there, that's about it. I use it as a dumb terminal and it's great for that, but with the right software, it would also be a very capable computer.)
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ethbro on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:02AM
(#22977771)
Why don't we see more OS-level integrated remote computing in the Chromebook category?
I get Google started it to run their webapps.
But it doesn't seem technically infeasible to package and sell a set monthly subscription price, that gets you a lazy-allocated machine on GCP.
Spin up beefy software, your computer recognizes "this is more than I can do", checks current networking availability, and starts running the app remotely.
I know there are offerings like this, but it seems like a killer feature if it had full OS integration.
Just plop an overlay icon somewhere in the window to clearly note it's running remote. (Thereby letting users reason through why it occasionally behaves weirdly)
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluescrn on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:37AM
(#22977995)
People don't have room for any more subscription fees in their lives. Especially to pay for something like this (or game streaming) that offers an inferior/laggy user experience, when owning a reasonably powerful laptop or games console isn't all that expensive.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ethbro on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:22AM
(#22978787)
Subscription fee exhaustion seems an odd concept to me. Do people actually say "A service delivers me value for its price, but I already have too many subscription services, so I won't use it"?
It seems an ironic perspective given that "Time is the only real currency we have" is on the HN front page!
I specifically mentioned it because Apple (1) has cloud resources, whether they see it as an offering or not, (2) has full stack integration with their products, & (3) has historically prized ease of use and packaging new technology in a slick way.
"Underpowered Mac / iPad / etc, now with iPower transparent cloud compute" seems a unique way to leverage their strengths and abilities in ways that Google, MS, and Amazon lack the capabilities to match.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluescrn on Saturday April 25, 2020 @12:04PM
(#22979075)
> Do people actually say "A service delivers me value for its price, but I already have too many subscription services, so I won't use it"?
Sounds like Silicon Valley thinking. If you're used to massive salaries (and massive housing costs), you probably won't care about relatively small subscription costs.
But for the majority of people elsewhere in the world, those costs really do add up. There's very little appeal in renting a PC or games console in the cloud, then getting a sub-standard PC or console experience for an ongoing fee.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ac29 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @02:02PM
(#22979904)
Just to add to this - life is pretty expensive these days, and a lot of people really don't have much discretionary income left each month after taxes, rent, health insurance, food, etc. Median household income in the US is ~$63k, and after all of those expenses its pretty easy to be left with something like $100 a month (or less, or even worse, needing to take on debt to cover bills). When that is the case, even a $5/month subscription is a lot of money.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ethbro on Saturday April 25, 2020 @02:21PM
(#22980055)
Point not being that subscription is not a lot of money.
Point being that expecting someone with that level of disposable income to having savings that allow for capital expenditures (instead of amortized subscriptions) isn't likely either.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluehatbrit on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:12AM
(#22977834)
A few years ago I picked up a second hand 12" Macbook. Without a doubt it has been my favourite laptop I've ever owned. I'm pretty sure this is as close as they'll go to a chromebook competitor. I wouldn't want it as my main machine but for programming and general use on the go it's a joy to use. The dimensions are brilliant, it feels lighter than any chromebook I've used, and it has a "more full" OS than an iPad. I was so sad when I found out they'd discontinued the line.
The battery is on it's way out now and the keyboard is getting worn out but I'm pretty sure I'll get it repaired rather than picking up anything else. I'm not one to buy apple products usually but I've been so happy with this purchase, I'm not sure another laptop will ever top how great this one has been for me.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by danaris on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:17AM
(#22977865)
This...feels very much like the old canard of "Apple must release a cheap computer to compete with all the shoddily-made Windows computers!"
Apple's not shooting for marketshare. They never have been, they (probably) never will. And, conversely, it's very unlikely that most people with Chromebooks and Windows laptops today would be interested in switching to a Mac—the software's either not there, or very different.
And I say all this as a devoted lifelong Mac user.
That being said, like many urban legends, there is quite a bit of doubt as to whether the company's demise was caused by the pre-announcement, rather than by the fact that Osborne was trying to leverage its lead into bigger margins, without offering more computer for the dollar.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by jedieaston on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:54AM
(#22979003)
It didn't last time. Jobs went on stage to announce that Apple was starting a 2-year move to x86 from PPC, showed off a developer kit, then proceeded to announce a few more PowerPC products that were sold in the mean time. If they play it the same way this time and provide developer tools to make the transition easy-peasy, there's no reason it won't work fine.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by braythwayt on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:47AM
(#22977694)
What if they wait until all the early adopters have bought iPad Pros with magic keyboards, then release a more affordable keyboard/trackpad combo for iPad Air, and not just for iPad Pro?
In essence, they already have almost everything they need, but in a new form factor. And while an iPad on a stand is less nimble than a very thin screen, detachability and a better camera are very strong features for casual buyers.
At some point they will merge iOS and Mac OS, given that iOS makes them all the money, and is now capable enough (with a different UI toolkit) to provide both phone and desktop programs.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by grey-area on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:09AM
(#22994204)
Yes, in the same way as all Pascal apps had to be rewritten to the C API a long time ago, and all Mac OS 9 apps had to be rewritten as cocoa (NextStep), or all Objective-C apps will have to be rewritten as Swift as that is the new blessed SDK. In practice it won't be a huge burden as older apps will not be phased out for a long time - see the Objective-C to Swift transition - there will be a very long transition period.
I'm not saying this is great for developers, I'm saying it makes economic sense for Apple and the signs are they are moving in this direction.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by grey-area on Monday April 27, 2020 @02:34AM
(#22993433)
I mean they'll have one App and UI toolkit (probably based off ios) which handles both desktop and ios, simplifying development, making cross platform apps easier, and dramatically cutting support costs for Apple.
At the moment the base OS is the same but the huge SDK used to create apps has two parallel tracks without a huge amount of overlap (though they are increasing the overlap, and encouraging things like porting from ios to Mac OS). Each SDK takes a lot of resources to maintain and support.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by jki275 on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:16AM
(#22995512)
I don't think they'll ever do that. They would lose a significant majority of those of us who use Mac laptops to develop real software.
They'll make cross-platform development between iOS and macOS easier, they're already doing that -- but getting rid of macOS (which is essentially what you're saying) isn't smart for them.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by goatinaboat on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:45AM
(#22977673)
For the users who really just need a browser yes, but conventional laptops are overpowered for those use cases. Strip out the JavaScript, tracking etc and a browser’s CPU and memory requirements are actually pretty minimal.
Not for users who need to run native apps for which there will be years of lead time to port.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by downvoteme1 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:25AM
(#22978802)
If it is a MacBook, it will start at a minimum of $999. That is the price at which most chrome books end up for higher end pricing . The entry level chrome books for schools etc start at $250 where Apple competes with the entry level iPad
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by egypturnash on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:40AM
(#22978015)
I feel like “Destroying Chromebooks” requires competing with the Chromebook price point of around $300, despite the link near the top of the article to a list of “the best Chromebooks in 2020” that goes up to $1200. (https://www.tomsguide.com/best-picks/best-chromebooks)
Apple is picky about what it puts in its machines and what it makes them out of; can they make one of their signature milled aluminum cases cheaply enough to be a part of a BOM that lets them make a decent profit at $300? I can’t find much data on estimated BOMs for the Air (I feel that’s the closest thing in their line to this category) beyond a 2010 estimate of about $750 for machines sold starting at $1000. That price to users has remained consistent so I feel I can assume the cost to Apple hasn’t changed much. Some quick and sloppy searching shows that Intel’s prices on the CPUs in the current Airs are somewhere in the $150-300 range, if I make the best-case assumption that the cheapest Air’s CPU costs Apple $300 and that the cost of a desktop-level Apple CPU is zero, that’s still a BOM of ~350 for the rest of something built with the same specs as the cheapest Air. I guess you could bring in a mid-range Prestige Chromebook at that cost? Maybe? I have no idea what the Chromebook market is shaped like.
A plastic enclosure would probably lower the cost, but would they do that? I think the last time we saw plastic MacBooks was the “toilet seat” iBook back in the days of the gumdrop plastic iMac.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by giarc on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:33AM
(#22977612)
I would love to see this. I currently use a Chromebook as my 'around the house' laptop. It's great for that but once you start doing things like installing apps or having multiple users it breaks down fast.
For example, the Google Play store app is only accessible by a single account, and apps aren't available across users. So if another user wants to install an app, you have to log out all users and they need to log in as the primary user. It's super annoying.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by z3t4 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:44AM
(#22977670)
Still too expensive. Chromebooks are $200 and could probably go lower. If you want to compete on quality you must also compete on software/apps. The new Ipad pro would be interesting though, if it where not for the price. Maybe when everyone is going SAAS Apple could go with classic licenses, where software is run on the user machine rather then some very expensive server.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by keymone on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:52AM
(#22978105)
The comparison I’m making is that you could rip out internals of chromebook, fit the iPhone inside and have a ton more spare space for other crap. And no fans.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluescrn on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:09AM
(#22977806)
Macs still don't have serious GPUs.
But they did still have a growing selection of less-GPU-intensive games. And then Apple removed 32-bit support, wiping out a huge chunk of the Mac Steam library. Oh, and they deprecated OpenGL, too...
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by cameronbrown on Saturday April 25, 2020 @01:04PM
(#22979453)
I disagree - there is fun to be had in these games (same with those with Linux support). But as I mentioned in a sibling comment, the real issue is half of this half is now unsupported.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ghaff on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:52AM
(#22978104)
>Forget games, they still don’t have a UI that anybody wants to use or any software that businesses need.
A lot of businesses have relatively little desktop software that runs natively these days. And many of the key desktop apps like Office (though even that's less important these days), Adobe Creative Cloud, etc. do run on Macs.
Yes, Windows is and will remain the standard at the majority of companies. But increasingly the laptop OS/chip doesn't matter as much. I have a couple Macs but I often just use my Chromebook.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by michalf6 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:51AM
(#22978096)
I don't quite get why "entry level" products are being made. In almost every conceivable category, if your budget is limited, buying used premium products is most likely the best option. A few years ago I would consider myself rather poor (think ex-eastern block), and me and almost everyone I knew was buying used stuff - be it cars, phones, computers, tools etc.
If you aim at the entry level market, you either make something that will soon be obsolete, or cut corners on manufacturing - both options lead to the landfill rather soon.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by 5555624 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:34AM
(#22978857)
Because "used" is not the same as "new."
The definition can vary. What one person defines as "normal wear and tear" is not necessarily what someone else would define it as. A small crack on the corner? A dead pixel? A loose hinge? Scratches?
In addition, buying used is fine if you can support it; but, what if someone can't? A warranty can be a good thing, as can tech support.
I've bought a number of used Thinkpads and it takes work.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by michalf6 on Sunday April 26, 2020 @02:53PM
(#22989241)
Good point about support - I think this scenario could be more realistic if there were regulations in place which force manufacturers to enable third party repair (schematics, sale of parts etc).
It's working well already with cars - in places where labor is cheap things like older BMWs get extended life, as the same repairs wouldn't be affordable in other places, and as a consumer you get the benefit of driving a decent car for a reasonable price.
I see quite a bit of refurbishers in my area selling ex-leased laptops for a low price with a warranty, so it looks like the market finds a way.
My point is, there are upsides to buying new, but I think the environmental downside is much much greater.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by Yetanfou on Saturday April 25, 2020 @11:41AM
(#22978903)
Only if the machine lent itself to the installation of alternative operating systems, whether that be some form of Linux or Windows or anything else. That would imply the hardware would need to be open enough for drivers to be developed. The chance of Apple launching something like this seem slim, they may have started as a hardware company but by now they are well hooked on spreading their 'ecosystem' as well as on their secondary income streams from the app store etc.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by Mindwipe on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:36AM
(#22977629)
Pretty weak article.
Tries to argue the Windows transition failed because of the lack of a walled garden app store. But Windows on ARM did have a (to all intents and purposes) mandatory app store. Indeed, as the Mac App Store has broadly failed it had more of one.
Apple is going to have the same issues with third party software transitions. The reality is that consumers don't seem to really like the idea of a "proper" computer that can't run everything.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluescrn on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:49AM
(#22977703)
The walled garden nonsense thankfully helped to destroy WinRT. If they'd let developers recompile their desktop apps for ARM and run them on RT tablets, maybe it would have taken off, especially as mobile GPUs and ARM CPUs got faster. But as it was, they had an ARM port of desktop Windows that people weren't allowed to fully use, and they just pushed the not-very-mature 'Metro' stuff.
The walled garden push may destroy MacOS too, if they go 'total lockdown' on their ARM release, and only allow store apps (so no Steam, no Bittorrent, no VLC, no cryptocurrency software, even more developer pain). Although I guess they did the 'killing Steam' thing already with the removal of 32-bit support wiping out ~50% of the Mac Steam library.
There's still as significant audience that wants a serious OS and serious software, not dumbed-down touch-centric 'Appified' rubbish.
I'm very interested to see how functional (or completely-dumbed-down) the rumoured iPad version of XCode will be. It could prove that 'serious work' may be possible on iOS in the future, or just another data point to confirm that we still need a clear separation of 'mobile OS' (primarily for communication and content consumption) and 'serious OS' (for everything else, serious work, creativity, development, gaming)
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by braythwayt on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:49AM
(#22977702)
> The reality is that consumers don't seem to really like the idea of a "proper" computer that can't run everything.
Only when you call it a computer. The other reality (I’m saying this for style, not to disagree with your core point) is that if you call it an iPad, it becomes one of the biggest hits in computer product history, a product that can only be judged as “meh” if you’re comparing it to iPhone.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by sheeshkebab on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:44AM
(#22977669)
> The reality is that consumers don't seem to really like the idea of a "proper" computer that can't run everything.
I think this will be the real deal breaker with these arm pcs... personally, I have enough of these arm phones/tablets/pi devices to skip paying $2k+ for a laptop with these processors inside that would have problems running anything but basic browser on them.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by adrianmsmith on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:41AM
(#22977652)
Right, and I'm really not sure what this paragraph from the article means, or if it actually has any meaning at all.
> With iPadOS now offering macOS-like features, as well as keyboard and trackpad support, it’s arguably not too much of a challenge for Apple to rework macOS to run on RISC and ARM.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by braythwayt on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:47AM
(#22978063)
I can answer that. Apple already has macOS running on ARM, and has had for years.
This gives them two things:
1. Leverage on pricing with Intel;
2. The ability to ship ARM macs whenever they are ready.
So the next thing is, "what's the definition of 'ready'?" Opinions about that vary. I side wth tthe popular speculation that the 'problem' with macOS on ARM is not macOS, but all the legacy apps that need to be recompiled or run in some kind of emulation or need some other magic solution to "just work."
It's easy to ask every developer to recompile, but people have lots of shareware apps, unsupported old apps, enterprise apps, and apps from developers who aren't making enough money to justify putting a lot of work into supporting a new chip.
So for now, we have this weird situation where phones and tablets have enormous amounts of computing power but require less power and thus provide longer battery life for a given mass... Mostly to support computational photography.
p.s. Completely spitballing here, but I wonder if their hesitation to ship with an emulator—as they did when they made the PowerPC -> Intel switch—is because on a mobile device, emulation might be a heat source and power hog. With desktops, they didn't have the same concern about power draw or heat.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by norswap on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:20AM
(#22977883)
Their regular laptops are priced at 2x or more the market for similar specs. The Mac Pro is more than 4x.
Unless they align themselves with market price (within a premium range, maybe up to 50% more than median), I don't see how they can "destroy the market" (they could still be a commercial success though).
The prime selling point of cheap laptops/chromebooks is their price.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by karmakaze on Saturday April 25, 2020 @06:12PM
(#22982036)
When I'm not using a MacBook 15", I'm on a Surface Go for it's ultraportability. If Apple made effectively an iPad Go that ran an ARM macOS, I'd use it. I don't care for apps, I make them usually for web.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by m-p-3 on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:29AM
(#22977942)
And it would become a great and cheap portable option for iOS developers that just needs an Apple system to develop and compile and publish mobile apps.
I get (but I don't agree) that Apple wants to lock developers into their platform.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by tpetry on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:42AM
(#22977661)
They are missing a very crucial point: even if apple will sell a cheaper macbook se it will still be a lot more expansive than the cheap windows notebooks bought. Apple will not make a 400-500$ notebook.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by sandoooo on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:42AM
(#22977655)
the page contains a redirect to a page telling me to turn off adblocking. Evidently this is because my adblocking didn't go far enough. It goes away if I disable scripts on the page altogether.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by new_realist on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:21AM
(#22977893)
According to Wikipedia, Chrome OS usage share is just 0.18%. Yes, that’s just one fifth of one percent. And their K-12 share is nowhere near that high, worldwide.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by ghaff on Saturday April 25, 2020 @10:54AM
(#22978560)
In the US ChromeOS seems to have about 4-6% market share [0] with about 60% share in K-12. As you say, those are US numbers and the K-12 figures are much lower (single digits) elsewhere. Of course, not sure what availability and promotion to school systems even looks like outside the US.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by Theodores on Saturday April 25, 2020 @08:54AM
(#22977728)
An affordable Ferrari could put VW, Ford, GM and Toyota out of business. Imagine if that was possible, would everyone want it? Or would they buy themselves another Golf?
Given the choice of a deluxe Apple computer (never mind an SE one) I would still take the regular PC or the Chromebook. Sounds mad but I like ChromeOS, Chrome and the normal PC keyboard. I don't actually want MacOS and I would pay to not have it. I am not alone in thinking this way.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by bluescrn on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:04AM
(#22977789)
Not having a touchscreen is a big plus point these days. It usually means you get to use much more precise input devices instead!
Touchscreen devices with touch-centric operating systems/UI systems will never replace 'proper computers' for 'serious software' as everything has to be so completely dumbed-down for touch, simply because you can't build a complex and feature-rich UI for such a limited input device.
Re:An ARM-based MacBook SE could destroy Chromebooks and mid...
by flipcoder on Saturday April 25, 2020 @09:48AM
(#22978075)
I don't think this will always be the case. Applications like Bitwig Studio have both traditional and touch interfaces. It's only a change in GUI. I can see most applications in the future having "responsive" gui layouts like how web designers deal with screen sizes, but for touch interfaces.
a) They'd have to release it at the same price point or less than those products (that's not The Apple Way)
b) Chromebooks have a huge market share in the educational space, and Windows low-end laptops have a massive market share everywhere else (and in general, the first person to a market usually maintains their lead for a long time, even given other factors - just like Apple with the iPhone)
c) This would require users to switch from one app ecosystem to another on a different platform that attracts developers that want to monetize directly compared to the app ecosystem on most Chromebooks and low-end Windows laptops (which are still x86_64-based and have a plethora of free/FOSS productivity apps)
Who's going to buy the $1k macbook when a $300 one works just as well? This isn't going to happen. Apple is a company built on high margin products, they aren't going to change that.
If they do an update with an Apple chip, I would almost certainly get one.
>a) They'd have to release it at the same price point or less than those products (that's not The Apple Way)
When I covered IT hardware companies on Wall Street, I heard Apple's CFO say that his company could release a $799 computer "but we don't want to".
Around the same time, at an investor dinner with the Dell CFO, an attendee asked how sales were of a $299 computer on Dell's print catalog cover. The CFO replied, "the problem with advertising a $299 computer is that people want to buy it".
a) What people don't understand about the SE strategy, besides economies of scale and a smaller, more powerful phone, is that the device was made to offer extreme value targeting a demographic using a specific strategy called "Price skimming": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_skimming
The iPhone SE was designed to lower consumer's (Android users) barrier to entry (price) into the brand, to quickly gain market share, then sell them services or premium devices in the future. This is possible because of Apple's established reputation as a premium brand (as opposed to penetration pricing): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penetration_pricing
b) The "1st mover advantage" is a myth. Consider Facebook or Google, they gained near monopoly market share because they were first in their technology/approach, not market.
The 'Apple way' is to wait for competitors to test new markets and get consumer validation, lowering risks by learning from early competitor errors, then grab market share with a product that delivers a better UX due to its superior combination of technologies. Look at Fitbit's demise with the Apple Watch - Google is now trying to replicate its Android success by acquiring Fitbit- "2nd mover advantage" works if done right.
c) If a and b work, this will make no difference to users, considering that Apple's strategy will not be focused on apps (this is a strength in phones, not laptops), but rather to sell a value performance device for the general public.
The Macbook failed not because it targeted the wrong demographic (business users) vs Air (students and commoners) and Pro (other professionals), but because it failed to provide value as an 'entry level' device: low specs, highly priced - they (partly) wrongly assumed business users' willingness to pay a premium for portability (inelastic demand) without regard for the value.
Nevertheless, the Macbook offer (a 1st gen. test product) did serve its purpose by anchoring users to see the next better offer at hand- the Air. This strategy called "bundling" in 3 options: good (price), better (quality), best (both) often serves to guide users to avoid extremes by choosing the middle option (usually most profitable), also called the "center stage effect": https://kenthendricks.com/center-stage-effect/
I recommend reading Stanford consultants' "Monetizing Innovation" to understand these strategies: https://www.amazon.com/Monetizing-Innovation-Companies-Desig...
In short, if they can offer a value laptop (priced below ~$700, best deal ultrabooks at this range) in an old body design (12 inch) and best tech specs (A14 or ARM), then this could be Apple's 'Macbook SE' offer. Heck, even test a 1st generation with cheaper AMD's chipset.
The unfortunate reality with all of these stripped-down computers, though, is that nobody is writing software for them. While the CPUs are powerful enough to run pretty much anything, nobody is porting their AAA games or CAD software or video editors. Maybe Apple's ability to dynamically recompile Mac Store apps to ARM will help, but I still think MacOS is seriously lacking compared to Windows. So the best Apple can hope for is a "budget Mac" which power users won't buy (and power users write all the software), and they'll just be an expensive Chromebook. (ChromeOS doesn't have a lot of native software either, but at least you can run a normal Linux environment in a container and write software on the device. And, I don't think any person goes out to buy a Chromebook... they just get them for "free" from their school or company. It is an interesting segment of the market that can be profitable, but I really want to see these chips in something I can sink my teeth into. Set up a development environment, write software, and run the same software in production on those chips too.)
My takeaway is that it's a shame that this amazing CPU-design division exists inside a company that is all about dumbed-down user experiences. They could probably kill Intel overnight if you could just buy the chips on their own, but instead they insist on putting these chips in devices that are hamstrung by arbitrary policy. Obviously they are playing a long game, but as someone who just wants the best possible equipment... I can't afford to wait. (And I don't think the end result of the game -- Apple makes the CPU, laptop, OS, and software -- is very good for anyone.)
ARM devices have become associated with App Stores, touchscreens, locked-down and dumbed-down systems. And there's a very real risk that Apple will take this as the opportunity to completely lock out any software that's not been censored and taxed by their App Store.
I personally doubt they will do that. If anything I could see them making iPadOS more capable, moving more of the consumer market there, and making the Mac line even more suited to pro users with more compute power and more OS capability.
BTW the ARM move could fit into this. I wonder how a 32 or 64 core A series ARM64 chip in a laptop form factor would perform? Our company runs some infrastructure stuff on Cavium ThunderX chips with 96 ARM cores and the performance is comparable to high end Xeons for very parallelizable load. The Apple A series core is far superior. I'd take 64 of those in a laptop.
It would be so fast I'm sure it would have no issue running transpiled X64 code at perfectly adequate speeds. Could probably even run X64 VMs in emulation at speeds that were at least quite usable for testing and dev.
From the start, it was clear that a decent arm chip in a laptop is very usable. Paired with an SSD, and more ram, it would be killer.
MacOS would need some care to make it less heavy in terms of background consumption, but I don’t see that as being beyond Apple’s reach. Windows is a different matter, not sure what MS can bring to the table there.. The work being done right now in porting iOS applications to work on macOS clearly points to a strategy being developed.
Think it’s going to be an interesting couple of years.
Random example: https://www.macrumors.com/2018/11/01/2018-ipad-pro-benchmark...
I hook my 2018 MacBook Pro up to a 4K TV to present to a meeting and the battery goes down to about 35% after two hours.
iPad apps are expected to have massive buttons for big fat fingers. Pro software requires a mouse and a keyboard, a much more precise and flexible combination.
(Yes, you can get the Apple Pencil and an iPad keyboard. But it's a bit chicken-and-egg, people don't have the accessories because there's little software that uses them. And there's no software as few people have the accessories...)
I want my iPad Pro to be a good workstation, but the reality is that will probably never happen. However, if Apple uses the same hardware to run MacOS, then it could happen. Yes, they would need to tack on some more I/O (or at least release a first-party dock) and RAM, but they could still make a very thin and fast device that would blow Intel laptops out of the water. I would not buy one of these because I don't really care for MacOS. (I use the iPad as my "laptop" because it doesn't really require any customization or maintenance. I have my SSH key on there, that's about it. I use it as a dumb terminal and it's great for that, but with the right software, it would also be a very capable computer.)
I get Google started it to run their webapps.
But it doesn't seem technically infeasible to package and sell a set monthly subscription price, that gets you a lazy-allocated machine on GCP.
Spin up beefy software, your computer recognizes "this is more than I can do", checks current networking availability, and starts running the app remotely.
I know there are offerings like this, but it seems like a killer feature if it had full OS integration.
Just plop an overlay icon somewhere in the window to clearly note it's running remote. (Thereby letting users reason through why it occasionally behaves weirdly)
It seems an ironic perspective given that "Time is the only real currency we have" is on the HN front page!
I specifically mentioned it because Apple (1) has cloud resources, whether they see it as an offering or not, (2) has full stack integration with their products, & (3) has historically prized ease of use and packaging new technology in a slick way.
"Underpowered Mac / iPad / etc, now with iPower transparent cloud compute" seems a unique way to leverage their strengths and abilities in ways that Google, MS, and Amazon lack the capabilities to match.
Sounds like Silicon Valley thinking. If you're used to massive salaries (and massive housing costs), you probably won't care about relatively small subscription costs.
But for the majority of people elsewhere in the world, those costs really do add up. There's very little appeal in renting a PC or games console in the cloud, then getting a sub-standard PC or console experience for an ongoing fee.
Point being that expecting someone with that level of disposable income to having savings that allow for capital expenditures (instead of amortized subscriptions) isn't likely either.
The battery is on it's way out now and the keyboard is getting worn out but I'm pretty sure I'll get it repaired rather than picking up anything else. I'm not one to buy apple products usually but I've been so happy with this purchase, I'm not sure another laptop will ever top how great this one has been for me.
Apple's not shooting for marketshare. They never have been, they (probably) never will. And, conversely, it's very unlikely that most people with Chromebooks and Windows laptops today would be interested in switching to a Mac—the software's either not there, or very different.
And I say all this as a devoted lifelong Mac user.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect
That being said, like many urban legends, there is quite a bit of doubt as to whether the company's demise was caused by the pre-announcement, rather than by the fact that Osborne was trying to leverage its lead into bigger margins, without offering more computer for the dollar.
In essence, they already have almost everything they need, but in a new form factor. And while an iPad on a stand is less nimble than a very thin screen, detachability and a better camera are very strong features for casual buyers.
https://www.cnet.com/news/macos-catalinas-ipad-apps-for-the-...
At some point they will merge iOS and Mac OS, given that iOS makes them all the money, and is now capable enough (with a different UI toolkit) to provide both phone and desktop programs.
And just outright kill a bunch of applications?
They'll support older apps for a long time though, it just won't be the preferred sdk and will gradually be phased out.
The situation they have right now is madness - two parallel slightly different UI toolkits and SDKs, one of which makes vastly more money.
And one which has a longer history. Should every Cocoa application be written in UIKit to continue working?
I'm not saying this is great for developers, I'm saying it makes economic sense for Apple and the signs are they are moving in this direction.
iOS (with a different UI toolkit) is macOS.
At the moment the base OS is the same but the huge SDK used to create apps has two parallel tracks without a huge amount of overlap (though they are increasing the overlap, and encouraging things like porting from ios to Mac OS). Each SDK takes a lot of resources to maintain and support.
They'll make cross-platform development between iOS and macOS easier, they're already doing that -- but getting rid of macOS (which is essentially what you're saying) isn't smart for them.
Not for users who need to run native apps for which there will be years of lead time to port.
Apple is picky about what it puts in its machines and what it makes them out of; can they make one of their signature milled aluminum cases cheaply enough to be a part of a BOM that lets them make a decent profit at $300? I can’t find much data on estimated BOMs for the Air (I feel that’s the closest thing in their line to this category) beyond a 2010 estimate of about $750 for machines sold starting at $1000. That price to users has remained consistent so I feel I can assume the cost to Apple hasn’t changed much. Some quick and sloppy searching shows that Intel’s prices on the CPUs in the current Airs are somewhere in the $150-300 range, if I make the best-case assumption that the cheapest Air’s CPU costs Apple $300 and that the cost of a desktop-level Apple CPU is zero, that’s still a BOM of ~350 for the rest of something built with the same specs as the cheapest Air. I guess you could bring in a mid-range Prestige Chromebook at that cost? Maybe? I have no idea what the Chromebook market is shaped like.
A plastic enclosure would probably lower the cost, but would they do that? I think the last time we saw plastic MacBooks was the “toilet seat” iBook back in the days of the gumdrop plastic iMac.
For example, the Google Play store app is only accessible by a single account, and apps aren't available across users. So if another user wants to install an app, you have to log out all users and they need to log in as the primary user. It's super annoying.
It feels a bit like comparing DSLRs to smartphones. Sure, there's some overlap in function but they're not directly comparable.
But they did still have a growing selection of less-GPU-intensive games. And then Apple removed 32-bit support, wiping out a huge chunk of the Mac Steam library. Oh, and they deprecated OpenGL, too...
A quick glance at the front page of Steam shows at least half the games support Mac and Linux: https://store.steampowered.com/
It's never been easier to write a cross platform game with toolkits like Unity.
Though it's also true that, for a lot of casual gamers, laptop gaming generally may not matter all that much.
Google had to build their own fleet management system for Macs for crying put loud!
The thought of Macs replacing most Windows machines is going to make me just laugh and laugh and laugh at random times today.
A lot of businesses have relatively little desktop software that runs natively these days. And many of the key desktop apps like Office (though even that's less important these days), Adobe Creative Cloud, etc. do run on Macs.
Yes, Windows is and will remain the standard at the majority of companies. But increasingly the laptop OS/chip doesn't matter as much. I have a couple Macs but I often just use my Chromebook.
If you aim at the entry level market, you either make something that will soon be obsolete, or cut corners on manufacturing - both options lead to the landfill rather soon.
The definition can vary. What one person defines as "normal wear and tear" is not necessarily what someone else would define it as. A small crack on the corner? A dead pixel? A loose hinge? Scratches?
In addition, buying used is fine if you can support it; but, what if someone can't? A warranty can be a good thing, as can tech support.
I've bought a number of used Thinkpads and it takes work.
It's working well already with cars - in places where labor is cheap things like older BMWs get extended life, as the same repairs wouldn't be affordable in other places, and as a consumer you get the benefit of driving a decent car for a reasonable price.
I see quite a bit of refurbishers in my area selling ex-leased laptops for a low price with a warranty, so it looks like the market finds a way.
My point is, there are upsides to buying new, but I think the environmental downside is much much greater.
To be honest, I'll buy an ARM Macbook right now if I can use Microsoft Office, Safari and VS Code.
Tries to argue the Windows transition failed because of the lack of a walled garden app store. But Windows on ARM did have a (to all intents and purposes) mandatory app store. Indeed, as the Mac App Store has broadly failed it had more of one.
Apple is going to have the same issues with third party software transitions. The reality is that consumers don't seem to really like the idea of a "proper" computer that can't run everything.
The walled garden push may destroy MacOS too, if they go 'total lockdown' on their ARM release, and only allow store apps (so no Steam, no Bittorrent, no VLC, no cryptocurrency software, even more developer pain). Although I guess they did the 'killing Steam' thing already with the removal of 32-bit support wiping out ~50% of the Mac Steam library.
There's still as significant audience that wants a serious OS and serious software, not dumbed-down touch-centric 'Appified' rubbish.
I'm very interested to see how functional (or completely-dumbed-down) the rumoured iPad version of XCode will be. It could prove that 'serious work' may be possible on iOS in the future, or just another data point to confirm that we still need a clear separation of 'mobile OS' (primarily for communication and content consumption) and 'serious OS' (for everything else, serious work, creativity, development, gaming)
Only when you call it a computer. The other reality (I’m saying this for style, not to disagree with your core point) is that if you call it an iPad, it becomes one of the biggest hits in computer product history, a product that can only be judged as “meh” if you’re comparing it to iPhone.
I think this will be the real deal breaker with these arm pcs... personally, I have enough of these arm phones/tablets/pi devices to skip paying $2k+ for a laptop with these processors inside that would have problems running anything but basic browser on them.
> With iPadOS now offering macOS-like features, as well as keyboard and trackpad support, it’s arguably not too much of a challenge for Apple to rework macOS to run on RISC and ARM.
This gives them two things:
1. Leverage on pricing with Intel;
2. The ability to ship ARM macs whenever they are ready.
So the next thing is, "what's the definition of 'ready'?" Opinions about that vary. I side wth tthe popular speculation that the 'problem' with macOS on ARM is not macOS, but all the legacy apps that need to be recompiled or run in some kind of emulation or need some other magic solution to "just work."
It's easy to ask every developer to recompile, but people have lots of shareware apps, unsupported old apps, enterprise apps, and apps from developers who aren't making enough money to justify putting a lot of work into supporting a new chip.
So for now, we have this weird situation where phones and tablets have enormous amounts of computing power but require less power and thus provide longer battery life for a given mass... Mostly to support computational photography.
p.s. Completely spitballing here, but I wonder if their hesitation to ship with an emulator—as they did when they made the PowerPC -> Intel switch—is because on a mobile device, emulation might be a heat source and power hog. With desktops, they didn't have the same concern about power draw or heat.
Unless they align themselves with market price (within a premium range, maybe up to 50% more than median), I don't see how they can "destroy the market" (they could still be a commercial success though).
The prime selling point of cheap laptops/chromebooks is their price.
I get (but I don't agree) that Apple wants to lock developers into their platform.
[0] https://calacanis.com/2019/01/02/chrome-os-is-the-ultimate-p...
Given the choice of a deluxe Apple computer (never mind an SE one) I would still take the regular PC or the Chromebook. Sounds mad but I like ChromeOS, Chrome and the normal PC keyboard. I don't actually want MacOS and I would pay to not have it. I am not alone in thinking this way.
edit: why downvotes? machines like that are also replacement for a tablet.
Touchscreen devices with touch-centric operating systems/UI systems will never replace 'proper computers' for 'serious software' as everything has to be so completely dumbed-down for touch, simply because you can't build a complex and feature-rich UI for such a limited input device.
My 7 years old dell can replace desktop workstation and tablet. Its replacement better have the same features.