News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:57AM (#22624620)
So in short: if you are being truly logical, every statement of fact is just a statement of belief, it seems.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by jaw on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:02AM (#22625215)
I think that's a potentially misleading way of summarizing it. Facts are true beliefs; not all beliefs are true. The trilemma only implies that there's no way for me to step outside of my own head and know, beyond the possibility of error, that my beliefs are true. But they may still be true. (That applies recursively to the trilemma itself!)

So if you dig far enough, how accurate our beliefs are is partly reliant on factors beyond our control: if our minds happen to be wired with bad axioms we may be unable to avoid inaccurate conclusions.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by wellpast on Thursday March 19, 2020 @06:20AM (#22626123)
> But they may still be true.

How? If beliefs have no way to be verified, what does it mean to say one still may be true.

This statement has as much meaning as randomly uttered noise.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by gwd on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:38AM (#22626508)
> If beliefs have no way to be verified, what does it mean to say one still may be true.

It may not be able to be verified, but it can often be falsified. Suppose I believe that all bridges are safe for me because there is a swarm of fairies following me around holding up the bridges. And suppose you believe that no bridges are safe between the hours of 2 and 3 am, because the gods have so decreed. And suppose we both come to a bridge at 2am.

If I walk over the bridge and it collapses, it falsifies my belief that fairies will always hold up bridges for me, but it doesn't prove your belief that the gods have promised universal collapse for bridge-walking at 2am. On the other hand, if I walk over the bridge and it doesn't collapse, it falsifies your belief that the gods have promised universal collapse for bridge-walking at 2am, but does not prove my belief that fairies will always hold up bridges for me.

"All models are wrong, but some models are useful."

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by gwd on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:02AM (#22627565)
As a corollary to this - a principle I've accepted goes like this: "If you don't know what evidence could show your belief to be false, you don't really know what it means for your belief to be true."

For all of our important beliefs -- about people, politics, religion, whatever -- it's always important that we ask ourselves, "How would I know if I was wrong?"

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by wsy on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:13PM (#22628865)
It seems that falsifying would provide an escape route. Unfortunately it doesn't, because you would first have to establish - without a doubt - the truth of the contradicting statement. That works ok-ish for collapsing bridges, but it breaks down for less direct observations, e.g., when reading experimental data from a computer screen, collected to refute a Physics theory.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by close04 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:32AM (#22626480)
Moral and purely subjective beliefs aside, unless we're talking about a wave function collapse, observing (proving?) a belief does not change the truth value of the underlying point of discussion. So implicitly... it is what it is whether you confirm it to be true or not. Broken clock telling the right time twice a day and all that.

Take "the Earth is round" belief. The Earth was round since before humans existed. Having or not having evidence to support this belief did not and does not alter the shape in any way. The Earth is still round. So this belief was always true (even if unbeknownst to anyone) regardless of who held it and whether they had any evidence to support it.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by jaw on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:51PM (#22630445)
I'm not sure the concept of "truth" is reducible. Any argument about the question "what does truth mean?" implicitly requires that participants can already make some sense of the idea that some answers would be true and others would be false. Also, it seems like you're implying that unverifiable claims are meaningless - but isn't that an unverifiable claim?

Putting that aside, some things are unverifiable yet have concrete ramifications for people's lives. Some examples:

- If "earth will be swallowed by a black hole in ten seconds" is true, I'll never be able to verify it, even though it will have the concrete effect of ending my life.

- I can't verify _or_ falsify that other humans have conscious experiences, but I believe they do. If that belief happens to be false, the world is vastly different than if it is true.

- _Nobody_ could 100% verify that a given physical law applies everywhere at all times. But if it does, some people's lives will be different than if it did not. The fact that everyone in the cosmos has experiences consistent with the law being true, and nobody ever has an experience inconsistent with the law, are part of what make the law true. But that fact can't be verified by anyone.

(A hypothetical omniscient person could verify all these things, but omniscience just means "knowing all true things", so redefining truth in terms of what an omniscient person could verify would be circular.)

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by hammock on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:43PM (#22629194)
I don't believe the other replies answer your question sufficiently. Here is my answer:

Just because you can't prove something is true, doesn't mean it's not true. You can just never know whether it's true or not. See also the Zen Proverb that someone posted in this thread.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by phkahler on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:21AM (#22626415)
When people start debating the truthfulness of things the rest of us agree upon, it's usually time to disengage because they are being unreasonable. Another option is to question not the truth of a belief, but its usefulness.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by guerrilla on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:50AM (#22625152)
No, this is not the conclusion that analytic epistemology has come to. Have a look at coherentism, foundationalism and reliabalism for example. The view you describe is skepticism and is held by a very small minority of modern philosophers.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justep-coherence/

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justep-foundational/

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/reliabilism/

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/skepticism/

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by paganel on Thursday March 19, 2020 @06:10AM (#22626065)
> The view you describe is skepticism and is held by a very small minority of modern philosophers.

To be honest the percentage of modern philosophers (or any other modern profession) having a view on something like this has no relation to the actual thing being true, false, or true or false at the same time or neither true nor false at the same time. We're all playing glasperlenspiel [1] trying to make sense of some of the things that surround us, that is until all of us will inevitably die.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Glass_Bead_Game

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by guerrilla on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:01AM (#22627008)
Whether anyone has a view on anything like this has no bearing on the actual thing being true, false, or true or false at the same time or neither true nor false at the same time, but they're specially trained in determining which is the case, so there is very likely a relation. I'm going to defer to them until such time I ever have the skills to do otherwise. That's how the division of labot goes.

Thanks for te book recommendation. Looks amazing. Loved Siddartha.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by wsy on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:08PM (#22628815)
After the postmodernist wave, analytic philosophers have attempted to rescue the notion of truth. All those attempts, including the ones you listed, change the meaning of 'truth' significantly, compared to how non-philosophers use that term.

None of the listed options is so convincing that everybody using their rationality would immediately agree with the proposed model of truth. That seems to indicate that also for these options, rationality alone is insufficient to establish truth, and a belief/irrational/social factor still would be at play.

I'm not implying that the mentioned approaches developed by analytic philosophers are useless. They do deepen our understanding how reasoning and fact establishing works. But in my opinion they are still very far away of solving the Münchhausen Trilemma.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by guerrilla on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:14PM (#22629517)
This isn't a history that an analytic philosopher would give, its just question begging from a postmodernist bias.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by wsy on Thursday March 19, 2020 @04:33PM (#22631434)
So which of those approaches is the one all rational humans would agree on, so that we can base the notion of truth on it from now on?
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:25AM (#22627223)
Awesome, thanks for the links - I’ll dig into those the next chance I get.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by ajna91 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:58AM (#22625193)
The 3 schools against skepticism all argue against each other's points, so in a sense they strengthen the skeptical position.

Appears there is no clear consensus on exactly why skepticism is false.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by guerrilla on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:10AM (#22625255)
Your argument is an argument of Pyrrho, 3rd century BC. It refutes itself if you think about it. What they have in common though is making or relying on strong arguments against skepticism. The question is which alternative is the best, not whether an alternative is necessary.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by Swenrekcah on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:56AM (#22625460)
Can’t one turn this argument around to any other school of philosophy?
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by scarmig on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:55AM (#22625177)
Counterargument: skepticism is kind of boring compared to the other positions. There's just not much to build on if you flatly reject the ability to build things. People who're inclined to take that route are likely to avoid modern philosophy, so of course they would be a small minority of philosophers.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by justin66 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:59AM (#22626630)
> Counterargument: skepticism is kind of boring compared to the other positions. There's just not much to build on if you flatly reject the ability to build things.

Skepticism doesn't demand that you "reject the ability to do things." See Hume.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by Der_Einzige on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:36PM (#22629130)
Hahahah it's like people just ignored all the awesome philosophy from radical skeptics.

Max Stirner, the most radical skeptic of them all, is without a doubt a more interesting philosopher than many others one is forced to read. Moreover, contrary to the claim made by the OP - he expects the reader to have read philosophy from other authors.

A radical skeptic like Stirner loves Kant and Hume. Maybe it's because Kant shows that the "thing-in-itself" is unknowable even if it exists and Hume shows us that empirical observation is basically all we have for trying to work with the world. Both show that no one in science has found anything resembling truth

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by paganel on Thursday March 19, 2020 @06:13AM (#22626081)
You're assuming "building things" will bring us closer to getting to know the world a little better (or its essence), that might be false.

> so of course they would be a small minority of philosophers

I'm not a philosopher myself but I found Heraclitus's writings (Democritus's, too) a lot more interesting than many philosophers' writings from the 20th century, in this field being more modern doesn't necessarily mean being better or knowing more.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by guerrilla on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:01AM (#22625211)
Or you could take a look at the references and the corpus and see that there are strong arguments against it instead of just guessing with no data. Analytic philosophers don't tend to build things anyway. They focus more on answering specific questions. There are plenty of "continental" philosophers who still do and many in fact have no problem with this.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by SarikayaKomzin on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:47AM (#22624874)
Indeed. This is why it often seems like anything built up rationally can be tore down rationally.

This leads some to the interesting (and perhaps terrifying) conclusion that narratives are more important and useful than rationalism. Example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_de_Maistre

“ According to Maistre, any attempt to justify government on rational grounds will only lead to unresolvable arguments about the legitimacy and expediency of any existing government and that this in turn will lead to violence and chaos.[23][24] As a result, Maistre argued that the legitimacy of government must be based on compelling, but non-rational grounds which its subjects must not be allowed to question.”

Perhaps whatever is useful is oftentimes more important than what is true.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by eb3c90 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @06:57AM (#22626306)
>“ According to Maistre, any attempt to justify government on rational grounds will only lead to unresolvable arguments about the legitimacy and expediency of any existing government and that this in turn will lead to violence and chaos.[23][24] As a result, Maistre argued that the legitimacy of government must be based on compelling, but non-rational grounds which its subjects must not be allowed to question.” > >Perhaps whatever is useful is oftentimes more important than what is true.

There has been an ongoing debate in the UK about proportional representation and the first past the post system. It has not, as yet, lead to violence and chaos. So I think that the link Maistre identifies between questioning the status quo and chaos is not always true.

Admittedly there is time and place for debate. You don't argue about the cars direction, when the driver is trying to concentrate in a dangerous situation.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by SarikayaKomzin on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:47AM (#22627965)
Yeah. I shared that quote as an example of the “terrifying” conclusions this good lead one to, not necessarily because I though his reactionary stance was true (or useful, haha).

But maybe the success of representative democracy is not based in rationalism but instead the mythology around individual liberty.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by SarikayaKomzin on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:30PM (#22630234)
I meant "conclusions this could lead to". Not sure how I ended up with the above. Sorry about that.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by dntbnmpls on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:26AM (#22624762)
Yep. It's like the God problem. If God created the universe, then who created God? If another God created God, then who created that God. Ad infinitum. Or you can just ignore the exhausting issue altogether by claiming it is axiomatic.

It's the same with any logical statement. You could go all the way up to the premises and question that and when given a proof of the premises, then you can question the premises of the "proof of the premises". Ad infinitum. Or you just take the axiomatic approach.

I think most of life is lived axiomatically.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by guerrilla on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:03AM (#22625223)
Coherentism ans reliabakism address this. You're alao confounding infinite regression in metaphysics (causality and/or composition) with imfinite regression in epistemic justification.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @05:02AM (#22625735)
If you're going to accuse someone of confounding infinite regression with infinite regression, you really need to give some explanation of the difference between infinite regression and infinite regression.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by guerrilla on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:04AM (#22626651)
The difference is the difference between metaphysics and epistemology. One can consistently accept that there is no first cause (everything has a cauase), smallest thing (everything has a part) as examples while rejecting infinitely chained justificationa or vice versa. They don't necessarily or usuallydepend on eachother.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by psychoslave on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:45AM (#22626559)
Well, obviously they don't occur at the same position! ;)
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by AmericanChopper on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:17AM (#22625019)
This is correct, but a lot of people derive and indefensible conclusion from it. The real insight is that any belief in an axiom is an exercise in faith. A scientist who fails to recognise the role of faith in their beliefs commits the same error as a religious person who fails to recognise the role of faith in their beliefs.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by mannykannot on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:12AM (#22627126)
This is a common argument, and it is a form of argument by dictionary definition, which are seldom informative, and most often used to avoid the issues.

While individual scientists may hold beliefs that go beyond scientific premises, the significant difference between scientific and religious belief is that in the former case, all axioms are considered to be defeasible - and they quite often are overthrown.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by AmericanChopper on Saturday March 21, 2020 @06:44AM (#22645683)
The foundational axioms of scientific practice are generally not considered to be defeasible at all. The axioms of any particular theory or field may also be considered entirely beyond reproach.

This is also not a semantic argument at all. It is strictly a logical one.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by specialist on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:54AM (#22627492)
Please humor me. Trying to articulate a half-baked notion.

A close relative went from marine biologist to creationist (et al), and I've been struggling to accept the change. My Calvinist self still doesn't understand Evangelic system of faith.

--

Given Structure + Process => Outcomes:

Scientist: Faith in processes, eg scientific method. Belief is based on reproducibility.

Evangelical: Faith in outcomes. The book (authority) is used to rationalize (justify) proclamations of belief.

To your point: Yes, both have "faith", but with different starting points and emphasis.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by xelxebar on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:52AM (#22625162)
> ... every statement of fact is just a statement of belief, it seems.

Perhaps. The "just" part gets me thinking.

There seems to be an important qualitative difference between prototypical statements of belief---e.g. I believe in the healing power of reiki---and prototypical statements of fact---e.g. This is a glass of water.

While both of the above do contain elements of belief---namely, narratives about what things are in the world---they seem to operate quite differently in many respects.

Belief-style statements tend to more overtly signal traits like social ingroup or self-identity. In particular, declaring belief in the power of reiki seems more likely to influence how others think and concieve of you as a person. I doubt that declaring the existence of a glass of water is likely to do the same.

More generally, this line of thought makes tempts me to say that fact-like staments tend to have less social content than belief-style ones.

Or, more susinctly, facts are a proper subset of beliefs.

In the same way that 2D space differs wildly from 1000D space, despite the former being a subset of the latter, I think it ignores a lot to treat "facts" as "just beliefs." How a belief operates matters.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by abtinf on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:19AM (#22625023)
Humans require food and water to live. You might evade that fact as a mere belief, but you cannot escape the consequences of such an approach.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by normalnorm on Thursday March 19, 2020 @04:33AM (#22625616)
What are the consequences? Have you ever experienced them yourself?
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by briefcomment on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:00AM (#22624632)
Yes. Another way of looking at it is that there are no first principles.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by KingMachiavelli on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:26AM (#22624769)
And a similar concept to this is that given a set of accepted axioms, two parties should always come to the same conclusion if both parties are behaving rationally. All debates are at best disagreements of accepted premises and definitions.

It's a important concept to remember for anyone who's argumentative/legalistic since understanding the oppossing sides definitions and desired conclusion is often the cause for disagreement. If there are no first principles, then there are no definitive last principles.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by scarejunba on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:45AM (#22625135)
An entertaining related concept https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aumann%27s_agreement_theorem

Also, in some ideal sense, since we attain consciousness as pure minds untainted by experience, tabula rasa, all that follows is the result of sense information on the network. The concept of individuality is weak. Two pure minds, fully rational and capable of honest communication, can be different by having different sense information, but if they are able to communicate with each other they should, in time, be identical. i.e. once I have given you everything I know completely and you have given me everything you know completely, we are not distinct, you and I are the same. A full mind meld.

We can't do this for all sorts of reasons, but two AGIs truly meeting may, which means that there is a sort of greyness to this true meeting of AGIs: by meeting they achieve unity. All AGIs behaving in this manner then become the same purely by meeting. Interesting.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by rocqua on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:29AM (#22625340)
This makes total sense, because of the assumption of common priors.

Drop that assumption, and fully rational people can indeed agree to disagree. This is a large part of why rational people can look at the same evidence, and come to different conclusions.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @05:01AM (#22625729)
> This makes total sense, because of the assumption of common priors.

That's the Wiki article, yes. But scarejunba is going past that, to something more fundamental.

If you have "pure minds untainted by experience, tabula rasa", then you remove the issue of priors. No longer is there any matrix of prejudices that have to agree. You start with observations about the world and logic, and nothing else, and everyone ends up in agreement.

(To an extent you might bootstrap with priors, but over time you'd use observations and logic to replace them, especially when they disagree with someone else you're debating.)

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by smallnamespace on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:39AM (#22626514)
This seems unworkable because it ignores the role instincts have in living things, which are prior beliefs about the world put immediately into action.

For example, an infant has an instinct to breathe right after birth. Is that a belief or an action? It’s both—a strategy to survive in the world encoded in genes attached to an implicit belief. An infant that tries to breathe two minutes later would suffer hypoxia and brain damage, while one that tries sooner will choke.

There is no pure tabula rasa untainted by priors, as soon as you acknowledge minds are embedded in bodies shaped by millions of years of evolution and steeped in survival tactics, and what are tactics except a set of useful priors about good actions?

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by Dylan16807 on Saturday March 21, 2020 @02:05AM (#22644868)
Things your body does don't have to be integrated into the priors you use when performing logic.

But "You need to breathe." and things like that would be the easiest priors to replace with observational data.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by rocqua on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:32AM (#22625356)
Also, I believe this requires full mutual trust between the two parties, and perfect communication.

Any breaks in trust, or breakdowns in communication can disrupt the process of mind melding. And it seems to me that trust and failure of communication are features of boundaries between individuals.

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:34AM (#22627299)
> but two AGIs truly meeting may

Interesting indeed

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by psychoslave on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:44AM (#22626545)
> Another way of looking at it is that there are no first principles.

Is that part of the principles you adhere to? :)

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by cwojno on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:10AM (#22624991)
100% this. Most people do NOT realize this when engaged in normal conversation nor while in philosophical debates.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by skrebbel on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:59AM (#22625198)
That's just like, your opinion, man.