News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @05:01AM (#22625729)
> This makes total sense, because of the assumption of common priors.

That's the Wiki article, yes. But scarejunba is going past that, to something more fundamental.

If you have "pure minds untainted by experience, tabula rasa", then you remove the issue of priors. No longer is there any matrix of prejudices that have to agree. You start with observations about the world and logic, and nothing else, and everyone ends up in agreement.

(To an extent you might bootstrap with priors, but over time you'd use observations and logic to replace them, especially when they disagree with someone else you're debating.)

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by smallnamespace on Thursday March 19, 2020 @07:39AM (#22626514)
This seems unworkable because it ignores the role instincts have in living things, which are prior beliefs about the world put immediately into action.

For example, an infant has an instinct to breathe right after birth. Is that a belief or an action? It’s both—a strategy to survive in the world encoded in genes attached to an implicit belief. An infant that tries to breathe two minutes later would suffer hypoxia and brain damage, while one that tries sooner will choke.

There is no pure tabula rasa untainted by priors, as soon as you acknowledge minds are embedded in bodies shaped by millions of years of evolution and steeped in survival tactics, and what are tactics except a set of useful priors about good actions?

Re:Münchhausen Trilemma by Dylan16807 on Saturday March 21, 2020 @02:05AM (#22644868)
Things your body does don't have to be integrated into the priors you use when performing logic.

But "You need to breathe." and things like that would be the easiest priors to replace with observational data.