S.Korea did extensive testing, which reduces the number of unreported infections. So the calculated death rate in S. Korea is 4x lower than a comparable country like Spain, which has similar # of confirmed cases, population, GDP, and GDP per capita.
If we assume S. Korea's calculated death rate(<1%) is closer to the true death rate and apply it to other countries to derive the total # of infections (reported + unreported) based on the reported death count, we can see there may be far more infections than we know.
Is Spain and S. Korea really that much different to have a 4x difference in death rate?
The former suggests what your population mortality rate will be if your healthcare system is overwhelmed, and could possibly be derived from Italian data. The latter gives you a resources vs effectiveness sweet spot that maximises health system throughput, so you can save the maximum number of lives over time given the resources you have (or can build/find.)
The age profile is relevant, but worryingly there seem to be a number of reports that it's not just the over-65s who are at risk.
I haven't seen anything more recent about this than the Chinese estimates from a month or so ago.
We by all means should collect more data, just don't shoehorn it into such a very primitive yet very essential statistic. Give them new names and new, more appropriate semantics. I suspect that after this is over they're going to tighten the criteria around CFR, and in particular exclude by definition asymptomatic cases and possibly non-hospitalized cases. They never had to do that before as "cases" usually implied someone sick enough to be given a diagnosis, which in turn implied someone at least moderately sick--e.g. actual or suspected case of pneumonia.
One study I've seen pinned the median time-to-death after symptom onset at 18 days. Even in Korea you won't get less than a 2-3% CFR with that estimation.
edit: I don't know anything about statistics by the way, please tell me that I'm wrong.
https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-death-rates-by-a...
20-29: 0%
30-39: 0.1%
40-49: 0.1%
50-59: 0.4%
60-69: 1.5%
70-79: 4.3%
80+: 7.2%
ie: if you have cov2 you have a 7% chance of dying from it but dont you already have say a 50% chance of dying in your 80s anyway?
to be strictly logical and not emotional about this moral question: are we unhinging society (effects we cannot begin to calculate) to keep the fatality rate for the population 80+ at 50% instead of 57%?
in terms of costs to the healthcare system, might this equate to a net relief if the peak were accelerated instead of flattened?
That's a standard actuarial problem, answered with life tables (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr61/nvsr61_03.pdf -- pdf, US 2008). In said life tables, there is a 7% death rate between ages 83 and 84.
To an order-of-magnitude approximation, infection with the novel coronavirus seems to impose roughly one year's worth of mortality risk on the victim.
It’d be interesting to see how many healthy 80+ year olds have died.
There's a ~6% chance of dying during the year you turned 80. That chance goes up dramatically every year you get older. By 85 it's nearly 10%.
It would be interesting to calculate how this virus changes those rates. I feel like these kind of analysis are completely lacking in any reporting.
And then it's also about the rest of the population that needs medical attention for a different reason.
Imagine the medicial facilities being flooded by COVID-19 patients. There are enough severe cases already in many countries that non essential operations are suspended.
Good luck getting adequate treatment for your broken leg.
https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/16/coronavirus-model-shows-...
And all of that is ignoring the possibility of people suffering nonfatal chronic health problems, which has been reported.
Meanwhile, remdesivir and lopinavir/ritonavir are in trials and once we actually have drugs available the hospitalizations would be shorter and the death rates much lower. At that point quarantine becomes less important.
80 5.8%
81 6.4%
82 7.1%
83 7.8%
84 8.7%
85 9.7%
86 10.7%
87 11.9%
88 13.3%
89 14.8%
https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html1) But # infections were growing exponentially, we need to use numbers from the same cohort, which implies much lower # infections & higher CFR. Naive CFR will go up once infections grow more slowly. (It is already going up over time.).
2) South Korean confirmed cases are much younger than their median age, mainly between 20-29 years old (perhaps because of where superspreading events happen—that church). This age group has a much lower fatality rate from Covid-19.
3) # hospital beds per capita in South Korea is second highest among OECD countries (1st is Japan) and ~4 times that of the US. They already have patients waiting for beds.
Most countries will do much worse if they reach the same # infections per capita, since fatality rate surges to multiple times as high without proper care (as can be seen in several places around the world now, unfortunately).
(SK has ~12 beds/1000 capita; China ~4.3; US ~2.8)
CFR (Case Fatality Rate) is based on the # people who were tested. IFR (Infection Fatality Rate) which includes people with no or mild symptoms will be lower.
"On this basis, using WHO data on the cumulative number of deaths to March 1, 2020, mortality rates would be 5·6% (95% CI 5·4–5·8) for China and 15·2% (12·5–17·9) outside of China. Global mortality rates over time using a 14-day delay estimate are shown in the figure, with a curve that levels off to a rate of 5·7% (5·5–5·9)"
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3...
According to this article (https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-death-age-older-...) an 80 year old has a 15% chance of dying. Is that actually "extremely bad" though? I think if 80 year old grandma got cancer and the doctors told you there was a 85% chance she'd recover, you might well breath a sigh of relief. For somebody that old, there are much worse mortality rates than that. Breaking your hip is more deadly than getting the coronavirus for people that old[0].
Rather the legitimate concern is due to how rapidly the disease is spreading. 15% is enough to kill TONS of people when you scale it up to the whole population. It's a high mortality rate considering the scope of the pandemic, but a relatively low mortality rate for the individual.
[0] "The risk of death in the year following a fracture is about 20% in older people." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hip_fracture
On an individual level however, adding an illness with 15% mortality on top of all the other things over 80s can get is a big deal.
80+ year olds are a varied cohort, and some are reasonably healthy, with multiple years left to live. The hip fracture data is biased because frail people with other problems are more likely to fall.
Yes.
How much money would I have to offer you that you took your chances?
Unnecessary deaths are worse than life threats you can't do anything about it.
That depends on how old I am. If I'm in my 80s with a fulfilling life behind me, playing russian roulette would disturb me a lot less than if were a young adult with a potential life before me. From elsewhere in this thread, it seems like simply being that old in the first place is like playing russian roulette anyway (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22600562)
Now obviously in this case you'd be playing it twice instead of just once. But I hope that by the time I'm that old I've had enough time to come to terms with my mortality, write a will, make amends with family, etc. Because there are much worse prognosis's for somebody at that age than 15% mortality rate.
Or to look at this from another angle: 'extremely' bad is inherently relative. And taken relative to other common ailments people that old content with, I don't think 15% chance of death qualifies as 'extreme'. If 15% is 'extreme' then what adjective would you use for a cancer with a 50% mortality rate? "Super-dooper-uber extreme"?
You're missing the time frame. Getting cancer is a threat that many old people face but that's spread over decades.
With COVID-19, we face 70%-80% of the population being infected within a much shorter time, possibly a year or less (depending on how well or bad the delay measures are).
Yes, people die at that age for many reasons. But here, we have a potential death threat that is avertable and, most importantly, that affects the whole of society, not only old people.
Don't think that only old people get it and need medical attention. Lots of young people also need medical attention, even if they don't die from it. Ignoring long term effects from having caught it (as we don't know them yet), this alone would disrupt society. And then the secondary effects of people with other medical conditions not being treated as they are triaged.
Modern society doesn't need a lot to be disrupted. Look at how disruptive 9/11 was.
The most likely explanation is that Korea is catching more mild cases that other countries are missing.
While I agree with your overall point, I don't believe this is a good assumption. I think some percentage of unreported fatal cases are reported as pneumonia/cardiac arrest/etc.
It's certainly not uniformly distributed. Testing is not random. Typical test guidelines are to test when some combination of the following are present:
* Flu-like symptoms, after ruling out all other infectious causes
* Travel to a known outbreak region
* Close contact with a confirmed or strongly-suspected case
Asymptomatic people without known exposure are left untested (as is sensible to economize resources), and even people with mild symptoms but no known exposure may be left untested -- this makes it particularly difficult to catch the early stages of community spread, before people have had time to be hospitalized.
You seem to be implying that maybe there are a load of us that had it already (and maybe, hopefully, that’s the case). But if so, doesn’t it seem weird that we’ve basically watched its progress as it’s spread around the world? Why would most people get it and be asymptotic followed by a series of unlucky people that are getting it now and falling ill? Though again, maybe I’m misunderstanding.
> You seem to be implying that maybe there are a load of us that had it already (and maybe, hopefully, that’s the case).
Yep, and that as a result our mortality projections from CFR are quite overstated.
> But if so, doesn’t it seem weird that we’ve basically watched its progress as it’s spread around the world?
I wouldn't be shocked to see a retrospective on this in the future tell us that we've been seeing the spread of availability of the test rather than the disease.
> Why would most people get it and be asymptotic followed by a series of unlucky people that are getting it now and falling ill?
Symptoms are basically the same as the flu for most people (Korea has a 0% CFR under 29, and 0.1% under 49), and for older folks, well, they're older, and basically anything can kill them. Some studies showed a fatality rate of 10% for the H1N1 flu -- and so far we're seeing a CFR of 15% for old folks in Korea. It's possible the fatalities we'd been seeing were written off as just that.
Ok, I could buy into that (and I really hope that's the case - though I'm still doubtful). The main thing I didn't realise was that the tests didn't show who had had it. Thanks for taking the time to work your point through with me.
So, no.
This paper is about undetected carriers spreading SARS-CoV2 across China prior to the Jan 23 lockdown. It does not imply that 86% of all total infections that we see currently are undocumented, it only reflects the relatively narrow testing that was happening prior to Jan 23 (likely only the severe cases).
After Jan 23, China expanded its testing much more broadly, and other countries (such as South Korea) have done so as well. You should not take this paper to mean that the actual number of cases for these countries is larger by a factor of 1/(1-0.86).
We should be conscious of this desire, and be careful assessing new evidence that comports with this notion.
But this isn't a bad thing -- having strong opinions and questioning the veracity of data is key to having informed, strong opinions.
And, hearteningly, we see that OP has edited his comment to reflect the knowledge you passed along and has a better understanding of the situation. Inquiry at work.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DqfSnlaW6N3GBc5YKyBOCGPfdqO...
This also explains why Korea’s [edit: case fatality] rate is so low and so correlated with their high incidence of testing.
I wouldn’t be surprised if the majority of us have already had it. There’s a decent shot this all amounts to a big ol nothing burger.
It sounds like you may be interested in reading this paper: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.04.20031104v...
>I wouldn’t be surprised if the majority of us have already had it. There’s a decent shot this all amounts to a big ol nothing burger.
Unsupported by any evidence and complete wishful thinking. Please stop with the irresponsible speculation.
I won’t bother re-creating the epidemiological studies as professionals have much better simulations than I could offer.
I will urge you to read up on the models before assuming this thing is “already everywhere” which also implies it won’t grow exponentially.
100% complete bullshit, nobody can know this kind of thing for sure right now.
The danger with this disease seems to be that it is highly contagious and countries tend to see a huge spike in cases that completely overwhelms the healthcare system and leads to a several-fold increase in the case fatality rate (e.g. Iran, Italy).
So I agree that on its own COVID-19 is likely less fatal than some of the numbers we tend to see cited, but under outbreak conditions it can be much much more fatal.
I mistyped in my original post which I have since edited.
> Presently, there are four, endemic, coronavirus strains currently circulating in human populations (229E, HKU1, NL63, OC43). If the novel coronavirus follows the pattern of 2009 H1N1 pandemic influenza, it will also spread globally and become a fifth endemic coronavirus within the human population.
This thing is extremely contagious, it's probably already everywhere, and there's a good chance it will be circulating indefinitely. Hopefully folks will just get tired of the panic after a while. And if we're lucky, this might lead to more awareness about the devastation that respiratory illnesses cause, especially to old folks, every year across the world.
If you want to yell at me because I'm not panicking enough, save your breath. I'm just as pissed at you for spreading a terrible mind-virus, so call it even if you must.
The death count math and growth rate doesn't check out. If that were true (i.e that the total infection rate was already non-negligible) then the disease must have either been growing for months without detection and without spreading from Hubei, or it must in some crazy way be spreading much faster among the asymptomatic than among the serious cases.
The article argues for a roughly 6x undercount. That's still much lower than saturation, meaning that we have a lot of headroom to grow out of control still.
Stay. At. Home.
Would that be surprising? If you're contagious a few days before any symptoms, you'd have plenty of time to transmit it to several other folks. Even if your case then becomes serious (which is not terribly likely in this model), you're going to be staying home or in treatment, and probably much more careful about contact with others.
(86% of cases unreported, eg about 1 in 10 reported, assume that number of unreported fatal cases is 0)
Edit: closer reading suggests the optimism is sadly unwarranted, the headline under-reporting number of 86% is from the early pre-travel ban model, post-travel-ban estimates give a 65% detection rate, combined with the increased number of cases in this later period this implies that naive mortality estimates are more like 2x off than 10x off.