That's a standard actuarial problem, answered with life tables (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr61/nvsr61_03.pdf -- pdf, US 2008). In said life tables, there is a 7% death rate between ages 83 and 84.
To an order-of-magnitude approximation, infection with the novel coronavirus seems to impose roughly one year's worth of mortality risk on the victim.
It’d be interesting to see how many healthy 80+ year olds have died.
There's a ~6% chance of dying during the year you turned 80. That chance goes up dramatically every year you get older. By 85 it's nearly 10%.
It would be interesting to calculate how this virus changes those rates. I feel like these kind of analysis are completely lacking in any reporting.
And then it's also about the rest of the population that needs medical attention for a different reason.
Imagine the medicial facilities being flooded by COVID-19 patients. There are enough severe cases already in many countries that non essential operations are suspended.
Good luck getting adequate treatment for your broken leg.
https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/16/coronavirus-model-shows-...
And all of that is ignoring the possibility of people suffering nonfatal chronic health problems, which has been reported.
Meanwhile, remdesivir and lopinavir/ritonavir are in trials and once we actually have drugs available the hospitalizations would be shorter and the death rates much lower. At that point quarantine becomes less important.
80 5.8%
81 6.4%
82 7.1%
83 7.8%
84 8.7%
85 9.7%
86 10.7%
87 11.9%
88 13.3%
89 14.8%
https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html
ie: if you have cov2 you have a 7% chance of dying from it but dont you already have say a 50% chance of dying in your 80s anyway?
to be strictly logical and not emotional about this moral question: are we unhinging society (effects we cannot begin to calculate) to keep the fatality rate for the population 80+ at 50% instead of 57%?
in terms of costs to the healthcare system, might this equate to a net relief if the peak were accelerated instead of flattened?