In Europe by contrast, much more of life revolves around public spaces, like the park, cafes, the city square, and public transport. Americans tend to spend little time in restaurants, whereas Europeans relax and enjoy the meal, thus increasing their exposure time.
Think of the areas in the US that seen the worst outbreaks. Seattle, the Bay Area, New York, Boston. These are the metros, where the average resident is least likely to live a typical middle-American lifestyle. San Francisco in many ways is closer to Copenhagen than it is to Jacksonville.
Overall, social distancing is probably easier for Americans because our way of life already involves a good deal of social distance to begin with.
Do you have a source for that? I couldn't find a great single source but this says 9% of retail sales were ecommerce in Europe in 2018:
https://ecommercenews.eu/ecommerce-in-europe/
and this says 8% in the US in 2018:
https://www.invespcro.com/blog/global-online-retail-spending...
If you treat North and South Europe separately, it looks like Northern Europe has most ecommerce, then the US, then Southern Europe.
Have you? Most of the US urban population in the US fits the points of the OP:
- Very few people use public transportation regularly (they use cars, in the cities, yes)
- Most people have private back yards (the infamous "American suburbs", where 50% of Americans live, count towards the urban population you mention)
- Many more meals are take-out or drive-thru
- More Americans use e-commerce for shopping than Europeans
Poke around https://www.hemnet.se/topplistor
What the OP was saying is that americans don't eat out that much, is a very heavily home-oriented society - thats why the OP mentioned take out and delivery - not going out for lunch.
And yes people out of cities in nearly all countries have big backyards, but you are missing the people have big back yards in the US EVEN inside city limits. There are ofcourse the couple exceptions like NYC etc. but mostly even big cities have the weird suburban style houses even in the most expensive areas!
What will happen or won't in US or Europe is not anymore dependent on these behaviors.
> you are missing the people have big back yards in the US EVEN inside city
hardly.
I don’t think I know anyone who haven’t ended up in a house eventually tbh.
> The World Bank.
Here's some direct links though:
- https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS?locat... - https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS?locat...
While that's true, behavior trumps lifestyle I think. I had a dentist appointment scheduled for this morning in San Francisco. I called my dentist office and explained that my wife has some mild-flu symptoms and asked if we should reschedule. They said that's since I don't have symptoms myself it's not necessary to postpone the appointment. That may happen in Jacksonville too.
This is FUD. That isn't where you risk getting sick. The countries with the most effective response to COVIR-19 doesn't even try to stop everyday shopping or movement in cars at all.
>In Europe by contrast, much more of life revolves around public spaces, like the park, cafes, the city square, and public transport.
You don't get sick by being in a park or city square with someone else. More FUD. Please do some reading on the appropriate measures and what actually constitutes a risk of infection.
- we have a better healthcare system than is US (better as in public and for everyone)
- we own the most cars per capita in the west and are second in the world, public transport wasn't a big factor in this pandemia here
- food is much more controlled and we have a tradition of home made, home grown food, that doesn't require to go to the supermarket
- things are closer so trips are shorter and you can shop at many non packed smaller shops
- we react better to panic and are not armed
- infection has spread in small cities in the country where houses are larger, they have more storage, don't use public transport and social distancing in theory was easier
All in all, there are many ways to look at this
Wait until all the coronavirus infected hourly workers, who can't get treated because of a lack of healthcare and who have to continue going to work so they can pay rent, infect everyone through the take-out food :)
Also traffic is great now. One good thing to come out of this is that governments might see the huge infrastructure benefits from just a small increase in remote workers.
https://newsroom.airasia.com/news/2020/2/29/eng-aaunlimitedp...
Stopping the CTA would virtually shut down Chicago.
No they don't. No one in NYC, Boston, San Francisco, Seattle, ... have big garages to stockpile supplies and most of the US lives in those big cities with apartments without garages.
In the suburbs they do but that's a minority of the population.
> About 46 million Americans live in the nation’s rural counties, 175 million in its suburbs and small metros and about 98 million in its urban core counties.
> As a group, the population in rural counties grew 3% since 2000, less than their 8% growth in the 1990s. Urban county population rose 13% since 2000 and the population in suburban and small metro counties went up 16%, growth rates somewhat higher than in the 1990s.
It's hidden in plain sight: you mention "Boston, San Fransisco, and Seattle" in the same breath as NYC, but numbers-wise those are all pretty small and you're leaving out not only their suburbs but also the LA, Chicago, DFW and Houston areas which all have considerable amounts of suburbs and single family living, and hold almost 40M people alone...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_populous_cities_i...
People in the suburbs do have big garages (think long island vs manhattan)
https://www.citylab.com/life/2018/11/data-most-american-neig...
https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2018/05/22/demographic-and-e...
I think most of San Francisco by area is zoned "RH-" (Residential Housing), and most of that RH- area is RH-1 or RH-1D (single family). Most of the homes in those regions have lots of space.
We're not just talking about Zuck's mansion either, plenty of homes in the Sunset or other West SF areas that have that kind of room.
One other factor in the US favor, it’s extremely low population density compared to the rest of the world. The US, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand are all similarly low density and in this specific case likely to benefit from that.
I'm not sure the average population density across the entire country is that relevant - it doesn't tell you anything about the distribution of population.
The US is actually rather an urban country - 82% live in urban areas which is more than Italy (75%):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization_by_country
Edit: Also noticed that Australia is 86% and Canada 81%!
I mean, Berlin has 3.7 million people in a city of 890 sq km. Melbourne has about 5 million people in a city of almost 10,000 km. They're incomparable, and so the urban population of Australia and Germany are incomparable. (You can play with the definitions as much as you like but you'll never be able to compare arbitrary Australian and German cities.)
Half of the US population lives in the suburbs (see above posters). What we would recognize as a real urban environment only accounts for less than a third of the US population (98M people).
I did see a figure of about 55% of everyone in England and Wales living in suburbs - but I suspect our suburbs look pretty dense to someone from Houston or indeed Achiltibuie!
Such as??
I'm living California, outside a major city. I don't see anything.
Cities and counties in CA had been doing the same with different thresholds. Which meant an NBA game was going to be played without fans (since then, the NBA season has been suspended, which is a pretty significant measure in and of itself).
Many schools have been closing in the Seattle area, and just today the Seattle school district, and many outlying school districts closed for at least two weeks. That's a lot of school closures.
Many companies are having employees work from home wherever possible. The amount of traffic in Seattle during rush-hour is an astronomical change. There's very light traffic during rush hour in places that used to be wall-to-wall vehicles.
As someone living in the Seattle area, it feels like life has substantially changed.
https://www.usnews.com/news/education-news/articles/2020-03-...
Washington Gov. Jay Inslee said he’s banning gatherings of more than 250 people in several counties.
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/11/washington-state-bans-large-...
Many local businesses have soft-closed their offices at behest of city including Amazon and Microsoft.
I don't know if they're all just being exceptionally prepared or if there's plans for a more widespread school shutdown here.
This now includes Bellevue School District (Bellevue WA).
King (Ground Zero, US), Pierce and Snohomish Counties all have a ban on any event with 250 or more people (this was declared by WA State's governor)
City council meetings are being conducted remotely.
University of Washington has moved all their classes online for the remainder of the semester.
Gatherings are also being shut down. Public meetings are shutting down.
What else would you have them do?
laughs in jersey
----------------------------
Wuhan Central Districts
population: 6,434,373
density: 7,242/km2
----------------------------
New York
population: 8,398,748
density: 10,715/km2
Many parts are really not as collectivist as people seem to think. Not as collectivist as Asia at least, not even close. Individualistic tendencies are strong over there, although not as strong as in the US.
I guess it's all down to the economy, business travel spread it a lot. that's why areas with strong economies seem to be affected more than others (at least in Spain, Italy and Germany). Banning travel could work quite effectively for that.
Are you saying Spain and Italy has strong economies?
For Italy it's the North, for Germany South & West, for Spain the regions around Barcelona & Madrid. In each case, they were hit hardest. I don't believe that this is coincidence. There are other factors, like wealth leading to more travel and general, as well as population density. But interconnection by economic activity looks to me like a major factor.
And yet here we are the next day. The situation is evolving rapidly.
Meh.
Your personal risk to become infected via $generic_domestic_holidays is pretty low, but the risk to increase the overall threat-vector by allowing open flights from domestic zones is very high.
The personal assessment just differs from the supervising political assessment, while the observed/assessed situation is exactly the same. Also: be careful with "experts", whenever that label is used, you should be very wary. A "medical expert" doesn't inherently know anything about politics at scale, he just (simplification alert) knows which medication to apply when which symptoms arise.
I think there's more of the latter.
So less dramatically: individuals can (and will!) reduce their exposure to infected people that make poor choices.
Of course the more people that do the right thing the better, but it isn't a situation where the outcome is controlled just by the worst actors.
(I'm being sarcastic, but changing the exponent is (literally) what all the public health messaging about flattening the curve is about)
Community mitigation changes the rate.
https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/core-fi...
By that logic, unless you hermetically seal yourself from the outside world, you are still putting everyone else at risk.
And in either case, by that same logic, isolation apparently doesn't matter, so might as well still go to the bar.
The United States has a very individualistic attitude. Sure, we can pause travel from Europe, but the current administration is very anti-europe. Can we pause travel in the US? I strongly doubt that we can effectively given the strong anti-expertise attitudes as well.
My guess is that the United States will become a more major hot spot for the virus than other locales. It will spread rapidly and the supply hoarding and sad state of our medical system will mean that in a few months, other nations will be rejecting flights from the US.
It's a prediction, a guess, but there are aspects of our culture that just makes it seem very likely. I'm not going to make any more predictions than the idea that we'll have more cases per capita than any other developed nation.
It's be interesting when I'm proven incorrect over time.