Re:How Pandemics Change History
by Leary on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:26AM
(#22516973)
If locking down a whole city - "cordon sanitaire", doesn't work, why did Italy just do so? Do they not have the same public health experts, or were they educated at different schools.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by lbeltrame on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:56AM
(#22517065)
As a person who lives in the region just locked, I can tell you: the government is totally in panic for the increase in cases (about 50% of them found with aggressive screening with little or no clinical manifestations, FTR, although that does not mean the hospitals are not under pressure) and played the "Wuhan" card.
How much this is enforceable remains to be seen. What's worse, there was already histeria caused by a leak of the document before it was completed (and people blaing the "lack of responsibility" for the leak, when such things have been going for more than a decade...), with people rushing to stations trying to get away.
There is no clear communication (the same government ministers saying different things over the course of a day), there's the "emergency department" (Protezione Civile) that is not able to keep up, there's blaming the victim ("Act responsibly", "You must change your way of life", said from people who have never understood how normal people live and work).
This has been a mess from a policy and communication perspective. Not surprising from a government that was elected "to give politicians a lesson", "to crack open the Parliament like canned tuna", and in the supreme name of "honesty" was built out of complete incompetents.
I'm truly hoping that we'll get out of this... despite them.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by Al-Khwarizmi on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:37AM
(#22517191)
Well, in Spain the evolution of cases is very similar to that of Italy but with a 10-day delay, and the government is doing practically nothing (apart from some very localized measures like close elderly daycare centers after there was an outbreak in one). They keep repeating that it's just like a flu and nothing needs to be done. Today there are going to be feminist demonstrations and next Sunday is the beginning of the Fallas de Valencia, a massive celebration that attracts tourists and locals alike, and they keep repeating that none of that is going to be cancelled.
Don't they have a freaking advisor that understands the exponential function? It doesn't seem that hard to look at the graphs and see that we are heading the same way as Italy.
I think I'd prefer the way of acting of the Italian government who at least seem to be trying to do things. Although who knows. The grass is always greener at the other side of the fence.
Good luck with the situation there for you and your loved ones.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by lbeltrame on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:49AM
(#22517236)
> I think I'd prefer the way of acting of the Italian government who at least seem to be trying to do things.
I understand that Singapore is a very small country and ran way differently than my own, but please look up what the PM there said when he addressed the country on COVID-19 matters and compare it (if you can find a subtitled version) with what our "Giuseppi" said. A world of difference.
Of course now they must do something. But way before the outbreak, local administrations of the now-locked regions who asked for quarantine controls from people from Wuhan and China in general were called "Sinophobes" and the government was far more eager to lock down direct flights from China (useless if you go via hub) as opposed to quarantining or at least tracing those people, and of course to show all support for Chinese people. (Note that I do not condone Sinophobia at all: but a matter of public health policy - like everything, improvable - was just framed as racism).
Ok, this might have not helped at all given that the current theory is that SARS-CoV-2 came to Italy from Germany. But the government was too eager to return to the "important affairs" (meaning, discussing whether a member of the coalition would leave the majority or not). Then when the first cases arrived, there was a total "tug of war" with the legislation ("close down", "ok, maybe not", "maybe yes", "SHUT DOWN EVERYTHING").
So nothing Singapore or South Korea-like. COVID-19 worries me, but I'm far, far more worried about this government.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by xbmcuser on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:14AM
(#22517645)
Singapore had been through this because of sars so had systems in place to deal with a viral outbreak. Quarantining is mostly to decrease the rate of spread so that the healthcare systems don't collapse under the weight of to many patients. But China did a true quarantine they not only stopped people from leaving the cities but also from coming out of their homes. I don't think quarantining cities without people staying in would help much.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by lbeltrame on Sunday March 08, 2020 @11:32AM
(#22518485)
More than how they deal with the outbreak, I was referring to the communication of said events. It's much better than what our disfunctional government is doing.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by makomk on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:27AM
(#22517684)
What really gets me about all this is that, after pushing the narrative that imposing quarantine on travellers from China would be racist and getting Italy and a bunch of other countries to buy into it back when travellers from there were spreading the virus, the Chinese government has now decided that it's going to enforce quarantines on travellers from Italy.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by Broken_Hippo on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:24AM
(#22517143)
I was wondering about this just earlier today - more specifically, how one eats.
I'd be just fine for some days. But by the end of a 2-week quarantine, I'd be eating much more poorly than I would the first week. And I'd be lucky: I have a well-stocked kitchen. I eat a lot of beans and lentils and rice and have all three around. There is pasta here. I make bread most days: I'd certainly have to ration the dried yeast, though.
I'll run out of milk and vegetables (I don't use a lot of frozen ones). If the timing was wrong, I'd run out of flour.
Other folks would fare worse, though. So much worse, just because of what they have in the house. I'd definitely run out of canned tomatoes, even if I used only half. My food wouldn't taste.. wonderful, per se, but I'd survive.
But I'd be lucky: I have this stuff around. Not everyone does and lots of folks would be learning to cook with weird stuff. Some folks simply wouldn't have food.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by Broken_Hippo on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:07AM
(#22517288)
To be fair, I was more curious about the mechanisms in place to avoid it. A google search just had advice on stocking up supplies (for most).
I'd really like to believe this - and I hope it is the case.
But geez, we let folks die of starvation on the best of days. We let folks eat literal trash. We let folks have cases of malnutrition, too, without fixing things. The only thing I think that saves folks in the states is that during a lockdown, it is the government's responsibility to do stuff - but I'm not really convinced so many governments have stuff in place.
Early on, when they could still go out, the husband would visit various supermarkets that were open and before you entered, the greeter would take your temperature.
Then when the lockdown intensified and the people were restricted to their apartment complexes, designated sellers would visit the apartment complexes every day at a specific time so you could buy things.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by jpster on Sunday March 08, 2020 @11:42AM
(#22518568)
These seem like ineffective measures. Planes and trains seem like great vectors for letting the virus live on surfaces. What kind of disinfecting protocols are they following? I have doubts that the hustle and bustle of a typical restaurant would allow the 1m apart rule to be well implemented.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by lbeltrame on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:35AM
(#22517178)
Similar questions were raised by other interested parties (like for goods travel).
Some of these measures are quite onerous and I can expect that many smaller establishments will prefer to close than try to enforce them: how can a bakery, for example, make sure that "not many people enter at once" ("restricted access", says the document, or at least my poor translation from "bureaucrat-speak") and that "distance is at least one meter" between people?
Personally, I can work remotely if need be (haven't done that in about ~10 years, but technically, I can). I've yet to see what my workplace will do, though.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by heavenlyblue on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:58AM
(#22517789)
>> how can a bakery, for example, make sure that "not many people enter at once" ("restricted access", says the document, or at least my poor translation from "bureaucrat-speak") and that "distance is at least one meter" between people?
You make them queue in front of the bakery keeping a distance of a meter between each other?
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by chvid on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:30AM
(#22517164)
Ok. Let's hope that is enough to get the spread under control.
It is still far from the lockdown in Wuhan where people are not allowed to leave their appartments and get food delivered by the authorities.
I am in Copenhagen where the latest is that the government has adviced against gatherings of more than 1.000 people causing some football matches to be on TV only and some concerts to lower their number of attendees to 950.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by J_cst on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:39AM
(#22517201)
We are Italians and we are unable to respect the rules. Tonight a pdf of a draft of the above document has leaked and we had thousands of people rushing to the train stations to get out from Milan and Lombardia region. So basically we created a situation where thousands of people packed to flee from the red zones to get back to their regions in south italy (and possibly to spread the disease even more). Italians are strong individualists and think they're really smart. Spoiler: we are not
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by lbeltrame on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:52AM
(#22517242)
> Tonight a pdf of a draft of the above document has leaked
I'm surprised people are surprised that such a thing leaked. This has been going on for years, except, no one batted an eye.
> We are Italians and we are unable to respect the rules.
As an Italian too, I don't like this generalization. You can make people more willing to follow rules if you approach them correctly. Going full-paternalistic mode (like this government has been doing) or even blaming them ("don't play dumb", is that something one would expect from a PM?) isn't going to help.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by J_cst on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:12AM
(#22517307)
Ok, so the thousands people at the train station it must be a one off situation, my mistake.
It's quite obvious that generalizations are always wrong, but you know our people as I do. I believe the patterns should be quite evident by now. Obviously there are outliers that do not share the common patterns among Italians too.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by lbeltrame on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:41AM
(#22517394)
Ignoring the snark, I'm not surprised by people rushing to trains. It's not their fault: they perceived a threat, they're not equipped to deal with it, so "everyone for himself".
And why that happened? Because whoever is in charge of making sure that the population is reassured (and that's different from pretending that nothing is happening) did not do that.
(Personally, I believe that it's those who not do what should be done are the actual outliers, although the media does an excellent job at cherry picking bad apples).
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by jacobwilliamroy on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:31AM
(#22516987)
What I heard is that it does not stop the virus, but it does slow the spread, which is key considering that we are currently in a flu season. If 40% of the population is going to get infected, it's better to deal with them over a couple years than have them show up all at once.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by bryanrasmussen on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:04AM
(#22517085)
actually I wonder if that 40% still holds given the recent news that the study showing that it could be transmitted by asymptomatic people wasn't correct (although I guess that doesn't mean it can't be transmitted by asymptomatics, only that we are back to uncertain)
Then again, the world is not really structured to letting someone with light fever lay in bed for two weeks so maybe it's the same thing.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by saurik on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:48AM
(#22517232)
The references I have found for "the recent news that the study showing that it could be transmitted by asymptomatic people wasn't correct" are all over a month old, while the references I find for asserting that new evidence is confirming asymptomatic transmission is in fact happening are only a week and a half old. Can you help disambiguate?
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by bryanrasmussen on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:38AM
(#22517727)
I saw a an article yesterday (I believe it was linked here on HN) it was on some science site which said basically that everyone was on agreement that asymptomatic transmission happened because of this study that was done a while ago but it turned out the study had an improper methodology and the lady they thought had been asymptomatic (some Chinese lady visiting Berlin IIRC) had in fact had light fever and weakness.
However this does not mean that asymptomatic transmission does not happen, the article said that the study had been supposed to be true for confirming what a lot of people had suspected.
I can't remember the article, I didn't bookmark, also I'm not sure what computer it was on.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by culturestate on Sunday March 08, 2020 @07:50AM
(#22517578)
For what it's worth, the WHO assesses the situation thusly:
"The main way the disease spreads is through respiratory droplets expelled by someone who is coughing. The risk of catching COVID-19 from someone with no symptoms at all is very low. However, many people with COVID-19 experience only mild symptoms. This is particularly true at the early stages of the disease. It is therefore possible to catch COVID-19 from someone who has, for example, just a mild cough and does not feel ill."
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by fierarul on Sunday March 08, 2020 @10:02AM
(#22518059)
> the study showing that it could be transmitted by asymptomatic people wasn't correct (although I guess that doesn't mean it can't be transmitted by asymptomatics, only that we are back to uncertain)
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by yodsanklai on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:43AM
(#22517217)
> If locking down a whole city - "cordon sanitaire", doesn't work
It's not as simple as "work or doesn't work". It slows down the spread, for a certain cost. Whether it's worth it or not is a matter of appreciation. Just like the speed limits. Decreasing speed limit saves lives, so it works, but do we want to do it?
> Do they not have the same public health experts
Ultimately, the final decision is taken by politicians, who answer to the public.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by tanilama on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:57AM
(#22517067)
Because it works.
I think some experts are too fond of their theory, the beauty and sophistication of it, and forgets about the problem that it tries to solve.
Lock-down does work, but only if you can execute it effectively. Apparently that is conditioned on individual countries. Some countries can't make it work, doesn't necessarily means others cannot.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by masklinn on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:45AM
(#22517222)
The main goal at this point is to flatten the curve, you might have the same number of patients but there's a difference between having them all at once and having them spread out over time, especially with respect to the healthcare system's (over)load.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by mytailorisrich on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:48AM
(#22517231)
I feel that lately there is a lot of politics involved in these issues.
China has taken drastic measures of quarantine and they seemed to have worked reasonably well: the bulk of the cases have remained in Wuhan and Hubei.
That seems to created a political issue in the West with, I feel, a lot of reluctance to be seen praising China or copying China because the Chinese government is the boogeyman.
Certainly in Europe it seems to me that governments are neither prepared not willing to take decisive measures, or (like Italy now) they start taking them late.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by endogui on Sunday March 08, 2020 @07:12AM
(#22517478)
If the West is going to eschew the Chinese route, then they need to embrace the Korean route: agressive testing and contact tracing, mandatory quarantines for suspected contacts, bans on public gatherings, massive PSA campaigns about hand washing and wearing face masks, providing a hotline people with symptoms can call so they don't walk into an ER and accidentally shut down their neighborhood hospital for two weeks.
So far the West is striking out on most of these measures, either for lack of political will or for technical incompetence.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by mytailorisrich on Sunday March 08, 2020 @07:31AM
(#22517523)
This "Korean route" is what China has been doing (see WHO fact-finding mission). If calling it "Korean" rather than "Chinese" helps make it happen in the West so be it. But I fear that there is indeed no readiness or much will at the moment.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by neffy on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:31AM
(#22517705)
Your part of the West may not be doing that, but my part started doing all of that as soon as the first cases showed up. (Via the skiing holiday route from Italy.)
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by chewz on Sunday March 08, 2020 @11:49AM
(#22518610)
"cordon sanitaire" works - it worked well in China. But European politicians are way behind curve with this epidemics.
Europe had been trying to keep the borders open while France and Germany forbade exporting masks, respirators and other equipment to Italy.
They have closed borders way too late. Italy won't be able to build a hospital in a week, won't manufacture quarter million tests per day, won't make special squads that will trace every single person suspected of transmitting the disease. Won't enforce total lockdown.
In my opinion Europe is in it for a long time with way too many victims.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by altcognito on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:05PM
(#22519121)
And it does require a certain amount of discipline. So far Italy hasn't done great, we had trains of people trying to escape the quarantine, which is pretty much the opposite of what you want.
From the doc above, CDC estimates 5% Nationwide will require ICU care. That's 18.5 million people. We have 100k beds. The US medical establishment does not have the surge capacity for an epidemic of this scale. All of our manufacturing is in China too - and medicine and semiconductors and just about everything else.
Only a monumental Civic movement will make containment possible and, as the article suggests, the pandemic will expose the rot that has gutted this country over the last few decades, as the system shuts down in an attempt to contain the pandemic, when the hospitals are quickly overwhelmed.
This is undoubtedly a historic event. Based on the other countries this has happened in, we are 1-6 weeks, most likely 1-3, away from full outbreak and the start of widespread business closures and possible food scarcity in some regions. Stores and truckers may be hard to keep open if no one wants to risk getting sick.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by all_blue_chucks on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:51AM
(#22516872)
If we don't slow this we will overwhelm ICUs, but your math is all wrong. You assume every single American is exposed, every American contracts the disease, and every American develops symptoms at exactly the same time. That is flatly wrong.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by cousin_it on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:00AM
(#22517268)
Here's the right math afaik. Over 15% of infected people need a hospital bed with oxygen to survive (that's the important number, not just those who need ventilator). Doubling time is a week or less. Hospital stay is two weeks or more. Infections should slow down once half the population is infected. We can mostly ignore the time from infection to hospital, because it's a constant plus a spread that's shorter than hospital stay. So at peak load, 50% of the population have been infected and passed the initial period, 75% of those have passed the initial period within the last two weeks, and 15% of those need a hospital bed to survive. That's 5% of the population or more. Hospital beds are way fewer than that, so most of these people die.
The only hope is to slow it with non-medical measures. Check the progression dashboard for your country: https://coronavirus.arik.io/ You can see which countries are serious (most of Asia - graph looks linear) and which aren't (US and most of Europe - graph looks like a hockey stick).
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by bsaul on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:57AM
(#22517436)
Where did you get that 15% number from ? From my understanding, a huge number of people infected by the virus are asymptomatic and go completely undetected. Given that, any estimation is clearly really hard to make, right ?
> Most people infected with COVID-19 virus have mild disease and recover. Approximately 80% of laboratory confirmed patients have had mild to moderate disease, which includes non-pneumonia and pneumonia cases, 13.8% have severe disease (dyspnea, respiratory frequency ≥30/minute, blood oxygen saturation ≤93%, PaO2/FiO2 ratio <300, and/or lung infiltrates >50% of the lung field within 24-48 hours) and 6.1% are critical (respiratory failure, septic shock, and/or multiple organ dysfunction/failure). Asymptomatic infection has been reported, but the majority of the relatively rare cases who are asymptomatic on the date of identification/report went on to develop disease. The proportion of truly asymptomatic infections is unclear but appears to be relatively rare and does not appear to be a major driver of transmission.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by matwood on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:54AM
(#22517770)
The article says 'laboratory confirmed patients'. Because the large majority of cases are mild (this is also why the disease spreads so effectively), it makes sense to assume there are people who went through the disease and were never tested.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by schoen on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:40AM
(#22516831)
I think you've misinterpreted two items there (although they're ambiguously phrased and it would be helpful to have a source with clearer phrasing).
First, I think the 5% refers to 5% of persons infected with the virus, not to 5% of the entire population of the U.S., although this is the least clear part.
Second, the "critical care" part refers to "being admitted as an inpatient" (not being admitted to an ICU), as distinct from an outpatient office or ER visit.
I don't think the authors meant to suggest that the CDC believes that 5% of the U.S. population will require ICU care during this epidemic.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by allovernow on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:48AM
(#22516860)
No. This is written ambiguously. It starts with
>As the virus continues to spread nationally
And then the numbers are listed as
>80% of the population may experience mild symptoms, such as fever or flu-like symptoms that they treat at home
If it were as you say, they would write x% of the infected population, or something to that effect. Then again, given all the incompetence I've witnessed lately across the news, it wouldn't surprise me if they ambiguously wrote it by mistake.
In any case, you'll note that China just shut down it's entire industry for two months over this. That's not something an authoritarian state does lightly. Especially considering it may, say, make it obvious that sending all of your production offshore to China is a national security threat.
Edit: Italian Prime Minister just made a 2AM press announcement of the Isolation of Lombardy. That's 16 million people. We're approaching the right ballpark here. 8% of the Iranian parliment have confirmed cases. Two are already dead. This is everything we've been warning you about.
This source from business insider reports that the US gov is preparing for 96 million infections. 5% is almost 5 million hospitalizations.
At this point you people just don't want to believe. This is not yet another flu scare. This is the real fucking deal. A historic pandemic. Prepare while you can. Just look at what's going on in what, 10 countries now? Millions of people placed on lockdown in Western nation's now? Italy just locked down 16 million people on Lombardy. French PM says he doesn't think the virus can be contained.
It is only prudent at this point to stock up on nonperishables. This isn't just to protect yourself - if you get the virus it will be responsible to sequester yourself in your home to protect the population. The irresponsibility of those who refuse to take this seriously and prepare is putting all of us at risk now. The U.S. is NOT EQUIPPED to handle this kind of outbreak. The system WILL BE OVERWHELMED in the next 1-6 weeks. And if China, SK, et al. are any indication, it will drag on for months.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by yzmtf2008 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:55PM
(#22520157)
Nobody said you shouldn’t be prepared. The system will be overwhelmed (and probably already is from the flu this year).
We’re just saying not 100% of people are going to be infected. Even your business insider article is not saying that. Stop moving the goalpost. Sometimes we're wrong or we misread something, and that's okay.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by yzmtf2008 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:37AM
(#22516825)
So one thing to note is that the “population” referred in the doc you linked is talking about people that are infected, not the general population. Of course, that doesn’t make the outlook that much better: if history is any guidance, H1N1 likely infected 15% of the world’s population[0], and interpolating that makes the required number of beds ~3 million. That’s still a lot of beds, but a lot more manageable. With techniques to delay the arrival as much as possible (e.g. at least wait out the flu season), and to avoid spikes, we’ll make it through this.
It’s still undoubtedly a monumental event in history, but we will make it through.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by franciskim on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:46AM
(#22516853)
The stated source: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6909e1.htm does not seem to have anything about 5% nationwide requiring ICU care although I've not checked the links within that. But it does seem a bit off.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by taneq on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:03AM
(#22516903)
You’re right. If the 100k figure for beds is right, and each case needs to be hospitalised for a week, then we’ll be fine as long as we can drag the epidemic out over no less than 3-4 years.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by jaclaz on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:01AM
(#22517269)
The issue is not-so-slightly different.
The total number of places available in a given country in ICU's is (assuming a perfect world) the exact needed amount for "ordinary" cases + some slack, let's say 10%.
So you cannot count the total number of available beds as if they were free, as 90% (or change the percentage according to the specific country) are always, constantly, in use for patients affected by other - totally unrelated to Covid-19 - issues.
Part of these "ordinary" cases can be reduced (as an example by delaying a number of not-really-urgent surgery interventions) but this is also not without consequences.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by taneq on Monday March 09, 2020 @12:27AM
(#22522994)
Good call, I was treating total beds as free beds when in fact the number of free beds is somewhere between zero and 10% of that. It won't take much at all to overwhelm the available ICU resources.
Re:How Pandemics Change History
by masonic on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:28AM
(#22516977)
5% Nationwide will require ICU care. That's 18.5 million people.
No, that is not what the CDC says, and it is not even remotely what your link says.
It says "5% of those who contract Covid-19" would require ICU, which is .5% of those exposed to Covid-19, which is itself a small subset of the population.
How much this is enforceable remains to be seen. What's worse, there was already histeria caused by a leak of the document before it was completed (and people blaing the "lack of responsibility" for the leak, when such things have been going for more than a decade...), with people rushing to stations trying to get away.
There is no clear communication (the same government ministers saying different things over the course of a day), there's the "emergency department" (Protezione Civile) that is not able to keep up, there's blaming the victim ("Act responsibly", "You must change your way of life", said from people who have never understood how normal people live and work).
This has been a mess from a policy and communication perspective. Not surprising from a government that was elected "to give politicians a lesson", "to crack open the Parliament like canned tuna", and in the supreme name of "honesty" was built out of complete incompetents.
I'm truly hoping that we'll get out of this... despite them.
Don't they have a freaking advisor that understands the exponential function? It doesn't seem that hard to look at the graphs and see that we are heading the same way as Italy.
I think I'd prefer the way of acting of the Italian government who at least seem to be trying to do things. Although who knows. The grass is always greener at the other side of the fence.
Good luck with the situation there for you and your loved ones.
I understand that Singapore is a very small country and ran way differently than my own, but please look up what the PM there said when he addressed the country on COVID-19 matters and compare it (if you can find a subtitled version) with what our "Giuseppi" said. A world of difference.
Of course now they must do something. But way before the outbreak, local administrations of the now-locked regions who asked for quarantine controls from people from Wuhan and China in general were called "Sinophobes" and the government was far more eager to lock down direct flights from China (useless if you go via hub) as opposed to quarantining or at least tracing those people, and of course to show all support for Chinese people. (Note that I do not condone Sinophobia at all: but a matter of public health policy - like everything, improvable - was just framed as racism).
Ok, this might have not helped at all given that the current theory is that SARS-CoV-2 came to Italy from Germany. But the government was too eager to return to the "important affairs" (meaning, discussing whether a member of the coalition would leave the majority or not). Then when the first cases arrived, there was a total "tug of war" with the legislation ("close down", "ok, maybe not", "maybe yes", "SHUT DOWN EVERYTHING").
So nothing Singapore or South Korea-like. COVID-19 worries me, but I'm far, far more worried about this government.
Are you still going to work?
Are supermarkets open? Are restaurants and cafes?
Is public transport running?
I'd be just fine for some days. But by the end of a 2-week quarantine, I'd be eating much more poorly than I would the first week. And I'd be lucky: I have a well-stocked kitchen. I eat a lot of beans and lentils and rice and have all three around. There is pasta here. I make bread most days: I'd certainly have to ration the dried yeast, though.
I'll run out of milk and vegetables (I don't use a lot of frozen ones). If the timing was wrong, I'd run out of flour.
Other folks would fare worse, though. So much worse, just because of what they have in the house. I'd definitely run out of canned tomatoes, even if I used only half. My food wouldn't taste.. wonderful, per se, but I'd survive.
But I'd be lucky: I have this stuff around. Not everyone does and lots of folks would be learning to cook with weird stuff. Some folks simply wouldn't have food.
I'd really like to believe this - and I hope it is the case.
But geez, we let folks die of starvation on the best of days. We let folks eat literal trash. We let folks have cases of malnutrition, too, without fixing things. The only thing I think that saves folks in the states is that during a lockdown, it is the government's responsibility to do stuff - but I'm not really convinced so many governments have stuff in place.
I particularly like this family, as they show what they cook everyday.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsa3H2gvWgP5mm4OUcu7rLA
Early on, when they could still go out, the husband would visit various supermarkets that were open and before you entered, the greeter would take your temperature.
Then when the lockdown intensified and the people were restricted to their apartment complexes, designated sellers would visit the apartment complexes every day at a specific time so you could buy things.
I was surprised to see so many fresh vegetables.
"It's not quite a complete lockdown - planes and trains are still running and access will be permitted for emergency or essential work reasons."
"Restaurants and cafes in the quarantined zones can open between 06:00 and 18:00 but customers must sit at least 1m (3ft) apart"
Some of these measures are quite onerous and I can expect that many smaller establishments will prefer to close than try to enforce them: how can a bakery, for example, make sure that "not many people enter at once" ("restricted access", says the document, or at least my poor translation from "bureaucrat-speak") and that "distance is at least one meter" between people?
Personally, I can work remotely if need be (haven't done that in about ~10 years, but technically, I can). I've yet to see what my workplace will do, though.
PS: for the HN crowd, you can look up data by region in Italy here: https://opendatadpc.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index....
Bear in mind that the numbers on the map are incorrect (as opposed to tables): they're the cumulative sum of current cases + deaths + recoveries.
You make them queue in front of the bakery keeping a distance of a meter between each other?
The official document enforcing the "red zone " for this morning is here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Y3Vl8VmAww2sGfFBSH9Vfa4fwQ8...
It's in Italian, you may try a machine translation if needed
It is still far from the lockdown in Wuhan where people are not allowed to leave their appartments and get food delivered by the authorities.
I am in Copenhagen where the latest is that the government has adviced against gatherings of more than 1.000 people causing some football matches to be on TV only and some concerts to lower their number of attendees to 950.
I'm surprised people are surprised that such a thing leaked. This has been going on for years, except, no one batted an eye.
> We are Italians and we are unable to respect the rules.
As an Italian too, I don't like this generalization. You can make people more willing to follow rules if you approach them correctly. Going full-paternalistic mode (like this government has been doing) or even blaming them ("don't play dumb", is that something one would expect from a PM?) isn't going to help.
And why that happened? Because whoever is in charge of making sure that the population is reassured (and that's different from pretending that nothing is happening) did not do that.
(Personally, I believe that it's those who not do what should be done are the actual outliers, although the media does an excellent job at cherry picking bad apples).
Then again, the world is not really structured to letting someone with light fever lay in bed for two weeks so maybe it's the same thing.
However this does not mean that asymptomatic transmission does not happen, the article said that the study had been supposed to be true for confirming what a lot of people had suspected.
I can't remember the article, I didn't bookmark, also I'm not sure what computer it was on.
"The main way the disease spreads is through respiratory droplets expelled by someone who is coughing. The risk of catching COVID-19 from someone with no symptoms at all is very low. However, many people with COVID-19 experience only mild symptoms. This is particularly true at the early stages of the disease. It is therefore possible to catch COVID-19 from someone who has, for example, just a mild cough and does not feel ill."
https://www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/q-a-coronaviruses
[citation needed]
It's not as simple as "work or doesn't work". It slows down the spread, for a certain cost. Whether it's worth it or not is a matter of appreciation. Just like the speed limits. Decreasing speed limit saves lives, so it works, but do we want to do it?
> Do they not have the same public health experts
Ultimately, the final decision is taken by politicians, who answer to the public.
I think some experts are too fond of their theory, the beauty and sophistication of it, and forgets about the problem that it tries to solve.
Lock-down does work, but only if you can execute it effectively. Apparently that is conditioned on individual countries. Some countries can't make it work, doesn't necessarily means others cannot.
China has taken drastic measures of quarantine and they seemed to have worked reasonably well: the bulk of the cases have remained in Wuhan and Hubei.
That seems to created a political issue in the West with, I feel, a lot of reluctance to be seen praising China or copying China because the Chinese government is the boogeyman.
Certainly in Europe it seems to me that governments are neither prepared not willing to take decisive measures, or (like Italy now) they start taking them late.
So far the West is striking out on most of these measures, either for lack of political will or for technical incompetence.
Europe had been trying to keep the borders open while France and Germany forbade exporting masks, respirators and other equipment to Italy.
They have closed borders way too late. Italy won't be able to build a hospital in a week, won't manufacture quarter million tests per day, won't make special squads that will trace every single person suspected of transmitting the disease. Won't enforce total lockdown.
In my opinion Europe is in it for a long time with way too many victims.
It is just very expensive.
From the doc above, CDC estimates 5% Nationwide will require ICU care. That's 18.5 million people. We have 100k beds. The US medical establishment does not have the surge capacity for an epidemic of this scale. All of our manufacturing is in China too - and medicine and semiconductors and just about everything else.
Only a monumental Civic movement will make containment possible and, as the article suggests, the pandemic will expose the rot that has gutted this country over the last few decades, as the system shuts down in an attempt to contain the pandemic, when the hospitals are quickly overwhelmed.
This is undoubtedly a historic event. Based on the other countries this has happened in, we are 1-6 weeks, most likely 1-3, away from full outbreak and the start of widespread business closures and possible food scarcity in some regions. Stores and truckers may be hard to keep open if no one wants to risk getting sick.
The only hope is to slow it with non-medical measures. Check the progression dashboard for your country: https://coronavirus.arik.io/ You can see which countries are serious (most of Asia - graph looks linear) and which aren't (US and most of Europe - graph looks like a hockey stick).
> Most people infected with COVID-19 virus have mild disease and recover. Approximately 80% of laboratory confirmed patients have had mild to moderate disease, which includes non-pneumonia and pneumonia cases, 13.8% have severe disease (dyspnea, respiratory frequency ≥30/minute, blood oxygen saturation ≤93%, PaO2/FiO2 ratio <300, and/or lung infiltrates >50% of the lung field within 24-48 hours) and 6.1% are critical (respiratory failure, septic shock, and/or multiple organ dysfunction/failure). Asymptomatic infection has been reported, but the majority of the relatively rare cases who are asymptomatic on the date of identification/report went on to develop disease. The proportion of truly asymptomatic infections is unclear but appears to be relatively rare and does not appear to be a major driver of transmission.
and that's why they are trying to slow it down, we'll get it but in stages so those in dire need will get care and survive.
First, I think the 5% refers to 5% of persons infected with the virus, not to 5% of the entire population of the U.S., although this is the least clear part.
Second, the "critical care" part refers to "being admitted as an inpatient" (not being admitted to an ICU), as distinct from an outpatient office or ER visit.
I don't think the authors meant to suggest that the CDC believes that 5% of the U.S. population will require ICU care during this epidemic.
>As the virus continues to spread nationally
And then the numbers are listed as
>80% of the population may experience mild symptoms, such as fever or flu-like symptoms that they treat at home
If it were as you say, they would write x% of the infected population, or something to that effect. Then again, given all the incompetence I've witnessed lately across the news, it wouldn't surprise me if they ambiguously wrote it by mistake.
In any case, you'll note that China just shut down it's entire industry for two months over this. That's not something an authoritarian state does lightly. Especially considering it may, say, make it obvious that sending all of your production offshore to China is a national security threat.
Edit: Italian Prime Minister just made a 2AM press announcement of the Isolation of Lombardy. That's 16 million people. We're approaching the right ballpark here. 8% of the Iranian parliment have confirmed cases. Two are already dead. This is everything we've been warning you about.
Especially when the "80%" is followed by:
> 80% of the population may experience mild symptoms, such as fever or flu-like symptoms that they treat at home
> 15% may seek medical care, such as visiting an Urgent Care or Emergency Department
> 5% may require critical care, meaning being admitted as an inpatient
This source from business insider reports that the US gov is preparing for 96 million infections. 5% is almost 5 million hospitalizations.
At this point you people just don't want to believe. This is not yet another flu scare. This is the real fucking deal. A historic pandemic. Prepare while you can. Just look at what's going on in what, 10 countries now? Millions of people placed on lockdown in Western nation's now? Italy just locked down 16 million people on Lombardy. French PM says he doesn't think the virus can be contained.
It is only prudent at this point to stock up on nonperishables. This isn't just to protect yourself - if you get the virus it will be responsible to sequester yourself in your home to protect the population. The irresponsibility of those who refuse to take this seriously and prepare is putting all of us at risk now. The U.S. is NOT EQUIPPED to handle this kind of outbreak. The system WILL BE OVERWHELMED in the next 1-6 weeks. And if China, SK, et al. are any indication, it will drag on for months.
We’re just saying not 100% of people are going to be infected. Even your business insider article is not saying that. Stop moving the goalpost. Sometimes we're wrong or we misread something, and that's okay.
It’s still undoubtedly a monumental event in history, but we will make it through.
[0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_flu_pandemic
The total number of places available in a given country in ICU's is (assuming a perfect world) the exact needed amount for "ordinary" cases + some slack, let's say 10%.
So you cannot count the total number of available beds as if they were free, as 90% (or change the percentage according to the specific country) are always, constantly, in use for patients affected by other - totally unrelated to Covid-19 - issues.
Part of these "ordinary" cases can be reduced (as an example by delaying a number of not-really-urgent surgery interventions) but this is also not without consequences.
It says "5% of those who contract Covid-19" would require ICU, which is .5% of those exposed to Covid-19, which is itself a small subset of the population.
You're off by well over two orders of magnitude!