News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by acidburnNSA on Friday February 21, 2020 @10:23AM (#22383729)
Always happy to see people doing new and interesting stuff with fusion. I got into nuclear technology because of ITER back in the early 2000s. Worked on it continuously (mostly in advanced fission) ever since.

> "The timeline question is a tricky one," he says. "I don't want to be a laughing stock by promising we can deliver something in 10 years, and then not getting there. First step is setting up camp as a company and getting started. First milestone is demonstrating the reactions, which should be easy. Second milestone is getting enough reactions to demonstrate an energy gain by counting the amount of helium that comes out of a fuel pellet when we have those two lasers working together. That'll give us all the science we need to engineer a reactor. So the third milestone is bringing that all together and demonstrating a reactor concept that works."

The fourth step is to deliver the reactor concept as promising machine. The fifth step is to attach it to power generating equipment and demonstrate the power plant. The sixth step is to scale up a supply chain capable of delivering multiple units that compete with other sources of commodity electricity (or other energy products). The seventh step is to scale to large scale without being unduly burdened by either supply chain (raw material, skilled labor) or regulatory impact/public concern that inevitably scales with any large fleet of any new tech.

Fission made it to step 7 and then faltered and is now teetering depending on where you look. It never scaled past 5% of total world primary energy.

The promise of fusion is to deliver nuclear energy with less public concern than fission because it makes less radiologically hazardous material. The challenge is to go through the physical, engineering, and commercial viability phases as a power plant.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by dfsegoat on Friday February 21, 2020 @11:39AM (#22384436)
FWIW as an aside: I always scan comments on nuke-related HN posts to find yours first. Super informative and easy to digest. Thanks again.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by acidburnNSA on Saturday February 22, 2020 @01:33AM (#22389735)
Happy to hear it! I love the discussions that happen here so it's my pleasure.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by ccleve on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:13PM (#22384746)
A number of these steps become easier if the reactor is physically small. A plant that fits in a shipping container has a way easier path to commercial viability.

Small plants require less capital. They're easier to manufacture. They can iterate faster. They have less environmental impact, and therefore fewer regulatory hurdles. They require less labor to build and a smaller supply chain.

I expect that the engineering is harder, because scale can bring efficiencies. But still, I think the winner is going to be a small device, not a behemoth, if only because a small device can come online years earlier.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:28PM (#22384884)
I expect that you lose efficiencies with respect to security. I.e., it's not easy to secure one large nuclear reactor (fission or fusion), but it's a lot easier than securing dozens of small reactors.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by goda90 on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:57PM (#22385157)
Nuclear fission reactors need more security than other power plants because of the implications of stolen fuel/waste, or fallout from sabotage. A fusion reactor like the one this group is working on probably doesn't have as high as security concerns. In fact the only concern might be that it is critical infrastructure(like our entire power grid), and a distribution of smaller reactors would be better for reliability anyway.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by LeifCarrotson on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:45PM (#22385595)
Traditional fusion reactors do produce fast neutron radiation, which, in addition to causing problems like weakening the structure (which can be mitigated with better materials, better engineering, and by replacing subcomponents over time) is able to irradiate U238 into PU239.

Drop a chunk of U238 in/near the fusion reactor somewhere, let it absorb stray neutrons, and you'll soon have some plutonium. That's bad for control of nuclear weapons proliferation, which relies on high-energy neutron sources like breeder reactors being difficult to build and expensive.

Not sure about the radiation profile from this system though.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by goda90 on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:49PM (#22385627)
I'm not very knowledgeable about fusion, but it looks like this system is aneutronic fusion, so those concerns would be lessened too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion#Boron
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by mrfusion on Saturday February 22, 2020 @09:19AM (#22391143)
A simple security camera or hank the security guard could easily guard against someone setting up shop and producing plutonium.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by philipkglass on Saturday February 22, 2020 @12:50PM (#22392257)
The general anti-proliferation challenge is harder than that. It includes guarding against the production of weapons material with the collusion of the host country and plant operators. Consider e.g. the degree of assurance needed to provide North Korea with a new power plant that can never aid its nuclear weapons program.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by earthboundkid on Saturday February 22, 2020 @12:43PM (#22392209)
If you have the uranium, couldn’t you afford to bribe Hank?
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by PakG1 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @01:23AM (#22389714)
If the security concerns decrease, perhaps they can get to the point of how security is done for ISP and power substations. If so, many smaller nodes across a city are much more feasible.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by lallysingh on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:15PM (#22385333)
If these reactors are low heat, not radioactive, and use plentiful fuel, what's the threat model? Is it just worried about availability of power?
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by jandrese on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:21PM (#22385391)
"Not Radioactive" is the trick. Even if the fuel isn't hazardous you have lots of radiation being kicked off by the reaction that irradiates the surrounding equipment and the waste products.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by DennisP on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:38PM (#22385540)
The HB11 reaction doesn't produce neutron radiation. I've seen claims that there would be side reactions, generating neutron radiation totaling under 1% of the energy output, but the only source of that I can think of is if deuterium isn't removed from the hydrogen, and we could do that if necessary. It might not be, since neutrons from deuterium fusion are a lot less energetic than D-T neutrons.

The energy output of HB11 consists of fast-moving alpha particles, which is good because that's the energy you capture, along with x-rays. None of this would activate reactor components. The waste product is non-radioactive helium.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by Retric on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:53PM (#22385669)
It’s not that simple. 1% of even 1MW is a lot of radiation so it comes down to what the walls are made of more than the total neutron flux. ITER style lithium blankets would be recycled for tritium without producing much net waste. Light water nuclear reactors have several feet of water to absorb fast neutrons, which makes a huge difference. The walls of this are a more open question.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by DennisP on Friday February 21, 2020 @02:37PM (#22386041)
So I looked it up, and found there actually are two side reactions from the primary fuels, no deuterium required. In a thermal plasma the resulting neutrons would carry less than 0.2% of the energy output. I don't know what the percentage would be for this reactor, since the fuel isn't a thermal plasma while fusion is happening.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion#Boron

Neutron energy would be a bit under 3 MeV, comparable to fast fission neutrons but in much lower quantity for the power output.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_temperature

Interestingly, that page says the thermal neutrons in a conventional nuclear reactor are better at activating materials than fast neutrons.

According to a presentation I saw by the leader of MIT's fusion program, the inner wall of a D-T tokamak would be activated by the neutrons, but would only need to be stored for a few decades. D-T releases 80% of its energy as 14 MeV neutrons.

According to LPP, which is working on a different boron fusion design, a 20MW reactor would activate the walls with short-lived radiation, but it could be safely opened for maintenance after about twelve hours (iirc).

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by microtherion on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:53PM (#22386609)
According to the article, the energy is generated by alpha particles, which are in principle a very dangerous form of radiation. It's not clear to me, though, whether the radiation stops as soon as the fusion does or not.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by DennisP on Friday February 21, 2020 @05:48PM (#22387759)
Substances which continuously emit alpha particles are dangerous.

This is something different. With every laser shot there will be a burst of alpha particles. Then they'll slow down and just be plain old helium. If the direct energy conversion works, they'll get slowed down very quickly.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by Animats on Friday February 21, 2020 @11:42PM (#22389469)
Substances which continuously emit alpha particles are dangerous.

Only if you eat or inhale them. A sheet of paper will stop alpha particles.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by mcswell on Sunday February 23, 2020 @06:21PM (#22400285)
Up until a decade or two ago, tritium--which emits alpha radiation--was commonly on wristwatch dials, precisely because they were not dangerous. Alpha radiation is easily stopped; it's only dangerous if you breathe it (or drink it, if that's even possible).
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by microtherion on Monday February 24, 2020 @06:01PM (#22409363)
Tritium emits beta radiation. It would be an interesting trick for an atom to emit radiation with a higher weight than itself.

It might also be worth pointing out that "It must be safe! They even put it on wristwatch dials!" is not, historically, a sound argument.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by kbenson on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:51PM (#22385106)
There might also be less security needed if you have dozens of smaller reactors. You have to secure the one because losing it affects so much. If losing a couple is not as big a problem, you an rely more on the redundancy of the system than on the redundancy of the component.

This depends on the threat model to some degree, but there's security in knowing that it's vastly harder for a threat to affect multiple targets at once, no matter the threat.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by caymanjim on Friday February 21, 2020 @10:28PM (#22389216)
There's not much security around existing power plants, even nuclear ones. There's vastly more security around a casino or even a large shopping mall. I don't think it's a limiting factor, especially for non-weaponizable fusion reagents.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by jacobedawson on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:04PM (#22385230)
Isn't this just the same scenario as we currently have, just with different underlying technology? Do coal-powered plants have additional security outside of a few private guards?
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by numpad0 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @12:26AM (#22389584)
For fission reactors that is not the case, a fission core can be as small as few liters in volume without losing power, but are artificially kept to less dense forms, such that runaway supercritical events(intended or not) can only result in Fukushima and not a Nagasaki.

That might be different for this fusion device, but for outdated looking fission reactors it’s artificial dilution for NPT purposes and by no way a technological limitation.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by Someone on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:37PM (#22384974)
If that’s a problem, you can locate hundreds of small reactors together.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by mrfusion on Saturday February 22, 2020 @09:18AM (#22391135)
Fusion shouldn’t need any more security than a coal plant.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by tinco on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:22PM (#22386347)
Off-topic question: is there some software part in nuclear energy systems that is restricting plants or research? I'd like to contribute to the industry as a non-physicist, but it's hard for me to imagine what kind of software might be missing or is being sold by too expensive specialist companies.

I imagine most software is tied to the specific devices they run on, but perhaps there's coupling or analytical software that could be better geared towards the problem domain. Is there any fundamental issue that is waiting for a good software solution?

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by acidburnNSA on Friday February 21, 2020 @04:23PM (#22386920)
It just so happens that a nuclear fission reactor analysis framework recently emerged on github partially with hopes that people like you would be interested in contributing. It hasn't been widely publicized and is pretty esoteric but is there.

https://github.com/terrapower/armi

Some more open source things in the domain can be found here: https://github.com/paulromano/awesome-nuclear/blob/master/RE...

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by ttul on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:31PM (#22386419)
I'm not an expert at all, but I follow news about fusion energy with keen interest. Getting to conditions where fusion reactions can take place requires modeling the physics with supercomputers. I think the physicists have a handle on the software required to do that modeling; they also have access to the computers.

I think if you have a software background and want to contribute, you should consider applying for a job with one of the projects themselves. General Atomics lists 135 software jobs (https://www.ga-careers.com/search-jobs/software/499/1) for instance.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by LaMarseillaise on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:49PM (#22386565)
I think it must be mentioned that in addition to fission and fusion (ITER) work, General Atomics is the creator of the MQ-9 Reaper, which is commonly used for drone strikes. A software job at this company may involve work on these aircraft.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by eloff on Friday February 21, 2020 @06:27PM (#22388059)
And that's bad because drones are evil? I'm sure I don't agree with a blanket statement to that effect. They're a tool of warfare and I don't see how they're particularly worse than other ways of killing your enemies. I can think of a few ways they're better.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by lovemenot on Friday February 21, 2020 @07:33PM (#22388482)
While you may not agree, you can surely recognise that others may appreciate the heads-up. I can easily imagine some people may be pleased to work on fusion, but not on drones.

Your parent merely notified us that more than one type of product is in development at that company and one that is not fusion is specifically designed to kill people.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by sterlind on Friday February 21, 2020 @08:22PM (#22388748)
another factor is clearance. people may be unwilling or unable to obtain security clearances that General Atomics requires for all their engineers, if they're a major defense contractor.

I've dreamed about getting into fusion research myself, and concluded the best pivot would be to help with the plasma simulations at a university while obtaining a PhD.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by eloff on Friday February 21, 2020 @09:48PM (#22389054)
Yes, that's fair. I think the subtext of the OPs post is that drones are evil, but he didn't write that.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by LaMarseillaise on Friday February 21, 2020 @11:12PM (#22389374)
lovemenot is correct. I do not think drones are evil.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by pontifier on Saturday February 22, 2020 @01:08AM (#22389686)
I've been trying to find affordable software for modeling my proposed fusion reactor, but some of the software packages I've looked at cost upward of $50k, with no guarantee that they will be able to give the answers I need. It seems to be a problem of low demand for highly specialized software, and scale issues in the different regimes within the device.

In my device, sometimes, some ions will be traveling in a vacuum with a high mean free path, and at other times, the plasma will be as dense as lead. It's VERY difficult to simulate, to the point that it's almost better to just estimate and start building to see if I can start to get close to a solution through careful experimentation.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by jxy on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:30PM (#22386406)
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by wtracy on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:38PM (#22385539)
> The fifth step is to attach it to power generating equipment

The part that jumped out at me as strange is that they claim their process generates electricity "directly" without having to drive a turbine. Supposedly they produce helium cations, and that can drive a circuit.

Can anybody comment on whether that makes sense?

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by Rhinobird on Friday February 21, 2020 @02:10PM (#22385822)
The main Proton-Boron reaction produces charged particles instead of neutrons. You can capture the charged particles directly as a source of voltage with no intermediate step. Just stick a piece of metal in the way and hook up wires.

Conventionally, neutrons are used to generate heat which is then used to drive steam turbines.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by NortySpock on Friday February 21, 2020 @02:27PM (#22385979)
Wouldn't it produce high-velocity charged particles?

Thus you would capture the energy with a "reverse coilgun", "regeneratively braking" the particles down to a non-relativistic speed, rather than just using them to charge a capacitor plate.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by rklaehn on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:05PM (#22386237)
Once the capacitor plate has a voltage in the range of the kinetic energy of the particles, this is exactly what will happen. The particles convert their kinetic energy into electrical energy by rolling "uphill" against the electric potential.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by pfdietz on Friday February 21, 2020 @06:11PM (#22387945)
And all the free electrons produced in that target are helpfully just sitting there, right?
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by Zardoz84 on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:51PM (#22386584)
Interesting... I remember reading about fusion on the high school, and I thought that must be a way to collect the energy directly.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by frankus on Friday February 21, 2020 @02:07PM (#22385800)
Huge if true.

Most fission plants throw away about two-thirds of their energy output as waste heat (according to: https://www.answers.com/Q/How_much_of_the_heat_generated_in_...), and their cooling towers are so much bigger than the reactor itself that they've become a symbol of the plants as a whole.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by graycat on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:02PM (#22386212)
Sorry to get away from some really nice physics and suggestion of some really good news for some of relevant reality:

The cooling towers? The photographs in the news commonly show huge clouds of water vapor escaping from the tops of the towers with a picture caption about "nuclear" power or some such.

So, the suggestion is that nuke plants generate huge clouds of dangerous radioactive byproducts.

Such news content is easy: (1) Suggest that the cooling towers are the nuclear reactors and (2) don't mention that what is coming out is just water vapor, from water recently in some river or lake. Now the news people have their audience by their eyeballs for ad revenue and/or politics as in

https://www.peakprosperity.com/2019-year-in-review-part-1/#c...

“The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by an endless series of hobgoblins, most of them imaginary.”

~ H.L. Mencken

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by philipkglass on Friday February 21, 2020 @09:22PM (#22388960)
Nuclear plant operators show the steaming cooling towers on their own web sites:

https://www.exeloncorp.com/locations/power-plants/limerick-g...

The same imagery shows up on the covers of nuclear textbooks:

https://www.amazon.com/Nuclear-Engineering-Handbook-Mechanic...

If anything, laypeople think that radiation is scary because it's invisible, tasteless, and odorless.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by Gibbon1 on Friday February 21, 2020 @09:27PM (#22388981)
Laypeople think radiation is scary because they don't understand it and the nuclear industry lies reflexively.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by vilhelm_s on Friday February 21, 2020 @07:44PM (#22388553)
There are various proposed schemes for doing so: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_energy_conversion

In principle this could be more efficient than a heat engine, although the Wikipedia page seems to say that an "economically feasible" version would have around 60% efficiency, which is the same as a combined-cycle power plant.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by naiveprogrammer on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:42PM (#22385018)
I don't know whether this is a legit breakthrouhg. But technological progress is often a sigmoid (S-shaped) growth curve, it may take a while to get past certain steps but once you are through, money flows and more people devote time to that technology which accelerates the process. It is not hard to imagine, say, 20 years from now, we have power plants running on fusion given the interest we have in solving the climate crisis.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by anonuser123456 on Friday February 21, 2020 @10:42AM (#22383883)
>I got into nuclear technology because of ITER back in the early 2000s. Worked on it continuously (mostly in advanced fission) ever since.

What is your opinion on SPARC and tokamak energy?

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by acidburnNSA on Friday February 21, 2020 @10:53AM (#22384002)
High temperature superconductors are absolutely an interesting pathway to make magnetic confinement fusion significantly easier than the big tokamaks like ITER. I have friends working at Commonwealth Fusion who are good people and I wish them much success. That said there are still a lot of phases to go through, from physical viability at stage 1 to scaled commercial fleet at stage 7, and that pathway is impossible to predict without getting on the ground and going through the stages. I certainly think it's worth running through the stages.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by njarboe on Friday February 21, 2020 @11:55AM (#22384587)
I really hope that fusion power can become a major power source in the future and humanity really needs it to expand off planet, but like you said above, nuclear fission power got to stage 7 and then stalled. I think the nuclear fusion community should drop the word nuclear completely from their vocabulary or they are likely to end up with the same fate, if they ever get to stage 7.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by smolder on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:49PM (#22385635)
If we can figure out fusion as a power source, maybe we can also figure out how to improve the quality of people's information exposure too, leading to a smarter population. Currently we try to hide the best information behind paywalls or in private knowledgebases, we neglect schools or profiteer through them (US in particular), and we inundate people with stupefying advertisements and misinformation.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by njarboe on Friday February 21, 2020 @04:13PM (#22386805)
Although both things are very difficult, the knowledge needed to create a commercial fusion reactor is very different to educating a whole populous not to be so afraid of radiation (which is natural and found everywhere all the time).
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by freeopinion on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:38PM (#22386470)
How about "Smart Plant"©™?
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by petre on Friday February 21, 2020 @11:37PM (#22389456)
Fusion will do just fine.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by ncmncm on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:26PM (#22384870)
There is no actual expectation of ever getting useful power generation from magnetic confinement fusion (ITER, Tokamak): it has always been, instead, a jobs program for high-neutron flux physicists, to maintain a population to draw on for weapons work.

p-boron fusion is interesting as a possibly practical energy source. The hurdles are a matter of engineering and finance, not fundamental design flaws. But it's useless as a jobs program for weapon experts, so must rely on commercial investment.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by philipkglass on Friday February 21, 2020 @02:29PM (#22385988)
I think that you have that backwards. It's the laser driven inertial confinement fusion approach that is useful for weapons insights. The very low density and slow kinetics of fusion in a tokamak are much less like weapon fusion reactions.

Lawrence Livermore -- a nuclear weapons lab -- has studied inertial confinement fusion for decades. They don't have a tokamak.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by ncmncm on Saturday February 22, 2020 @02:16PM (#22392733)
It's all about the neutrons.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by anonuser123456 on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:12PM (#22385304)
SPARC is not ITER.

It's seems bizarre to ignore the impact HTS tape would have on the plausible operation of MCF.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by pfdietz on Friday February 21, 2020 @06:12PM (#22387958)
ARC's power density is only 40 times worse than a PWR, rather than 400 times worse like ITER.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by 1024core on Friday February 21, 2020 @04:52PM (#22387230)
Apparently Step 5 is not needed?

> The alpha particles generated by the reaction would create an electrical flow that can be channeled almost directly into an existing power grid with no need for a heat exchanger or steam turbine generator."

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by sandworm101 on Friday February 21, 2020 @05:20PM (#22387511)
It isn't that simple. This thing will be DC, and at some random voltage. They will need huge bits of kit to convert the output into some sort of usable power. It is electricity yes, but not clean useful power.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by ChuckMcM on Friday February 21, 2020 @02:43PM (#22386089)
Spot on analysis. There is one loophole which is Total Cost of Ownership (TCO).

If you energy production solution can achieve a lower TCO in an existing market segment, steps six and seven (production and supply chain) take care of themselves. The poster child for this was 'on premise PV generation.'

Once a nuclear technology demonstrates a lower TCO for baseline power generation, its game on.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by sf_rob on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:00PM (#22385181)
Tangent, but assuming fusion energy generation will be a reality in the next 30 years, what do you believe the price/KWH will be? I am not knowledgeable enough to parse the estimates I've seen and want to believe in the post-energy-scarcity future.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by joshvm on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:21PM (#22385388)
Price per kwh is not solely about generation efficiency, it's also about distribution and infrastructure. There will always be a cost associated with that which will rise with inflation. Even if we went totally renewable and all your electricity was "free" then you'd still have to account for on demand storage and infrastructure costs.

The main benefit of nuclear is its relatively low carbon footprint and in theory less risk of spiking fuel costs because we run out of raw materials. That's the dream of fusion anyway.

Nuclear power infra is not cheap and even fusion will have security and decommissioning costs.

Forget cost as the main factor, grid power will never be free. That's a fantasy - even publicly owned utilities will/are funded by taxation. You're paying for price and power stability. Domestic fusion means you don't need to rely on foreign resources (eg Russia cutting off the gas).

Putting renewable generators in your home has a high capital cost, but people forget that you're also cushioning yourself against grid outages. It's insurance more than anything else.

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by freeopinion on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:49PM (#22386568)
What's the fun of tech forecasting if you don't over-promise?

A fusion reactor the size of a shipping container? Plop one down between my neighbor's house and my house. Right where our backup generators now sit. It's about the same footprint.

No more distribution costs. Well, except for Amazon's fees to drop off the uranium now and then. :)

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by DennisP on Friday February 21, 2020 @04:11PM (#22386778)
Uranium is for fission, not fusion. Fuel for this fusion reactor would be some compound of hydrogen and the most common boron isotope. There's plenty of that in a regular box of Borax.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by DennisP on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:43PM (#22385578)
D-T fusion would have security and decommissioning costs, but neither would be an issue for aneutronic fusion.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by malux85 on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:07PM (#22385254)
I doubt we are even anywhere near close to being able to calculate that because there’s still too many unknowns with regards to materials required to build, their rate of depreciation, and other things we discover in the scaling/commercialisation phases, and also exactly how much net energy will be produced!
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by Accujack on Friday February 21, 2020 @12:29PM (#22384896)
Love the user name. I always thought that movie was amusing, and so is the NSA :)
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by acidburnNSA on Friday February 21, 2020 @02:15PM (#22385857)
Ha thanks. I kind of made it before I knew Hacker News was more or less a serious place. And snowden was in the news at the time.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by throwaway010718 on Friday February 21, 2020 @09:27PM (#22388979)
> because it makes less radiologically hazardous material

Why is there any radioactive material produced by a fusion reactor ?

Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by analog31 on Friday February 21, 2020 @10:07PM (#22389137)
You don't get to precisely choose which isotopes are produced by the reaction. Even among the light elements, there are radioactive isotopes, such as tritium. And it doesn't take much of it, to render the entire mixture hazardous unless refined in some fashion. One hope is that the refinement process can return the radioactive stuff to the cooking pot, so that the ultimate waste products are safe.
Re:Radical hydrogen-boron reactor leapfrogs current nuclear ... by deadundead on Saturday February 22, 2020 @02:10PM (#22392694)
Considering the DT reaction D + T = a + n.

Neutrons produced in this reaction, being chargeless, cannot be contained within the electromagnetic field, thus leaving plasma and reacting with the surrounding material (e.g. tokamak chamber walls) and producing radioactive elements. This leads to activation and radioactive degradation of the reactor itself.