News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by inamberclad on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:51AM (#22297045)
BWBs are tempting, but let me state the usual cons mentioned for them.

- More passengers sit farther from the longitudinal axis, and consequently experience larger vertical accelerations from turbulence, as well as normal banking maneuvers.

- More passengers are farther from the windows.

- No great place to put a high bypass turbofan.

I'm hopeful that one eventually gets built though, it'll be interesting how these pan out.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by vl on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:08PM (#22300822)
> More passengers are farther from the windows

I’m not sure it’s a big problem: I took a flight in business class of A380, and it was a bit of surreal experience: you are so far from the window, and there are so many partitions, that basically there could have been no window at all and experience would be the same. It was a bit spooky, but turned out fine in practice. On regular flights people actively close shades to use entertainment system, so everyone used not to having windows now.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by adrianmonk on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:20PM (#22302978)
All other things being equal, I'd prefer a real window. But another thing I'd prefer is being able to look forward instead of to the side.

If they replaced a real window with some kind of system that showed different angles (forward, maybe also downward), that might be a net improvement to me.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by dr_dshiv on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:57PM (#22303352)
Still waiting for the Zeppelin they promised me in the future, with the gigantic picture windows and glass bottomed dance floor.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by PopeDotNinja on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:52PM (#22301364)
Even more basic than that, everyone who doesn't have a window seat is not super close to a window. Most 787 overnight flights I've taken darken the windows to the point that no one can see out anyway.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by hammock on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:24PM (#22302414)
Can we put in skylights?
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by dzhiurgis on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @11:02PM (#22305631)
Any sort of window is a compromise for structure and weight. I think in future we'll see even usual design aircraft to ditch windows.

I certainly would welcome better cameras and better flight info (something that I can connect tho via my own device). Or larger, wider angle windows around bathrooms, bars or other places people go to fight deep vein thrombosis.

That said I've always wondered why business/first in double deckers don't have windscreen. That would be an amazing experience.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by hammock on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:31AM (#22309573)
>Any sort of window is a compromise for structure and weight

That's fine and we are saying the windows on the sides are now useless so you could simply move them to the ceiling. No compromise. I'm not a huge fan of adding computer screens everywhere and many people probably agree with me. I have been on planes with exterior camera feeds that get piped into the IFE and it's not that great except at takeoff/landing. It's also not the same as natural light.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by smoyer on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:46PM (#22302654)
I like watching the ground ... can we have a glass-bottom plane?
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by hammock on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:12PM (#22304414)
If it's sanity we're trying to preserve, natural light may be more important than a view.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by FreeFull on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:00PM (#22302788)
All the luggage is stored below the passenger cabin, though.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by tandr on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:20PM (#22303582)
make it virtual - like F35 see-through visor does it. Put a monitor + camera outside + "live" stream
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by JoblessWonder on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:39PM (#22302576)
There is a business jet line (Falcon 5X/6X) with a single Sky Light. It is basically just a window on the top of the airplane... but definitely cool and unique.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by dotancohen on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:51AM (#22297267)
Perhaps the baggage would be placed at the extreme ends, which should reduce the leverage that people moving about would have on the roll axis.

That does exacerbate the window issue, but honestly the last times that I've flown myself and my children seemed to be the only people looking out the windows anyway. Everybody else has a small screen shining in their face for almost the entire flight.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by fyfy18 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:35AM (#22297943)
For most intercontinental flights I've been on, at least half the flight the windows are closed to block the sun so people can sleep or watch the screens. They could design a viewing area at the edge and fill the interior (where passengers sit) with natural light from light tubes. Combine that with a few more cameras so you can view the exterior from different angles, and I don't think anyone would complain.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by Mirioron on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:16AM (#22299079)
>Combine that with a few more cameras so you can view the exterior from different angles, and I don't think anyone would complain.

While this is fantasy: imagine if you could put on an AR headset and be able to "look through the plane" in any direction. Like that F-35 AR helmet. Maybe allow people to use their screens to also look out around the plane using the same system.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by salawat on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:38PM (#22301206)
I think there may have been an international gentleman's agreement about not putting external cameras on civil transport aircraft.

It may have been more of a Cold War thing, but I seem to remember running into that in a book at some point that there was a tacit agreement to not do that in the interest of not turning civil transport aircraft into mass produced intelligence gathering platforms, therefore in theory rendering them completely neutral in reference to needing to be taken into account in international sales/intelligence gathering.

I may be completely wrong or misinformed on that though; or the info may have been valid, but hasn't aged well taking into account how capabilities have evolved.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by mark-r on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:02PM (#22301473)
I remember flying over Cuba a number of years ago and having the captain tell all the passengers to stow their cameras. Evidently it was part of the agreement that allowed the flight path to cross into their airspace.

On the other hand I had no problems getting some good but very distant pictures of Havana a year and a half ago when our cruise ship sailed past.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by csteubs on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:37PM (#22304168)
I'm the founder of a startup that's working on precisely this issue; high revisit rate and high predictability of commercial flights + internal window-mounted camera arrays = vastly more data at a fraction of the cost of earth-sensing incumbents (Planet). We're @notasatellite on all the platforms if you're interested.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by ekingr on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:25PM (#22301717)
It's not that fantasy anymore: Emirates' new first-class suites in the 777 [1] have fake windows that display a live feed from the outside.

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/1/16723152/emirates-first-c...

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by perl4ever on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:30PM (#22305195)
If I was super wealthy, I'd prefer to fly like that over having my own plane. No matter how much money you have, the pilots are probably better, and it would feel like you were economizing.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by rconti on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:47PM (#22301295)
Can't reply to salawat, but the Airbus a380 as well as the a340 and others have external cameras you can view in your in-flight entertainment.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by archi42 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:05PM (#22302839)
At least our Thai Airways A380 only had a singular, front-facing camera at the top of the vertical stabilizer. No other view was possible. But this may depend on the plane's configuration.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by rconti on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:23PM (#22303604)
On Lufthansa and Emirates A380s, there are 4, but I can't remember exactly the views. One is forward from the vertical stabilizer, one is straight down from the belly of the plane... I want to say another is front landing gear or cockpit?
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by reportgunner on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @11:25AM (#22299674)
I figure that would be fun for about 2 minutes.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by snowwrestler on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:21PM (#22301665)
Definitely would be cool around takeoff and landing IMO. At cruise things tend to look about the same for while though.

That said the last time I flew east to west across the U.S., I was glued to the window as we crossed Utah. Killer views of canyonlands and mountain ranges. I found it was at least as impressive to view them from 35k feet as it was on the ground.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by reportgunner on Thursday February 13, 2020 @07:05AM (#22317079)
Imagine hitting your head into the person next to you because you can barely move without touching others while travelling via plane.

Also I see no added value of doing this on a plane as opposed to doing the same thing at home with the flight path pre-recorded or even being able to pick from multiple pre-recorded ones.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by dzhiurgis on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @11:09PM (#22305672)
Superzoom camera on a gimbal would make things quite interesting.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by perl4ever on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:28PM (#22305184)
As an adult, my neck doesn't bend in a way that would allow me to look out the window no matter where I sit. I wouldn't have any interest in a simulated view, but a large screen with a camera feed would be great. I am increasingly anxious about flying, but I haven't lost my interest in seeing outside. Seeing nothing but the interior makes it worse.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by ahartmetz on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @11:42AM (#22299842)
More than that, at least for me. Maybe half an hour of an eight hour flight? It was on a Finnair A350.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:40PM (#22302585)
That part where we're crossing Greenland, and you can see glaciers coming down and icebergs in the ocean? Yeah, that was a lot longer than two minutes...
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by SwiftyBug on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:23AM (#22299137)
That would be insanely scary. Or maybe the ability to see what's going on outside makes me less afraid of flying.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by inamberclad on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:04PM (#22301492)
I noticed this the last time I flew to the East Coast - nearly all the windows were closed. I was somewhat disgusted with the people - why would nearly everyone prefer their windows closed?
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jerrysievert on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:25PM (#22301713)
> I was somewhat disgusted with the people - why would nearly everyone prefer their windows closed?

as a person who usually gets a window seat, and often closes it, hopefully my response will help you be less disgusted with people: the window seat gives me a wall to lean up against, which stops me from trying to take the arm rest from the center seat, and gives me something to fall asleep against without bothering others. sometimes it's nice to be able to relax without having to get up for others or inconvenience other people.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by yibg on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:21PM (#22302998)
I’m often annoyed with people that leaves them open when the sun is right there. Blinds me and makes it nearly impossible to watch anything on the screen.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by paulie_a on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:41PM (#22301914)
Because I hate the glare and there is nothing to see anyways.

Airlines could do away with Windows for all I care and would probably prefer it.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EdwardDiego on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:53PM (#22303847)
From my experience flying long-distance - aside landing and take-off, the thunderstorms around the tropics if you're there at night, or when you fly over a new country, there's generally not much to look out at and see unless you're into clouds and the ocean - and even then, unless you have a window seat, you're not seeing much anyway. When I did want to have a gander, it was a good reason to stretch the legs and walk down to the tail of the plane to look out through the door window there.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jlmorton on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:07PM (#22300819)
I think the window issue is already well-solved. Emirates has proven that virtual windows work great.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by rob74 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:06AM (#22297100)
One more: the classical tube fuselage is much cheaper/easier/more efficient to build, because it consists largely of identical segments. Plus it's much easier to build shortened/lengthened versions of an existing airplane.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by 01CGAT on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:55AM (#22297532)
It's easier because the current tools of building the planes are not made for this new type of planes. Update the tools and building this new type of plane will be easy too.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by rob74 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:34AM (#22297938)
Let me quote from the Wikipedia article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Constellation:

> One of the reasons for the elegant appearance of the aircraft was the fuselage shape, a continuously variable profile with no two bulkheads the same shape. This construction was expensive and was replaced by mostly tube-shaped modern airliners. The tube is more resistant to pressurization changes and cheaper to build.

With blended wing bodies, you would again need a continuously variable profile for the whole fuselage (rather than only the wing, as in modern "tube-and-wing" planes). To build a larger or smaller variant, you would have to redesign the whole fuselage, rather than just adding/removing a few tube segments. So, even with updated tools, there will still be a lot of challenges...

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by londons_explore on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:40AM (#22298807)
In todays world of most high value things being CNC machined rather than made from hand crafted moulds and templates, every part being different is less of a concern. Just download the set of designs to the machine, do a test run of the smallest and largest part, and then hit 'start' and come back in the morning.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jbay808 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:49AM (#22299370)
This is so, so not the case! If anything it's the opposite.

First of all, nobody is CNC machining airplanes from billet. They're sheet metal structures. But that aside...

For handmade structures with little tooling, the difference is less because it takes only a bit more training and about the same amount of time to make a bunch of unique parts as to make a bunch of identical parts. The economies of scale are there, but less so.

But even for CNC parts, extra shapes means extra CNC programming time (expensive but amortizes over the number of pieces made, so n unique parts costs n times as much to setup and amortizes n times less). It means more inspection gauges. More tooling. Significantly more inventory costs.

Design a machine from a single modular piece, and all else equal it will be much cheaper than one made from a bunch of unique parts.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by calaphos on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:13PM (#22301589)
Modern aircraft, as in 787 and a350 are mostly carbon composite structures by now. I image that would be even more the case for a blended wing body Design
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by gumby on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:53AM (#22299400)
You're not machining large surfaces like wings, windmill blades and the like, not just because it's hard to make machine tools that size but because the structure and performance of the materials depend on not being machined.

When you machine an amorphous or crystalline material like a metal alloy you aren't always simply removing material, but can be putting a specific finish on the surface for mechanical reasons. Sometimes you want to cast again for performance (or cost) reasons because machining can't get you what you want.

When you build a shape from a composite material such as fibreglass in epoxy you want the longitudinal fibres to run long distances to distribute the stresses. Machining it would defeat the purpose. They are cast.

I like these blended wing designs; I'm just pointing out that your argument is not applicable to this application.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by Gravityloss on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:54PM (#22302732)
They are made from composites. The moulds are machined.

Airliner structures are very conservative. They still use a lot of fasteners, lowering manufacturing and structural efficiency.

There is a lot of room to improve. There is a huge space for innovation in composites. It just takes a lot of time and money to ensure the more modern methods are also durable and safe.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by PietdeVries on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:45AM (#22299337)
Also in today's world it is cheaper for one machine to produce 1.000 identical parts than for the same machine produce 10 times 100 different parts. You need stock of each, tests of each.

Imagine how efficient car maintenance would be of only we'd use one standardized car. You can have the larger model, but all components are the same, every garage has them...

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by lowdose on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @11:29AM (#22299714)
Like Tesla is doing with one engine for all cars and a mono frame pressed out of a metal sheet. Cybertruck deliverable in every color you like as long as it's metal. I have read somewhere the complexity in production lines are similar as the big O notation. Henry Ford would be proud of Elon.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by mediaman on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:07PM (#22301529)
Most car manufacturers are massively reducing complexity. Toyota's Next Generation Architecture is reducing total manufacturing costs by 20% by simplifying their entire platform of vehicles into a common set of types and using similar hardware wherever possible.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by himinlomax on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @06:21PM (#22313869)
3D printing.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by throwanem on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:41AM (#22299307)
Yeah, a passenger aircraft is somewhat more complex in manufacture than a MacBook Pro.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by digikata on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:16PM (#22301620)
I imagine even larger gantry variant of this carbon fiber loom:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j19na8LMBnE

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by hinkley on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:13PM (#22300898)
A tube fuselage is also easier to build offsite. Boeing still carts 737 fuselages back and forth across Seattle on the railways.

Have you seen how Boeing was building (well, how Mitsubishi was building, in point if fact) carbon fiber wings? They were doing it with carbon fiber ribbons as a single piece.

I don’t know if that scales up to the size of a blended body, though.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:43PM (#22302622)
Not just "across Seattle". From Wichita to Seattle.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EliRivers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:21PM (#22301671)
From what I can tell of the passenger airline business over the last few decades, lots of people will say that they would never fly in such an aircraft because of those things, and it wouldn't be true.

Lower cost - they'll fly. Over and over and over, lower cost? They'll fly.

Here's Forbes on it back in 2015; https://www.forbes.com/sites/airchive/2015/01/14/actually-ai... , and here's someone else on it in 2016; https://www.businessinsider.com.au/scandinavian-airline-sas-... , and someone else in 2017 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/heres-what-us-airline-pass...

Price. Price. Price. That's what passengers show they care about through their actions. They like to pretend, we all like to pretend, but the evidence is clear.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by big_chungus on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:37PM (#22301851)
It's to the consumer's advantage to tell his buddy about how terrible such-and-such-an-airline's new cuts to foot room are and how he wouldn't fly and neither should anyone else. That could possibly lead to better policies. It's not to his advantage to skip flying or to by a more expensive ticket. People are acting according to their best interests, nothing to see here.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EliRivers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:39PM (#22301877)
I disagree.

If the consumer convinces everyone else not to fly on those cheap flights, the cheap flights discontinue and the consumer is left paying more. How's that to the consumer's advantage?

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by tuna-piano on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:44PM (#22302635)
I disagree that people will for sure choose price over uncomfortable aircrafts. The most clear thing to look at is turboprops vs regional jet aircraft.

Turboprops cost less to buy and burn less fuel(on shorter routes) and take roughly the same amount of time for hourlong trips. But yet, at least in the US, turboprops have been almost completely replaced by regional jets.

This is because passengers prefer the small jet experience to the small turboprop experience, even though the turboprop is cheaper.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EliRivers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:31PM (#22303105)
I have heard the alternative conclusion that the expense and reduced inter-changeability of airframes in a mixed fleet of turboprops AND jets, outweighs the costs of just jets, and furthermore the US domestic market has seen a reduction in demand for the short flights that turboprops excel at.

Put another way, the jets are cheaper, even though they individually cost more and burn more fuel. That the turboprops have been phased out of larger airlines that both run long distance flights and would benefit most from the economics of just jets in their fleet, while turboprops are still in use at smaller airlines who would not benefit as much from a single airframe fleet and serve a higher proportion of short distance routes, does seem suggestive.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by tuna-piano on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:14PM (#22303534)
Interesting theory, and I'm no expert, but it doesn't feel correct to me. Of course United flies only jets, but it has a variety of regional partner airlines that also fly only regional jets.

In a slightly similar way, FedEx operates only jets but for small cargo routes seems to operate only propeller planes (along with its large FedEx feeder partner feelts)[1]. This could be for a variety of reasons, but it seems most logical (to me) to assume that props are more economical and of course cargo doesn't care about comfort.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FedEx_Express#Fleet

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jonathanpoulter on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:10AM (#22299036)
Cruise ships handle plenty of non-window "accommodation": https://www.royalcaribbean.com/blog/an-inside-room-with-a-vi...
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by 0xffff2 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:47PM (#22301301)
I've been on a lot of cruises. Aside from sleeping, I'm pretty much never in my cabin. Doesn't really make for a good comparison to a flight.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by beamatronic on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:45PM (#22300544)
For a certain price, you’ll find someone to do it
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by big_chungus on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:43PM (#22301949)
I've never been on one; to some one who has, how do you avoid going nuts or getting depressed after a few days?
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by zentiggr on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:03PM (#22302205)
I deployed on a sub five times in four years, so I'm maybe not the best one to give an example. For us, we got used to the 'no outside' within a day or so as there is always so much else to do.

Long term, you make friends, come up with portable hobbies, and just dig in to the job for a while.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by tastyfreeze on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:00PM (#22302169)
Consume as much food and booze as possible to drown your depression caused by being crammed on a disease-ridden ship with 3,000 strangers.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jdonaldson on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:34PM (#22301139)
I think the airlines will find a way to turn these problems into advantages.

- Passengers won't have "normal" seats far from the plane's central axis. The distal axis seats will contain steward seating, bathrooms, additional storage, and maybe even a small lounge.

- Windows on planes are dirty and small. You're also dealing with more noise and vibration being closer to the frame and engines.

- I don't know enough about turbofans, where can I learn more about the bypass limitations?

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EForEndeavour on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:40PM (#22301228)
- Placing bathrooms and lounges where turbulence is guaranteed to be highest strikes me as a potentially poor idea.

- Airliner passenger windows have been getting bigger. https://i.imgur.com/ISWgvZF.jpg

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by bdamm on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:32PM (#22301801)
The 1925 Ford Trimotor[1] had big beautiful picture frame windows. A silly comparison but if you've ever flown in one you'll know what I mean when I say they had a luxurious view of air travel.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Trimotor#/media/File:NC84...

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by zentiggr on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:07PM (#22302246)
I had the privilege to take a flight on one a few years ago; aside from the expected difference in engine noise (which was actually way more fun as an aviation buff) it was rather comfy for a seventy year old design. And yes, awesome views from the row behind the cockpit.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by the_mitsuhiko on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:46PM (#22301284)
Windows have not been getting bigger as a rule. Boeing did make larger windows but Airbus didn’t. The A350 has small windows.

Window size is also not the main factor that matters. For instance I would take an A350 over an 787 any day (also because of the terrible tint windows) due to cabin layout and size.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EliRivers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:31PM (#22301798)
Why not just more seats? If the cost of the flight is lower, people will buy it. They will, over and over. They kick and scream and say "this, this, THIS is the line I finally won't cross" and then they buy a cheap ticket.

Here's Forbes on it back in 2015; https://www.forbes.com/sites/airchive/2015/01/14/actually-ai... , and here's someone else on it in 2016; https://www.businessinsider.com.au/scandinavian-airline-sas-... , and someone else in 2017 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/heres-what-us-airline-pass...

Price. Price. Price. That's what passengers care about. Same story, over and over.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by exhilaration on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:22PM (#22303013)
I'm very much in this camp. Two weeks ago, my 6 member family took a flight on Frontier, one of the discount airlines, from Philadelphia to South Florida. The seats didn't even recline! But don't take that as a complaint, the fact that we paid $611.79 for 6 round trip tickets (and 2 checked bags) makes up for the slightly less comfortable trip and no pretzels.

Fares like that make flying possible for so many more people now. If we had to pay $200 or even $300/ticket (instead of $100) it would have made the trip unaffordable.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EliRivers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:01PM (#22303385)
The seats didn't even recline!

I'd actually pay a little more for seating that didn't recline (or rather, for the seat in front of me not to recline, but more than happy for that to be the case on all the seats). Genuinely would. Not a lot, but a little.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by dzhiurgis on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:08AM (#22306284)
Second emergency exit row on Ryanair (AFAIK they fly 737's exclusively) costs about $30. It reclines but seat in front doesn't...
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by big_chungus on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:41PM (#22301909)
The line for me is United's "basic economy". I'm pretty sure I'd have difficulty fitting in the seat because they're so small; I'm skinny enough, but have long legs. There's a line between "nice-to-have"s (extra room, early boarding, etc.) and things that make passengers plain uncomfortable, and that's it. This is true for a good number of others I know, too.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by EliRivers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:43PM (#22301938)
Is that the line? How much of a discount would you need to cross it? 50%? 20%?

If you wouldn't cross it, how many people are there poorer than you who almost, almost fly? There are a LOT of them. A LOT.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by danmaz74 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:22AM (#22298668)
The article shortly addresses these points:

... One unresolved question is whether such a plane would have windows or use video screens to give passengers a sense of their surroundings.

Another issue that has dogged such experiments in the past is how to handle sensations of movement.

Because passengers would be sitting further out from the center of the aircraft, compared to the classic ‘tube and wings’ model, they would move further when the aircraft turns. Rival Boeing has put more weight on a potential cargo role.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by mrfusion on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @08:04AM (#22298117)
It would be neat to put windows on the floor. You’re most interested in looking down anyway.

And otherwise you could have a cool hang out / lounge with nice pa Aramaic windows and everyone could have turns sightseeing.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by hnarn on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @08:13AM (#22298173)
That's not a very good idea. Most people are terrified of glass floors in other scenarios, like balconies for example, especially combined with some altitude. It may be just as safe as "normal" windows but I doubt most people would be comfortable with it. I'm not even sure I would be and I have no more fear of flying than most people. I'm not sure it's suitable for other reasons as well, such as hull integrity (but I'm not an engineer), or actually getting sunlight into the cabin. I'm fairly sure most people want to watch sunsets and sunrises, not clouds or how insanely high up you're sitting.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by hbosch on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:50PM (#22301337)
> It would be neat to put windows on the floor. You’re most interested in looking down anyway.

I don't think so. Looking down isn't what people look out the windows at, it's the horizon. Looking straight down would be generally frightening, sickening, to many people... whereas the horizon is steady and calming.

But either way, once you're above the clouds, windows are OK but kinda useless. View doesn't change much up there, or at night!

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by throwaway55554 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:37AM (#22299261)
> It would be neat to put windows on the floor.

Depends on if they put cargo down below or not. Makes sense they would so they can easily on/off-load it.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by foobiekr on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:37PM (#22301193)
project the open sky on the ceiling
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by mrfusion on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:48PM (#22301319)
Don’t forget mrfusions law. “Any screen will eventually show ads”
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by emiliobumachar on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:24AM (#22297645)
>More passengers [...] experience larger vertical accelerations

Economy-minus section?

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by alexis_fr on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:53AM (#22297762)
To be honest, air travel used to be very noisy and expensive, sometimes with fumes events, let alone smokers. Despite the legroom, I’m pretty sure it is more comfortable now.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jotm on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:11AM (#22297845)
Please, that's an Adventurer seat and costs more than economy.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by continuations on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:30AM (#22297425)
> More passengers are farther from the windows

Why is that a con? Seems to me most people don't like window seats & want aisle seats.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by cbzbc on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:07AM (#22297580)
Well, you also end up with longer rows - and so potentially more middle of row seats which are less desirable.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by consp on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:44AM (#22297726)
Or you create corridors? Most 10 wide have a 3-4-3 already and if you have more horizontal space 3-3-3-3 might be an option with the same amount of middle seats and two extra seats.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by hawski on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:03AM (#22297571)
In a way windows are more of a psychological problem I think. They are already quite small and not that reachable for most passengers, but closing an option is tough.

Would it be possible to have at least roof windows for natural light or then it's not worth the bother?

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by petre on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:52AM (#22298897)
Less windows = less chance an aircraft would depressurize. An array of small roof windows could be a solution.

https://edition.cnn.com/travel/gallery/stephen-chang-imagina...

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by Yizahi on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:24AM (#22297891)
- No great place to put a high bypass turbofan.

This especially. USSR Tu-154 with a 3rd engine in this spot was very affected by aerodynamic shadow from a airplane body at certain angles.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by throwaway55554 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:35AM (#22299244)
I wonder about egress during an emergency as well.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by ragebol on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:56AM (#22297770)
I think I'd like windows in the floor so I can see what we're flying over. But I doubt that will be very popular.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by 0xffff2 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:57PM (#22301425)
On any current airliner a window in the cabin floor would only allow you to stare at your luggage. That arrangement seems to efficient to change just for the sake of a bit of a view.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:30PM (#22300373)
Airlines don't care about our comfort. They would ship us in intermodal Connex boxes if they could.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by nmeofthestate on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:49PM (#22300580)
I would definitely try "BA Baracus" mode for intercontinental flights if it were available and safe.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:17PM (#22304031)
I pity the fool...
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by vl on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:12PM (#22300881)
People don’t care about comfort, airlines just sell what people pay for.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by mgolawala on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:05PM (#22301497)
Exactly this. There is plenty of comfort available in air travel if you are willing to pay for it.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jessriedel on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:21PM (#22302382)
> as well as normal banking maneuvers

Aren't these maneuvers done such that the local acceleration for all the passengers remains pointing straight toward the bottom of the plane, so that if they close their eyes they don't feel like they are tipping at all? Why can't this continue to work for BWB?

I also don't really understand the turbulence issue. Do planes typically roll during turbulence? My experience has been mostly vertical vibrations.

Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by ithkuil on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:30PM (#22302495)
That's once you set the bank angle and are turning. But in order to initiate the bank you need to apply a torque (via ailerons). If you sit at distance d from the axis you'll experience an acceleration due to this torque changing the angular velocity (four times per turb: once when the banking is initiated and the second time in the opposite direction when the desired bank angle is reached; then the same thing reversed when existing from the turn). An increased distance d exacerbates the effect (think of a lever).
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by jbay808 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:58PM (#22303360)
The trajectory is the second integral of the acceleration, so if the local acceleration were pointing exactly straight down at all times, you'd have to be moving along a vertical line.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by Lendal on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @08:40AM (#22298335)
That's the first thing that went through my mind when I saw that picture. "No windows--I'm not flying on that."
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by CandidSubstance on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:48AM (#22297748)
Wasn't the main issue that flying wings have a very narrow Center of Gravity range? I thought the main reason that airliners have such a large trimmable horizontal stabiliser is to configure for varying CofG.
Re:Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after sec... by upofadown on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:58AM (#22298081)
Yes, but it is harder to get a long ways from the center of gravity on a flying wing.