News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:50AM (#22179895)
In 2004 solar power was still far too expensive to be a viable option, to the point where he didn't even bother to mention it: "there is no chance that the renewables, wind, tide and water power can provide enough energy and in time." This is no longer true; installing new photovoltaic generation capacity is now cheaper than continuing to run existing coal plants in much of the world, and although the humans still need to ramp up production capacity to build enough panels, it looks like they are on track to make the switch in the 2020s. The total solar resource is about three orders of magnitude larger than marketed world energy consumption.

We shouldn't fault James for not seeing this in 2004, but now we know he was wrong, as many of us were.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics

Edited to add: competitive-bid power purchasing agreements hit a new low this week of US$15.67 per MWh in Qatar https://archive.fo/UBWWi but there are projects in many equatorial parts of the world hitting similar lows. This is a factor of 10 less than what end-users currently pay for electricity in California and roughly a factor of 3 less than the average wholesale cost there.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by ArtWomb on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:30AM (#22180218)
A more recent reference and thorough analysis on moving to 100% wind, water and solar (WWS) can be found in the soon to be published, 100% Clean, Renewable Energy and Storage for Everything. A draft is available online

https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/WWSBook/WWSBook...

While I am still bullish on nuclear, particularly for space operations, the time delta argument is most compelling against nuclear plants. It can take 20 years for a new plant to become operational. Even after 70+ years of controlled nuclear fission. This is the cost then of not allocating research dollars to civilian long term projects.

And even with a transition to 100% WWS, carbon capture tech will still require some sort of Manhattan Project level of urgency. This may be a great candidate for AI-mediated materials discovery. To search for the "tungsten filament" which will power next-gen "artificial tress" ;)

https://asunow.asu.edu/20190429-solutions-lackner-carbon-cap...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:47AM (#22180362)
Let's recall that the author of that first link literally sued his scientific critics who published a peer-reviewed take-down of his 100% renewable plan a few years ago.

https://www.technologyreview.com/f/609308/a-renewable-energy...

One element not often mentioned in these is the Energy Return On Investment which drops to around 5:1 as intermittent renewables with massive backup systems ramp up. This low level (5:1) seriously challenges the renewable transition plans.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esr.2019.100399

Nuclear eroi is closer to 50:1.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:02AM (#22181234)
That paper looks very interesting, thanks! I'll have to read it. I agree that the cost of storage is an important concern, but the calculations I've done don't substantiate the worries I've often seen. On skimming the paper, it isn't obvious what level of overprovisioning, utility-scale storage, and demand response they're presuming, or what learning curves for PV and battery costs (including energy and material costs). Have you been able to find where they described those assumptions?
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by Scea91 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:04AM (#22180020)
But coal plant as opposed to solar plant has a reliable, predictable output and works after dusk. Nuclear power plant also has these characteristics.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by AstralStorm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:09AM (#22180058)
We do not have to limit ourselves to just one source. Blocking nuclear in favor of some sort of pie in the sky global power network and huge renewable infrastructure is common for some reason.

We can use any and all power sources that are clean.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by rob74 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:43AM (#22180334)
> We can use any and all power sources that are clean.

I completely agree with you on that. Of course, the disagreement hinges on whether you can consider nuclear power "clean"...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:51AM (#22180396)
There's enough data today to show that it absolutely is. No air pollution, very little CO2, almost no deaths/TWh compared to other sources.

Accidents have been bad but recall that fossil while operating normally kills 3.8 million/year and causes climate change. In comparison to that nuclear is absolutely pristene.

Germany's choice to phase nuclear out and leave coal on straight up kills a few thousand people per year.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pjc50 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:09AM (#22180588)
Nuclear risks tend not to be straight up death; the risk is that a Chernobyl type incident would contaminate a very large area of farmland with bioaccumulative fission products, eg. Cesium-137: https://www.oecd-nea.org/rp/chernobyl/c06.html

The risk can't be measured in "lives per year" because for most years it will be zero. The "long tail event" is something like: each reactor has a 1/10,000 lifetime chance of an incident of releasing cs137 which will contaminate a random area of Europe in which agriculture becomes uneconomic to make safe. It's a probabilistic judgement of the type that we're very bad at dealing with.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:12AM (#22180613)
The numbers I'm using incorporate the UN UNSCEARs estimate of long term cancers due to Chernobyl. These are factored in.

In fact, building a straight-up Chernobyl reactor that runs for 5 years and then explodes is still safer than running a regular old coal plant for 5 years. Fossil is that bad.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by jyounker on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:05AM (#22181978)
People's emotional reaction to nuclear plants isn't about long term safety, it's about the failure mode. When a nuclear plant fails catastrophically it becomes a long-term area denial weapon.

At a statistical level, I'm willing to bet that driving a car is probably much more dangerous than living near either a nuclear plant or a fossil fuel plant, but we still do it.

The problem with nuclear power is, unlike fossil fuel plant or cars, an accident takes your home, your daily social connections, and your daily life. It turns you and your family and friends into refugees.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pjc50 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:14AM (#22182110)
It's not impossible for fossil accidents to be that bad; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aberfan_disaster / https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buncefield_fire are the ones from the UK I remember, but the biggest may be the huge poisioning of the Bhopal disaster which is technically more the chemical industry's fault.

But the big shadow behind nuclear is weapons proliferation. From the 60s onwards nuclear bombs brought the possibility that there might be a civilisation-destroying nuclear exchange, and as the discourse around Iran has shown it's quite difficult for bystanders to distinguish between the two.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by keanzu on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:43AM (#22182548)
Something else is at the root of nuclear fear. There have been much more serious renewable accidents.

Banqiao Hydroelectric Dam, China, was breached Aug. 8 1975 killing more than 85,000 people that day. A study conducted by eight Chinese water science experts who probably had access to censored government reports, estimated the number of total dead — from flooding and the resulting epidemics and famine — at 230,000.

https://www.ozy.com/flashback/230000-died-in-a-dam-collapse-...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:44AM (#22181000)
The concern about farmland contamination is not because people are farming around Pripyat and getting cancer. On the contrary, it's because people are not farming around Pripyat. Deaths per terajoule doesn't factor in the loss of the farmland.

I think you're probably right that, even with frequent meltdowns, nuclear power would be less bad than coal. But I also think that we don't have a large enough number of disasters to extrapolate reliably. A hundred Chernobyls might produce much more than a hundred times the deaths from one Chernobyl — or much less.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:19AM (#22181415)
Well we just had a triple-meltdown at Fukushima where the plants actually had containment domes. Estimated deaths from radiation integrated over all time? Up to 1.

The difference between nuclear's safety and fossil fuels anti-safety is astounding. They are not even remotely comparable. 4 million deaths per year from fossil, year after year. Up to 4000 total deaths across the decades from nuclear.

Fossil fuels are causing over 2 long-term cancer-included Chernobyls per day every single day right now.

This is an important point that's hard to get through to people.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by craftinator on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @02:52PM (#22185045)
Sounds like fossil is really helping to prevent overpopulation.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by Wildgoose on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:04AM (#22180546)
Although Germany do say they will phase out their Coal-fired power stations by 2038 - so another two decades to go.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/26/germany-agrees...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:55AM (#22180437)
> Germany's choice to phase nuclear out and leave coal on straight up

Often repeated, but still wrong: Germany also phased out coal.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:02AM (#22180528)
Incorrect. Here's some live data for you to gander at: https://www.electricitymap.org

They still run over 40 GW of coal.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:14AM (#22180641)
Yeah, sorry, native German speaker here, I got the tense wrong. Germany is in the process of phasing out coal, just as with nuclear. https://www.latimes.com/world/europe/la-fg-germany-coal-powe...
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:17AM (#22180681)
Yup. They promised to phase coal out later and phased nuclear out today. Literalling killing a few thousand per year by air pollution while they're at it. It's a great anti-scientific tragedy of our times due to fear of radiation and inability to judge actuarial statistics correctly.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:34AM (#22180883)
I'm not at all disagreeing. The coal phase-out should have happened a) before the nuclear phase-out and b) decades earlier. Processes like these tend to be pretty sluggish, the political discussions for both date back to the 1970s. Chernobyl was a big thing in German politics, and there are still some species of mushrooms that can't be eaten in the country. The actual health problems were negligible, but this isn't how politics work.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:22AM (#22181457)
Gotcha. Yeah the mental effects of Chernobyl melded with all the fears about nuclear weapons fallout, which Russians and American had been scaring people with for years at that point.

The nuclear industry totally failed to recover from a PR point of view, and since then has hid under a rock rather than explained how low carbon and safe it is.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pjc50 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:00AM (#22180501)
"Is in the process of phasing out", maybe, but it's absolutely not phased out yet. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-51133534
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:56AM (#22180459)
Are solar panel and wind turbines clean ?

They need to be changed often, they use lots of concrete (especially for wind turbines), they need lots of materials and have a quite low power factor (10-20%).

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:19AM (#22180697)
> They need to be changed often, they use lots of concrete (especially for wind turbines), they need lots of materials and have a quite low power factor (10-20%).

How many tonnes of concrete per megawatt do wind turbines use, and how many do nuclear power plants use? Solar plants used to use a lot of concrete, but they no longer do.

"Power factor" is an attribute of electrical loads, not electrical generating equipment; it describes how far the load's current consumption deviates from the perfect in-phase sine wave of, say, a resistor. Perhaps you meant "capacity factor", the ratio of average power produced to peak power produced. Typical capacity factors for wind turbines are in the vicinity of 35%, although some offshore wind farms reach 60%. Photovoltaic plants typically have a capacity factor of around 25%, though in sunny places like Arizona and California it can exceed 30%. In the US, the lowest PV capacity factors are in Maine, which averages 12%. Germany's average PV capacity factor is 10%. Natural gas peakers are around 9%.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor

I've already thoroughly demolished this nonsense about "need to be changed often" in the case of photovoltaic panels. I don't know what wind turbine lifetimes are. Shorter, I imagine, but they still have a much higher ERoEI than PV or in fact any other power source.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:29AM (#22180820)
> Nuclear power plants built in the 1970’s used 40 metric tons of steel, and 190 cubic meters of concrete, for each megawatt of average capacity.

> Modern wind energy systems, with good wind conditions, take 460 metric tons of steel and 870 cubic meters of concrete per megawatt.

https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2007/07/constructing-lot-of-nu...

First source I found.

Wind turbine lifetimes are 20 to 25 years at the best.

I agree for solar panels, they don't need lots of concrete and only loose efficiency over time. But you would need lots of them + a complete power storage system behind. So the cost and material used to have a similar power output is still order of magnitude higher.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edynoid on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:12AM (#22181339)
My first thought to this: can the turbines be made from wood instead? Searching for it, I found this:

https://newatlas.com/timbertower-wooden-wind-turbine/25007/

Making things out of wood is generally a good idea to save on carbon footprint. I have doubts you could build a nuclear power plant from timber given all the containment & shielding requirements.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by DuskStar on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @02:55PM (#22185084)
Nice! But I bet it still uses a comparable amount of steel to the reactor reactor (in the blades), and I don't think replacing steel with wood would impact the concrete usage either.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:55PM (#22185710)
I think the blades are mostly fiberglass these days?

Glulam wood can substitute for some uses of concrete, but I'm thinking it's probably not ideal for earth contact applications. Especially in places like Ohio, which we mentioned as an example in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22181187

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:40AM (#22180943)
Can you find a source from, say, the last five years? I think wind turbines have changed substantially since 2007.

> But you would need lots of them + a complete power storage system behind. So the cost and material used to have a similar power output is still order of magnitude higher.

This turns out not to be true.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:58AM (#22181187)
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:11AM (#22181332)
https://www.forconstructionpros.com/concrete/article/1088605... is still 7 years ago, but it says they used 30,000 "tons" (probably about 27000 tonnes in modern units) of cement occupying 122500 "cubic yards" (94000 m³ in modern units) to support the 152 2-MW turbines of a 304 MW wind farm. That's 89 tonnes (though that number is probably wildly approximate) or 304 m³ per megawatt. This is a little more than the 190 m³/MW for nuclear plants cited by the 2007 NextBigFuture artcle, but a lot less than the 870 m³/MW for wind farms they cited.

So, if concrete requirements for wind farms dropped by two thirds from 2007 to 2013, what do you suppose they are today?

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:36AM (#22181643)
Dropped by 2/3 ok. For a lifespan of, 20 years ?

Again a power plant life expectancy is 3, maybe 4 times that. And you need to do the foundation once.

You don't replace a wind turbine over a wind turbine, you need to redo the foundations (the concrete is constantly stressed and fragilized through the years), same for a power plant (also for security purposes).

This doesn't count the concrete needed for the access roads and cables to connect everything. From the article "Lafarge also supplied 20,000 tons of Type I cement for soil stabilization of approximately 44 miles of roads".

Let's try to do the maths with a modern power plant as well. Knowing that you produce more energy than in the 70' with modern turbines and we have bigger plans as well on smaller areas.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pfdietz on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:24AM (#22180749)
There are utility-scale solar installation options that use no concrete at all. Steel earth anchors support the frames on which the modules are mounted.

The low capacity factor (it's actually around 30% for new solar and 50+% for wind) is already accounted for in the levelized cost of energy. LCOE from renewables is a factor of 3-4x lower than from new nuclear.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by keanzu on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:56AM (#22182752)
> They need to be changed often

I looked for some reference material and I found a "rule of thumb" which claims that PV panels lose about 1% efficiency per year of operation and can last 25-30 years.

Nuclear power stations (in China) are designed for a 40 to 60-year operating life.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:21PM (#22185970)
25–30 years is the design life; they can last a lot longer than that. Silicon is an astoundingly stable substance.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by marcosdumay on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:32AM (#22181583)
> We do not have to limit ourselves to just one source.

Well, as long as it is no coal or nuclear, no, we don't. But those two do not like to share capacity, so as much as you have them, you better use them.

> Blocking nuclear in favor of some sort of pie in the sky global power network...

The natural state of nuclear is blocked. It's not in favor of a renewable network, it simply is. Maybe it would be better if it wasn't, but that's not reality.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by Scea91 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:19AM (#22180127)
I completely agree with you. My argument was not against solar. It was against ‘solar only’. Of course, there are other renewables and if some country has an option to use solar + hydro then they do not need nuclear. But not everyone has that option.

Disclaimer: I am a layman in this topic and not energetics expert, this is my understanding of the state but please feel free to correct me.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by belorn on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:30AM (#22180842)
> We can use any and all power sources that are clean.

I would prefer if we did not use use any power source that is dirty. It might sound similar but the outcome is very different. A ban against fossil fuels would prevent countries from relying on fossil fuels for base load when wind or solar can't fulfill demand.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by cygx on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:20AM (#22180137)
What's more predictable than the day/night cycle? We can work around that. More problematic is what's known as a 'Dunkelflaute' in German: Overcast skies, fog, etc, combined with no wind, for days. Doesn't happen that often (in Germany, every 2 years or so), but it happens.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:27AM (#22180195)
You can easily find people that did the math for those cases.

Basically we still need to do x10 or more in electricity storage (hard to do when you already built all the reversible damns you can build in your country) in most places by still having the risk of a several day grid cut if we don't have wind and enough sun for a while.

In France for example, we don't have space to build reversible damns anymore. Which represent a huge majority of the electricity stored (batteries are only 2%). We can basically store 14h of the country consuption. Handling those "no wind, no sun" cases would need up to weeks of storage.

Moving to renewable energy is basically stressing the grid. The Germans can use the other countries to limit the impacts but it doesn't work when everyone is doing it.

Except if our society is ok to have multiple times per year global power cuts of several days.

I'd also like to stress that CO2 emission are also massively coming from transports and buildings. Focusing massively on electricity generation decarbonation only is I think a nonsense.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by skitout on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:37AM (#22180281)
Energy can be stored as electricity... or thermally (most of our electricity is used to create heat or cold, that we can cheaply store for days and even months)

Reversible damns are for small amount of energy and short term... but most classical damns do store much more energy - that is an energy you can decide to use now, or in two weeks, or sometime in few months. They store energy, just can't store already produced electricity

Energy efficiency and demand-response have HUGE potential to reduce energy consumption, and to make energy consumption "programmable"

A good mix of different renewable energy (hydro, biomass, onshore wind, off-shore wind, solar) make it impossible to have a "no wind, no sun" case, even if there will be fluctuation in what level of electricity you can produce

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:48AM (#22180367)
Germany is a terrible place for solar; their solar plants average a 10% capacity factor. By contrast, solar plants in Arizona are around 30%, and even the worst lower-48 US state, Maine, is 12%. Yet they've largely made it work, though perhaps as with Harvard's early computer and the US's early adoption of the Tele-phone, perhaps their pioneering status will slow them down further down the road.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:03AM (#22180531)
> What's more predictable than the day/night cycle?

Human stupidity.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by Scea91 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:27AM (#22180192)
You answered it yourself, it’s not about day night cycle only but also about the weather. But I agree that in this particular area we can probably achieve solid innovation.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:32AM (#22180235)
Do you think we should base all our hope into things that are not even in the labs yet ?

I prefer to use good ol' technologies such as power plants/damns, they are reliable, they can be done locally (most of solar panels are coming from China), they can be repaired and we can handle them country wise easily.

If we want to reduce our CO2 emissions, we move to gaz (coal -> gaz is -20%), we reduce our consumption (building isolation is -30%, sometimes -50%), and we massively reduce cars usage (by developing trains, another good ol' technology that works really well).

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:57AM (#22181891)
BTW in English the word for "isolation" in this sense is "insulation".
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edynoid on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:53AM (#22181842)
Trains and isolation are great. But gas still produces net carbon emissions. So if you adopt it, you have to move away from it very soon anyway. Seems like wasted effort from my point of view.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:08AM (#22182024)
It is indeed for a transition phase. I agree.

But if we need to reduce our CO2 emissions really fast it's one of the most efficient way to cut 1/5 of the emissions without massively changing how the grid and the other things are working.

But for sure in the end it's more a way to save time and to reduce coal usage that is also producing serious health issues to the populations.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by skitout on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:29AM (#22180211)
Wind + Solar + hydro + demand response + some thermal and electric storage has a reliable, predictable output and works after dusk

And for new capacities, that is cheaper than coal or nuclear

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by leecarraher on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:44AM (#22180348)
what about pumped storage hydroelectricity? It currently accounts for 95%-99% of potential energy storage capacity, is far cheaper and more efficient than current commercially available chemical battery storage methods.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:54AM (#22180423)
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pfdietz on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:54PM (#22240846)
That's primary hydropower, where there is an external water source constantly carrying organic material into the reservoir. A closed pumped hydro system could have much less organic input (and possibly could exploit the pumping to keep the water oxygenated, so methane would not be produced.)
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by mattgibson on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:30AM (#22180217)
Solar power towers can be built with molten salt heat stores, which continue to power the turbines during the night, so they do work after dusk now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_tower

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:53AM (#22180418)
The thermal part of these is essentially the same cost as a coal plant — the only difference is that you're boiling the water with molten salt instead of burning coal — so they're having a really hard time competing with modern photovoltaic. It's true that they're a zero-carbon option for energy storage, but batteries are a more likely option.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:54AM (#22180429)
Any power plant basically. All those kind of plants are mostly similar (turbines activated by steam that produces electricity), the biggest difference is how you produce the heat.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by crdoconnor on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:19AM (#22180129)
Reliable and predictable at 2x the cost.

Saving 50% on generation gives you a lot of options in terms of demand shaping and storage.

It's also far, far less capital intensive and doesn't require an uncapped disaster insurance subsidy from the taxpayer.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by Scea91 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:24AM (#22180178)
1) Increased investment in nuclear energetics should bring the cost down

2) 2x cost for these attributes does not seem particularly bad to me.

3) I am not aware of any production ready options that have been deployed at scale somewhere. I know there are a lot of ideas however. If you have time can you please point me to the most promising ones? I am genuinely interested.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:40AM (#22180304)
Nuclear is way too expensive, it essentially has lost. It will certainly will play a part for decades, but e.g. wind turbine parks are already at the same price level and have none of the disadvantages of nuclear. Plus several wind parks in a grid work just fine as base load providers, see e.g. https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.475...
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by belorn on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:42AM (#22180974)
Nuclear is more expensive than building a combination of wind turbine parks and natural gas plant. That is a fact.

People theorize that nuclear could be more expensive than a grid that relies on over capacity wind turbine parks in combination with thermal or hydro batteries, but no country has gone that route yet. We have countries that are almost 100% nuclear and we have a bunch that are a mix between wind/solar which falls backs to fossil fuels when needed.

The cost of running a energy grid is the total cost, not individual megawatts being produced in isolation.

Ban fossil fuels and the real costs comparison between clean energy becomes apparent.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:55AM (#22180442)
The intermittency is the one thing nuclear does better than wind. Nuclear can run 24/7 for multiple years on one fuel load on a tiny land footprint with very few raw materials. No other low-carbon source can do that.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:11AM (#22180606)
But real world nuclear plants seldomly run for years. I just posted links in another comment, nuclears capacity factor in France (the country with a high nuclear buildout) is about 72%, while that of wind is about 50%. The nuclear plants in France routinely have to be shut down / throttled during the summer heat - just at the times of high energy demands.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:14AM (#22180646)
In the US the nuclear capacity is over 90% across 100 plants. Just because France chooses to curtail doesn't mean they have to. Wind cannot be higher than the wind itself. The characteristic of coming on and off when you want is called being dispatchable.

In the us northwest there's a fairly regular 2-week wind outage across a 4 state area each winter.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:25AM (#22180763)
It's unavoidable that if you get almost all of your power from some source, but demand varies, you will have a lower capacity factor for that source, unless you have utility-scale power. France does indeed have to curtail nuclear power plant output, because they get almost all their electrical power from nukes, and they don't have big enough resistors to burn up the excess electrical energy that would be produced otherwise. The US has a higher nuclear capacity factor because it gets most of its power from other sources.

> This characteristic is called being dispatchable.

While I mostly appreciate your contributions to this conversation as being informative, a dispatchable plant is one that you can turn on and off to respond to demand, not one that cannot be higher than the wind itself.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:29AM (#22180823)
If we do get serious about intermittent renewable scale-ups without fracked gas backup we will have to build giant energy storage systems that the nukes will be able to feed into just like the solar PV and wind.

Additionally, nukes can be used for district heating, seawater desalination, hydrogen production, and lots of other non-electric things when the electricity demand is low by using steam bypass techniques.

Regarding correction: I meant to say that but thank you for pointing out that it made no sense as written. I have edited accordingly.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:53AM (#22181132)
That's an excellent point about the fungibility of energy storage. But I don't think the lower capacity factor of nuclear plants in France is a reasonable argument against nuclear energy anyway.

The non-electric uses of nuclear thermal energy you mention are potentially interesting, but essentially they're just a slightly different form of demand response. If you're doing demand response in your desal plant, you can do it regardless of whether it's an MSF plant driven from nuclear thermal power or an RO plant driven by electric pumps. (And RO is usually considered more efficient.) I think it's more common for waste heat from power plants to be a nuisance that results in cooling towers rather than an asset that results in district heating, although I'm not entirely sure why that is.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:06AM (#22181265)
You are completely wrong on your numbers, in France in 2018 nuclear has a capacity factor of 71% and wind of 21,1%

https://bilan-electrique-2018.rte-france.com/eolien/

Also there is currently no offshore wind park, as only offshore would approach the 50% capacity factor, but they won't, they will be in the 43% as estimated by renewables.ninja

Throttling nuclear power happens only a few days in the summer, once every few years, with only a few percent because it only impact a few reactor on some rivers for environmental norms, during the lowest electricity usage of the year.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:21AM (#22181442)
> in France in 2018 nuclear has a capacity factor of 71%

Which is the same number I wrote?

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:25AM (#22181499)
This is what I said, I was talking about the ludicrous 50% capacity factor for onshore wind.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:32AM (#22181581)
Well I never said "onshore". Nevertheless, wikipedia has an example of an onshore wind farm with 60.2% in 2015: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#Wind_farm
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:34AM (#22181610)
There is currently no offshore wind park in France.

Maybe you mean to compare wind in France with world best wind, but this is what you wrote.

"nuclears capacity factor in France (the country with a high nuclear buildout) is about 72%, while that of wind is about 50%"

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:27AM (#22181529)
There are a number of onshore wind farms that reach 50%, but a better average for onshore wind is 35%. But offshore wind can reach 60%, and so 50% is a reasonable overall average, depending on where you expect wind farms to be built in the future.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:33AM (#22181592)
And the onshore wind in France is 21%, and that is a fact you can easily check on the internet with public numbers.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by crdoconnor on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:34AM (#22180253)
Nuclear has shown no particular inclination to come down in price whereas renewables have.

It's just not cost effective without both massive implicit and explicit government subsidies.

Renewables are cost effective now and will only become more so.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by acidburnNSA on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:41AM (#22180318)
They're cost effective when the sun is shining or wind is blowing but are strongly tied to increased high carbon fracked natural gas otherwise. When batteries are used the Energy Return on Investment drops below what's necessary to sustain industrialized civilization (around 5:1).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esr.2019.100399

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:05AM (#22180553)
Even without including cost overruns and decomissioning, wind energy costs the same per kilowatt of capacity[0,1].

And the actually produced energy as share of capacity (= the capacity factor) is way better than most think. For the nuclear plants in France it currently is just over 70%, while it is about 50% globally for offshore wind parks [2,3]

[0] http://www.windustry.org/how_much_do_wind_turbines_cost

[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-edf-nuclear-epr/frances-e...

[2] http://css.umich.edu/factsheets/wind-energy-factsheet

[3] https://www.worldnuclearreport.org/IMG/pdf/20170912wnisr2017...

Edit: Changed phrasing because it apparently sounded like the 50% capacity factor also referred to France.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:00AM (#22181203)
You are completely wrong on your numbers, in France in 2018 nuclear has a capacity factor of 71% and wind of 21,1%

https://bilan-electrique-2018.rte-france.com/eolien/

Also there is currently no offshore wind park, as only offshore would approach the 50% capacity factor, but they won't, they will be in the 43% as estimated by renewables.ninja

The price of the MWh of offsore park will be from 44 to 150€/MWh, where EDF is forced to sell its nuclear at 42€/MWh, average price of wind in 2020 93€/MWh.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:25AM (#22181506)
I'm a bit confused where we disagree? You posted the same capacity factor for nuclear. Here is a real world example of a Danish wind farm averaging 47.7% over 7 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horns_Rev_Offshore_Wind_Farm#H...
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:32AM (#22181576)
I disagree that current onshore wind in France is not 50%, only 21%; also maybe you were comparing the low capacity factor of French nuclear because it is used for load following and curtailed in summer because it is scaled for winter usage using restive heating. And comparing it to offshore with intermitttent power, not dispatchable in the best location. Totally misleading.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:46AM (#22181767)
You are right, it wasn't my intention to imply the 50% refer to France. I'll try to edit the phrasing.

I don't get why you think comparing to offshore wind is misleading, though. Could you expand on that?

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:58AM (#22181901)
Comparing worst capacity factor (for cited reasons) with best CF without saying it is offshore in some of the best location is misleading. Also is comparing dispatchable and intermittent/fatal. There a other factors to consider like reserve ratio, or how the production can cover the power needs over the year, it gives hints at how you need to scale seasonal storage.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:14AM (#22182119)
I see, thanks. 50% isn't that much of an outlier, though, as the average over both onshore and offshore farms seems to be 42% for younger projects: http://css.umich.edu/factsheets/wind-energy-factsheet
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:18AM (#22181402)
It sounds like you confirmed their nuclear capacity factor ("just over 70%") and pointed out that French wind farms have a lower capacity factor (21.1%) than wind farms on average. I don't think that constitutes evidence that they are "completely wrong on [their] numbers".
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:26AM (#22181520)
Price and capacity factor where completely wrong for wind, also current wind subsidies are about 93€/MWh.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:38AM (#22181665)
Let's look at actual and current numbers for construction costs, ignoring subsidies:

Wind: "The costs for a utility scale wind turbine range from about $1.3 million to $2.2 million per MW of nameplate capacity installed." http://www.windustry.org/how_much_do_wind_turbines_cost

Nuclear: " Companies that are planning new nuclear units are currently indicating that the total costs (including escalation and financing costs) will be in the range of $5,500/kW to $8,100/kW or between $6 billion and $9 billion for each 1,100 MW plant." https://www.synapse-energy.com/sites/default/files/SynapsePa...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:43AM (#22181733)
I was giving actual current feed in tariff for French wind.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bildung on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:59AM (#22181910)
Then it's now my turn to call your numbers misleading ;) I don't think you can directly compare the two that way because a) The French government heavily invested in nuclear for strategic reasons, not directly economical ones. The EDF still is essentially state-run. We can't really infer cost arguments from this. b) Practically all nuclear plants in France are decades old, and had many years for recouping initial investments. Current market prices for energy are therefore not a good argument for costs of newly built plants.

If we look at the costs of constructing new nuclear plants (which the article we comment on is about), France is a particularly bad example, with current costs already at $11B for 1600MW of capacity for the Flamanville project. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-edf-nuclear-flamanville/e...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:29AM (#22181555)
They were citing worldwide capacity factors and prices for wind, not French ones, which I agree are much worse.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:41AM (#22181700)
That was not obvious, it was written like a French nuclear with French wind comparison. And also that is misleading because comparing the low capacity factor of French nuclear because it is used for load following and curtailed in summer because it is scaled for winter usage using restive heating. And comparing it to offshore with intermittent power, not dispatchable in the best location, does not make sense. With penetration wind will also be curtailed, and is already happening in china and Germany.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by i_am_proteus on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:11AM (#22180605)
Most of the world's population does not live near the equator.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kitd on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:26AM (#22180777)
The top of the bell curve is roughly on the Tropic of Cancer [1], ie roughly Central America, North Africa, Arabia, northern India, China, etc. That's a lot of solar availability for a lot of people.

[1] - https://www.themarysue.com/world-population-latitude-longitu...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:27AM (#22180802)
20 years ago most of Earth's humans did not live in cities, either.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by taw12 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:50AM (#22181099)
It's a common misconception that the closer to the equator you go the better solar panels work. Solar panels are less efficient the more heat they are exposed to.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:23AM (#22181477)
Far from being "a common misconception", it's definitely true that solar power plants closer to the equator have a higher capacity factor than solar power plants further from the equator. It's true that warm solar panels are less efficient than cooler solar panels, but there are two countervailing effects: solar panels (at a given temperature) become more efficient when more brightly illuminated, and the day is longer and there are less clouds in tropical regions. It turns out that these effects are enormously more important than the thermal effect. That's why PV in the UK has a capacity factor of 11%, German PV 10%, Maine PV 12%, California PV 28%, and Arizona PV 29%.

There's a lovely bargraph in the US at https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=39832 and an even nicer colorcoded map of the US at http://euanmearns.com/solar-pv-capacity-factors-in-the-us-th...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wayoutthere on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:11AM (#22180070)
You're not wrong here, but solar isn't the whole answer either. While storage is also important, there will always be a need for reliable "baseline" power located closer to usage centers in order to reduce strain on the national grid.

Right now, that is produced by coal or gas. Nuclear is the only realistic "green" option to replace them. Newer small-scale sealed reactor designs make nuclear energy both safer and cheaper than it ever has been. Solar / wind / hydro will certainly displace a lot of coal and gas, but they're not the whole answer in every location.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by keanzu on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:47AM (#22180364)
> power located closer to usage centers

If you are willing to throw money at the problem then high voltage DC transmission lines can move a lot of power over long distances with surprisingly little loss.

A 1,100 kV link in China was completed in 2019 over a distance of 3,300 km with a power of 12 GW. HVDC transmission losses are quoted as less than 3% per 1,000 km.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by belorn on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:31AM (#22181562)
What did that cost per km? A large part of the nuclear vs renewable discussing is one about which is cheaper.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:25AM (#22182260)
Probably not much more than regular transmission lines. Making transmission lines higher in voltage means that they can carry more power over the same amount of current, which means the same amount of aluminum. You just have to put them further apart.

A lot of the costs of transmission lines have to do with safety: it's dangerous to repair them, even when you take expensive safety measures. AC and DC lines have different safety characteristics. You've probably seen the videos of helicopter transmission line mechanics working on HVAC lines like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x94BH9TUiHM — you see those meter-long arcs when they establish and terminate contact with the lines? Those don't happen on HVDC lines. But HVDC lines have their own special safety concerns. We just don't have the century-plus of experience with them, so it wouldn't be surprising if they were more dangerous at first.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by keanzu on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:28AM (#22182303)
Unknown.

ABB has won orders worth over $300 million to supply breakthrough technologies for the world's first 1,100 kilovolt (kV) ultra-high-voltage direct current (UHVDC) transmission link. [1]

For an 8 GW 40 km link laid under the English Channel, the cost was ~£750M.

An April 2010 announcement for a 2,000 MW, 64 km line between Spain and France is estimated at €700 million. This includes the cost of a tunnel through the Pyrenees.

I'd guess ABB's contract was equipment only and that installing 3000km of power line would have been the majority of the costs based on the Spanish/English/French pricing.

[1] https://new.abb.com/news/detail/13922/abb-wins-orders-of-ove...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by arghwhat on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:24AM (#22180177)
At the same time, nuclear, coal and gas are exactly the power sources that you do not want located close to usage centers, due to their environmental problems. If grid strain is a concern, local storage is likely the best solution, which could be charged slowly from large remote sites. A small windmill or solar farm could also be present nearby.

Plus, with solar panels on the roof and batteries like the PowerWall, it's possible for many homes to be self-sufficient from the solar panels, as well as run off their storage (even if charged by the grid instead of solar) to offload the grid, either due to supply issues or just to level out peak demand.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:14AM (#22181367)
No, not for winter heating, also shared is cheaper than privately owned.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:29AM (#22182322)
You can definitely provide winter heating from rooftop solar panels except within the Arctic and Antarctic circles. Shared things may or may not be cheaper than privately owned; it depends on the particular situation. A utility-scale battery energy storage system needs inverters and distribution lines, each of which have both costs and energy losses; a home battery energy storage system doesn't need distribution lines and may not need inverters. And even if you have shared utility energy storage, it may not meet your reliability needs, so you may need private energy storage anyway, as most data centers do, adding to the costs.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by arghwhat on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:26PM (#22187164)
Solar in winter is not as bad as you might think. Up here in Scandinavia, the primary issue is the shortened days, which obviously cut our capacity a bit.

However, if you're using electric heating in your country, maybe we should start by fixing that first. Use something more efficient like ground heat exchange, and possibly remote heating for residential areas. Electric heating is silly.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by readams on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:56AM (#22180446)
there is no technology that exists or is contemplated that can provide storage at the required scale. renewables are very cheap when they are a smaller percentage of the power, but as the percentage increases you need to massively over provision them to deal with the variability.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by arghwhat on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:13AM (#22180638)
For current large-scale battery projects, see the 100MW (soon 150MW) Tesla battery deployment in Australia.

It is also much easier to install something like a PowerWall in individual homes, and alternative storage forms such as good ol' potential energy storage with water dams or hoisted weights are also available.

Finally, unlike with coal/gas/nuclear where plant size and number has a direct negative environmental impact (one thing being that they all need to run idle even if unused), over-provisioning with renewable energy, especially wind, is not really a problem.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wayoutthere on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:20AM (#22182202)
PowerWall doesn't remotely scale to grid-scale, and 150MW battery deployments don't begin to address the hundreds of 2000+ MW coal plants [1] out there. They're a band-aid that only works in specific use cases. Battery manufacture, recycling and transport, combined with the need to replace most of the cells every decade are seen to largely negate both the carbon offset and cost benefits of solar.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_coal_power_stations

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by keanzu on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:35AM (#22190886)
PowerWall scales fine, like most things do, with infinite money. All you need is a ~$10K [1] investment (including installation) for every house every 10 years (warranty period) and voila - grid scale! Oh warranty doesn't cover normal degradation of energy capacity over time. [2]

[1] https://www.energysage.com/solar/solar-energy-storage/tesla-...

[2] https://www.solarquotes.com.au/blog/new-powerwall-warranty/

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:30AM (#22182339)
Clearly you haven't done the calculations. And what is this nonsense about negating carbon offsets?
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:05AM (#22180552)
You'll probably want to read the calculations in Dercuano about lithium reserves, but I agree that massive overprovisioning is a better solution than just massive batteries.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by skitout on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:27AM (#22180194)
Well, hydro is still a big source of energy... A diversified renewable energy mix, including offshore wind is much less intermittent than what u imagine

Massive investment in both energy efficiency and demand-response would reduce the need of electricity (even with electric car), and would make the energy consumption more controlable...

And mechanical, thermal and electricity storage could be the final peace allowing a mostly renewable grid... Nuclear could definitely help, but not required

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by belorn on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:47AM (#22181772)
https://www.electricitymap.org shows a rather simple pattern. When the wind is clam in EU it goes brown in most countries right now. I take a walk outside and even if south of Sweden is only a single data point, I can often make a pretty good prediction about the color of the map.

More dynamic energy grid and storage could change that, as could investment in nuclear. In the mean time the investment money are currently going into the combination of gas plants and wind farms. Its a local maximum where investment into wind pays off as it is cheaper than fossil fuels when the winds blows, and investment into natural gas pays when the wind is still because then its a sellers market.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by koheripbal on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:32AM (#22180234)
Hydro is not possible in most locations. Diversification is important, but each region must have its own 99.95% reliable power sources.

The national grid cannot provide power beyond a few hundred miles without major losses in power. If you look at Quebec, as an example, they lose between 20-40% of their power in transmission because the hydro dams are so much further north than the population centers.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:41AM (#22182525)
"Cannot" and "does not" are not the same thing; existing 735kV lines in Québec have losses in the 5%–8% range, and new HVDC designs can lower the losses even further. HVDC transmission is potentially economical even at transoceanic distances — thousands of "miles", if you insist on using poorly defined units from the Roman Empire.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydro-Qu%C3%A9bec's_electricit...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by tim333 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:59PM (#22188236)
As a point of comparison with the UK's forthcoming Hinkley C reactor they negotiated "£92.50/MWh (in 2012 prices) which will be adjusted (linked to inflation)" which comes to about US$135 per MWh just now. That is on the high side for nuclear but still illustrates that it can cost a fair bit.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by fifnir on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:10AM (#22180063)
Can solar scale enough to cover our needs or would we run into space issues? (And keep in mind most countries don't have the USA's space availability) What would be the environmental impact of covering as much land as we need to cover with photovoltaics or wind turbines?
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:18AM (#22180118)
http://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/15/pdf/rap-enq/r2195-t1.pd...

"Lors de leur audition précitée, les représentants du BRGM ont indiqué que pour remplacer un réacteur nucléaire de 1 GW fonctionnant avec un facteur de charge de 75 %, il faudrait recouvrir 5200hectares de panneaux photovoltaïques, soit la moitié de la surface de Paris."

Replacing a 1GW nuclear reactor (a power plan can have 2, 3 or 4) with a capacity factor of 75% will need 5200h of solar panels, half of Paris surface.

This doesn't also solve the transport and storage issues to handle the intermittence.

After that you simply have to do the maths. Knowing that solar panels are loosing efficiency over time and needs to be replaced after 20 years. Nuclear power plants are currently holding after 70 years.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by iso1631 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:36AM (#22180269)
5200h is 52km2

France is 551,695 km2

So 1/10,000th of france would be needed for 1GW

A 1GW reactor produces 9 billion kwh a year

France's entire electric requirement is 450 billion, so needs about 50GW, or 0.5% of France's surface area.

Based on those figures, space isn't a problem.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:58AM (#22180478)
If you draw a 50x50km square on a map of France, you'll quickly realize that's an area the size of Luxembourg - not exactly negligible.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by iso1631 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:01AM (#22190741)
Pretty much. How much is used by vinyards? Or farms?

It's the yellow dots here

https://imgur.com/418BI6Q

France has about 1 million km of roads [1], lets assume at least 2m wide. That's 2,000 sq km.

How many of these roads can you see on this picture

https://imgur.com/FCyt4O6

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_road_netw...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:30AM (#22180840)
A 50×50 km square would be 2500 km². We're talking about 52 km², which is a 7.2 km × 7.2 km square. Shitty dimensional analysis strikes again!
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:37AM (#22180916)
> A 50×50 km square would be 2500 km². We're talking about 52 km², which is a 7.2 km × 7.2 km square. Shitty dimensional analysis strikes again!

According to the parent poster, those 52 km² are needed for 1GW. France needs around 50GW, 50 times more power and area, ergo 2500 km².

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:00AM (#22181931)
Oh, I see. Thank you for clarifying.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by fifnir on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:24PM (#22184021)
The US would need about 50x500km !
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:11AM (#22181329)
It is becoming very hard to install news wind onshore in France, people are revolting against wind turbine because it decrease real estate price and are found ugly and noisy, and it is happening at a way lower penetration rate than Germany.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by koheripbal on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:33AM (#22180246)
Generation isn't the bottleneck - it's the storage.

Solar produces dramatically less power in the winter, and having season long storage is not practical.

As an example, the largest plant in Arizona produces only 10% in January compared to June.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:08AM (#22180577)
Seasonal grid-scale energy storage is indeed not practical, but a factor of 10 is unusually large; the sun angle doesn't change that much. (Must be clouds?) Even seasonal thermal stores are infeasible under some circumstances, although in other circumstances they do work. Massive overprovisioning is probably practical. Demand response is definitely practical, and in Arizona happens by coincidence to some extent, but it remains to be seen whether the reduction delivered by demand response is a factor of 2, 3, 10, or 100.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by 7952 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:21PM (#22185969)
Finding a grid connection can be a serious bottleneck. Rural substations often lack the capacity to export lots of power. And reinforcing capacity or building new lines is expensive. Interestingly this can make it viable to co-locate battery storage at solar sites. This reduces the peak power that is exported and makes the power line cheaper to build. And the battery's can be recharged from the grid if generation is low and used to generate income through storage contracts.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pfdietz on Saturday February 01, 2020 @10:22PM (#22214934)
> As an example, the largest plant in Arizona produces only 10% in January compared to June.

Utterly false.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesquite_Solar_project

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by dumbfounder on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:34AM (#22180885)
Source? From what I have seen it is more like 40%.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by skitout on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:42AM (#22180323)
1) That is why you should rely on different (renewable) complementary energy : solar, onshore wind, offshore wind, biomass, hydro

2) You don't really NEED Season long storage, but Season long thermal storage would do the job

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by koheripbal on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:00AM (#22180499)
1. This doesn't address my point at all.

2. Of course you do. Power needs to be 99.95% reliable. We cannot have entire winters without power just because the sun wasn't out enough in one particular June. ..."thermal storage" is incredibly inefficient and entirely theoretical.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:36AM (#22180899)
No, seasonal thermal energy stores are a well-known technology with many large-scale deployments: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_store

But they are only applicable in some cases. Utility-scale seasonal electrical energy storage is orders of magnitude from practicality.

You don't need it, though. Most populated places can easily install enough solar panels to provide their winter energy demands, providing a great surplus of energy during the summer.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:33PM (#22186707)
Perhaps continuous power is a luxury we can’t afford.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by Gibbon1 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:15PM (#22187091)
My thought is we could use combined cycle nature gas power plants to back stop renewable's. So lack of storage isn't the show stopper people seem to think it is.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by tonyedgecombe on Thursday January 30, 2020 @01:42AM (#22189394)
Perhaps with CCS but that is yet to be proven.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pfdietz on Sunday February 02, 2020 @12:41PM (#22218123)
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:13AM (#22181345)
Not really, you need massive seasonal storage, like giant hydrogen cavern, or lot of methane gas holder.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:08AM (#22180576)
Again, show us papers that did the maths where such things are working, even "theoretically".

Throwing techs at a problem will not solve the problem.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:10AM (#22182056)
The environmental impact of covering enough land to fulfill world marketed energy demand would probably be insignificant, especially compared to agriculture. The sun on 0.1% of the world's surface would provide all of world marketed energy demand.

There are some possible nuances, though:

1. We do need to be careful about the environmental impact of the manufacturing. Current semiconductor manufacturing is not a major polluter, but semiconductor manufacturing has been a major polluter in the past before emissions controls were imposed, and we're talking about scaling up semiconductor fabrication by about three orders of magnitude.

2. Shading a significant proportion of the Atacama, the Sahara, and the Gobi will surely produce local environmental changes. Perhaps it will give rise to new oases, as shipwrecks sometimes become artificial reefs. But it's hard to predict things like this.

3. It seems very unlikely that energy demand will remain static in the face of such a dramatic expansion of energy supply and consequent lowering of costs, so construction probably will not stop just because current world marketed energy demand is met. In the 2040s we will surely be complaining about the percentage of the Pacific that is covered in nasty solar barges.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:27AM (#22180799)
Many are only looking at solar panels in term of greenhouse gas emission in the production chain, while any kind of semiconductor processing will have a lot of chemical waste occuring.

Edit: Also, recycling solar panels isn't sraightforward at all because of heavy metals (e.g. Cadmium) being used as dopants.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:49AM (#22182629)
No, most solar panels do not contain cadmium, and cadmium is not used as a dopant in any kind of semiconductor. Cadmium telluride is a semiconductor, and there are some thin-film solar panels that use it, but the market is dominated by silicon solar panels, which do not contain any cadmium. (CdTe is the most popular thin-film type, though.) Recycling CdTe is enormously easier than mining cadmium and tellurium from ore, so it won't be a problem. If I were doing it, I'd be more worried about the tellurium than the cadmium — that shit stinks in a way that gives new layers of meaning to the word "stench". Finally, "cadmium" is not a brand name; it is a chemical element and thus does not need to be capitalized. This isn't German.

> Excretion is mainly renal although small amounts of tellurium are exhaled as dimethyl telluride which has a distinctive garlic odour which may persist for many days; Reisert (1884) reported garlic breath odour for 237 days following ingestion of 15 mg tellurium oxide.

In short, you have managed to pack so many errors into under 20 words that it required an entire paragraph to explain most of them. Your epistemology is bad and you should feel bad.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:17PM (#22183924)
Thank you for clearing that up then. For the record, I do feel bad.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:25PM (#22185411)
Sending hugs. Next time you can leave a higher-quality comment by checking Wikipedia before commenting!
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:33AM (#22180873)
Semiconductor process waste is a real problem (I used to work in an office where the old Fairchild Semiconductor plant had been, which I was told was the first Superfund site, though it wasn't) but it's actually a very manageable problem. It isn't inherent to the process in the way that CO₂ emission is inherent to burning coal, smelting steel, or making concrete, and it's orders of magnitude better than it used to be.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by arghwhat on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:17AM (#22180115)
The benefit of solar is that you can install it on homes and make them self-sufficient (using battery storage at night), or at least vastly reduce the load on the grid. It does not require "new" space, as it simply takes over your roof.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by fifnir on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:28AM (#22180807)
That would probably work in american suburbia but would it even make a dent in the power consumption of densely inhabited cities?
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by nickik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:08AM (#22180042)
Solar power is still a tiny part of global power and even in terms of growth its not dominate. Not a single industrial country is anywhere close to use solar as their primary power source.

Their are massive unsolved problem when it comes to energy distribution and storage. People love to quote prices of the cells, ignoring the larger end to end cost. Solar power will have to be replaced much, much faster then a nuclear plant. Replacing 1000s of km² of solar is a massive problem in itself.

France used nuclear to go to zero carbon power in the 70s its truly a sad state when 50 years later we are still saying 'solar is gone soon replace coal', the same thing that Jimmy Carter was advocating.

This was and is the fundamental failure of environmental policy and environmentalist have not a small part of the responsibility for the situation.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:39AM (#22180294)
> Solar power is still a tiny part of global power and even in terms of growth its not dominate. Not a single industrial country is anywhere close to use solar as their primary power source

This demonstrates how poor the humans are at reasoning about exponentials. In September 1918, the flu was still a tiny part of global mortality; not a single industrial country was anywhere close to having flu as their primary cause of death. By December it had killed several percent of the global population.

> Their[sic] are massive unsolved problem when it comes to energy distribution and storage

I think you mean transmission, not distribution, presumably because you don't know the difference. There actually aren't.

> People love to quote prices of the cells, ignoring the larger end to end cost

Nowadays people instead love to quote the prices established in power purchasing agreements won by competitive bidding; these hit a new low this week of US$15.67 per MWh in Qatar https://archive.fo/UBWWi but there are projects in many equatorial parts of the world hitting similar lows.

> Solar power will have to be replaced much, much faster then a nuclear plant

Although the most common solar modules are sold as having a 25-year lifespan, they typically continue to work after that time with modest power degradation. Solar cells made in the 1970s are still in use today. Unlike the situation with nuclear plants, there is no known danger in leaving obsolete solar panels in use. Typical nuclear plant design lifetimes are 30–40 years, though some new plants have design lifetimes of up to 60 years.

> Replacing 1000s of km² of solar is a massive problem

Yes, but it's a much cheaper massive problem to solve than replacing the 50 or more nuclear power plants that would be needed to produce the same 250 GW as 1000 km² of solar panels, assuming a typical 25% capacity factor (that's 1000 GWp). At today's prices we're talking about something like 400 billion dollars; this is comparable to the US$200B Qatar spent to prepare for the World Cup or the US$400B budget for the Siberian gas pipeline.

> This was and is the fundamental failure of environmental policy

I would rather say that the fundamental failure of environmental policy is a failure to think through possibilities and consequences using knowledge and reason, instead acting based on gut feeling. Your comment betrays a similar lack of knowledge and reasoning. I suggest you level up your game before you lose all your money in a pyramid scheme.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by nickik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:23AM (#22182230)
> I think you mean transmission, not distribution, presumably because you don't know the difference.

Any and all problems from production source to consumption fall under the category of energy distribution. That includes long range transmission, storage, last mile and so on.

> This demonstrates how poor the humans are at reasoning about exponentials. In September 1918, the flu was still a tiny part of global mortality; not a single industrial country was anywhere close to having flu as their primary cause of death. By December it had killed several percent of the global population.

Environmentalist have predicting the raise of solar since 1970. Around 15-20 years ago they started arguing 'its actually cheaper' and 'exponential growth is coming'.

Maybe humans are bad at exponentials, but they are also bad at predicting when exponentials will happen.

And as far as I can tell growth of solar has not been on that aggressive of a curve. If you want to see exponential growth of energy policy go look at the first 20 years of nuclear.

> I would rather say that the fundamental failure of environmental policy is a failure to think through possibilities and consequences using knowledge and reason, instead acting based on gut feeling. Your comment betrays a similar lack of knowledge and reasoning. I suggest you level up your game before you lose all your money in a pyramid scheme.

The difference is that my ideas are actually proven in reality. You know the thing we live in. And it has been done with technology from the 70s. So its a simple fact that if the political will exists a massive nuclear build out can be achieved very quickly and historic data is also totally clear on the fact that nuclear plants, like basically everything else, get massively cheaper if built in high volume.

Carbon energy production had a solution and it had it for 50 years. As anybody knows, carbon that escapes earlier in time is more harmful. Countries like France have done a huge service to humanity by not polluting for the last 50 years.

And not admitting the complete and utter failure of environmental policy in light of this fact is just denial. If nuclear had been adopted on a large scale, we wouldn't even be having this discussion.

Your solution basically says 'well hopefully this 5-10 industries will be able to show exponential scales in the next 30 years' because only if that happens to you have even a small chance at actually reaching 2050 goals.

> 250 GW > 400 billion dollars

If we want 250 GW of reliable power at the times we need them will require lot more then just panels.

For that same money we could just build the same basic nuclear plant over and over again, literally at the same location as current coal plants. Requiring almost no broader infrastructure change. A fraction of environmental disruption. A fraction of land use. A fraction of overall resource use. And I would be willing to be, less overall cost.

France build close to 50 GW in the 70s.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by aargh_aargh on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:11AM (#22180069)
Not to speak of the costs of waste disposal.

https://www.google.com/search?q=solar+panel+waste

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by bb88 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:22AM (#22180162)
I found this article illuminating on that topic:

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:42AM (#22180327)
Even the Grauniad article is giving far too much credit to the waste concerns; it talks a lot about the risks of cadmium leaching, for example, but the panels in current massive deployment don't contain cadmium. (By contrast, cadmium was a common anti-corrosion cladding metal for ships 50 years ago, and while it caused environmental problems, it was far from an environmental disaster. We aren't talking about PCBs or mustard gas here.)
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by nickik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:23AM (#22182227)
> About 80% of a solar panel module can be recycled

Operative word here is 'can'. The reality is that this is not happening for the most part and there is no standard solution in sight.

> The Electric Power Research Institute notes that long-term storage of used panels until recycling technologies become available may be the best option for dealing with this waste stream. Ultimately, it’s an issue that will need to be addressed as solar panels become more widespread and reach the end of their 25-plus year lifespan, much like the issue of nuclear waste. But it’s an issue that we should be able to resolve with smart policies and technologies.

Unlike with nuclear waste, this is not actually regulated or managed, most of solar cell waste is simple general electronics waste and gets resold to Africa where kids can get to take it apart. Solar also produces about 1000x more waste in volume.

In comparison not a single gram of the wast from nuclear escapes into the environment. Its all captured and accounted for, and in most countries already financed by part of the electricity price. The US already has a huge saving account with money (that is politically deadlocked).

I really don't see how this is a defense.

> But that’s only a problem for broken panels, which are relatively rare except perhaps in the wake a natural disaster like a hurricane or earthquake. In a disaster area, leaching of metals from some broken solar panels is the least of a city’s problems.

I agree that that is not to bad of a concern.

This articles seems to basically say, 'well, Michael Shellenberger, was right' BUT technology can eventually solve this. This is incredibly weak defense when it comes to the nuclear critics. They are right on some of the EV stuff, but that's not what we are talking about.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @12:38PM (#22183373)
> Operative word here is 'can'. The reality is that this is not happening for the most part and there is no standard solution in sight.

The reality is that the vast majority of solar panels are still in operation, not junked, so they are being reused rather than recycled, which is even better.

> Unlike with nuclear waste, this is not actually regulated or managed

Well, not any more than things like concrete. You can still get fined for littering if you dump broken solar panels. But there's no reason it should be regulated or managed; broken solar panels are less toxic than things like concrete, chicken bones, fluorescent light tubes, and brass pot scrubbers, and enormously less toxic than things like used cars and CRT TVs. (Even the tiny fraction of solar cells that are the CdTe thin-film type contain only a tiny amount of cadmium or tellurium.)

Spent fuel from nuclear reactors, by contrast, is extremely dangerous, and it makes sense to treat it specially.

> most of solar cell waste is simple general electronics waste

No, that is not true. The usual kind of solar cells are not circuit boards; they are silicon chips, although much larger than the usual kind, and mostly polycrystalline rather than monocrystalline. They are covered by a sheet of glass which is many times heavier than the cells themselves.

I am curious where you picked up such remarkable misconceptions about electronics recycling.