News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by fifnir on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:10AM (#22180063)
Can solar scale enough to cover our needs or would we run into space issues? (And keep in mind most countries don't have the USA's space availability) What would be the environmental impact of covering as much land as we need to cover with photovoltaics or wind turbines?
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:18AM (#22180118)
http://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/15/pdf/rap-enq/r2195-t1.pd...

"Lors de leur audition précitée, les représentants du BRGM ont indiqué que pour remplacer un réacteur nucléaire de 1 GW fonctionnant avec un facteur de charge de 75 %, il faudrait recouvrir 5200hectares de panneaux photovoltaïques, soit la moitié de la surface de Paris."

Replacing a 1GW nuclear reactor (a power plan can have 2, 3 or 4) with a capacity factor of 75% will need 5200h of solar panels, half of Paris surface.

This doesn't also solve the transport and storage issues to handle the intermittence.

After that you simply have to do the maths. Knowing that solar panels are loosing efficiency over time and needs to be replaced after 20 years. Nuclear power plants are currently holding after 70 years.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by iso1631 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:36AM (#22180269)
5200h is 52km2

France is 551,695 km2

So 1/10,000th of france would be needed for 1GW

A 1GW reactor produces 9 billion kwh a year

France's entire electric requirement is 450 billion, so needs about 50GW, or 0.5% of France's surface area.

Based on those figures, space isn't a problem.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:58AM (#22180478)
If you draw a 50x50km square on a map of France, you'll quickly realize that's an area the size of Luxembourg - not exactly negligible.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by iso1631 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:01AM (#22190741)
Pretty much. How much is used by vinyards? Or farms?

It's the yellow dots here

https://imgur.com/418BI6Q

France has about 1 million km of roads [1], lets assume at least 2m wide. That's 2,000 sq km.

How many of these roads can you see on this picture

https://imgur.com/FCyt4O6

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_road_netw...

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:30AM (#22180840)
A 50×50 km square would be 2500 km². We're talking about 52 km², which is a 7.2 km × 7.2 km square. Shitty dimensional analysis strikes again!
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:37AM (#22180916)
> A 50×50 km square would be 2500 km². We're talking about 52 km², which is a 7.2 km × 7.2 km square. Shitty dimensional analysis strikes again!

According to the parent poster, those 52 km² are needed for 1GW. France needs around 50GW, 50 times more power and area, ergo 2500 km².

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:00AM (#22181931)
Oh, I see. Thank you for clarifying.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by fifnir on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:24PM (#22184021)
The US would need about 50x500km !
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:11AM (#22181329)
It is becoming very hard to install news wind onshore in France, people are revolting against wind turbine because it decrease real estate price and are found ugly and noisy, and it is happening at a way lower penetration rate than Germany.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by koheripbal on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:33AM (#22180246)
Generation isn't the bottleneck - it's the storage.

Solar produces dramatically less power in the winter, and having season long storage is not practical.

As an example, the largest plant in Arizona produces only 10% in January compared to June.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:08AM (#22180577)
Seasonal grid-scale energy storage is indeed not practical, but a factor of 10 is unusually large; the sun angle doesn't change that much. (Must be clouds?) Even seasonal thermal stores are infeasible under some circumstances, although in other circumstances they do work. Massive overprovisioning is probably practical. Demand response is definitely practical, and in Arizona happens by coincidence to some extent, but it remains to be seen whether the reduction delivered by demand response is a factor of 2, 3, 10, or 100.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by 7952 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:21PM (#22185969)
Finding a grid connection can be a serious bottleneck. Rural substations often lack the capacity to export lots of power. And reinforcing capacity or building new lines is expensive. Interestingly this can make it viable to co-locate battery storage at solar sites. This reduces the peak power that is exported and makes the power line cheaper to build. And the battery's can be recharged from the grid if generation is low and used to generate income through storage contracts.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pfdietz on Saturday February 01, 2020 @10:22PM (#22214934)
> As an example, the largest plant in Arizona produces only 10% in January compared to June.

Utterly false.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesquite_Solar_project

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by dumbfounder on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:34AM (#22180885)
Source? From what I have seen it is more like 40%.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by skitout on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:42AM (#22180323)
1) That is why you should rely on different (renewable) complementary energy : solar, onshore wind, offshore wind, biomass, hydro

2) You don't really NEED Season long storage, but Season long thermal storage would do the job

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by koheripbal on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:00AM (#22180499)
1. This doesn't address my point at all.

2. Of course you do. Power needs to be 99.95% reliable. We cannot have entire winters without power just because the sun wasn't out enough in one particular June. ..."thermal storage" is incredibly inefficient and entirely theoretical.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:36AM (#22180899)
No, seasonal thermal energy stores are a well-known technology with many large-scale deployments: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_store

But they are only applicable in some cases. Utility-scale seasonal electrical energy storage is orders of magnitude from practicality.

You don't need it, though. Most populated places can easily install enough solar panels to provide their winter energy demands, providing a great surplus of energy during the summer.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:33PM (#22186707)
Perhaps continuous power is a luxury we can’t afford.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by Gibbon1 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:15PM (#22187091)
My thought is we could use combined cycle nature gas power plants to back stop renewable's. So lack of storage isn't the show stopper people seem to think it is.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by tonyedgecombe on Thursday January 30, 2020 @01:42AM (#22189394)
Perhaps with CCS but that is yet to be proven.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by pfdietz on Sunday February 02, 2020 @12:41PM (#22218123)
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by hokkos on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:13AM (#22181345)
Not really, you need massive seasonal storage, like giant hydrogen cavern, or lot of methane gas holder.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by edhelas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:08AM (#22180576)
Again, show us papers that did the maths where such things are working, even "theoretically".

Throwing techs at a problem will not solve the problem.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:10AM (#22182056)
The environmental impact of covering enough land to fulfill world marketed energy demand would probably be insignificant, especially compared to agriculture. The sun on 0.1% of the world's surface would provide all of world marketed energy demand.

There are some possible nuances, though:

1. We do need to be careful about the environmental impact of the manufacturing. Current semiconductor manufacturing is not a major polluter, but semiconductor manufacturing has been a major polluter in the past before emissions controls were imposed, and we're talking about scaling up semiconductor fabrication by about three orders of magnitude.

2. Shading a significant proportion of the Atacama, the Sahara, and the Gobi will surely produce local environmental changes. Perhaps it will give rise to new oases, as shipwrecks sometimes become artificial reefs. But it's hard to predict things like this.

3. It seems very unlikely that energy demand will remain static in the face of such a dramatic expansion of energy supply and consequent lowering of costs, so construction probably will not stop just because current world marketed energy demand is met. In the 2040s we will surely be complaining about the percentage of the Pacific that is covered in nasty solar barges.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:27AM (#22180799)
Many are only looking at solar panels in term of greenhouse gas emission in the production chain, while any kind of semiconductor processing will have a lot of chemical waste occuring.

Edit: Also, recycling solar panels isn't sraightforward at all because of heavy metals (e.g. Cadmium) being used as dopants.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:49AM (#22182629)
No, most solar panels do not contain cadmium, and cadmium is not used as a dopant in any kind of semiconductor. Cadmium telluride is a semiconductor, and there are some thin-film solar panels that use it, but the market is dominated by silicon solar panels, which do not contain any cadmium. (CdTe is the most popular thin-film type, though.) Recycling CdTe is enormously easier than mining cadmium and tellurium from ore, so it won't be a problem. If I were doing it, I'd be more worried about the tellurium than the cadmium — that shit stinks in a way that gives new layers of meaning to the word "stench". Finally, "cadmium" is not a brand name; it is a chemical element and thus does not need to be capitalized. This isn't German.

> Excretion is mainly renal although small amounts of tellurium are exhaled as dimethyl telluride which has a distinctive garlic odour which may persist for many days; Reisert (1884) reported garlic breath odour for 237 days following ingestion of 15 mg tellurium oxide.

In short, you have managed to pack so many errors into under 20 words that it required an entire paragraph to explain most of them. Your epistemology is bad and you should feel bad.

Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by wnkrshm on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:17PM (#22183924)
Thank you for clearing that up then. For the record, I do feel bad.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:25PM (#22185411)
Sending hugs. Next time you can leave a higher-quality comment by checking Wikipedia before commenting!
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:33AM (#22180873)
Semiconductor process waste is a real problem (I used to work in an office where the old Fairchild Semiconductor plant had been, which I was told was the first Superfund site, though it wasn't) but it's actually a very manageable problem. It isn't inherent to the process in the way that CO₂ emission is inherent to burning coal, smelting steel, or making concrete, and it's orders of magnitude better than it used to be.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by arghwhat on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:17AM (#22180115)
The benefit of solar is that you can install it on homes and make them self-sufficient (using battery storage at night), or at least vastly reduce the load on the grid. It does not require "new" space, as it simply takes over your roof.
Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004) by fifnir on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:28AM (#22180807)
That would probably work in american suburbia but would it even make a dent in the power consumption of densely inhabited cities?