Re:Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004)
by kragen on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @12:38PM
(#22183373)
> Operative word here is 'can'. The reality is that this is not happening for the most part and there is no standard solution in sight.
The reality is that the vast majority of solar panels are still in operation, not junked, so they are being reused rather than recycled, which is even better.
> Unlike with nuclear waste, this is not actually regulated or managed
Well, not any more than things like concrete. You can still get fined for littering if you dump broken solar panels. But there's no reason it should be regulated or managed; broken solar panels are less toxic than things like concrete, chicken bones, fluorescent light tubes, and brass pot scrubbers, and enormously less toxic than things like used cars and CRT TVs. (Even the tiny fraction of solar cells that are the CdTe thin-film type contain only a tiny amount of cadmium or tellurium.)
Spent fuel from nuclear reactors, by contrast, is extremely dangerous, and it makes sense to treat it specially.
> most of solar cell waste is simple general electronics waste
No, that is not true. The usual kind of solar cells are not circuit boards; they are silicon chips, although much larger than the usual kind, and mostly polycrystalline rather than monocrystalline. They are covered by a sheet of glass which is many times heavier than the cells themselves.
I am curious where you picked up such remarkable misconceptions about electronics recycling.
The reality is that the vast majority of solar panels are still in operation, not junked, so they are being reused rather than recycled, which is even better.
> Unlike with nuclear waste, this is not actually regulated or managed
Well, not any more than things like concrete. You can still get fined for littering if you dump broken solar panels. But there's no reason it should be regulated or managed; broken solar panels are less toxic than things like concrete, chicken bones, fluorescent light tubes, and brass pot scrubbers, and enormously less toxic than things like used cars and CRT TVs. (Even the tiny fraction of solar cells that are the CdTe thin-film type contain only a tiny amount of cadmium or tellurium.)
Spent fuel from nuclear reactors, by contrast, is extremely dangerous, and it makes sense to treat it specially.
> most of solar cell waste is simple general electronics waste
No, that is not true. The usual kind of solar cells are not circuit boards; they are silicon chips, although much larger than the usual kind, and mostly polycrystalline rather than monocrystalline. They are covered by a sheet of glass which is many times heavier than the cells themselves.
I am curious where you picked up such remarkable misconceptions about electronics recycling.