News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:02PM (#22156312)
Or maybe Apple just patented all of it. Assholes.

Extremely succinct. Apple's the only company possible that could get a patent for turning a page in a book.

https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/11/16/apple-now-owns-the...

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by threeseed on Sunday January 26, 2020 @10:59PM (#22156765)
Except that you're completely wrong.

It's a design patent. It's for specifically how it looks not for the actual functionality. And they are basically just given out like candy to anyone that applies since they are only useful in situations where companies do an exact 1-1 copy. Otherwise it doesn't infringe.

So feel free to create your own iBook clone knowing you won't infringe on this.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Sunday January 26, 2020 @11:49PM (#22156909)
An exact, 1-1 copy shouldn't be prevented.

Also, you're either completely wrong or completely misleading, and I can't tell which (maybe both) because of HN's history with completely misinterpreting patent law. They've gotten other software patents before (on things no more based on functionality as the above patent), and utilized them to sue opponents.

"Slide to Unlock" comes to mind.

https://www.theverge.com/2014/5/2/5676776/samsung-found-to-i...

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by threeseed on Monday January 27, 2020 @12:06AM (#22156962)
Design patents serve a useful purpose though.

Companies should be encouraged to innovate on a design and arrive at their own implementation. Otherwise you would see large companies simply duplicate en masse the works of smaller ones.

Utility patents like "slide to unlock" are obviously more about protecting an idea by patenting the most common implementation. But again in this case it was trivial to workaround since we've seen many unique phone unlock mechanisms come from the Android ecosystem.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by ascagnel_ on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:41AM (#22159635)
Design patents are why Apple sued Samsung, and won, over the Fascinate (the Verizon-branded version of the original Galaxy that was pretty naked in its attempt to clone the look & feel of iOS in that era).
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by dylan604 on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:10PM (#22156342)
This isn't just an Apple thing as this isn't the most ridiculous sounding patent (it is ridiculous) that has been posted here. There are so many patents that take an existing concept but add the phrase "on a computer" or "digitally" or some such. Is it an example of one company being an asshole or yet another example of how the patent system is patently broken?
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by crooked-v on Sunday January 26, 2020 @10:38PM (#22156700)
With company-being-an-asshole complaints, there's also game theory issues to keep in mind: because obviously stupid and invalid patents get approved all the time, not patenting something could mean being issued with patent troll lawsuits from a different company that does.

That doesn't necessarily excuse it, but there's definitely more of a motivation than 'because we can' behind what these big companies do, especially considering that most of these patents never get used for anything inherently money-making and so are just cash tossed down the drain in filing fees and time spent.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by threeseed on Sunday January 26, 2020 @11:12PM (#22156803)
> There are so many patents that take an existing concept but add the phrase "on a computer" or "digitally" or some such

Please show us just one example of this.

Because it's a myth that gets perpetuated that this is how patents work. You patent a specific implementation of a concept not the concept itself. If you implement a concept in a different way it won't infringe the patent.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by comex on Monday January 27, 2020 @12:49AM (#22157113)
> Please show us just one example of this.

How about the patents at issue in Alice v. CLS Bank? Or any of the “hundreds” of patents, according to Wikipedia, that have been found invalid by lower courts in decisions citing Alice.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:32PM (#22156449)
Why can't it be both? It's both.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by zweep on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:27PM (#22156417)
I don’t like when patents get used by big companies against small ones, but I also don’t see why a company of Google’s size should be able to just freeload on Apple’s meticulously designed interactions (that the author praises effusively) instead of designing their own.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:45PM (#22156504)
Because it's not actually in the interests of users/consumers (woohoo! over here! remember us?) for everyone to have to "design their own" interaction model.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by zweep on Sunday January 26, 2020 @11:11PM (#22156801)
Well if you believe in the “promote the useful arts” logic (I do, to an extent) then having exclusive rights to things like “butter” smooth animations makes companies like Apple more willing to invest in them, which is in the consumer’s interest.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by missingrib on Sunday January 26, 2020 @11:57PM (#22156927)
So the efforts and rights of the company don't matter anymore? We should not just legislate everything based on the interests of the consumer.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by slimsag on Monday January 27, 2020 @12:04AM (#22156947)
Ah yes, the classic "But who will think of the shareholders?!?!11" argument, good point.

Frankly, yes, regulations should exist to serve consumers not companies.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Monday January 27, 2020 @12:08AM (#22156965)
Companies aren't people, and people will always be more important than an abstraction. So let's reduce the abstraction here a bit.

80,000 Apple employees.

~330,171,224 residents of the United States of America.

      330,171,224
     -     80,000
     ------------
      330,091,224

Would you say that 330,091,224 is more than 80,000?

I would.

And really, optimizing for the rights of the consumer helps everyone, including all Apple employees. And this helps the producer, too, because it allows them to ignore software patents as well.

Software patents weren't for the good of anyone but executives and legislators when legislators first forced them on everyone against the protests of software devs everywhere decades ago, they aren't suddenly for the good of the common man, now, either.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by zweep on Monday January 27, 2020 @01:34AM (#22157256)
What makes software patents different from other patents? For example for things like the cotton gin.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Monday January 27, 2020 @02:28AM (#22157475)
https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/projects/lpf/Patents/agains...

This article explains far more elegantly than I will as to why software patents don't make sense.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:31PM (#22156433)
Apple got their start by copying Xerox, so it's only fair that other people should be able to copy Apple without repercussions. Besides, most of the most memorable gestures and interactions of iOS were under the direction of people who were fired after Jobs died.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by threeseed on Sunday January 26, 2020 @11:06PM (#22156792)
Might want to go and read the history books.

Apple didn't get their start by copying Xerox. They got their start by building and selling the Apple 1/2/3/Lisa. Xerox only came into the picture during the development of the Mac. And there is this myth that Xerox invented all of the GUI metaphors we know today. But actually about half came from Apple e.g drag & drop file manipulation, multiple file system views, drop down menus, clipboard.

Also only one person was fired from Apple and that was Scott Forstall. After whom quite a number of memorable iOS gestures were invented i.e. when the click button disappeared.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Sunday January 26, 2020 @11:44PM (#22156901)
Why do you lie? The Mac and Lisa both were post-Xerox-trip, and were only a year apart.

"got their start" was obviously intended to mean "in GUIs."

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by macintux on Sunday January 26, 2020 @10:17PM (#22156633)
Apple also paid Xerox for the use of those patents.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Sunday January 26, 2020 @10:57PM (#22156758)
Because they were sued (and it wasn't patents, as far as I'm aware, because Xerox didn't patent their GUI paradigm):

https://www.nytimes.com/1989/12/15/business/company-news-xer...

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by nottorp on Monday January 27, 2020 @06:53AM (#22158497)
Paywalled link.

Every other history piece I've read said Xerox got a good chunk of Apple shares in exchange for them using their research. Perhaps they decided it isn't enough when they saw Apple was successful and sued for more money?

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by neurostimulant on Monday January 27, 2020 @12:25AM (#22157019)
I remember when multi-finger gestures were still patented by apple so android couldn't implement despite the hardware capable of doing so [1]. Not sure what happened but the feature eventually land on android 2.x.

[1] https://androidcommunity.com/google-axed-android-multitouch-...

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by egdod on Sunday January 26, 2020 @10:29PM (#22156677)
That's a design patent, not a utility patent.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by classified on Monday January 27, 2020 @07:19AM (#22158640)
Well, Amazon got a mouse click patented.