News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by dylan604 on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:10PM (#22156342)
This isn't just an Apple thing as this isn't the most ridiculous sounding patent (it is ridiculous) that has been posted here. There are so many patents that take an existing concept but add the phrase "on a computer" or "digitally" or some such. Is it an example of one company being an asshole or yet another example of how the patent system is patently broken?
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by crooked-v on Sunday January 26, 2020 @10:38PM (#22156700)
With company-being-an-asshole complaints, there's also game theory issues to keep in mind: because obviously stupid and invalid patents get approved all the time, not patenting something could mean being issued with patent troll lawsuits from a different company that does.

That doesn't necessarily excuse it, but there's definitely more of a motivation than 'because we can' behind what these big companies do, especially considering that most of these patents never get used for anything inherently money-making and so are just cash tossed down the drain in filing fees and time spent.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by threeseed on Sunday January 26, 2020 @11:12PM (#22156803)
> There are so many patents that take an existing concept but add the phrase "on a computer" or "digitally" or some such

Please show us just one example of this.

Because it's a myth that gets perpetuated that this is how patents work. You patent a specific implementation of a concept not the concept itself. If you implement a concept in a different way it won't infringe the patent.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by comex on Monday January 27, 2020 @12:49AM (#22157113)
> Please show us just one example of this.

How about the patents at issue in Alice v. CLS Bank? Or any of the “hundreds” of patents, according to Wikipedia, that have been found invalid by lower courts in decisions citing Alice.

Re:iOS First Impressions (2018) by kick on Sunday January 26, 2020 @09:32PM (#22156449)
Why can't it be both? It's both.