Re:iOS First Impressions (2018)
by threeseed on Monday January 27, 2020 @12:06AM
(#22156962)
Design patents serve a useful purpose though.
Companies should be encouraged to innovate on a design and arrive at their own implementation. Otherwise you would see large companies simply duplicate en masse the works of smaller ones.
Utility patents like "slide to unlock" are obviously more about protecting an idea by patenting the most common implementation. But again in this case it was trivial to workaround since we've seen many unique phone unlock mechanisms come from the Android ecosystem.
Re:iOS First Impressions (2018)
by ascagnel_ on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:41AM
(#22159635)
Design patents are why Apple sued Samsung, and won, over the Fascinate (the Verizon-branded version of the original Galaxy that was pretty naked in its attempt to clone the look & feel of iOS in that era).
Companies should be encouraged to innovate on a design and arrive at their own implementation. Otherwise you would see large companies simply duplicate en masse the works of smaller ones.
Utility patents like "slide to unlock" are obviously more about protecting an idea by patenting the most common implementation. But again in this case it was trivial to workaround since we've seen many unique phone unlock mechanisms come from the Android ecosystem.