I'm with you 100%. I lived in SF from 1998-2006, then again for a few years in the 2010's, and when rental prices are high landlords seem to prefer holding out rather than lowering their rates. I assume this is to avoid locking a potentially valuable rental unit into a low, rent-controlled lease. (On a side note, this is why many economists believe rent control is bad overall for rental markets: http://freakonomics.com/podcast/rent-control/)
(1) Repealing prop-13 is probably a non-starter but we could probably get away with repealing it for non-owner-occupied homes. Prop-13 was meant to prevent people from being driven from their homes by property tax increases, not to protect speculators from being taxed.
(2) Levy a substantial additional property tax on residential properties that are not currently occupied by either the owner or a renter (for more than e.g. 6 months). These should at the very least be on the rental market.
(3) Subject all real estate purchases and investments to KYC/AML and other rules. AFAIK one of the things driving this loony real estate speculation is that RE has become a preferred vehicle for money laundering after KYC/AML made other financial investments less attractive for that.
(4) Tax foreign (non-US-citizen) purchases of residential real estate. Yes they'd set up shells and recruit locals to be proxy buyers, but at least this would give them more hoops to jump through and would probably reduce the extent of the problem.
I have never lived in California, and Prop 13 passed before I was born anyway, so I don't know much about the political backstory. That said, if this was the purpose that got it passed, why is the exemption so broad? How does capping Safeway's property taxes keep people from being driven out of their homes?
But getting anyone to fix proposition 13--even in this very limited instance of not protecting corporations anymore--brings out all the apocalyptic messaging (from basically everyone, but especially the corporations) that the old folks who bought in 1970 and have lived their whole lives there will be out on the street when their property taxes go up 10x.
There is no nuance in these messaging battles. And quite frankly, what property owner wants to take any kind of risk with this?
So permanent residents and visa holders cannot buy property and are instead forced to rent? What a terrible idea.
edit: forgot to add non-primary home.
Just do what Texas does and allow deferred property tax payments for when the owner dies or sells.
Why should we be giving tax breaks to people who have seen incredible appreciation of their homes. Those are the last people who should be getting tax breaks.
> Why should we be giving tax breaks to people who have seen incredible appreciation of their homes. Those are the last people who should be getting tax breaks.
It's about not forcing people to move because he area they live in appreciates suddenly. Basically, the same argument as rent control. That an owner gets to cash out some value is cold comfort when their life is uprooted against their will.
The end result is, if the owner chooses, they can continue paying the same property rate until they die or sell. The govt eventually collects the full tax from the equity of the house (or estate).
You solve the issue of people being forced from their homes while at the same time being more equitable in terms of tax burden.
In your grandparents case, they could freeze their property taxes, but when the houses switches ownership, they’d need to pay all the back taxes they avoided with the cap.
Why shouldn’t your grandparents have to pay current property taxes? They just had a windfall increase in property value.
Of course, none of that is going to happen anytime soon…
Prop 50: pass your current tax rate on to your children.
Prop 68: pass your current tax rate on to your grandchildren.
So the homes just sit... empty.
Surely that's not significantly more burdensome than the bureaucratic hassle of purchasing the property in the first place.
I guess there's some significant tax/regulatory difference between capital gains from holding property vs. an income stream from renting said property.
And in the Bay Area people invest more for appreciation than rent. The rent/price ratio is much higher elsewhere.
unfortunately management companies require managing themselves. even if you find a good one, they won't necessarily stay good, so you're firing them, getting new ones, etc.
and i've never heard of one that will let you hand them a property, and then eat all of the risk for you and provide a simple de-risked income stream. even if they'll do a good job of handling 100% of maintenance tasks, they're still going to send you the bills.
anybody who can afford to de-risk a real estate income stream can afford to just buy real estate themselves, they don't need yours. there's no market here.
Sounds like an opportunity here! The Chinese market for "stores of value" is quite high! There are tons of largely empty high-rise condos in China for this very reason. What about a company that has the connections and know-how to smooth over the transactions, then puts management into place to get AirBNB/rental income?
These debates always turn into anecdotes that cover up the real reasons why people oppose or support housing—a preference for the suburban or urban lifestyle respectively. People who argue that newly-built condo buildings are mostly vacant always happen to prefer the suburban lifestyle; people who argue that newly-built condo buildings provide much-needed housing always happen to prefer the urban lifestyle (including me). It's all a facade.
The actual vacancy rate in San Francisco, as we expect, is relatively low for US cities.
On the other hand that can be detrimental to the economy depending on how something like that is implemented.
Rules around vacant homes are good, though, and I strongly support them.
There are more nuances to this. Chinese millionaires and billionaires don't care about the sales price. They do it to diversify their portfolio to avoid CCP. Some of them did this to launder the dirty money as well.
Their numbers might be small but the chilling effect of outbidding everybody else outrageously will incentivized realtors to spread the "good news" to their customers/clients that "hey... that unit over there is sold $ x million dollars, would you be interested to sell yours as well?"
Suddenly before you know it, the market is f*cked.
As a bonus those property owners are politically active and fight zoning reform and development/transit projects to protect aforementioned real estate boom.
Even if the empty home consumes no water, electricity, classroom capacity, bus seats, etc., it still consumes police and fire protection services. Someone else's empty home can be used for crime without worrying about civil forfeitures.
A better resident lives in their home, and cares about what is happening in its neighborhood.
At the end of the day, it's not good for the local residents.
It's not as simple as "they're not here thus they're not consuming any services". The resulting effect of sky-high property cost ripples to everything else below it (jobs, transportation, etc).
False, even if you're not US resident, you still have to file non-resident tax returns and pay taxes on all US sourced income.
https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/nonr...
> A nonresident alien (NRA) usually is subject to U.S. income tax only on U.S. source income.
The solution to this is to fix the tax code, not retreat further into nationalism.
Such an affinity is not "natural" because no one is born with any sort of innate ability to distinguish among nationalities, much less feel any affinity towards certain nationalities.
Any such distinctions and feelings are taught through indoctrination such as nationalistic rituals, media, and the attitudes of those around you.
A nationality is a legal fiction which changes absolutely nothing about who a person really is or what they do.
Nationalism and group affiliation have been the causes of some of the worst atrocities in history, so we should be very wary of encouraging either.
Regardless of their nationality, I personally feel much more affinity with someone who is helping others over one who is hurting others.
You can iteratively, conservatively try to approach an equilibrium where borders and divisions no longer matter and all of humanity joins together in enlightenment. That seems to be the general direction we're going and it's a good thing. What you can't do is unilaterally make a cooperative system out of a competitive one. If you go all at once by yourself you just get killed.
Nationality is a big (and in some cases literal) Chesterton's Fence. It is somewhat arbitrary, but that doesn't make it meaningless.
* people you love, care about, or otherwise know socially
* groups that are oppressed along some axis
* all of humanity
Yeah, that's gross.
the homes are sold for profit, which does leave the country. but more importantly, there is a housing shortage. plus, the costs are kept high.
I think this a fairly superficial claim. I agree that there are reasons to question the moral basis of national borders (why should someone be given additional rights based on where they were born?) but there are immense practical benefits that arise from having national borders. From a utilitarian perspective, these practical benefits likely outweigh the costs.
In the case of placing additional taxes and restrictions on foreign investment in real estate - yes, this may restrict the freedom of foreigners, but the overall benefit of these laws could be sufficient moral justification.
Faceless "wealthy foreigners" are easier to dislike than their own neighbors who show up at planning commission meetings to rant about someone adding an extra bedroom to their home (this is an actual thing I read about in San Francisco).
My point is that there's a small but persistent current of thought regarding the housing crisis that wants to pin the blame on "wealthy foreigners buying up all our real estate", as sort of an 'out' for taking a good, hard look at local housing policies.
If the property tax is paid and the maintenance is kept up what is the problem created solely by the fact some homes are empty? The only reason these properties have such high values is because there is a demand that is not being supplied. Supplying more housing makes this a non-issue.
> San Francisco has felt the brunt of this due to their insanely restrictive development laws.
This is the real issue. Governments restrict housing supply for whatever misguided reasons and prices go up, those prices make it a good place to park cash. Government should stop picking winners and losers.
Some look at the situation, question what's different about SF that might be causing this, and point to the highly restrictive development laws the city has. These prevent new comers from entering the market leaving only those who are primarily playing the long game and looking to build wide moats. If investors who required a much shorter return could compete, it's assumed the situation would normalize
If this isn't the case, then what is the underlying issue? Simply attacking wealthy people for doing something that is a) completely legal and b) obviously providing them some sort of benefit doesn't solve the underlying problem. To look at it another way, SF has clearly been trying to "solve" this problem through increased regulation for many decades now. Where are the success stories we can point to that show the direct approach is working?
Restriction of housing is not limited to Government, housing developers also do it:
"[Kate] Barker reached a similar conclusion in her interim report, where she noted that in order to maximize their profits, developers control the rate of production and ‘trickle out’ no more than 100–200 houses a year from a large development. ‘This may not be desirable from society’s point of view,’ she wrote." (from https://www.annaminton.com/bigcapital)
Personally, I trust the reasons that a Government would limit housing more than I would a for-profit company who are probably operating in the interests of investors who don't live in the affected areas.
Even more than Big Government control though, I would prefer the people that live in an area to have the biggest say into how things are run.
The fact still remains though that the housing developers wouldn't be able to trickle out homes at their whim if the government enforced limits on housing weren't preventing other developers from competing.
If the property ends up vacant for 2 years, government appoints random renters - for a maximum rent no higher than the rate the lowest 10% city-wide is. No possibility of eviction for ten years, except for willful/grossly negligent damage to property or unfit conduct (e.g. disturbing the peace, running drug dens or harassment of other renters). If an owner intentionally does not repair damages to claim the tax exception, government is authorized to do the repairs themselves and recoup costs from the owner.
That should be proper incentive for developers to build housing that is actually wanted and for speculation owners to rent out homes and to keep them intact/rentable.
Edit: for the downvoters, please explain why. This is a system that is the law in Berlin, only with a drastically higher tax rate and lower minimum rent.
The comment reads as an extreme solution that no one would ever implement. The fact that it is already implemented somewhere gives it a lot more credibility.
Was this system intended for the homeless?
Were there many vacants before?
How has the offer responded to such measures?
How difficult is to evict a grossly negligent or misbehaved tenant?
The rise of foreign money parking money in real estate has screwed things up on a global level. San Francisco has felt the brunt of this due to their insanely restrictive development laws.
Frankly, for the 7+ years I was in San Francisco I was always saying they should pass laws to prevent foreign investment in real estate or at a minimum require people live there for X% of the year.