There are more nuances to this. Chinese millionaires and billionaires don't care about the sales price. They do it to diversify their portfolio to avoid CCP. Some of them did this to launder the dirty money as well.
Their numbers might be small but the chilling effect of outbidding everybody else outrageously will incentivized realtors to spread the "good news" to their customers/clients that "hey... that unit over there is sold $ x million dollars, would you be interested to sell yours as well?"
Suddenly before you know it, the market is f*cked.
As a bonus those property owners are politically active and fight zoning reform and development/transit projects to protect aforementioned real estate boom.
Even if the empty home consumes no water, electricity, classroom capacity, bus seats, etc., it still consumes police and fire protection services. Someone else's empty home can be used for crime without worrying about civil forfeitures.
A better resident lives in their home, and cares about what is happening in its neighborhood.
At the end of the day, it's not good for the local residents.
It's not as simple as "they're not here thus they're not consuming any services". The resulting effect of sky-high property cost ripples to everything else below it (jobs, transportation, etc).
False, even if you're not US resident, you still have to file non-resident tax returns and pay taxes on all US sourced income.
https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/nonr...
> A nonresident alien (NRA) usually is subject to U.S. income tax only on U.S. source income.
The solution to this is to fix the tax code, not retreat further into nationalism.
Such an affinity is not "natural" because no one is born with any sort of innate ability to distinguish among nationalities, much less feel any affinity towards certain nationalities.
Any such distinctions and feelings are taught through indoctrination such as nationalistic rituals, media, and the attitudes of those around you.
A nationality is a legal fiction which changes absolutely nothing about who a person really is or what they do.
Nationalism and group affiliation have been the causes of some of the worst atrocities in history, so we should be very wary of encouraging either.
Regardless of their nationality, I personally feel much more affinity with someone who is helping others over one who is hurting others.
You can iteratively, conservatively try to approach an equilibrium where borders and divisions no longer matter and all of humanity joins together in enlightenment. That seems to be the general direction we're going and it's a good thing. What you can't do is unilaterally make a cooperative system out of a competitive one. If you go all at once by yourself you just get killed.
Nationality is a big (and in some cases literal) Chesterton's Fence. It is somewhat arbitrary, but that doesn't make it meaningless.
* people you love, care about, or otherwise know socially
* groups that are oppressed along some axis
* all of humanity
Yeah, that's gross.
the homes are sold for profit, which does leave the country. but more importantly, there is a housing shortage. plus, the costs are kept high.
I think this a fairly superficial claim. I agree that there are reasons to question the moral basis of national borders (why should someone be given additional rights based on where they were born?) but there are immense practical benefits that arise from having national borders. From a utilitarian perspective, these practical benefits likely outweigh the costs.
In the case of placing additional taxes and restrictions on foreign investment in real estate - yes, this may restrict the freedom of foreigners, but the overall benefit of these laws could be sufficient moral justification.
Faceless "wealthy foreigners" are easier to dislike than their own neighbors who show up at planning commission meetings to rant about someone adding an extra bedroom to their home (this is an actual thing I read about in San Francisco).
My point is that there's a small but persistent current of thought regarding the housing crisis that wants to pin the blame on "wealthy foreigners buying up all our real estate", as sort of an 'out' for taking a good, hard look at local housing policies.
Rules around vacant homes are good, though, and I strongly support them.