This already happens in India. I can’t remember the title but there was a film where two stars from neighbouring states (I think it was Kerala and Tamil Nadu) fought each other and each one won the final battle in their respective states.
https://slate.com/culture/2015/07/inside-out-director-pete-d...
The problem is that this doesn’t play out well at all and isn’t sustainable for the production houses actually working on the film. VFX work on a film can finish months, and few weeks, of days before a release date. As soon as that deadline is hit, workers either: go on break, get reallocated to another show, or leave as their contract is up (non-contract artists are very few in this industry). Having to pull people that worked on a show back to fixes after being put on a new one, or they may be completely gone, will only damage the show they are currently working on.
It’s not a practice that is sustainable, and with the pretty thin margins of VFX right now isn’t something that is as simple to solve as keep people around or hire more. And most studios can’t follow MPC/Technicolor’s philosophy of throwing as many junior bodies at the task.
Of course, not everything could be automated but I think a good portion of it could be. The original VFX team would just have to insert "markers" into the workflow which could then be replaced and re-rendered. Almost like changing build flags and recompiling a program.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLg5CZ-AG0g&feature=emb_titl...
This shows a product that apparently can scan a video for good places to put ads, and then replace or insert advertisements into it. And by "insert" I mean "add branded cups on the table where none existed" or "add a billboard to the cityscape where none existed". Scary stuff, I absolutely hate that people are working on such things.
This was literally the project I worked on this summer, as an application of GANs for "image translation". We basically trained some of the latest GAN models on our dataset of Pepsi and Coke bottles. Thankfully, all the research papers are accompanied by complete tensorflow/pytorch implementations so we only had to do minor modifications to train/test them on our dataset. The results were mixed, it worked pretty well for bottles on white backgrounds, and one network properly learnt the importance of orientation of the logo (horizontally flipped images generated corresponding flipped target logos). The field is pretty nascent, and from the papers I've read, NVIDIA Research seems to be making good progress on this. I believe in two or three years, we can definitely see this tech in production.
The ability to make changes like that already exist. Scenes and assets built procedurally can be altered with relative ease as long as they don’t encroach on other aspects of the shot.
> Specifically things like changing sponsor logos or animation models.
Logos and for the most part basic comp-only changes? Yeah that’s fine. Animation model is a completely different story. Changing the base model means the UV’s likely changed so the texture artists will have to either update (can be complex if they’re trying to maintain their original stack) or redo their work. It means the rig needs to be updated and modified. If it’s a muscle based system for precise and realistic skin deformation, have fun. If there character has fur, then the grooming team has to do another take on the asset as well. Animation then needs to make another pass on their scenes to make sure the animation actually looks good and lookdev needs to make tweaks to maintain the look they had before. And then you have to rerender, which will likely conflict with the rendering allocations (if using an on-prem farm) of the current deliverable unless the studio is in a lull point. And rendering takes time. Then comp gets to deal with the change and make sure it still sits in the shot. And we still haven’t discussed the time and tweaks to re-sim and cache any affected effects.
For a movie like Cats, this is going to be a lot of work, with a ton of anim, matchmove, and comp fixes.
> The original VFX team would just have to insert "markers" into the workflow which could then be replaced and re-rendered. Almost like changing build flags and recompiling a program.
That is a significant misrepresentation/and lack of understanding of how these pipelines work and function. No matter how much you can automate, this is not just data the way the typical HN user sees things. This is someone’s art and vision, and will always require a hands on approach with human eyes. If it was as simple as changing a few parameters or altering a few lines of code, there would be far fewer people in the industry.
If they are paid to provide "tail" work to adjust "released" movies they'll take money and happily do it. If the money is there, they'll adjust resource allocation as needed.
(The interesting thing here is what "released" means now -- that seems to be a soft concept now.)
The shared cultural experience of the movie is lost if everyone has different scenes, if the jokes are different, if the details vary too much.
It would be quite easy to fall into uncanny valley territory.
20 years later I found out that there was such a scene, and it was just as I remembered, but it was only in an extended, poorly made tv-edition cut that was never shown in theatres.
I still don't know what happened there, really.
This already happens. Pixar movies for example do this, Inside Out for example used different region-specific foods that kids didn't like for that memory in the movie. Movies released in China and the US often are cut differently where in China the Chinese actor or actress is given more prominence in the plot.
There is an interesting bit in Le Ton Beau de Marot about the French translation of Gödel Escher Bach where Hofstadter says he instructed the French translation team to feel free to "culturally translate" analogies and examples etc, but is horrified when they translate a personal anecdote about attending an American football game in Ann Arbor into a rugby match.
Like how in 90s videogames localisers thought they were being smart renaming items from Rice Ball to Hamburger. Usually without changing the sprites.
I’d prefer it if the initial ideas and setting of the story were kept in tact and just translated rather than someone trying to be smart about it and failing.
Did you hear how many changes they had to Harry Potter to make it understandable to an American audience? And that's the same language even!
Perhaps because USAns don't have as much interest in pseudoscience as British ;-)
https://www.hp-lexicon.org/2001/08/25/differences-between-br...
Having it explicitly done in a transparent way would actually be an improvement. It would trigger the necessary alerts for archivists to get to work, and we’d never risk losing the historical record of a film.
It could spectacularly backfire when the audience say "let's wait until they release version 3 in a few months, after they've patched up the shitty parts the beta viewers didn't like.".
Yesterday I saw the headline that in Singapore, a lesbian kiss was deleted from the Skywalker movie, so a version of your idea exists.
What's special about Cats is that they changed the movie after it "shipped". This is a watershed like when video games started getting day one patches. Super Mario Brothers had no day one patch, it was a physical hunk of metal and plastic, when we played Outer Worlds we set apart an hour the day before for the patches to apply, knowing there would be patches because all games do that now.
That film cemented Gary Oldman as my favorite actor for that decade. It’s also just a really good action film. And I was bummed when Danny Aiello passed and hardly anyone mentioned Old Tony.
Test screenings are a thing and they can very much influence the final product: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Test_screening
I guess they didn't test Cats.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Big_Blue#Original_and_alte...
soo... what happened with evangelion?
Cinema as a Service (CaaS)?
> We're going to wind up in some terrible place where if you pre-order your movie ticket you can see the Target special edition of Avengers Endgame 8 that is only available in theaters for two weeks before it switches to some other version. Maybe we'll get to the point where movie theaters will just perpetually have the same film on roll and update it every couple of months with the latest patches like an MMO. Remember, your Avengers and Superman subscriptions are different.
Not sure about the last one, but you could imagine lots of possibilities:
- Regional versions of films with anything from chunks of dialog ("I'm from X") up through entire cityscape backgrounds changed depending on the theater location. With CG, even things like character appearance (e.g. race) could be regional.
- Brand placement: Top sponsor's products appear in the first two weeks of showings, then second bidder for the next two weeks, etc.
- A/B testing different versions of films with live audiences and tweaking.
- The opposite of what akersten said: introduce new little easter eggs or features regularly over the course of the film's theater run to encourage repeat ticket buying from the hardcore fans.
What else?