To be honest, as a Chinese, I don’t believe the claim that Huawei has no government ties. But I don’t think it’s what Huawei wants.
- By Someone
It's still entirely in the realm of possibility that the Chinese diplomat in question asked for unfair non-market advantage, but I find it quite unnecessary because Huawei's technology is already competitive on its own, why spend political capital for such minute economic gains? A more probable story, as has already happened in many other countries, is that local ISP chooses Huawei based on price and competitiveness and is blocked by government on security grounds, then Chinese diplomats step in to remove that block based on other stick and carrots.
Basically, China agreed to license CDMA from Qualcomm, despite already deploying GSM. Once China started paying, the US dropped its objections.
So I think it’s quite normal for politicians to advocate for their nation’s companies.
They either care for intelligence gathering or political reasons. Politically it could be anything from ideology to corruption and backroom politics. But, again the economic angle is hardly worth the effort when their risking a major backlash.
The social credit system for businesses is there just for this.
Just observe how Apple has changed since that launched.
Genuine question - What are the big European network infra equipment makers? You only ever hear of US and Chinese companies like Cisco and Huawei operating in this space.
But today they are still much more expensive than Huawei, AND their bet on Intel 10nm Custom Foundry didn't help.
Again, blame Intel.
The relationship between the US and Europe for many reasons is different, most specifically, the US will not use 'Cisco spying' to steal German companies IP, or to otherwise screw up Germany.'
In the bigger picture, the US provides the first and last line of defence to Europe. Putin is actively trying to 'pull a Crimea' in the Baltic states and only US led activities are keeping them out. That's the top of the iceberg.
Also the 'Cisco spying' that is done by the US, mostly in the Middle East etc. actually has a lot of security value for Europe.
Of course, Europe is way behind on many tech fronts and would be hurt badly by being cut off by America (you don't think there will be repercussions?) though Europe doesn't need anything made in China ... they need China as a customer for stuff.
There are 100 consumer related issues to be addressed between US/EU before the possibility of Cisco spying comes into question.
Even if it was it's like saying Boeing has no ties to the US government. Yeah right.
Just like there is a degree of difference between China and the US, and it's not as different as you may have been taught to believe.
Believing the Chinese govt don't interfere is attributing some fairly superhuman levels of self-control to the govt...even in a system with controls over govt, that would be unlikely...in a system with no controls, it is a little ludicrous.
I’m not entirely convinced of your expertise.
https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/politics/article/3038655/chin...
This false claim by Huawei, is one of the most important reasons why Huawei isn‘t already banned here in Germany.[1]
And while we are at it, we should also ban US companies from providing critical infrastructure like this in Germany (and Europe). After Snowden, its clear that hardware from US vendors like Cisco should be seen as potentially compromised.[2]
1) https://www.businessinsider.de/trumps-huawei-verbot-ist-rein... 2) https://www.infoworld.com/article/2608141/snowden--the-nsa-p...