Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by kjksf on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @02:51PM
(#21651356)
Here's something that will shock you: this story is false.
Based on comments so far most people, even those defending Tesla, accepted the false premise that NHTSA decided to investigate Tesla on its own.
That's not what happened.
Originally the author claimed NHTSA launched "investigation" into Tesla.
NHTSA contacted LATIMES and said this is "defect petition", not an investigation, so he reluctantly changed it to "probe" because he "doesn't want to argue over definition of words".
The short of it is: someone complain to NHTSA and they are bound by the law to investigate the complaints, hence the "defect petition" (i.e. someone petitioned NHTSA claiming that Tesla's are defective) even if they don't believe any of it. Hence request of relevant documents from Tesla.
For context: Russ Mitchell, the author of this article, is a full-on Tesla hater.
If you read his LA Times articles you'll see an extreme anti-Tesla bias.
His tweeter feed is almost a daily stream of retweeting anti-Tesla news, making anti-Tesla comments.
That LA Times allows this guy to report on Tesla is just mind-boggling.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by mlindner on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:12PM
(#21651607)
The author of the story claims he has no financial position in any company he reports on in his bio, but it doesn't say he doesn't write paid editorials.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by imglorp on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:10AM
(#21649065)
Two fires were mentioned in OP, 2012-2019. Even if it's 200 that get surfaced, look at the alternative: about 180,000 highway vehicle fires per year in the US. Having a compartment full of leaky flammable fluids and hot exhaust components might tend to do that on occasion.
The bigger story might be the risk/reward tradeoff of those few battery fires vs everyone's charge capacity.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by Jamwinner on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:27AM
(#21649250)
I have put out even large car fires with a small extinguisher. A lithium fire takes hours and thousands of gallons of water to subside. There is also the possible issue of rapid exit when electrics are dead. While the chance is clearly lower, the risk is higher to you should it occur. Currently there is no good accepted methodology for firefighters and first responders beyond 'more water' or 'let it burn'. That is a real problem.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by maratd on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:43PM
(#21650063)
> There is also the possible issue of rapid exit when electrics are dead.
This is not an issue with Tesla design, all of that is handled by a traditional car battery that every car has, not the main battery. Those batteries are completely separate and in different parts of the car, I think specifically because of this safety issue.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by Doxin on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:42AM
(#21658048)
If anything teslas are safer in this department because of the temperature sensors in the battery pack. There's several stories out there of battery fires in teslas where the fire only occurred after the car warned the driver, and after all the participants got out.
On the other hand you're unlikely to notice a fire in a gasoline car before there's smoke or fire.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by Smoosh on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:35PM
(#21652348)
I believe that in Teslas, the main battery pack is for motive power, while the vehicle's electrical system (including doors and windows) is powered from a standard 12V car battery which is kept charged from the main battery pack. Thus egress would be the same as in any other vehicle in a crash/fire.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by jolmg on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:48PM
(#21650716)
> A lithium fire takes hours and thousands of gallons of water to subside
Doesn't lithium react violently with water? Looking online, lithium creates hydrogen gas on contact with water. That seems like adding fuel to the fire. Makes sense that it takes a lot to extinguish a fire with fuel.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by bananabreakfast on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:53PM
(#21652010)
A lithium battery is made of lithium compounds not raw lithium. Expecting it to react the same way as pure lithium is a profound misunderstanding of basic chemistry.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by matt-attack on Thursday November 28, 2019 @11:28AM
(#21658464)
Kind of like when people commonly refer to table salt as “sodium”. Sodium is a highly caustic and reactive metal. The metal sodium is profoundly different than the salt called sodium chloride. Sharing a specific type of element means nothing when comparing compounds.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by jolmg on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:27PM
(#21652284)
You know, you could have left it at the first sentence. There's no need to incorrectly assume what my expectations were or the source of the misunderstanding.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by imglorp on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:37AM
(#21649354)
This is a strawman argument really: what if this very rare thing happens (battery fire), and then another really rare thing on top of that (entrapment); therefore EV bad.
Compared to flammable liquid fires at 180,000 per year, see above, which really are pretty common.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:49AM
(#21649475)
>Compared to flammable liquid fires at 180,000 per year,
This is a straw-man argument too. You're comparing battery fires to all vehicle fires. Ask any mechanic and they will tell you vehicle electronics systems are the primary source of crispness with stalled electric motors and rodent damage being the primary sources. Regardless of how it gets its motive power a vehicle's power-train rarely catches fire compared to other things that catch fire (which is probably in part why the NHTSA is interested in this).
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by j-pb on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:45PM
(#21650087)
I wouldn't trust a "news source" with headlines like "Climate-Fearing Millennial Snowflake Self-Triggers During Hunger Strike" further than I could throw them.
Their clearly biased against EVs because "libtards" drive them.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by DennisP on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:48PM
(#21650131)
I'm a huge Tesla and Musk fan but I'll point out the feds are investigating spontaneous fires, not those associated with collisions. I saw a video of this happening with a parked Tesla. How many gasoline vehicles spontaneously burst into flame?
Of course it's still rare, and I'll also mention that the Model 3 has a newer battery pack design and is not being investigated.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by imglorp on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:05PM
(#21650297)
> How many gasoline vehicles spontaneously burst into flame
Many, I think, mostly maintenance related. Frequent causes involve old gaskets or cracked fuel lines dripping onto the exhaust manifold, right on the side of the engine.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by DennisP on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:09PM
(#21650328)
Well, true, good point. I think much fewer while parked and turned off. But I do remember now my old VW Bug manual, which detailed at least four ways the little beast could catch itself on fire.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by hef19898 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:52PM
(#21650760)
To be honest, the old VW Bug was technically a less than perfect car already back the day. A nice car, for sure and I love quirky old cars. But technically not perfect.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by tomatotomato37 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @02:44PM
(#21651268)
I mean it was essentially a mass produced shitbox designed to be affordable to someone living in the economic clusterfuck that was interwar Nazi Germany, you can't expect miracles
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @02:41PM
(#21651247)
>Many, I think, mostly maintenance related. Frequent causes involve old gaskets or cracked fuel lines dripping onto the exhaust manifold, right on the side of the engine.
You're not wrong that fuel does sometimes catch fire but it is very rare for a fuel leak to cause a fire on its own. It usually happens after a fire starts elsewhere.
Fuel system integrity in crashes has been scored in crash tests for a very, very long time (I recall reading about it when I was reviewing some microfiche with crash tests results of 70s pickups) so OEMs have been trying to build secure fuel systems for a long time and have gotten pretty good. With cross flow cylinder head designs (which every engine today has) there is no reason (it would be a waste of material to plumb it) to have fuel on the same side of the engine as the exhaust. The routing between the engine and the vehicle body basically always (i.e. I know of 0 exceptions but can't prove one doesn't exist) go out of their way not to run over exhaust. Fuel systems rarely have gasketed connections, almost everything is sealed with O-rings.
Mature EV designs probably catch on fire less than ICE designs but not really for any of the reasons you specified. Fuel fires mostly come from crash damage to fuel tanks where the crash also leaves the vehicle overturned. Most fires come from electrical systems not related to the drive-train. Even engine fires are rarely fuel, animal nesting debris is a far more common cause.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by jhayward on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @02:44PM
(#21651273)
> How many gasoline vehicles spontaneously burst into flame?
Ford recalled 8.7 million cars for spontaneous fire risk.[1] And that's just one case.
It happens more often than you'd think, and coverage of it in media tends to be subdued. Automotive is the largest source of advertising dollars for many media markets.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by danso on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:17PM
(#21652215)
Using the numbers from the article you linked, and this WaPo article with more details [0]:
2,000 cars in the U.S. and Canada were believed to have had fires related to the ignition switches, which were installed in 23 million Ford vehicles. This is a failure rate of about 0.0087% overall, although Ford ultimately argued that it would only need to recall a subset of the vehicles with the ignition switch: 8.7M vehicles.
There are at least a dozen [1] Tesla fire incidents, and 720,000 Tesla vehicles sold through 2019 Q2 [2], which is a failure rate of about 0.0014%. So Tesla has a lower rate, but not by an order of magnitude, because Tesla has sold far fewer vehicles than Ford did over roughly the same number of years. So it seems justified for NHTSA to take a serious look into the issue.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by OnlineGladiator on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:02PM
(#21651490)
Comparing modern technology with decades old technology and claiming it's a fair comparison for safety standards is wildly disingenuous.
How many modern vehicles spontaneously burst into flame? I could easily believe it's orders of magnitude larger than for Teslas, but when you make comparisons like you did it just discredits your entire argument.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by jhayward on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:09PM
(#21652165)
Ok, I provided one example. It's on you to prove the point then. Please provide relevant facts proving your case. Prove my point is wrong.
Oh, and the majority of present-day ignitions in automobiles are still the exact same mechanical interlock switching types used since the 60's. Higher-end vehicles have solid state switching, but it's not the majority of vehicles.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by OnlineGladiator on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:17PM
(#21652217)
You made a claim, not me. I just said your argument is flawed. I didn't say you're wrong - I believe you're probably right. But you didn't actually provide any data for your claim.
The burden of proof is on the person making the claim.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by OnlineGladiator on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:28PM
(#21652296)
I consider criticizing an argument to be a contribution - I did not even say you are wrong. It seems you want me to provide a clearly detailed argument for why you are wrong, but I don't have that because I don't even believe you are wrong. I haven't looked at the data - I just looked at your argument.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by 6d6b73 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:59AM
(#21649588)
Oh FFS. It doesn't matter if it more or less likely, it matters that it does happen and therefore should be investigated to protect people now and in the future.. You want them to wait until number of ICE vs EV fires are equal to start investigating this? Why not do it now, and fix the problem? Not only it will potentially make EVs safer now, but it will potentially make EV companies more profitable in the long term ( less legal fees, recalls etc).
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by techstrategist on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:22AM
(#21649186)
I don’t think it’s rational to compare to overall highway vehicle fires. Wouldn’t you want to compare against similar luxury vehicles of a similar age?
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by im_with_stupid on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:30AM
(#21649278)
I'm not a fan of all of Tesla's management practices, but this does seem to be a bit of a knee jerk reaction. One company has less than 1% of all fires for the industry, and with a component with known combustibility.
Even if the electronics failed, leaving the driver stuck inside, you would think the owners would have the foresight to either have something capable of breaking windows or a method by which to break them.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by simion314 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:41AM
(#21649393)
Still OP is right, compare Tesla with similar car of price and age , there is a cool book "How to lie with statistics" that shows you how easy it is to manipulate with bad statistics though I am sure many Tesla fans spread this wrong statistics due to ignorance and not intentionally.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by Symbiote on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @06:06PM
(#21653077)
Are the doors not mechanical? That would seem dangerous.
I was in a significant crash when I was 10 years old, and had to kick the opposite-side rear door to get me and my younger sibling out of the burning vehicle. The latch still worked, but the body panel was heavily dented by the collision.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by mlindner on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:17PM
(#21651644)
> Even if the electronics failed, leaving the driver stuck inside, you would think the owners would have the foresight to either have something capable of breaking windows or a method by which to break them.
Just for clarification, all Tesla vehicles, Model X included, have a manual pull to open the door even in the case that the power is dead. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01lXcD_Uz74
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by Symbiote on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @06:20PM
(#21653168)
That looks awful! Especially for the rear doors, which don't have a mechanical opener on one model.
Basic design should mean that familiar methods work in an emergency. People often follow the usual way out of a building, even if there's a closer fire exit.
I just wrote above, but I was trapped in a burning car when I was a kid. The door latch worked, but I had to hold it open and kick the door to unjam it after a collision.
Had it been a Tesla, would I have known about unclipping the speaker grill, or finding a small tag to pull on at night? And been able to kick the door at the same time?
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by olyjohn on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:06PM
(#21649654)
Of course it's not true. People don't even read the owners manual, or care about how anything in their car works. The amount of times I've shown somebody a feature they didn't know about in their own car is staggering.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by hef19898 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:50AM
(#21649491)
The 1% only makes sense by normalizing for cars on the road and even better for distance driven. Otherwise it is not telling much.
And the only car I had in my live that has something to break a car window from the inside is my 4x4. And that only because the previous owner used it extensively for off-roading. So quite the opposite from your average Tesla.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:39AM
(#21649371)
In an ICE car fuel and ignition sources are generally separate there's little to be gained by being unsafe with fuel.
In an EV your fuel and ignition sources are fundamentally inseparable and you can gain a lot (range/capacity, charge time/peak power) by being unsafe with it (running the battery to the ragged edge of what it can tolerate).
The fact that in response they quickly rolled out an update that neutered a large amount of capacity is far more interesting than the fires themselves and probably what the NHTSA wants to look into.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by ryanmercer on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:19AM
(#21649151)
>Having a compartment full of leaky flammable fluids and hot exhaust components might tend to do that on occasion.
Indeed, but you also get animal related fires (I have no clue as to what percentage) as birds, mice, chipmunks etc will build nests in vehicles.
I imagine the animal related fires are pretty low and in the case of an EV would be next to non-existent for nest-related fires, I wonder though if EVs though are more at risk of electrical fire from pets chewing on wires.
Trying to find any sort of statistics I stumbled upon a wildfire site that documents animal-started fires, the most recent one gave me a bit of a chuckle so I'm including it here:
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by kurthr on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:39AM
(#21649370)
And don't forget carbon-monoxide poisonings and deaths...
Then there's hybrids. I've personally witnessed 2 fires and know another friend whos car burned. Two Prius and one Nissan something. Those are the worst of both worlds, gas and electric!
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by wiggles_md on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:37PM
(#21649999)
The lithium battery fires I’ve seen associated with BEVs accelerate faster (edit, was: are quite a bit more vigorous) than those I’ve seen associated with gasoline or diesel fueled vehicles. Shouldn’t the violence of the fire (not just the number of incidents) figure into the safety calculus?
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by maratd on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:41PM
(#21650043)
I would be far more concerned with the acceleration of the fire. If I have plenty of notice to get away from the vehicle and to keep others away, who cares how vigorous it is? Either way, the car will burn down. I don't think it matters how long that will take.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by wiggles_md on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:48PM
(#21650121)
That’s what I was trying to say but didn’t successfully, the BEV fires I’ve seen in testing accelerate quite a bit faster. Plus, the battery tends to be located below the passenger compartment, whereas fuel fires tend to start in the engine compartment. It doesn’t feel like the two types of vehicle fires are directly comparable by frequency of incidents alone.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by close04 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:15PM
(#21649747)
Full nuclear reactor meltdowns only happened once (Chernobyl). Far less often than a wind turbine generator failure. Which one shouldn’t be investigated?
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by wcoenen on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:11AM
(#21649077)
Tesla itself has previously claimed that its vehicles had fewer fires, per miles travelled, than other vehicles in 2012-2018: one per 170 million miles for Tesla, vs one per 19 million miles for all.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by mlindner on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:31PM
(#21651773)
If that were true the number of fires would be going down every year. However on average for the last 5-10 years the number of fires is pretty constant.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by mlindner on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:33PM
(#21651813)
By putting water on it they made the fire last longer. That just shows the fire crews need better training on how to handle electric vehicle fires. This is not unique to Tesla. You don't use water, you use non-flammable non-water-based suppressants.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by Kuinox on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:06PM
(#21650303)
Lithium react with water, pouring water on it will lower the temperature, but you can't stop a lithium fire with water, you need to wait that your pile of lithium burn.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by mlindner on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:32PM
(#21651794)
In battery fires the lithium is not burning, the electrolyte is. By dumping water on it you simply heat up the lithium causing the fire to continue. You don't want to use water on a battery fire. You want to use smothering agents that block off oxygen so that the liberated gas put off by the heated electrolyte doesn't ignite.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by toast0 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:10AM
(#21649070)
The pdf you linked is stamped October 24, a thursday. Nov 28 is five weeks (35 days) later. I don't know when Tesla received the letter or when it was released to the public, of course. This article is dated November 1st.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by krisoft on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:09AM
(#21649059)
Why do you say it has been issued on Nov 24? All I can find is a stamp with "Oct 24 2019" on the top of the letter. Do you say that it has been backdated?
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by tempsy on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:07PM
(#21649657)
I've never been one of the tin foil hat $TSLA bears but can't help but notice odd things surrounding Tesla that appear highly questionable.
e.g. Elon has tweeted the Cybertruck has 250k+ pre-orders and counting. The pre-order deposit is only $100 (vs. $1000 when the Tesla 3 came out). The fact the deposit is only $100 for a $50k+ truck makes me question whether they intentionally set it at a low price to pump pre-order numbers, knowing full well that in 2 years time the majority of these people will likely not actually purchase the truck at all. And at 250k preorders it means Tesla has raised at least $25M in interest-free loans that they can do whatever with for the 2 years.
More than that they have no clear idea on how to scale production of this vehicle at present time, and considering how many Tesla 3 owners have complained about defects with a "standard" Tesla why would anyone believe that Tesla can produce high quality Cybertrucks at scale in a reasonable amount of time to fulfill legitimate preorders?
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by mjamesaustin on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:58PM
(#21650235)
Tesla's revenue last quarter was $6.3 billion, so this amazing $25M interest-free loan is the same amount Tesla earns on average in just under 9 hours.
There could be any number of reasons why Tesla lowered the deposit amount. Either way, the purpose of a preorder is likely to gauge demand and not to guarantee sales. Of course the conversion rate won't be 100%, but 250k deposits is a much more promising signal to Tesla than 100k or 25k.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by tempsy on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:02PM
(#21650262)
Your revenue figures have little to do with whether a loan is useful to you. They have very few quarters in their history as a public company where they have had positive earnings, which means they are burning cash.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by zaroth on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:47PM
(#21652462)
You can read their financial statements if you’d like to comment on their financial position.
The pre-order deposits are not recognized as revenue and do not improve their cash flow. But in any case, Tesla has had ~$1B of positive cash flow over the last two quarters and has over $5 billion of cash on hand.
The $100 deposit is definitely designed to inflate the pre-order numbers versus the $2,500 Model Y deposit, for example. I think reading into the 250k pre-orders is extremely difficult. But the refundable cash itself will sit in escrow earning approximately nothing for Tesla other than the marketing value of the pre-order count.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by robbiep on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:35PM
(#21651835)
They don’t have a huge number of quarters as a public company (well, they’re 16 years old), and for most of their history they have been in Startup mode.
If most people on this forum’s startups went to cash positive in 14 years (which is basically how long it took them to get a positive quarter, and the balance for the last 8 has basically been 50:50) then I’m pretty sure everyone would be cheering
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by hef19898 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:19PM
(#21650409)
I think a lot of that perceived tin-foil-hat-bear thing comes from the way you look at Tesla. If you look at it the way I, and I suppose the OP does, as a car manufacturer, in deed a lot of things seem odd. Odd enough to be bearish. If you look at Tesla as a tech company, things are largely different.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by cagenut on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:35PM
(#21649973)
don't think of it as a deposit, think of it as reserving your place in line. whenever tesla gets around to being able to deliver you have to make up your mind, but at least you know you won't have to wait at the back of the line if you decide you do want it.
its an option not a deposit.
tesla obviously doesn't expect them all to convert, in fact they have their internal numbers on how well the model3 reservations converted so they can make a much more accurate estimate than either you or I.
tell me a marketing department for a product that can't be shipped for 2 years that wouldn't kill for a list of not just warm leads, but people who had out and out handed over money! its like they managed to get the customers to pay for the marketing budget.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by greglindahl on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:56PM
(#21652046)
The contract involved is public, so maybe the exact words used to summarize it isn't that important?
There was a lot of squabbling over the words used to summarize the Model S, X, and 3 waiting lists, too. I don't think anything good came out of the discussion.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by tempsy on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:42PM
(#21650055)
Model 3 was a $1000 deposit. They dropped it to $100 for the Cybertruck despite it being more expensive.
So they expect to convert fewer people than the Model 3. Likely far fewer.
So if Elon knows few people will convert then why call it a "pre order" and why does he keep announcing the numbers on Twitter every few hours?
Either way despite the frothy market investors don't appear to be biting at the preorder numbers anyway, but the whole preorder song and dance feels like the world's biggest Kickstarter whose main function is raising a bunch of interest free loans.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by Nasrudith on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:42PM
(#21650052)
You answered your own question with your previous objections you know. You complained about the supposed lack of capacity factor - now you complain about the distance of the preorder? Well that shows the utility of the preorder with lower production capacity, doesn't it?
A $100 deposit is large enough that people wouldn't feel overtly locked in while confirming a rough number for scaling. As opposed to other "probably want it" who decide not to preorder for $1000.
The function is mostly marketting in the "business intelligence" sense and the assumption that preorder fall throughs would be matched by non-preorder purchase demand is reasonable for anything which isn't a massive stinker.
Re:Federal safety agency launches probe of Tesla battery fires
by tempsy on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @01:06PM
(#21650305)
this is quite the mental gymnastics.
this is a brand new vehicle that is unlike anything they've offered in the past. they have historical data on conversion for the Tesla 3 preorders with a $1000 deposit. now they're offering preorders on something that is more expensive and "unique" for 1/10th the preorder amount. how would a business intelligence analyst on their team even begin to predict how many of these customers actually intend to convert given the data they have?
If they actually wanted a rough idea on how many people actually intend to order in order to plan how many resources they need to throw at cybertruck production then they've done everything possible to make their job harder with the preorder decisions they've made.
Based on comments so far most people, even those defending Tesla, accepted the false premise that NHTSA decided to investigate Tesla on its own.
That's not what happened.
Originally the author claimed NHTSA launched "investigation" into Tesla.
NHTSA contacted LATIMES and said this is "defect petition", not an investigation, so he reluctantly changed it to "probe" because he "doesn't want to argue over definition of words".
Here's the proof: https://twitter.com/russ1mitchell/status/1190352973013995520
https://twitter.com/VGrinshpun/status/1191187292288929792 is a longer expose of how biased and misleading this article is.
The short of it is: someone complain to NHTSA and they are bound by the law to investigate the complaints, hence the "defect petition" (i.e. someone petitioned NHTSA claiming that Tesla's are defective) even if they don't believe any of it. Hence request of relevant documents from Tesla.
For context: Russ Mitchell, the author of this article, is a full-on Tesla hater.
If you read his LA Times articles you'll see an extreme anti-Tesla bias.
His tweeter feed is almost a daily stream of retweeting anti-Tesla news, making anti-Tesla comments.
That LA Times allows this guy to report on Tesla is just mind-boggling.
Fake news! In the wild, unambiguously.
The bigger story might be the risk/reward tradeoff of those few battery fires vs everyone's charge capacity.
source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/377006/nmber-of-us-highw...
Tesla battery fires are not lithium metal fires. They are primarily organic solvent fires which evolve flammable gasses when overheated.
This is not an issue with Tesla design, all of that is handled by a traditional car battery that every car has, not the main battery. Those batteries are completely separate and in different parts of the car, I think specifically because of this safety issue.
On the other hand you're unlikely to notice a fire in a gasoline car before there's smoke or fire.
Doesn't lithium react violently with water? Looking online, lithium creates hydrogen gas on contact with water. That seems like adding fuel to the fire. Makes sense that it takes a lot to extinguish a fire with fuel.
Compared to flammable liquid fires at 180,000 per year, see above, which really are pretty common.
This is a straw-man argument too. You're comparing battery fires to all vehicle fires. Ask any mechanic and they will tell you vehicle electronics systems are the primary source of crispness with stalled electric motors and rodent damage being the primary sources. Regardless of how it gets its motive power a vehicle's power-train rarely catches fire compared to other things that catch fire (which is probably in part why the NHTSA is interested in this).
Their clearly biased against EVs because "libtards" drive them.
Of course it's still rare, and I'll also mention that the Model 3 has a newer battery pack design and is not being investigated.
Many, I think, mostly maintenance related. Frequent causes involve old gaskets or cracked fuel lines dripping onto the exhaust manifold, right on the side of the engine.
You're not wrong that fuel does sometimes catch fire but it is very rare for a fuel leak to cause a fire on its own. It usually happens after a fire starts elsewhere.
Fuel system integrity in crashes has been scored in crash tests for a very, very long time (I recall reading about it when I was reviewing some microfiche with crash tests results of 70s pickups) so OEMs have been trying to build secure fuel systems for a long time and have gotten pretty good. With cross flow cylinder head designs (which every engine today has) there is no reason (it would be a waste of material to plumb it) to have fuel on the same side of the engine as the exhaust. The routing between the engine and the vehicle body basically always (i.e. I know of 0 exceptions but can't prove one doesn't exist) go out of their way not to run over exhaust. Fuel systems rarely have gasketed connections, almost everything is sealed with O-rings.
Mature EV designs probably catch on fire less than ICE designs but not really for any of the reasons you specified. Fuel fires mostly come from crash damage to fuel tanks where the crash also leaves the vehicle overturned. Most fires come from electrical systems not related to the drive-train. Even engine fires are rarely fuel, animal nesting debris is a far more common cause.
Ford recalled 8.7 million cars for spontaneous fire risk.[1] And that's just one case.
It happens more often than you'd think, and coverage of it in media tends to be subdued. Automotive is the largest source of advertising dollars for many media markets.
[1] https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1996-04-26-mn-63066-...
2,000 cars in the U.S. and Canada were believed to have had fires related to the ignition switches, which were installed in 23 million Ford vehicles. This is a failure rate of about 0.0087% overall, although Ford ultimately argued that it would only need to recall a subset of the vehicles with the ignition switch: 8.7M vehicles.
There are at least a dozen [1] Tesla fire incidents, and 720,000 Tesla vehicles sold through 2019 Q2 [2], which is a failure rate of about 0.0014%. So Tesla has a lower rate, but not by an order of magnitude, because Tesla has sold far fewer vehicles than Ford did over roughly the same number of years. So it seems justified for NHTSA to take a serious look into the issue.
[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1996/04/26/f...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plug-in_electric_vehicle_fire_...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla,_Inc.#Sales
How many modern vehicles spontaneously burst into flame? I could easily believe it's orders of magnitude larger than for Teslas, but when you make comparisons like you did it just discredits your entire argument.
Oh, and the majority of present-day ignitions in automobiles are still the exact same mechanical interlock switching types used since the 60's. Higher-end vehicles have solid state switching, but it's not the majority of vehicles.
Also:
https://abcnews.go.com/US/bmw-recalls-million-vehicles-fire-...
The burden of proof is on the person making the claim.
https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFalla...
Anyway, agree to disagree I guess.
Even if the electronics failed, leaving the driver stuck inside, you would think the owners would have the foresight to either have something capable of breaking windows or a method by which to break them.
Also, lithium cells just need to be punctured to catch fire, they don't need an external ignition source.
I was in a significant crash when I was 10 years old, and had to kick the opposite-side rear door to get me and my younger sibling out of the burning vehicle. The latch still worked, but the body panel was heavily dented by the collision.
It is pretty clear though, Tesla has expensive new cars you need to compare them with similar cars.
Just for clarification, all Tesla vehicles, Model X included, have a manual pull to open the door even in the case that the power is dead. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01lXcD_Uz74
Basic design should mean that familiar methods work in an emergency. People often follow the usual way out of a building, even if there's a closer fire exit.
I just wrote above, but I was trapped in a burning car when I was a kid. The door latch worked, but I had to hold it open and kick the door to unjam it after a collision.
Had it been a Tesla, would I have known about unclipping the speaker grill, or finding a small tag to pull on at night? And been able to kick the door at the same time?
And the only car I had in my live that has something to break a car window from the inside is my 4x4. And that only because the previous owner used it extensively for off-roading. So quite the opposite from your average Tesla.
In an EV your fuel and ignition sources are fundamentally inseparable and you can gain a lot (range/capacity, charge time/peak power) by being unsafe with it (running the battery to the ragged edge of what it can tolerate).
The fact that in response they quickly rolled out an update that neutered a large amount of capacity is far more interesting than the fires themselves and probably what the NHTSA wants to look into.
Indeed, but you also get animal related fires (I have no clue as to what percentage) as birds, mice, chipmunks etc will build nests in vehicles.
I imagine the animal related fires are pretty low and in the case of an EV would be next to non-existent for nest-related fires, I wonder though if EVs though are more at risk of electrical fire from pets chewing on wires.
Trying to find any sort of statistics I stumbled upon a wildfire site that documents animal-started fires, the most recent one gave me a bit of a chuckle so I'm including it here:
"Bear falls on Sheriff’s vehicle causing crash and fire" https://wildfiretoday.com/2019/08/09/bear-falls-on-sheriffs-...
There's also the infrastructure damage caused by animals that is documented at https://cybersquirrel1.com/
Then there's hybrids. I've personally witnessed 2 fires and know another friend whos car burned. Two Prius and one Nissan something. Those are the worst of both worlds, gas and electric!
Have there been any deaths in these EV fires?
https://www.tesla.com/nl_BE/VehicleSafetyReport
Strung out million dollar Ferraris and PoS 30 year old death traps shouldn't count towards the normalization.
See: https://www.statista.com/statistics/377006/nmber-of-us-highw...
If anything there's a gradual trend of increasing number of fires in the last 6-7 years.
https://www.tesla.com/en_GB/firstresponders?redirect=no
Fires should be doused with lots of water.
https://www.tesla.com/en_GB/firstresponders?redirect=no
The timing and urgency seems interesting:
Letter issued: Nov 24
Due date: Nov 28 (Thanksgiving day in the US)
Extension can be requested no later than 5 days before due date (which isn't possible)
Is this normal for these types of petitions?
Edit: Oh jeez, I totally misread the Issued stamp (which is actually Oct 24). Ignore this comment.
e.g. Elon has tweeted the Cybertruck has 250k+ pre-orders and counting. The pre-order deposit is only $100 (vs. $1000 when the Tesla 3 came out). The fact the deposit is only $100 for a $50k+ truck makes me question whether they intentionally set it at a low price to pump pre-order numbers, knowing full well that in 2 years time the majority of these people will likely not actually purchase the truck at all. And at 250k preorders it means Tesla has raised at least $25M in interest-free loans that they can do whatever with for the 2 years.
More than that they have no clear idea on how to scale production of this vehicle at present time, and considering how many Tesla 3 owners have complained about defects with a "standard" Tesla why would anyone believe that Tesla can produce high quality Cybertrucks at scale in a reasonable amount of time to fulfill legitimate preorders?
There could be any number of reasons why Tesla lowered the deposit amount. Either way, the purpose of a preorder is likely to gauge demand and not to guarantee sales. Of course the conversion rate won't be 100%, but 250k deposits is a much more promising signal to Tesla than 100k or 25k.
The pre-order deposits are not recognized as revenue and do not improve their cash flow. But in any case, Tesla has had ~$1B of positive cash flow over the last two quarters and has over $5 billion of cash on hand.
The $100 deposit is definitely designed to inflate the pre-order numbers versus the $2,500 Model Y deposit, for example. I think reading into the 250k pre-orders is extremely difficult. But the refundable cash itself will sit in escrow earning approximately nothing for Tesla other than the marketing value of the pre-order count.
What is better than cash if you don't need it? An accurate predictor of demand. This is likely what the small $100 deposit is for.
And does anyone actual think that most of these 250k people actually intend to buy the truck when it comes time to put down the $49900+?
its an option not a deposit.
tesla obviously doesn't expect them all to convert, in fact they have their internal numbers on how well the model3 reservations converted so they can make a much more accurate estimate than either you or I.
tell me a marketing department for a product that can't be shipped for 2 years that wouldn't kill for a list of not just warm leads, but people who had out and out handed over money! its like they managed to get the customers to pay for the marketing budget.
There was a lot of squabbling over the words used to summarize the Model S, X, and 3 waiting lists, too. I don't think anything good came out of the discussion.
So they expect to convert fewer people than the Model 3. Likely far fewer.
So if Elon knows few people will convert then why call it a "pre order" and why does he keep announcing the numbers on Twitter every few hours?
Either way despite the frothy market investors don't appear to be biting at the preorder numbers anyway, but the whole preorder song and dance feels like the world's biggest Kickstarter whose main function is raising a bunch of interest free loans.
A $100 deposit is large enough that people wouldn't feel overtly locked in while confirming a rough number for scaling. As opposed to other "probably want it" who decide not to preorder for $1000.
The function is mostly marketting in the "business intelligence" sense and the assumption that preorder fall throughs would be matched by non-preorder purchase demand is reasonable for anything which isn't a massive stinker.
this is a brand new vehicle that is unlike anything they've offered in the past. they have historical data on conversion for the Tesla 3 preorders with a $1000 deposit. now they're offering preorders on something that is more expensive and "unique" for 1/10th the preorder amount. how would a business intelligence analyst on their team even begin to predict how many of these customers actually intend to convert given the data they have?
If they actually wanted a rough idea on how many people actually intend to order in order to plan how many resources they need to throw at cybertruck production then they've done everything possible to make their job harder with the preorder decisions they've made.