On the other hand there are reasons an employer may want or be required to allow this behaviour that have little to do with what a corporation is
I think people feel strongly about certain issues. That doesn’t imply that what they are doing is inherently wrong if driven by those core sentiments. How about we empathize- We can respect both Google’s and the employees’ action without choosing sides.
What I don't understand is to complain about or refuse to do things you morally object to and at the same time insist in keeping collecting a nice paycheck. You can't have both.
Yes, of course you can have both. Companies can and have been improved in their behaviour by employee protests, strikes, union bargaining, and other such measures.
I was empathetic with the initial walkout since it was addressing working conditions directly (covering up sexual harassment and forced arbitration).
Then the organizers of that action started agitating to change company direction regarding military contracts, censored search engines, and conservative people being on certain boards. While in general I have reservations about all those things, and think people should speak up about them, I don't think that organizing against general company direction should be protected in the same way labor organizing is.
At the same time, if your moral objections are strong enough, you should quit immediately. E.g. if your company says good news, everyone! We're opening concentration camps tomorrow!, I suppose the only reasonable action is to quit in disgust (as I said before, it's not like Google engineers are otherwise unemployable). If you stick around you're implicitly saying that your moral objections aren't that strong (at least not as strong as your desire to get a fat juicy paycheck), and sure, try to change from within, but keep it private and keep it civil, without biting the hand that is feeding you.
If they just wanted to come, milk it, and leave on the first sign of trouble, it would be just like your country of origin.
For example, Try as I might, I would suck at say building roads - just not strong enough. I will get done over 4x the time what an expert will need. I think this analogy applies to residence as well: I just don't feel I have the power to change a whole country or community. There is also a huge amount of force required to reverse a flywheel compared to adding to the current direction. Given a choice, people find the flywheel that's turning in their direction.
I also would like to work on what my specialization is and build up on it rather than trying to learn to lay roads. It is clearly better to do that in a place supportive of the same rather than trying to change my 3rd world country to adopt it, build it etc. Some probably have that skill to build from ground up in a hostile place - it is a rare skill.
You can also try and extend your argument to the millions of refugees / immigrants that flow away from poor spots and see if it holds: Why don't they stay and make their place better? Because more often than not, they just want to make a living and don't believe they can effect measurable change.
And believe me, this doesn't come as easy as you think. A ton of legal / ably employed / tax paying immigrants with completely clear records live 10s of years in the USA for example without any permanence or citizenship. IOW I wish it was as simple as you make it sound to up and leave :)
I say this as an ardent critic of Google: An individual finding irreconcilable differences with a bona fide good employer like Google is unlikely to find any other company fault-free. Tsk tsk: The issue is likely not with the companies.
Edit: Why are people downvoting me for asking for a source?
> Working time is for work, so your employer may maintain and enforce non-discriminatory rules limiting solicitation and distribution, except that your employer cannot prohibit you from talking about or soliciting for a union during non-work time, such as before or after work or during break times; or from distributing union literature during non-work time, in non-work areas, such as parking lots or break rooms. Also, restrictions on your efforts to communicate with co-workers cannot be discriminatory. For example, your employer cannot prohibit you from talking about the union during working time if it permits you to talk about other non-work-related matters during working time.
https://www.nlrb.gov/rights-we-protect/whats-law/employees/i...
I imagine that Googlers are generally permitted to socialise during work time, so they also get to unionise during work time. I even imagine they sometimes use work-provided services to organise non-work-related activity and this is permitted by the company.
That said, I do wonder if the fired workers could argue that they were merely taking an unscheduled break (permitted under Google's flextime policy) when demonstrating.
Intermittent strikes, for example, are not.
Nobody was fired, supposedly, in relation to that demonstration.
According to Google, but the workers are claiming otherwise.
> but it’s quite possible that they had that day off.
Indeed. In fact, with Google's flextime policy, can't they simply choose to have that day off?
> I'm not taking sides
Sure you are not.
> I'm talking simply from a contractual standpoint that you signed on the day of your employment.
As the article states, the people in question were union organizers. It's illegal to fire someone for union activities regardless of what their contract says.
So if you spend all day on "union activities" instead of doing the job that you were contracted to do, you can't be fired for it? That's incredible.
Is it also pure coincidence that these union organizers just happened to be fired for harrassment soon after Google hired a union busting company?
Pretty sure Google hires good lawyers. If us ramdom HN-ers know this, they probably went through the motions of covering their ass, legally
The power dynamic is lopsided in the favor of the company, righting this disparity - making things fair naturally hurts the company. Losing your job can be disastrous (especially if fired), and you can't just quit and go somewhere else, if everywhere else is the same. Even moreso for some people. Why don't you let me know all the places that have Engineering or IT unions. I've never heard of one, so they must be very rare, or none existent
As for the protest, the employee's right to protest is an important thing, and taking that away reduces you to an automaton. You'd be giving up the chance to hire great employees that have opinions of their own if you just want people that do what you ask. That puts you behind on innovation, and in the long term creates a very homogenous atmosphere that breeds complacency.
"do their damn job" (a word 'like "fuck"', in some sense, but one that people are less likely to be seriously offended by[1])
"do the job they are being paid to do" (stress the key point with words and typography)
"do their job -- you know, the thing Google is actually paying them to do" (words with a bit of sarcasm)
and to my mind all of these options have similar intensity. I don't personally mind "do their fucking job" (at least, I don't mind the swearing; I think the point being made is probably unsound, but that's a separate matter) but it's not by any means the only way to get the point across.
[1] Which is rather odd, if you think about it -- you'd think eternal torture was a nastier thing to have brought to your attention than sex -- but I guess sex is more hard-wired into our brains and few these days believe in eternal damnation.
I'd be interested to see where in this article you saw anyone imply the employees didn't fulfill their work duties?
So the threat of losing health insurance is a huge sword of Damocles employers get to dangle over employees.
When folk talk about the 'privelege' of HN, it's this. Unions exist because your suggested course of action isn't viable for the majority of workers.
Is it or isn't it my job to question bad decisions?
Because as a society we have moved beyond mere wage slaves that just do their job and call it a day, and found that certain activities that are not "contractual obligations" are also necessary for the well functioning of enterprises and societies.
The ability of workers/employees to protest, unionize, etc, has been historically important for all kinds of progress that we now take for granted (or that now has been starting to erode again, or completely eroded).
From hazard pay, to overtime, to paid vacations, to workplace safety gains, to maternity leave without vengeful termination, and all kinds of similar achievements, have been possible by people who organized inside companies.
"Affecting the company's image/revenues" is not a sufficient issue. If the company does bad stuff, treats employees badly, etc, then its image and revenues should justifiably suffer until it fixes those things, and that's good.
>I'm not taking sides nor talking about what's right, what's wrong
Oh, but you do, all the way to the weasel wording (1) "to do your fucking job Y", (2) "you use that money and time on activities Z", (3) "losing significant revenues", (4) "you didn't fulfil your contractual obligation to perform Y".
Who told you that (2), (3), (4) hold exactly, and especially (4)? Organizing some protest or unionizing is totally orthogonal to "performing Y" (your job) or not.
>If you don't like it, why don't you just quit and then sue the company instead?
Because this isn't the 1900s, and employees shouldn't be treated as mere replaceable cogs without rights and without say, even though many employees would prefer it that way.
So it gets very complicated when it comes to workers rights and ostensible legit claims of wrongdoing.
That said, it seems as the though the workers may have crossed some ugly lines which gives G some cover.
Kidding aside, if it's not your money and time on the line, it is hard to see people taking the side of a big co against a normal employee, even if the said employee was actively sabotaging the big co from inside. We are habitual to view all such scenarios as "David vs Goliath" kind of stories.