News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by Teever on Saturday October 12, 2019 @04:12AM (#21231427)
Can I ask you why you have this particular hope?

Is it because you are a user of apple products and hope that you will continue to do so in the future because you are dependent on them?

Is it because you believe that apple is a good company and you hope for the best for them?

Why should we hope for the best for a company that has made hundreds of billions off of offshoring jobs to an authoritarian country with little regard for investing in manufacturing in America?

The way I see it is that if China decides to squeeze Apple by restricting their production it will be a fair comeuppance for a company that has seen fit to extract billions in wealth from developers through their app store and has sought to turn their commodity hardware into status symbols to extract even more wealth from middle class people who want to feel like they're more than middle class.

If the executives at Apple had any foresight and any interest beyond self interest they would have encouraged domestic production a decade or more ago. Instead we have a situation where people are crying for poor Apple, a company who that has more money than god and who could have used that to create their own supply chain domestically which would have had tremendous benefits for America and the American people.

Instead they have chose to consort and ultimately enable an authoritarian country into a situation where they now pose a legitimate threat both militarily and culturally to America, the albeit flawed but last best hope for freedom in the world.

Think different indeed.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by awinder on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:37AM (#21232258)
Yeah, this is a super-weird anti-Apple flex. There’s a lot of problems with it, mostly that damn near every tech product is manufactured in China, or using majority components manufactured in China, etc. But here’s the biggest problem I have. China deliberately wanted to focus on this type of manufacturing for decades. You don’t just decide you’re going to manufacture iPhones and then poof in 6 months you’re running world-class operations. It would take untold time and dollars to develop these capabilities in a human workforce in America. What you’re all hopped up about, has literally no chance of happening.

I too have qualms with what is going on in China, but like everything that happens in this life, I’m flipping petrified of how much damage some reactionary american screed might do.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by ppf on Sunday October 13, 2019 @03:34AM (#21239003)
China accepts child labour, and runs ethnic concentration camps. Have you forgotten that standing up for what is right can result in negative personal consequences? Or have Americans gotten so used to consequence-free "protesting" of whatever is the current bogeyman in their safe country? This might be the most spineless and gutless comment I have seen on HN. If you ever wonder how people accept large-scale atrocities, here is the answer. They don't want any disruption to their supply of affordable iPhones.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by awinder on Sunday October 13, 2019 @10:34PM (#21244835)
If this is the most spineless and gutless comment you’ve read on hackernews, then welcome to hackernews and I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy the first comment you read here. Jesus, what an overreaction.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by ppf on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:41AM (#21246482)
Fine, but don't pretend you care about human rights in any context.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by awinder on Monday October 14, 2019 @06:43AM (#21246762)
Get help. Seriously. I don’t know why you’re keying in on me for making a comment about how Apple can’t just magically relocate millions of jobs to the US as being some kind of bad person. I’m purposefully not discussing the moral side of this, I’m rebutting the parents claim that Apple should just throw money at this and fix it. They can’t.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by ppf on Monday October 14, 2019 @09:18AM (#21247894)
Your first paragraph was on-point. I'm talking about the second one:

> I too have qualms with what is going on in China, but like everything that happens in this life, I’m flipping petrified of how much damage some reactionary american screed might do.

You make a moral statement about the activities of China, and then you say you're scared of the repercussions of taking any action.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by 14 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:55AM (#21233120)
You do realize how much money Apple makes right? They absolutely have the money to run these capabilities in America. They also have enough money they could do it in a timely manner. What they know would happen is the cost to actually manufacture an iPhone would shoot through the roof and they would be left either making less profit to sell the phone at the same price point it always has been, or they will have to dramatically reduce shareholder return. They don't want to do either of those things obviously because right now new iPhone cost around 1000$ and it is probably close to what the market will bare. So their only option would be reduce shareholder return and I think that is the only thing stopping them from moving home. Simply put they would not make as much profit.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by pwinnski on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:17AM (#21233285)
Is your argument that their manufacturing costs would increase by less than 30%? Or that you expect Apple to fold as a company?

You state "they absolutely have the money to run these capabilities in America." Apple's published margin on hardware is 30%, so if manufacturing in America increases costs by 30%, Apple no longer makes a profit selling hardware. If manufacturing increases costs by more than 30%, Apple starts losing money selling hardware.

Big numbers are big because Apple is selling many, many, many phones. That also means that adding to the cost of manufacturing by even a small amount per unit immediately chews up a lot of those outrageous profits.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by tooltalk on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:32AM (#21233428)
Apple buys iPhones wholesale from CMs (contract manufacturer) like Foxconn, Pegatron, etc for only $250-$350 and sells them for around $799-$1000 retail. The cost of labor (ie, final assembly; aka, manufacturing) in iPhone BOM, often born by CM's, is around $10-$12 per device.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by lovetocode on Saturday October 12, 2019 @05:15AM (#21231671)
This is spot on. I really enjoyed the point you made how this is karma for robbing App Store developers. I am not sure I understand the cultural threat though. Militarily from a cyber perspective they are certainly a threat.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by tonyedgecombe on Saturday October 12, 2019 @04:18AM (#21231447)
It's pointless expecting corporations do make those sort of sacrifices, it would be economic suicide.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by greggman2 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:14AM (#21232160)
Didn't pressure work for companies in South Africa? Didn't pressure work for catching dolphins in fish nets? Note I have no idea if those were effective. I was too young to know. I just remember lots of talk about it

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Apartheid_Movement

https://nvdatabase.swarthmore.edu/content/united-states-cons...

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:20AM (#21231933)
It's only economic suicide because people don't expect those "sacrifices". The market doesn't value ethics on its own, it has to be made to value it - by things like public expectations, customer pressure, or regulations.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by vharuck on Saturday October 12, 2019 @05:50AM (#21231811)
If a company chooses to heavily invest in a nation with limited freedoms, the suicide started when the decision was made. Not when the consequences start to hurt.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by throwaway2048 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @11:16AM (#21233785)
Yep, the idea that companies should be given a free pass to act with utter amorality because they put themselves in a situation where they are obliged to do so is ridiculous.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by LilBytes on Saturday October 12, 2019 @05:53AM (#21231828)
I very much doubt it would be suicide, it'd be an economic inconvenience. But even that cause hell to freeze over for their stock holders even if the loss was only momentary.

Publicly held companies will rarely choose the good of the public over the good of their stockholders unless given fiscal incentives through tax increases or tax decreases.

Unless they become as wealthy as Bill Gates and make a non-profit with their enormous wealth.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by lotsofpulp on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:04AM (#21231865)
Given that I don’t see ANY large companies that don’t manufacture or assemble in China, especially electronics, I don’t see how one can claim it would not be economic suicide.

Consumers have chosen their priorities, and they’re only able/willing to spend a little bit extra for a better product. They’re not going to spend that much more for more expensive labor too.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by mattacular on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:05AM (#21232385)
Interesting that you attempt lay some blame for the situation on consumers who have "chosen their priorities"

That is absurd. Consumers have absolutely no choice in the matter other than the most unpractical "avoid using modern electronics"

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by lotsofpulp on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:51AM (#21232650)
They did at some point in the past. Large portions of the US manufacturing and textile sector disappeared because people opted for the cheaper imported items. I don’t see any reason to assume they would be willing to pay more for labor now either.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by paulryanrogers on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:04AM (#21233184)
With increasingly depressed wages I do wonder at what point counterproductive choices become self reinforcing. Such as buying the cheapest even if it's long term cost is higher until there are no other options.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by mattacular on Saturday October 12, 2019 @11:13AM (#21233755)
I wonder if that has anything to do when flattening wages over the same period. I wonder if that has anything to do with trade and economic policy. Or you could just chalk it up to individual consumer choices (and their crazy preference for cheaper goods suddenly and magically on offer) if you'd rather not think much.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by Teever on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:05PM (#21234165)
Apple products have always been premium items that people choose to pay more for.

Apple could have simply raised their prices to account for differences in domestic manufacturing costs or swallowed the cost with decreased profit margins.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by lotsofpulp on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:46PM (#21234865)
Do you have any numbers on how much they would have to raise prices? Why would they already not be charging as high a price as they think their customers are willing (or able) to pay?
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by eastendguy on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:40AM (#21232577)
Samsung announced a few weeks ago to move all its (phone) manufacturing outside China:

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-samsung-elec-china/samsun...

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by tooltalk on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:54AM (#21233113)
Samsung is already gone. Samsung had foresight and is well diversified. The company started packing up and moving to Vietnam at their peak in China back in 2013. Most of their smartphones now come from Vietnam (and Samsung's Vietnam operation alone accounts for 1/4 of all export from Vietnam).
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by tuyhtoolots on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:54PM (#21238020)
> Samsung had foresight and is well diversified

By moving from one communist dictatorship to another communist dictatorship.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by tooltalk on Monday October 14, 2019 @07:02AM (#21246918)
from one man commie dictatorship that poses one political and economical threat to a one party commie dictatorship that poses no such risk. This is no brainer.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by lotsofpulp on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:55AM (#21232681)
Yes, and it’s going to Thailand and Vietnam and India, where the cost of inputs is cheapest (including dealing with government, the costs of which are going up in China).
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by tooltalk on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:50AM (#21233080)
Thailand No. It's mostly Vietnam -- and India possibly in near future. Sure, the wage is much lower in Vietnam, but the downside was that the country was known for low-cost textile and toys production until Samsung came along. There was literally no infrastructure for electronics production to speak of in those days and the company not only had to work with the gov't to build it from scratch, but also had to convince 200+ suppliers and contractors to move along with them.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by foogazi on Sunday October 13, 2019 @11:24AM (#21240867)
>a company that has seen fit to extract billions in wealth from developers through their app store

This doesn’t make sense - App Store is a voluntary program no one is forced to develop apps for iPhone, or even android

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by m10i on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:41AM (#21233029)
You didn't mention taxes. Doesn't Apple offshore their earnings as well?
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by csommers on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:12AM (#21233244)
Why would you NOT want to have that hope? Being reliant upon China for anything is a huge no-no.
[dead]
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by dang on Monday October 14, 2019 @01:23AM (#21245460)
Please don't post in the flamewar style to HN. Regardless of how strongly you feel and what good reasons you have for it (both are clear), it only makes this place worse and gives people more reasons to complain and post badly.

The way to respond to bad comments or misinformation is patiently and with correct information, delivered respectfully. That's hard to do when provoked, I know, but if you can't or don't want to do it, it's probably better not to post. Lashing back doesn't help.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by dtwest on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:10AM (#21232418)
Unfortunately, Apple's Chinese employees can't expect the same quality of treatment as their coworkers in America and Europe. The CCP allows this, and Apple (and the CCP) takes full advantage.

What does your nationality or your wife have to do with this? The Brits have an illustrious history of treating Chinese people well. Or all 'furriners' for that matter. But mocking Americans is much more fun than paying attention to any of that.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by vntx on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:52PM (#21234911)
>> “The Brits have an illustrious history of treating Chinese people well.”

Not sure if you’re being sarcastic, but you might have forgotten about the Opium Wars where no sides treated each other well, the Brits included.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by simonh on Sunday October 13, 2019 @08:03AM (#21239936)
Interesting. Redirection to discussing Chinese employment law. Redirection to talk about my nationality (which I just gave to give context for having a different view on moral treatment of Americans versus seemingly everyone else), and misdirection to a jab at British treatment of China in history.

Do you actually have any real point to make about the substance of my comment?

Accusing someone of having no interest above self interest, simply because they employ people in another country, is utterly morally bankrupt. Discuss.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by dtwest on Sunday October 13, 2019 @08:55AM (#21240121)
The original commenter is specifically objecting to outsourcing high tech manufacturing to a country with an authoritarian government. You are ignoring this point, and suggesting that the original commenter is morally bankrupt for hating foreigners. You are going after them for things they didn't explicitly say.

In my opinion, the real choice isn't between producing in China and producing in America. It is between China and countries like India or Brazil. If India is a democracy, has better labor laws than China, has more respect for free speech, then moving production to India is less likely to have negative externalities than China.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by yourbandsucks on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:30AM (#21232513)
You're eliding the part where said employees are often one generation away from subsistence farming and this is a step up for them.

That's how it happened in the west, too, no? Textile mills? I'm not saying anything about morality but it sounds standard to me.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by computerex on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:27AM (#21232220)
I don't even know what point you're trying to make. No one is inherently against the Chinese. People are against the CCP, and their disgusting authoritarian regime.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by javajosh on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:20AM (#21232192)
One must take care to distinguish between the Chinese people and their government. I don't think the GP was talking about the people - he was talking about the government. (I have always been impressed with the intelligence, humor and heart of the Chinese people I've known; and yet this makes the authoritarianism of their government even more striking).
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by yostrovs on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:00AM (#21232351)
Humor? Really?
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by javajosh on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:12AM (#21232426)
Well, I was last in China around 2005, and I could speak a little Mandarin, and this seemed to delight the people I (tried) to speak with. Once or twice someone bought be a beer, and even the vendors seemed happy to know that I knew how to haggle. I don't know -I just really liked it and felt at home.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by eternalban on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:16AM (#21231916)
This is a fair rant all around, but in my opinion your righteous anger is misplaced.

Apple, as other nominally American "multi-national" corporations, was and remains subject to government policy and plans.

Which institutions, centers of power, and influential individuals determined that the de-industrialization of United States was such a hot idea and pushed that to its extremes in the 90s?

Apple simply operated in the stated and promoted policy regime. They are not alone.

(Also cross your fingers regarding your "last hopes". Patriot Act. Secret courts. Permanent state of "national emergency" with attendant curtailment of our Natural Rights, "Surveillance Capitalism", ...)

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by goatinaboat on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:43AM (#21232044)
Which institutions, centers of power, and influential individuals determined that the de-industrialization of United States was such a hot idea and pushed that to its extremes in the 90s?

It’s worth remembering that in the 90s, Francis Fukuyama was the hottest philosopher around and there was a general belief that economic liberalisation would inevitably lead a country towards Western style democracy and all that entailed. No one, certainly no one as prominent as Fukuyama ever predicted the opposite would in fact occur.

Not that this excuses Apple or anyone else. Once it became apparent they should have acted urgently. Because it meant that all their basic assumptions about how the world works need to be re-evaluated.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by aiscapehumanity on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:54AM (#21232082)
Lol people like baudrilllard, gilles, and guattari had better 21st century predictions then fukuyama. Fukuyama is like the starwars of 90s philosophy, mainstream tripe.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by goatinaboat on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:01AM (#21232111)
Sure but I didn’t assert he was the greatest philosopher, only the most popular, the star of the show.

He has since renounced his 90s work, to be fair.

Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by FabHK on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:11AM (#21232794)
And arguably his 90s work has been caricatured and mischaracterised, too.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by mistermann on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:18PM (#21234662)
Ross Perot had a thing or two to say about the economic wisdom of offshoring America's manufacturing.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by pseudalopex on Saturday October 12, 2019 @03:15PM (#21235505)
Would Fukuyama have been as prominent if he predicted the opposite?
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by eternalban on Saturday October 12, 2019 @04:29PM (#21236002)
Fukuyama simply wrote a book. It strains credulity to think a single book moved the entire Western establishment to radically alter the status quo.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by goatinaboat on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:26PM (#21236804)
The End Of History wasn’t just a book, it was the whole fin-de-siecle zeitgeist. I guess you had to be there. He was the Anna Kournikova of philosophy back then.
Re:Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China by eternalban on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:13PM (#21237013)
I was there.

p.s.: https://www.newsbud.com/2018/02/09/the-rockefellers-and-roth...

(No, this news is not "fit to print" in The New York Times.)