News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by etchalon on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:19PM (#21196723)
I understand this is chaos, but it's chaos because it has to be. There's no way to move users from an world of opaque "if it's an application, it can do anything it wants" to a world of "applications should ask me when they want to do something" transparency.

The idea that Apple doesn't care about the Mac because it's trying to explicitly improve our privacy and security is … weird.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by mathemagics on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:06PM (#21198621)
Agree that it is overall an improved experience. After upgrading, I discovered that a VPN app wanted access to my Documents folder. No reason it would need that, so I simply denied it. Lo and behold, the app continues to work just fine as expected. IMO, this alone is a big reason to upgrade to Catalina.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by cactus2093 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:30PM (#21199744)
I wonder if maybe it just stores a settings file in there or something?

I've seen similar things with apps that request access to Dropbox or Google Drive just not being scoped granularly enough, so they just ask for access to your entire account to control a single file or folder. Which leads to a shitty situation, either you give up functionality like being able to declaratively override settings and sync them between machines, or you compromise your security and allow access. There's no way the PM for the product actually cares about granular permission scoping, so of course nobody actually implements in a safer way where you don't have to make this choice.

I haven't looked closely at the new MacOS permissions and how granular they can be, but I'm kind of curious how this will turn out. I suspect the average person will just get used to clicking allow on everything, so developers won't actually care about only asking for what they need, and not much will actually improve about security. But I hope to be proven wrong.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by mathemagics on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @12:38AM (#21200073)
Apple provides APIs for saving app settings in the app's sandbox. They require no additional permissions.

You're probably right that it's not nefarious in this app's case, but rather just developer ignorance. But even so, this is the right path to nudge developers towards better security practices.

Also, the permissions are contextual. I didn't see this dialog until I launched the app. Similarly, the first time an app wants to show a notification, the system prompts you to allow / deny it. I'm sure Apple can polish this more over time. But I will take this over the "nearly full-system access by default" paradigms that dominate desktop OS's.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by 72deluxe on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @04:26AM (#21201171)
Settings should be under ~/Library somewhere (perhaps ~/Library/Preferences?) and not in the Documents directory.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by cactus2093 on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @12:15PM (#21204602)
I've seen a number of apps that store settings or presets in Documents. Kind of the same ideas as dotfiles in your home directory, which seems pretty reasonable and I don't think there's one agreed right place for any of this.

A nice benefit of storing them in Documents is that it syncs to icloud automatically even on the free tier, so you can share it between all your computers.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Osiris on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:00AM (#21200459)
Another issue that comes up in these scenarios is after denying to change your mind. How do you give the app access now?

It's often not straight forward and often getting in some system settings somewhere. Android has this problem.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by mathemagics on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:02AM (#21200472)
Had the same concern, but the dialog tells you how to change it. Not only that, it'll take you directly to the correct location in system preferences, where all the apps & their permission status are listed.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by draugadrotten on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:33AM (#21200646)
So what you are saying is that you don't trust the application to access your Documents folder, but you trust it with creating a VPN tunnel to keep your network traffic safe?

uhmm....

To me, it seems that if the Documents permission dialogue in fact caught the app doing anything bad, it should remove all trust for the app and the developer. It's all or nothing, really.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by mathemagics on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:55AM (#21200743)
No, what I'm saying is that a VPN application does not need access to my Documents folder, and if it tries to access it, then I'd like to know about it.

Nor do I entrust it with all my network traffic. As to whether it warrants completely removing the app or not, it's up to the user to decide, isn't it?

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by berberous on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:44PM (#21197026)
It's a bad onboarding though, full stop, and not very Apple like. For example, I imagine there could be a way to present the user a screen with all apps, and ask the user on one screen to check/uncheck any that it would like to receive notifications for.

Similarly, for the apps requesting access to various things, if I were Apple, I'd wait a bit and then present the user a list with the apps requesting access, explaining why it's happening, etc.

So two simple screens with clear explanations and helpful advice, versus a million baffling popups.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Someone on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @06:36PM (#21198028)
”I imagine there could be a way to present the user a screen with all apps, and ask the user on one screen to check/uncheck any that it would like to receive notifications for”

All 150+ apps (I don’t know how many are installed by default, but I have 277 on my system), many of which the user won’t even know he has installed? (I just found out I have an “Adobe Air Uninstaller” and two “Abobe Air Application Uninstaller”s, something called “Computer.app”, and 11 different Java 8 updates, for example)

And no, I don’t think such a dialog would be useful because users could delete applications they “don’t use” from there. The average user simply doesn’t know which applications he doesn’t use. I certainly don’t.

I think they could do a bit better, but I don’t think this problem has an easy answer. For example, they could exclude all Apple apps from these questions, but I suspect that would (rightfully) give us “Apple gives its own applications preferential treatment” complaints.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by dpkonofa on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:33PM (#21198767)
I disagree but only for one major reason: the entire reason this is coming up is because the OP is using an old version of Alfred that wasn't prepped for the new permission settings of Catalina even though there's a fully compatible version that's been released since. The vast majority of users will never, ever get something this obnoxious so it's not a bad on-boarding experience as much as it's a side effect of running old software.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by ben509 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:33PM (#21199757)
I don't know the numbers, especially as companies have pushed hard to change upgrade habits. But unless they're forced by automatic upgrades, most people wait years to upgrade. Even if they are upgrading because they get new hardware, they run all those migration assistants and such to copy everything over.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by dpkonofa on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:49AM (#21200409)
I'm sure they do but, as in the case of Alfred, they're notified multiple times that there is a newer version and that their OS may not support all the features of the app and vice versa. You have to explicitly ignore the dialog boxes and install the new OS anyways to get the behavior being demonstrated in the OP.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by gowld on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:55PM (#21199552)
Surely many users have at least one piece of software that is a bit old.

This Mac notion of "if your software/hardware wasn't purchased this week, it's unsupported" is not a good look.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by etchalon on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @05:29PM (#21197474)
If you have one window, with checkboxes, the window would need to start with the boxes all unchecked. And users, being users, would then demand a way to check all of the boxes. And then what would the point of the notifications and requests be?

If they didn't, people would complain that they had to click all these checkboxes, and then missed one.

Or the window wouldn't have room for applications to explain why they needed that access.

Or they would, and users would maybe read the first one, but skip others.

There is no "better experience" which doesn't sacrifice the point of the prompts.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by ixtli on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:23PM (#21196784)
Yes their recent trend of moving user privacy to the forefront is one of the few really positive trends i've seen out of apple in the past 2-3 years. Ignoring that the questions being asked by the OS are good is very bizarre.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by danieldk on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:52AM (#21200425)
Yes their recent trend of moving user privacy to the forefront is one of the few really positive trends i've seen out of apple in the past 2-3 years.

Apple has moved privacy to the forefront for a much longer time. Apple was the first to roll out end-to-end encryption of messages to hundreds of millions of people (iMessage 2011), the first to roll out end-to-end encrypted (video) calls to hundreds of millions of people (Facetime, 2010). They introduced the secure enclave, which was quickly used throughout the OS with iPhone 5s in 2013.

Whatever reasons they have (and despite their failings), they have been pushing privacy for almost 10 years now.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:26PM (#21198733)
I expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked. It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard, or use my speakers, or read my keyboard.

If you bombard users with dialogues for every little thing, all you will do is train them to habitually click yes. Now you have lowered security, because users will ignore the more serious warnings too. And you've wasted everyone's time in the process.

This was exactly why UAC dialogues were largely a failure. And to think that UAC appears only once per app...

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by dpkonofa on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:35PM (#21198779)
You expect applications to have access to your desktop?

You should only ever expect the user to have access to the desktop and, even then, the only apps that would ever prompt for access to the desktop are those that aren't updated for High Sierra and above. On the latest versions of macOS, the Desktop folder is shared by iCloud. This is definitely not an instance where security has been lowered nor is this the standard behavior of the new OS.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @09:03PM (#21198963)
> You expect applications to have access to your desktop?

Yes! That's what applications do, they read and write files. Most other software is, more likely than not, either a game or a web page.

Does every app need to access my desktop specifically? No. But if we're trying to protect "normal users", I don't think most of them have the wherewithal to think through "what exact locations does and doesn't app X need to access?"

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by CDSlice on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @09:08PM (#21199001)
But they should only read and write files that you give it permission to. E.g, Word should only be reading and writing whatever files you open to edit, it shouldn't be able to access all the files in your Applications folder. If it needs temp files it can write those to it's designated section of the file system.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @09:55AM (#21203245)
Sure, if applications are able to do things in the exact way Apple imagines. Unfortunately, the real world is almost always more messy—there's always at least one exception that isn't provided for by Apple's sandbox. Look at how many Mac apps offer both stripped-down Mac App Store releases and separate, more robust versions if you buy from their official websites.

I'm by no means against Sandboxing, by the way. I think it's great that if you want to buy and use sandboxed apps—and are willing to accept more limited functionality as an occasional consequence—the Mac App Store provides that option for you. However, there needs to also be an alternate path, by which I can say "this is an application I trust, please let it do its job."

There should, of course, be several different permission levels—Parallels needs its own kernel extension, most applications don't. Permission prompts are an important part of enforcing that. And that's precisely why prompts need to be use sparingly—if you bombard the user with too many of messages, they'll ignore all of them.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by wayneftw on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:16PM (#21199367)
It should read and write whatever files it needs to without bothering me for every little thing. For instance, supposing they want to show you a welcome screen with all of your documents from your Documents folder (or anywhere else) - I don't want some asinine popup asking me for permission. Word is a well-known application. I installed it. I trust it and the corporation that wrote it. That's enough for me.

The alleged problem is not even solved by a permission dialog. I should answer OK to the fact that it needs to access all of my Documents, forever, and that's supposed to be more secure? Why not just ask me for permission to my whole drive so it can scan for documents everywhere? Apps will just start asking for more and more permissions like they do on iOS, which is annoying.

macOS is slowly but surely being turned into iOS. It's software for the lowest common denominator - the average idiot - which I'm not, at least when it comes to technology.

Thankfully, my workstations are all Linux but I still have to deal with both macOS and Windows on a daily basis. But at least on Windows, the permissions annoyances can be avoided by simply not using UWP apps from their app store. I hope there's a way to turn this off on macOS but knowing Apple I doubt there will be because clearly they're on a mission to wipe macOS off the table. Perhaps that would be a good thing though. More people will move to Linux.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by danieldk on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:17AM (#21200558)
For instance, supposing they want to show you a welcome screen with all of your documents from your Documents folder (or anywhere else) - I don't want some asinine popup asking me for permission. Word is a well-known application. I installed it. I trust it and the corporation that wrote it. That's enough for me.

But this is not how it works. Word from the App Store is sandboxed. If you open a document in Word, this is done using the native file opening dialog. This is a separate, privileged process. The file is symlinked into Word's sandbox as a result. This means that Word has access to that file from that point onwards. So, it can show a welcome screen with documents that you have previously opened (which is what applications typically do, very few applications will show all documents).

This is how things have worked ever since Apple required sandboxing for App Store apps. The problem is non-App Store apps that are not sandboxed. They have unfettered access to every file. I guess these extra permissions are to provide a certain level of protection against such apps, which is good.

Word is a well-known application. I installed it. I trust it and the corporation that wrote it.

There are many well-known incidents of trusted applications being compromised and backdoored. E.g.:

https://blog.malwarebytes.com/threat-analysis/mac-threat-ana...

To make things worse, the hash was updated in Homebrew cask. So even if you used a package manager, you would have installed a compromised application. Trusting applications may have been ok in the age of shrink-wrapped software. But now that applications are distributed over the web, allowing unfettered access is insanity.

More people will move to Linux.

The Linux ecosystem is also moving towards immutable base systems (Fedora Silverblue, NixOS) and restricted, sandboxed applications (Flatpak). Sure, it will always be possible to install a 70ies UNIX-style distribution. But the world is moving to sandboxing and putting up more restrictions, because the computing world became more hostile.

macOS is slowly but surely being turned into iOS.

This is getting tired and old. People said the same thing ten years ago and yet here we are, macOS is still an OS for 'general purpose computing'. I think Apple is finding a nice balance between securing the average user through sandboxing and SIP, while keeping giving the knobs to disable protections to advanced users. I say this as someone who currently uses Linux 95% of the time, but I wish Linux was as far as macOS with application sandboxing and system integrity protection.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Crinus on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @06:24AM (#21201750)
> People said the same thing ten years ago and yet here we are, macOS is still an OS for 'general purpose computing'.

Well, the "slow" part can be slower than ten years. It might just still not be there, but compared to how macOS was 10 years ago, it does have more iOS-like restrictions nowadays even if it isn't full-on iOS.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by wayneftw on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @09:40AM (#21203073)
> But this is not how it works. Word from the App Store is sandboxed.

Yes, that is how it works. Sandboxed apps can absolutely request access to an entire folder. See here:

https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Se...

> An app-scoped bookmark provides your sandboxed app with persistent access to a user-specified file or folder.

But all of that isn't really relevant to what I was saying. You're bringing up technical details about how sandboxed apps work. I'm saying that sandboxes suck and I don't want them, particularly from Apple who will just use security as an excuse to take away more of my freedoms.

> I guess these extra permissions are to provide a certain level of protection against such apps, which is good.

I would rather not trade my freedom and liberty for even more annoying and absolutely useless security measures. You see the top comment on this thread now right? It's about how useless these dialogs are and how Apple has actually argued against them in the past.

> There are many well-known incidents of trusted applications being compromised and backdoored.

So? Don't update right away if your OS manufacturer can't be bothered to run a properly curated package management system that vets packages before anyone installs them.

> But now that applications are distributed over the web, allowing unfettered access is insanity.

I've been using desktop software for 30 years and for 25 of them, I've been downloading it from the Internet. My simple security measure are to verify sources, turn off automatic updates, don't update right away and read the news. Haven't had a problem yet.

> The Linux ecosystem is also moving towards immutable base systems (Fedora Silverblue, NixOS) and restricted, sandboxed applications (Flatpak).

Some Linux distributions are moving towards that. Anyway, I'm fine with immutable base systems. I'm even fine with sandboxed apps, as long as the permissions request infrastructure isn't annoying as it is in iOS and now macOS. And, as long as I can still install non-sandboxed apps without any further useless annoyance.

> This is getting tired and old.

No it's not. It's getting one tick closer with every release and if you want, we can certainly detail each time that macOS has changed to become more like an iPhone. Some part of you must realize that this is exactly what Apple would love to do as quickly as possible but they won't risk alienating users just yet. Do you really not see how Apple has been moving towards a less general purpose computer?

I mean, I wouldn't even call macOS "general purpose" to begin with because you can only really install it on Apple hardware. Right from the very start with Apple, their OS has always been more like "Apple purpose" - software that you can only use for Apples purposes.

> macOS is still an OS for 'general purpose computing'.

Yes, for now. Just a little bit less with each release.

> I wish Linux was as far as macOS with application sandboxing and system integrity protection.

No thanks. The world needs less security theater, more actual security and more freedom to use our own bodies and properties as we wish.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by w0utert on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @05:24AM (#21201474)
The typical desktop for most user is a dumping ground for whatever it is they are currently working on. Or in some cases more or less anything they've been working on for the past years. A dumping ground full of potentially sensitive documents, work-in-progress files that are not supposed to leak beyond the computer, etc.

Do you really think any application on your computer should be allowed to read and write them because "that's what applications do"? 90% of the 'applications' on my computer I didn't even install myself, like uninstallers, updaters, helper applications, background services, whatever. These have no business looking at files in my Desktop folder. And particularly not if its on iCloud and shared with other devices like my phone.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:19AM (#21204030)
Applications can write files perfectly fine without the ‘can access the desktop’ permission. When you tell the application to open a file using the system dialogs, the system automatically grants the application access to read and write the file.

The permission is needed only when the application wants to go around the normal way of opening files.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by dpkonofa on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:46AM (#21200396)
Applications do not need permission. The user that is currently controlling the application needs to be able to use that application to read and write files but there's no reason that the application needs access when it's not in focus and, with the sandbox model in Catalina, applications have the ability to ask for explicit read/write permissions without prompting the user if they've already given access to install it.

The biggest protection here is that the folder is shared via iCloud in most instances. Asking for explicit permission is really the only way to do that safely.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by dwaite on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @03:35AM (#21200932)
> I expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked. It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard, or use my speakers, or read my keyboard.

I would like to know if an application:

- Is scanning the contents of my documents or desktop outside of files I specifically selected or it previously created

- Is monitoring data going on the clipboard

- Wants permission to make alert sounds or play other audio even if my sound is silenced/muted

- Wants to listen to my microphone

- Wants to monitor sound being output by other applications, such as VOIP

- Is monitoring for keystrokes even when it is not in the foreground.

> If you bombard users with dialogues for every little thing, all you will do is train them to habitually click yes. Now you have lowered security, because users will ignore the more serious warnings too. And you've wasted everyone's time in the process.

If the new permissions were about security, they would all be denied and applications would have to figure out how to cope. They are about user privacy.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @10:20AM (#21203508)
> If the new permissions were about security, they would all be denied and applications would have to figure out how to cope. They are about user privacy.

As I see it, those are the same things within this context. The effect is the same. Users are just going to click yes. They aren't going to think through "what other files are on my desktop right now?"

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by JustFinishedBSG on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @05:00AM (#21201358)
> I expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked.

You mean the place where your mom stores her confidential banking statements ?

> It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard,

You mean the place where you often copy paste passwords ?

> or read my keyboard.

You mean the place where you type your sensitive infos ?

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @10:18AM (#21203492)
This is precisely why I chose those examples. My keystrokes contain sensitive information—the ability to read them comes with enormous potential for misuse. However, if my keystrokes can't be read, my keyboard isn't useful for much.

At some point, the only way to be truly secure is to switch off the computer—that's why voting should be done on paper ballots! Once a computer is switched on and connected, everything is a tradeoff between usability and security. Personally, I have work to get done.

At what point is Apple the only one able to make useful software? And by the way, while Apple is pretty good at user privacy, they are by no means at the top of my list, particularly after the whole Siri debacle.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by GeekyBear on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @09:22PM (#21199076)
Not being asked to grant all permissions that an application wants up front (before you even get a chance to use the app) has a positive impact on the user experience.

If the application asks for permission to access my contacts only after I select an option to share information with others, for instance, I can feel more confident about granting that permission.

Asking for all permissions up front is the permissions model that Google just abandoned.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by js2 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:46PM (#21197045)
Apple could have figured out a way to coalesce all the individual pop-ups into a single window. I'm sure they considered it and deemed it not worth the effort since this is a one-time pain... of course it's one-time pain shared by millions of users. :-(
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by etchalon on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @05:26PM (#21197441)
An individual window would have completely destroyed the point.

The point was to make you aware of what permissions the applications you use require access to.

And to get explicit permission from the user.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by inferiorhuman on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:18AM (#21200259)
An individual window would have completely destroyed the point.

Hardly. Apple could have used the OSX installer to scan two or three common locations for applications and do a bit of static analysis. Apple could have put the permissions notifications in the notification center with an annoying nag screen every hour or two for the first ~30 days turning into an immediate prompt after that (or after all detected programs have been processed).

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by 72deluxe on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @04:29AM (#21201181)
If a program calls fopen, how is static analysis going to help?

It will just know that the program will open a file of some kind, not the location of said file.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by etchalon on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:30AM (#21200311)
That sounds like deeply awful UX.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by inferiorhuman on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:36AM (#21200343)
That sounds like deeply awful UX.

Indeed, almost as bad as popping up countless dialogs per application.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by etchalon on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:48AM (#21200401)
Ah, yes, the tyranny of using the mechanism designed to ask a user to read and confirm something to read and confirm multiple somethings.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by inferiorhuman on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:13AM (#21200532)
Ah, yes, the tyranny of using the mechanism designed to ask a user to read and confirm something to read and confirm multiple somethings.

So what's the point then? To inflict more pain?

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by toomim on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:24PM (#21198722)
You could do that within a single window.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by 72deluxe on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @04:32AM (#21201197)
How?

It shows it at the point of access request. If 2 programs request access 5 minutes apart, how would you show that in a single window?

Do you suspend the first program and wait until another application makes an access request? What happens if another doesn't make a request in a given time period? Will the user wonder why the first application has stopped doing anything useful for 5 minutes?

Honestly, how would you show this in a single window?

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by burk96 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:54PM (#21198909)
You certainly could, however I guarantee a huge majority of users wouldn't read a lick of what they were agreeing to.

Individual popups don't completely solve this, but it makes more obvious that a specific application is requesting a large amount of permissions. They're a bit more digestible to the crowd that won't bother to read an alert longer than one line.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:30AM (#21204134)
It’s not like an overwhelming majority of Mac OS users has configured their machine to auto start a vpn, a virtual machine server and all these fragile utilities.

I doubt any regular user is going to see anywhere near this amount of warnings.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by microcolonel on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @09:17PM (#21199055)
I don't know about this somehow being proof that "Apple doesn't care about the Mac" or something, but I remember distinctly when Apple themselves, and the fanboys, were ragging on Microsoft for UAC (which really only asks you to confirm occasional administrative operations).

As for the general quality of Catalina, there seems to be a deluge of amateur-hour flaws that affect real workflows for real users.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by charredbacon on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:57PM (#21199571)
I disagree that there's no transition.

This looks like a pretty good alternative:

https://www.andrew.cmu.edu/user/bparno/papers/user-driven.pd...

Instead of the OS displaying an annoying prompt when the application tries to use a privilege, the application embeds an OS-drawn access control gadget inside its UI, such that the user interacting with the UI grants the privilege.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by misterdata on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:37AM (#21200662)
Actually not far from how it works on macOS. Usage of a system "open file" dialog automatically creates a permission for the application to access that file from inside its container.

https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Se... (search for "Powerbox")

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by comex on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @02:34AM (#21200647)
macOS does something similar already for file open/save dialogs: they’re drawn by a trusted OS component instead of directly by the app, and the user’s act of selecting a file grants the app permission to access that file without an additional dialog.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by DevKoala on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:30PM (#21198748)
Very well said. It is a rough upgrade, but a step forward in security and privacy.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by celadevra_ on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @12:28AM (#21200022)
> a world of "applications should ask me when they want to do something" transparency.

Why not make the user know what applications do: which files, ports, devices it has to access, and what data it emits, to begin with?

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by rinchik on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:26PM (#21196820)
Second this. It's a major security update that allows you to re-evaluate and more precisely manage access rights that your existing apps have. Not sure what "super user" author is really sad about. No one is keeping him from using windows.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by mtrower on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:02PM (#21198231)
Erm, preferring the old Apple experience (or even a perceived old Apple experience) to the modern Apple experience does not necessarily mean he would prefer the Microsoft experience to the modern Apple experience...
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by bsaul on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:50PM (#21197094)
I don’t think that’s intentional though. Otherwise a proper way would simply be to prompt the user with something like « you’ve just upgraded your system, would you like to take this as an opportunity to reevaluate all your applications access rights ? ».
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by Spivak on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @05:25PM (#21197433)
Almost every user clicks no and moves on with their life and then we’re put into a weird situation where apps installed prior to Catalina have a ton of permissions and apps post Catalina have comparably few.

You could say this is fine but it does demonstrate that something bad probably happened because we’re they presented the immediate option for existing apps they would have made a different choice.

Right now I have iOS 13 and it’s been great to see how many apps want but 1000% have no need for Bluetooth access — it’s nice to not have to comb through settings and revoke them manually.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by agret on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:01PM (#21199277)
It really says a lot that he has no provision for comments on his posts.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by api on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:51PM (#21198881)
It's just change = bad without looking at what is being changed and why.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by fbelzile on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @09:07PM (#21198994)
The "privacy" dialog popups are just marketing. Sure, there may have been an issue with a few bad apps, but Apple found a way to continuously remind you that they are the only ones that 'care about your privacy'TM. Meanwhile, they still happily take Google's money to make it the default search engine in Safari.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by etchalon on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:52AM (#21200428)
… how is an actual functional limitation imposed on applications through an operating system's APIs "just marketing"?

If you click deny, BEHOLD, the application is denied that permission.

Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by bsaul on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:47PM (#21197063)
I don’t think you read the post properly : all those popups appeared after an OS migration. I don’t see why upgrading the OS would need you to reauthorize apps, and even parts of the OS like icloud shouldn’t require you to relog (unless the security mechanism of icloud itself has been upgraded to a new system with no migration possible of the credentials).
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by azinman2 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:20PM (#21198699)
These are new permissions that didn’t previously exist.
Re:macOS 10.15 Vista by gowld on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:59PM (#21199578)
No, they are new restrictions that didn't previously exist.

Users were already "owned" before Catalina, so waiting 5 minutes to avoid spamming 100 popups isn't a major risk.