All 150+ apps (I don’t know how many are installed by default, but I have 277 on my system), many of which the user won’t even know he has installed? (I just found out I have an “Adobe Air Uninstaller” and two “Abobe Air Application Uninstaller”s, something called “Computer.app”, and 11 different Java 8 updates, for example)
And no, I don’t think such a dialog would be useful because users could delete applications they “don’t use” from there. The average user simply doesn’t know which applications he doesn’t use. I certainly don’t.
I think they could do a bit better, but I don’t think this problem has an easy answer. For example, they could exclude all Apple apps from these questions, but I suspect that would (rightfully) give us “Apple gives its own applications preferential treatment” complaints.
This Mac notion of "if your software/hardware wasn't purchased this week, it's unsupported" is not a good look.
If they didn't, people would complain that they had to click all these checkboxes, and then missed one.
Or the window wouldn't have room for applications to explain why they needed that access.
Or they would, and users would maybe read the first one, but skip others.
There is no "better experience" which doesn't sacrifice the point of the prompts.
Similarly, for the apps requesting access to various things, if I were Apple, I'd wait a bit and then present the user a list with the apps requesting access, explaining why it's happening, etc.
So two simple screens with clear explanations and helpful advice, versus a million baffling popups.