News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by JohnGB on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:02AM (#21058224)
The fact that it was unanimous really drives home how obviously illegal it was. I would love to see a direct criminal or civil consequence for this, as it negatively affected the rights of all UK citizens.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by makomk on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:35AM (#21058432)
It wasn't obvious at all. Even ignoring the fact that traditionally this was outside the purview of the courts entirely, the Supreme Court had to take a very aggressive approach to the evidence to get this result. First, they decided that it didn't matter whether the Prime Minister had unlawful intent, only whether prorogation did in fact frustrate Parliament. Secondly, they decided that it was up to the Prime Minister to prove in detail that his prorogation didn't have this effect. (This was important because no-one has been able to come up with a convincing argument for how exactly this particular prorogation would stop Parliamentary scrutiny of Brexit. It was scheduled to avoid all the important dates where such scrutiny was likely, and the court had documents showing this was intentional.) Thirdly, they had to play up the fact that Parliament could theoretically sit or carry out other actions during the three-week party conference season if it was in the usual recess rather than prorogued in order to justify the claim that this prorogation was at all unusual in the first place. Which is technically true, but by convention no-one does this because using your control of parliament in ways that monkey with the other parties' annual conferences is pretty bad for democracy.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by conistonwater on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:19AM (#21060448)
You should be aware that your summary contradicts in parts the court's own summary at https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2019-0192-summar... You should just read it, it's not written in impenetrable legalese or something.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by jfk13 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:57AM (#21060865)
Or take 15 minutes to watch Lady Hale read the summary: https://www.supremecourt.uk/watch/prorogation/judgment.html

It's a model of calmness and clarity.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by rkangel on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:25AM (#21061171)
Thank you for linking that. I was immediately arrested by the following line: "On 27th or 28th August, in a telephone call, he formally advised Her Majesty to prorogue Parliament between those dates".

Is this really implying that the government doesn't keep track of Prime Ministerial communication to the extent that we're not even sure what day he gave formal advice to the queen?! Surely at the very least there is a call log.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by vidarh on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:58AM (#21060197)
There was no reason to come up with an argument for how this would stop scrutiny of Brexit, as the only arbiter of what matters to parliament is parliament. Further this argument rings hollow when Boris has demonstrated an extraordinary willingness to try to sidestep the wishes of parliament in this respect, and so Parliament has every reason to want to be able to react quickly to any further attempts from the government to act in ways it has no support for.

As such, when a group of parliamentarians are among those who have sued arguing their ability to do their job is frustrated, then parliament is frustrated.

The recess issue is relatively irrelevant given that we're already in uncharted waters, with Parliament having sat unusually long due to Brexit. It's already established that the timeline relating to Brexit means other conventions are being sidelined because of the importance of getting this sorted. Since Boris didn't wait for votes over recess to happen, he can not say that there would not have been adjustments made. E.g. even if Parliament as a whole were not to sit, there'd have been nothing stopping Parliament from continuing certain committee work, for example.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by mantap on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:59AM (#21060211)
> This was important because no-one has been able to come up with a convincing argument for how exactly this particular prorogation would stop Parliamentary scrutiny of Brexit.

I know that the judgment is very recent but I suggest that you read it in full when you get a chance. The court specifically noted that a substantial amount of delegated legislation related to Brexit was scheduled to be handled by parliamentary committees in the period (under provisions in the European Withdrawal Act), and that parliamentary committees continue to sit during recess. They specifically rejected the Government’s claim that a recess period is equivalent to a prorogation, noting that during a recess parliamentary questions can still be asked (and answered) and committees continue to sit.

The prorogation is unlawful not because it prevents debate on the floor of the houses, but because it shuts down all activity in parliament in way that recess does not, and that no reasonable explanation was given to do this.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by makomk on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:38AM (#21061318)
I'd have to have a very close look at the exact details of that. It's certainly possible for parliamentary committees to continue to sit during recess, but it doesn't look like they generally have during the conference period before (presumably because the Commons committees are made up of MPs who are busy with the conferences), and the government was already quite visibly scraping the barrel to find even delegated legislation to occupy Parliament's time back in July. There were some quite rude remarks from opposition MPs about how inconsequential some of the Brexit-related legislation they were scrutinizing was!
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:24AM (#21058361)
The funny thing is, prorogation was a democratically elected government trying to prevent a democratically elected parliament from democratically (by members of parliament) stopping a democratic (by the populace) decision to exit the EU.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by Ensorceled on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:31AM (#21058410)
I think we can all agree the referendum was not “I want to leave the EU in the most chaotic and economically dangerous way possible, preferably with no plan for what to do next”
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by stordoff on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:23AM (#21061153)
Indeed. Vote Leave, the campaign lead by Boris Johnson, Michael Gove, and Dominic Cummings, three of the men now at the helm (PM, Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, and adviser, respectively) said (add at the time):

> The day after nothing changes legally. There is no legal obligation on the British Government to take Britain out of the EU immediately. There will be three stages of creating a new UK-EU deal - informal negotiations, formal negotiations, and implementation including both a new Treaty and domestic legal changes. There is no need to rush. We must take our time and get it right.

http://www.voteleavetakecontrol.org/briefing_newdeal.html

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by repolfx on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:30AM (#21059328)
In fact it was. It was a simple vote between leaving and remaining, with the exact details of both options being left undefined. Certainly our remainer establishment would have wasted no time in interpreting a Remain vote as permission to rapidly speed up integration.

The pathologically EU-loyal British establishment is now trying to destroy the vote via the following simple trick:

1. Declare that there's no way to leave without a "deal"

2. Make it clear to the EU they can dictate any terms they want whatsoever because the UK will under no circumstances walk away from the table.

3. EU dictates terms that are essentially the same as not leaving, or actually even worse.

4. Establishment declares that this "deal" is the same thing as leaving and tries to ram it through, or failing that, to cancel the whole thing by claiming that the UK can't leave unless the EU agrees due to <generic chaos>. Both outcomes are fine by them because it establishes for good the principle that leaving the EU should be as impossible as an American State seceding from the Union, which is what they want.

What we see at the moment are people actually working in the real economy, like port operators, saying they're prepared for no deal and there'd be no disruption at all. The EU has also quietly agreed various unrelated agreements to e.g. keep planes flying and even granting London a financial passport, the thing they said they'd never actually do. The fact that "no deal" actually means already "a bunch of small continuity deals" has gone largely unnoticed in the UK.

But ultimately now it's gone far beyond port disruption, mobile roaming costs or other trivial things. The British people are receiving a message loud and clear that the entire ruling class simply will not let the UK leave unless the EU agrees, despite it being a theoretically self-governing nation. If the UK doesn't leave without the EU's agreement then many will conclude it's actually a dictatorship.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:54AM (#21059554)
To be fair, the reason that the UK has not left the EU is because the Tory Eurosceptics refused to vote for Theresa May's deal. Not once, not twice, but three times.

I think that the real issue here is that there doesn't appear to be a majority in Parliament for anything (witness the indicative votes earlier this year, which found no majority for any form of deal).

I think that the reason many MP's are unwilling to let the UK leave without a deal are as follows:

1) It doesn't solve anything. You still need to agree what to do for a future relationship, from a much, much weaker position (only Council of Ministers agreeement for Article 50 deal, versus Council, EU Parliament and all national regional parliaments required for a future trade deal).

2) The EU will not allow any trade deals to happen unless the Irish border, the rights of EU citizens and the money issues are resolved.

3) The UK imports the majority of their food, and WTO tariffs are really high on food, leading to potential problems with food supply (remember that it's November, when not much grows in the UK).

Like, I don't doubt that some MP's want to remain in the EU, but for my money most of them have voted for some form of Brexit deal, with the exception of the rabidly fanatical members of the European Research Group.

Additionally, with respect to the terms offered by the EU: Yes, they will be worse than staying in the EU. By definition, if you leave a club, you no longer have access to the facilities of the club. It would make zero sense for the EU to do a deal for the UK that was better or the same as membership, because no-one would remain in the EU then.

I think that the citizens of the UK have been let down by many of their political representatives, but i don't believe that their desire to remain in the EU is the cause.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by redslazer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:36AM (#21060626)
I don’t understand point 3. Why would the WTO tariff rate matter, are they not maximums? Couldn’t the UK just set import tariffs to 0 for a period?
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:45AM (#21060728)
No because of the most favoured nation principle. You have to have the same tax rate for everyone, hence if you set it 0% for EU imports, you need to do the same for everyone, and then no one will do a trade deal with you (as they already have no tariffs).
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomatocracy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:25AM (#21059856)
> To be fair, the reason that the UK has not left the EU is because the Tory Eurosceptics refused to vote for Theresa May's deal. Not once, not twice, but three times.

If all the Eurosceptics had voted for May's deal, it still wouldn't have had the numbers to pass. I think its fairer to lay the blame on the opposition parties who voted against it largely to try to create chaos which they thought would lead them to an election they could win.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by mpweiher on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:02AM (#21060252)
It's not the job of opposition parties to vote for the policies of the government.

Otherwise you don't have an opposition, and then you don't have much of a democracy.

It's the job of the government to secure the votes it needs for its policies, and conversely to propose policies for which it can secure the necessary votes.

That's democracy.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by iainmerrick on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:59AM (#21060207)
If the government needed opposition votes to pass a deal, why didn’t they make any concessions to opposition demands?

To the contrary, May’s government only tried to appease the hard-liners in her own party. Johnson has taken it even further in the same direction.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by sjogress on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:18AM (#21060440)
Didn't May have a majority of 1 vote (Tories + DUP) through the negotiations though?
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:01AM (#21060237)
That is completely incorrect. If everyone supporting the UK government at the time had voted for the deal, it would have passed. The ERG and the DUP were the cause of it's failure (and I'm looking forward to the reckoning the DUP get in the next elections as a result of this)>
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomatocracy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:08AM (#21060323)
The pro European Tory votes against the deal together with opposition votes were enough to sink it. Even if the entire ERG had voted for it.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:46AM (#21060752)
Sorry, which pro-European tories voted against Theresa May's deal? Can you supply a list?

Like, the first vote definitely wouldn't have passed with them, but the third definitely would have.

Now personally, I think the Opposition should have voted for the deal, but the primary respionsibility falls on the government.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomatocracy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:10AM (#21061011)
At least Guto Bebb, Phillip Lee, Dominic Grieve, Sam Gyimah, Jo Johnson, and Justine Greening (there may be others I’ve missed).

May’s majority including the DUP at the time was 7 (I think - this was after the defections to the Independent Group) so those 6 would have tipped it into a loss on their own.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:51AM (#21061452)
Cool, fair point. I didn't think that they'd rebelled till later. I still stand by my contention that the withdrawal bill would have passed were it not for the trenchant opposition from the ERG and DUP, but accept that the numbers don't entirely suport my story.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomatocracy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:20PM (#21061782)
I think to be fair, if the DUP had supported it then there’s a very good argument that that would have changed minds sufficiently elsewhere that it could have passed. Playing counter factuals on this type of thing is very difficult though because, for example, some MPs likely took a view that they wanted to be on the winning/losing side for reasons mostly unrelated to the contents of the deal itself.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by rtempaccount1 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:08AM (#21060332)
That's just not true. If the DUP and the conservatives had voted to pass Theresa May's deal they absolutely had the numbers to pass it, especially given that on each of the votes there were a small number of Labour MPs who voted with it.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:41AM (#21059436)
> Both outcomes are fine by them because it establishes for good the principle that leaving the EU should be as impossible as an American State seceding from the Union, which is what they want.

Leaving the EU is pretty easy. There's a raft of existing models to base the new relationship on - Norway, Switzerland etc. Pick one, maybe tweak it slightly to make sure you don't start a war in NI, done.

The problem is that the entire process is being run by isolationist extremists who see the UK's largest trading partner as Beelzebub and reject any form of broad agreement with the EU.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by viraptor on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:06AM (#21059689)
> Certainly our remainer establishment would have wasted no time in interpreting a Remain vote as permission to rapidly speed up integration.

That's a nice strawman you're building...

> EU dictates terms that are essentially the same as not leaving, or actually even worse.

Yes. I mean, what else would you expect? They're not going to treat a random country better than EU partners.

> working in the real economy, like port operators, saying they're prepared for no deal and there'd be no disruption at all

Real people already have to apply for residency and not everybody gets it. Disruption has already happened.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by repolfx on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:40AM (#21060006)
The Withdrawal Agreement is worth studying in more detail. The EU is demanding terms that are infinitely worse than it has ever offered to any country. The UK is not being treated as a third country like a Japan or America. That would be fine. It's being treated as a special case, like no other country anywhere in the world.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by ceejayoz on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:12AM (#21061047)
> The EU is demanding terms that are infinitely worse than it has ever offered to any country.

For example...?

> It's being treated as a special case, like no other country anywhere in the world.

It is a special case, like no other country anywhere in the world.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by Ensorceled on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:02AM (#21060254)
> In fact it was. It was a simple vote between leaving and remaining, with the exact details of both options being left undefined. Certainly our remainer establishment would have wasted no time in interpreting a Remain vote as permission to rapidly speed up integration.

While the referendum was yes or no, the framing was radically different. The "leavers" ran on a platform of, essentially, we have a plan, the EU will co-operate and there will hundreds of millions of pounds of savings. Then, post-referendum, some of the leaders (including Boris) promptly resigned because they had no plan, others negotiated badly (and one could say, in bad faith), and it became clear there was not going to be millions of pounds in savings.

"Vote yes! There'll be ice cream, cake, and unicorns."

"I vote yes!"

"Thanks! Now, there's no ice cream, the cake is Pineapple Upside-Down Cake and unicorns don't exist you bloody git."

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by elyobo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:56AM (#21059579)
> I think we can all agree the referendum was not “I want to leave the EU in the most chaotic and economically dangerous way possible, preferably with no plan for what to do next”

> In fact it was. It was a simple vote between leaving and remaining

So... do you mean "In fact it was", or do you mean "It was a simple vote between leaving and remaining"?

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:38AM (#21058450)
The government is not directly elected. It is, in a sense that's both very technical and actually constitutionally important at the moment, appointed by the Queen.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by maitredusoi on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:14AM (#21059756)
This is just a technical point of view, as from now on the Queen has always appointed a person that has been choosen by the parliament. Perhaps with Willam, thing will change, but sorry, with QEII , I can't see her saying I appoint Corbyn even if parliament decide it is Johnson ;)
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomatocracy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:28AM (#21059895)
Actually, the Queen was historically rather more involved than this in the era of Hume, Macmillan and Eden; and previous monarchs before her even more so.

I agree that in the current era though, she would only send for an alternate PM if they had demonstrated confidence of the House of Commons, which is very unlikely.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:28AM (#21058757)
> The government is not directly elected.

Almost no government is.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by pmyteh on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:07AM (#21059697)
That's the major difference between Presidential systems and Parliamentary ones. In the first, the head of government is directly elected and the legislature separately, and in the latter the legislature chooses one of its own as head of government. Semi-Presidential systems (like France) are somewhere in between.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by pavlov on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:28AM (#21058394)
The Johnson government isn't democratically elected by any usual definition.

The government doesn't have a parliamentary majority, and Boris hasn't stood as a PM candidate in a general election.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by jajag on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:24AM (#21059281)
All true - and yet this parliament seems remarkably reluctant to allow the electorate the opportunity to correct this state of affairs.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by taejo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:54AM (#21059561)
It's almost as if the clock is ticking on a very important deadline, and parliament wants to make sure it is dealt with before it takes any other action that might delay that.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by rsynnott on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:24PM (#21061827)
If parliament allows an election now, it presents an opportunity for Boris to weasel his way out of requesting an extension. Given past Boris performance, why on earth would they?
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by lambertsimnel on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:58AM (#21059590)
Opposition parties might be concerned about being absent from Parliament when the Brexit deadline passes.

There's another problem, too. The First Past the Post electoral system prevents the electorate from correcting the state of affairs (except perhaps by accident). Call me cynical, but calls for an early general election under the existing system look like a power grab rather than a sincere attempt to let the electorate decide.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by jajag on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @06:27AM (#21069366)
God forbid that voters have a say!
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by lambertsimnel on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @08:24AM (#21070046)
Voters should have a say under proportional representation. Holding a general election under First Past the Post would likely hand the government to a faction with minority support. I don't mean this to be partisan or pro-/anti-Brexit, but FPTP typically doesn't settle issues and increasingly doesn't provide good government in the UK.

FPTP typically overrepresents some parties at the cost of others (and at the cost of voters). Politicians might want an election when they believe they will be more overrepresented afterwards than before. That's why it's no surprise for the opposition to suddenly stop wanting an election when the government begins to want one.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by simonh on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:53AM (#21059543)
Prime Ministers are elected by parliament, not directly by the people although they must be elected MPs. This isn't America or France.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by matthewmacleod on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:22AM (#21059836)
Prime ministers are not elected by parliament. I appreciate the difference you are trying to highlight, but the current prime minister took this role without any form of election in parliament, and almost certainly no longer has the ability to command confidence.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by vidarh on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:09AM (#21060341)
> although they must be elected MPs

Alec Douglas-Home became PM while a member of the House of Lords in 1963, though he renounced his peerage on becoming PM and stood for a safe seat (Kinross and Western Perthshire). While waiting for the by-election, he was PM without being a member of either house.

It's unlikely this will happen again, but there's as far as I know still no law preventing it.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:30AM (#21058408)
I'm not exactly sure how UK government / prime minister elections work, but I'd expect that this government was elected on the exact same basis as previous governments. PM wants an election as well, which he's likely to win (well, according to polls... which are likely wrong!)

More importantly, the government isn't non-democratic by any definition.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:38AM (#21058451)
At the last GE, the government wasn't elected with a majority. The people specifically voted to not give the government unfettered power to do whatever they like.

Specifically, Boris was elected prime minister by a very small number of people, and no-one voted for the cabinet.

> PM wants an election as well, which he's likely to win (well, according to polls... which are likely wrong!)

It's kind of irrelevant what the PM wants - general elections are held in accordance to the Fixed Term Parliament Act 2011 (which was passed when the tories were in government). If he wants an election, it has to be with the consent of Parliament (ie the people).

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by lambertsimnel on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:09AM (#21059130)
The lack of proportional representation means that the consent of Parliament is rather different from the consent of the people.

Not since 1931 has a UK party received a majority of votes cast. A quirk of the voting system has usually given a parliamentary majority to one party.

Voters didn't specifically vote for a minority government in 2017. In fact, a greater proportion of them voted for the Conservative party than in the previous election, at which it "won" a majority.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:59AM (#21059609)
I'm a PR cheerleader as much as the next guy, but our FPTP system isn't exactly an obscure secret. You might not like the outcome that it gives you, but it's by definition what the voters voted for.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by lambertsimnel on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:30AM (#21059914)
I take a different view of whether the results of elections are "by definition what the voters voted for". FPTP tends to produce results at odds with popular support. It has produced majorities in Parliament for parties that received a mere plurality of the votes. It has produced at least one Parliament in which a party without even a plurality of votes received a parliamentary majority.

FPTP can even deny a parliamentary majority to a party with a majority of votes. This is essentially what happened in the last pre-Apartheid election in South Africa, at which most voters voted for the anti-Apartheid coalition.

I'd even go as far as to partly disagree with your judgement that FPTP isn't a secret. Clearly many do know that the House of Commons is elected by FPTP, but even most political correspondents seem unaware of its far-reaching consequences. Among ordinary voters, many are unaware of FPTP. I've met UK voters who don't accept the UK doesn't already have PR for general elections.

(I've also met teachers who tell me their politics students believe we have PR until taught otherwise. I think it's a natural assumption that it necessarily takes more votes to win an election than to lose.)

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by vidarh on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:17AM (#21060431)
I'd have to agree with you that I think a lot of voters don't understand FPTP.

I keep having arguments with UK voters that think that it takes a majority in a constituency to win a seat, for example. Many refuse to believe this isn't the case even when I give examples showing it takes just a plurality in each seat, because it just seems wrong to a lot of people, even when asking them how else you'd pick the winner in a single-seat constituency without any form of ranked voting.

FPTP just seems to seem totally counter-intuitive to people when you make them actually work through the implications.

As an immigrant, it's incredibly frustrating to come across "natives" that knows less about their own electoral system than I do.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:39AM (#21058456)
> I'm not exactly sure how UK government / prime minister elections work, but I'd expect that this government was elected on the exact same basis as previous governments

Well, you're wrong, so why don't you go and do the basic reading first?

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by lambertsimnel on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:23AM (#21059259)
There is a definition of "democracy" by which the government (and indeed Parliament) is non-democratic. Admittedly, it's a narrow definition, but nevertheless it's one that most developed countries satisfy. That definition is one suggested by Ernest Neville:

"In a democratic government the right of decision belongs to the majority, but the right of representation belongs to all."

The lack of proportional representation deprives UK voters of both majority rule and adequate minority representation. The consequences are usually subtle, but the February 1974 general election gave the most seats to a party without the most votes. The 1951 election gave a majority of seats to a party without the most votes.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by delfinom on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:43AM (#21060040)
I would argue that a 50/50 vote is not democratic, as it does not represent a majority.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by OJFord on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:08AM (#21058256)
So 'obviously illegal' that a high court previously dismissed the case as out of scope of the law?
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by celticninja on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:13AM (#21058294)
One did, one didn't, then the mother of those two courts came and sorted it out. Now the court that was wrong understands why it was wrong. It doesn't resent the decision.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by OJFord on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:22AM (#21058349)
I understand that, I'm just highlighting that perhaps a HN commenter (and I include myself) doesn't trump a high court on what's 'obvious' when it comes to the law.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by robin_reala on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:12AM (#21058282)
And another high court unanimously ruled it as inside the scope of the law. I think it’s obvious at this point that the English High Court got it wrong this time.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by OJFord on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:18AM (#21059794)
> And another high court unanimously ruled it as inside the scope of the law.

Sure, but if high courts are disagreeing about whether it's even within the scope of the law at all, isn't it a bit much to call it 'obviously illegal', i.e. not only in 'obviously' in scope, but also with 'obvious' ruling?

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by benj111 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:30AM (#21058406)
I don't think its fair to say the lower court got it wrong, the written and case law here is, sparse. TBH either way it was going to get appealed so the judges decision is moot. I certainly wouldn't be wanting to make the decision, and I'm sure he thought it was above his pay grade also.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by shakna on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:11AM (#21058275)
The High Court in the UK does not generally rule on matters of Parliament.

A matter undertaken by the Parliament may still have been illegal, but not under their purview, because of that.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by stordoff on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:29AM (#21061211)
Neither does the Supreme Court[1]. Prorogation is different in that it is not a proceeding of Parliament, but imposed upon them by the usage of the prerogative powers.

[1] It is forbidden from doing so by the Bill of Rights 1688: That the Freedome of Speech and Debates or Proceedings in Parlyament ought not to be impeached or questioned in any Court or Place out of Parlyament.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by samsari on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:54AM (#21060161)
Well, the High Court in England ruled it was not justiciable since it does not have the authority to do otherwise.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by OJFord on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:35PM (#21063245)
Thus, in its eyes, precluding it from being 'illegal'.

And thus, in my eyes, precluding it from being 'obviously' illegal!

[dead]
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by lawlessone on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:10AM (#21059724)
Because moneybags Farage isn't the elite or Jacob Rees Moggs?
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by rimliu on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:13AM (#21059749)
So court is undemocratic? People voting on falsehood is democtratic though? But the prospect of changing their minds when the new information becomes available (aka the second referendum) is undemocratic again?
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by turc1656 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:31AM (#21060557)
I have to disagree. Not only does it seem completely lawful to me, you'll notice that none of the justices could cite an actual law that was violated.

Their summary makes this a bit clearer - "...was unlawful because it had the effect of frustrating or preventing the ability of Parliament to carry out its constitutional functions without reasonable justification."

They never actually indicate any law that has been violated. Just sort of a general assertion that it was an asshole, undemocratic move that they have now declared to be "illegal".

Furthermore, I remember when it was originally announced that he was considering doing this and every single lawyer, pundit, and news outlet that I read said very clearly that while it was "unthinkable" it was completely legal and he had every right to do so with the power of his position/office.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by jfk13 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:46AM (#21060751)
> Not only does it seem completely lawful to me

Interesting. Do you have extraordinary legal qualifications that make your opinion more valid than the unanimous judgment of the highest court in the land?

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by turc1656 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @11:05AM (#21071436)
Ah yes, the old "you're not a lawyer so your opinion is worthless" argument. As I mentioned, every single thing I read by legal professionals leading up to this decision said it was entirely legal. I am not a UK citizen, let alone an expert in UK law. But I read up on it and I can follow my own path of logic based on what they described the law to be.

Also, let's not pretend like the courts get things right all the time. Even the "highest court in the land" fucks up all the time. Same here in the US. The judges are just as biased as everyone else. The law on this isn't even complicated. The Queen, not Boris Johnson, has the power to prorogue parliament. Therefore the request that she do so cannot be an illegal act by Boris Johnson. That's really simple logic to follow. And the Queen is immune from legal process so no act done by her can be deemed illegal which is why the court ruled that it was the advice/request that was illegal. This insane logic is just as outrageous as the actual request to prorogue parliament made by Johnson.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by pmyteh on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:51AM (#21061454)
British law is not all statute; some of it is "common law", which is essentially judge-made caselaw. The prorogation does not contravene statute, and wasn't held to. There is a long line of caselaw going back to the 1600s about the relationship of the Crown to Parliament which have been held to limit executive power, though. The court today held that the constitutional rule limiting royal power works to prevent prorogation under the circumstances seen this year.

Although the result is novel, this isn't particularly unusual for how the British legal systems work. Similar in principle to DC v Heller in the US Supreme Court, I suspect: the second amendment is known, but what is means for a particular DC handgun law isn't obvious until SCOTUS rules. The same here: the principle that the Crown can't use the prerogative to frustrate Parliament is now well established (starting with the Case of Proclamations [1610] EWHC KB J22) but it hadn't been tested in court whether that applied to these circumstances. Now we know.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by dadarepublic on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:13AM (#21061055)
What a horrible, biased analysis. Please cite your legal resources that would contradict the highest court in the UK who unanimously agreed that this was, in fact, illegal.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by turc1656 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @11:09AM (#21071486)
Biased how? Because I disagree with you?

And the courts always get things right, yeah? Especially when it's a rushed decision based on an urgent and time sensitive event? Also, I have no skin in the UK game at all. I'm not a citizen and don't give a shit who's in power over there. I'm just an outside observer with a tub of popcorn.

The court ruled that the advice given to the Queen was illegal and she was the one who actually has the power to prorogue parliament. The Queen is exempt from the legal process and as Queen everything she does within her powers is assumed to be legal. The courts know this, which is why they want the crazy route to declare Johnson's advice/request to be the thing that was illegal. It's absurd.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by dang on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:37PM (#21064899)
I'm afraid your comments have been repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. Would you please look them over and stick to the rules when posting to HN? We'd be grateful.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html