News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by pkaye on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:30PM (#20821335)
Can't they not put some of the waste into containment barrels and stow them somewhere?
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by moftz on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:39PM (#20821408)
Where do you stow those barrels safely? Permanent storage of nuclear waste is a tricky situation. You essentially need a very geologically inactive area away from people but can also be properly secured against thieves.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by Accujack on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:55PM (#20821591)
Lots of places fit the bill, it's just that NIMBY folks tend to be everywhere.

Provided the waste isn't liquid and won't migrate off site, it's fairly easy to contain. Much of the really bad waste that we have to deal with in the present is not the result of power generation reactors, it's the result of nuclear weapons production.

Unfortunately, most people since the 1970s are incapable of distinguishing between peaceful reactors and nuclear weapons, so there's an incredible amount of fear involved.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by manfredo on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:04PM (#20821694)
It's not tricky. There are already disposal sites that have enough capacity to accommodate nuclear waste for centuries.

Spent nuclear fuel is given time to cool off under a pool of water. After that, it is encased in a concrete cylinder. These cylinders are then buried. The main concern for the burial site is that it isn't close to an aquifer, in case the cylinders degrade and leak fuel.

Geologic activity is not a concern for the waste itself (but it could damage entrance tunnels for the digs), in fact some groups are experimenting with using subduction zones to make waste get sucked out of the earth's crust.

Thieves are not a concern either. The waste caskets are huge concrete cylinders buried underground. One might as well mine uranium. Or just buy it commercially. Reprocessing the waste into weapons requires large centrifuges which are much harder to obtain than uranium itself.

The hypothetical scenarios in which humans could be contaminated by buried nuclear waste are well into the realm of hyperbole. Sure, if someone dug hundreds of meters underground in a waste disposal site with no natural resources in the vicinity and broke open the storage caskets then yes, they will be exposed to radiation. There's no way that this would happen accidentally, at least short of even more outlandish scenarios that involve societal collapse, subsequent loss of all records describing nuclear waste disposal sites.

Edit (HN won't let me respond): Let me phrase it better: the Yucca mountain dig has enough capacity at the moment to accommodate the waste that would be generated by nuclear power over the course of centuries. The waste itself will be stored for millennia (though much of it will likely be reprocessed if nuclear power becomes more popular).

The point remains: nuclear waste disposal is a solved problem

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by moftz on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @04:06PM (#20823525)
France doesn't really have any big deserts for their own Yucca Mountain. So they would need someone willing to import their nuclear waste.

Also, you don't need to process nuclear waste to build a weapon. Attach some Caesium-137 to an air-burst weapon and you can ruin lots of land really quick.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by hollerith on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @04:10PM (#20823547)
Uh, how would I produce the Caesium-137 without using a nuclear reactor?
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by manfredo on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @04:36PM (#20823736)
Presumably, they're referring to the risk that someone might dig up nuclear waste and use it in a dirt bomb. But that kind of delivery method would be better used to deliver chemical weapons that are much more toxic than spent nuclear fuel (and probably easier to obtain, nuclear waste or not).
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by pizza234 on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @02:43PM (#20822712)
> It's not tricky. There are already disposal sites that have enough capacity to accommodate nuclear waste for centuries.

It's ironic how the "centuries" mentioned are in fact not enough (by a long shot) for 100% of the waste to decade.

If the more accurate "millennia" was used, it would be unrealistic in a very obvious way (at least, to prudent engineers/managers) to talk about maintenance.

---

Software project, 20 years after: "This project sucks. Nobody knows it. It's undocumented. There are bugs unfixed for years. There are no tools to work with it. We can't work on it without breaking something. It's a disaster."

Nuclear waste disposal project, 10.000 years after: "EVERYTHING IS PERFECTLY FINE".

Sure. /sarcasm

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by yummypaint on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:01PM (#20821662)
This is where people let the perfect become the enemy of the good. Even temporary storage suitable for 200 years or so would be vastly preferable to how most waste is stored now. There may actually be some organizational advantages to having to regularly revisit and reshuffle stuff intended to be stored long term.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by madamelic on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:41PM (#20821440)
>You essentially need a very geologically inactive area away from people but can also be properly secured against thieves.

Not to mention the need for extremely long-term solutions on the scale of 10,000 years. You can't rely on any current civilization or language still existing. So you have to properly communicate "Don't go in here or mess with anything, this is dangerous" without words.

And that's after figuring out the above problem of the actual storage facility.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by mrob on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:56PM (#20821603)
Hypothetical communications problems could potentially kill thousands of our distant descendants. The status quo could potentially kill billions. I don't think care for future humans is a good reason to avoid nuclear power.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by slenk on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:09PM (#20821740)
Likewise, if we don't curb our reliance on fossil fuels, there won't be future humans to think about
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by madamelic on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:13PM (#20821791)
>I don't think care for future humans is a good reason to avoid nuclear power.

Oh definitely not, just a consideration that's needed.

The bigger issue is that there is no current long-term storage solution. The communication bit is long-long-term thinking while storage of material is current need.

There is a long-term storage facility in Norway, I believe, that is being built or has been built.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by manfredo on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:20PM (#20821867)
These hypothetical concerns ten thousand years into the future are absurd. The waste is buried hundreds of meters below ground, far from any useful resources. There is no warning signs or communications, the disposal sites are just made to be as nondescript as possible. Or the sites are in places already contaminated by nuclear weapons testing, so the concern of contamination is largely moot.

So are we really going to block effectively unlimited non-intermittent carbon-free energy based on the concern that some future civilization might decide to dig deep in a remote location with no natural resources, and they might encounter a waste casket, and they might decide to open it. And they might do all of this without any knowledge of radiation poising. Yes, if all of those conditions are met, some poor sap thousands of years from now is going to get irradiated.

I'm going to weight the positives of nuclear power way higher than the narrow chances of people being contaminated by waste. There are valid concerns over safety and costs of decommissioning, but those are limited to the operation of the plant itself and the disposal of the reactor (the pressure vessel). The waste management argument is very weak.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by EpicEng on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:43PM (#20821454)
>So you have to properly communicate "Don't go in here or mess with anything, this is dangerous" without words.

That's a solved problem already. Skull and crossbones, etc.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by froindt on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:52PM (#20821552)
There's a really interesting 99% Invisible episode about this very topic.

https://99percentinvisible.org/article/beyond-biohazard-dang...

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by Godel_unicode on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:50PM (#20821537)
There are pirate groups which use skull and crossbones as a symbol that valuable things are located there.

Iconography across cultures is a fractally hard problem, as you just demonstrated.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by EpicEng on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:58PM (#20821624)
Yes, I'm sure that when people run across these[1] they're going to think "pirate booty!"

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazard_symbol

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by rtkwe on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:15PM (#20821820)
The problem is over 10k years and with the idea of a civilization collapse being part of your in scope posisble events you can assume nothing about the cultural link between us and them. That symbol means danger to us because it's been the sign for danger for a long time, subtract that and it could be markers for graves maybe a good place to look for resources or treasure like has been done to so many ancient tombs.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by ceejayoz on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:16PM (#20821823)
They might think "sweet, an old graveyard, wonder if they buried their dead with valuables" though.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by madamelic on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:49PM (#20821520)
Is it? Skull and crossbones is a cultural symbol. Would we understand cultural symbols of humanoids from 10,000 years ago?

Even having past civilizations being storytellers causes the story and culture to mutate over generations.

You are talking about a 100 generation game of telephone to make sure one particular symbol is passed down with perfect recall.

---

Personally the best solution in my opinion is bury it deep down in a chamber that can withstand the time needed, leave signs on the outsides of the container. Then forget about it.

Don't bother marking it visibly on the surface level.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by EpicEng on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:02PM (#20821677)
Will, you're right; "solved problem" was too strong a term for a complicated issue. What I meant to get across is that a lot of thought has gone into this already.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by madamelic on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:14PM (#20821803)
You're right. I am sorry you are being downvoted. Too many people think "downvote" == "disagree".
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by EpicEng on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:16PM (#20821830)
meh, don't mind downvotes. Even PG has said that using downvotes as a disagree button is standard practice on HN.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by maxerickson on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:51PM (#20821543)
The Jolly Roger?

Arrrrg, don't be riskin' yur life inna therr!

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by wtetzner on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:43PM (#20821448)
Fling them into space I guess... ;)
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by derivagral on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:58PM (#20821623)
The risk here is that the rocket explodes and spreads the stuff far and wide.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by cftorres on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:53PM (#20821564)
It wouldn't be nice if in an human exploration on outer space we find a container full of unknown harmful waste from another civilization. That shouldn't be our first option.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by johnr2 on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:15PM (#20821812)
> It wouldn't be nice if in an human exploration on outer space we find a container full of unknown harmful waste from another civilization.

The unshielded fusion reactor which we orbit around is likely to be a bigger problem.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by madamelic on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:56PM (#20821602)
Not to mention the really bad problem if a rocket carrying the waste exploded. You've basically made the problem 10,000x worse.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by stunt on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:01PM (#20821660)
There is a chance that it will fly back to earth. Not to mention there is also the risk of explosion during the launch. And also it’s not scaleable and super expensive.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by arkh on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:05PM (#20821703)
The Mariana Trench is better: 10 km of water then it's a subduction area so it'll end in the Earth mantle.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by pkaye on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:56PM (#20821597)
How does France stow all the radioactive waste from their nuclear reactors?
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by ceejayoz on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:03PM (#20821681)
Thus far, they don't. It's all in temporary storage awaiting a permanent solution.

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-26425674

> Despite advanced schemes in Finland, not a single country worldwide has an operational underground repository.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by jcrawfordor on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @01:12PM (#20821784)
Yes, and for many types of waste this is the process. However, it is an expensive and slow-going process, which means that even once started it takes quite a while to complete.

For medium-grade radioactive waste landfills typical at research sites (landfills that contain things like transuranic/TRU contaminated materials, things like gloves/aprons/tools/containers used with uranium), the process is generally to excavate the landfill using equipment with air filtration (and using chemical binders and site containment to prevent radioactive fugitive dust), then loading the material into large gloveboxes where workers sort through it by hand to classify based on type of material and radioactivity levels to ensure that it is all safe for the intended storage strategy. It is then usually mixed with something to provide shock protection, binding, and contain any liquid seepage (famously often cat litter).

The big problem is that acquiring equipment with operator protection for this kind of work, and building out a processing facility with gloveboxes, air filtration, and monitoring/sampling (which needs to be onsite since, prior to processing, none of the waste is considered safe for transport) is expensive and takes quite some time. Even then, since there is usually no perceived urgency, a relatively small facility will be built that will take many years to complete the job.

The waste, once packaged, may be stored on-site or transferred to a short-term repository (often just a well-built warehouse where certified staff monitor for any trouble). Ultimately it should be transferred to a long-term repository where it should be safe for the indefinite future without expensive continuous monitoring, but for a variety of reasons, both technical and political, this doesn't yet happen on a large scale.

This is, though, what is happening in New Mexico right now - various sites, but most notably Los Alamos National Laboratories, are excavating and processing their waste landfills, packaging the material, storing it temporarily on site in purpose-build facilities or transporting it to an off-site certified storage facilities (e.g. commercial operations near the New Mexico-Texas border), and ultimately transferring it to the WIPP geological repository. If you know anything about WIPP's rather rocky recent past, you will know that this process is still fraught with occasional problems and the industry has plenty more to learn about how to do it safely and efficiently.

Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by saalweachter on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @02:46PM (#20822730)
This is complicated by the fact that Marie Curie's workshop is a historic site, and many of the contaminated items are things like notebooks and lab equipment that you don't want to just throw away, because Marie goddamn Curie used them.
Re:France Is Still Cleaning Up Marie Curie’s Nuclear Waste by SiempreViernes on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @12:48PM (#20821512)
They can, they just didn't do much about it until 2010, and it costs a lot.