News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by the_duke on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:43PM (#20706899)
The free tier of Cloudflare has been really amazing for small to medium websites.

It gives you a basically unlimited CDN, SSL, HTTP/2, DDos protection and fast DNS servers with almost 0 effort... for free ...

Thus increasing the stability and speed of many web properties that otherwise wouldn't pay for it.

I'm afraid this could easily change once the company is public and is under the pressures that come along with it, which is a shame.

(I also try to get them paid business when I can by nudging companies to use them)

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by louis-paul on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:58PM (#20707090)
They list it as a key element of their business model:

> Free customer base—Free customers are an important part of our business. These customers sign up for our service through our self-serve portal and are typically individual developers, early stage startups, hobbyists, and other users. Our free customers create scale, serve as efficient brand marketing, and help us attract developers, customers, and potential employees. These free customers expose us to diverse traffic, threats, and problems, often allowing us to see potential security, performance, and reliability issues at the earliest stage. This knowledge allows us to improve our products and deliver more effective solutions to our paid customers. In addition, the added scale and diversity of this traffic makes us valuable to a diverse set of global ISPs, improving the breadth and economic terms of our interconnections, bandwidth costs, and co-location expenses. Finally, the enthusiastic engagement of our free customer base represents a “virtual quality assurance” function that allows us to maintain a high rate of product innovation, while ensuring products are extensively tested in real world environments before they are deployed to enterprise customers.

(page 80)

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by cosmie on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:16PM (#20707321)
This. I've mentioned the first aspect of that in the past here[1][2]. The interconnect benefit never occurred to me, though. That's a neat aspect!

Which just continues to reinforce what I said at the end of [2], about their business model instilling confidence in leveraging them at a free-tier level.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19127523#19130562

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19127523#19131411

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by btown on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:23PM (#20707389)
Yea, it didn't occur to me either - as implementers we'd be like "why would we want the responsibility of so much scale that we need to support without corresponding revenue," but in their position they can say "we need all the tooling for that scale anyways, why don't we leverage that into better bulk discounts with the interconnections!" And presumably they've run models that say that their bulk savings from interconnect make this far from just a loss leader.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by cosmie on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:35PM (#20707525)
> And presumably they've run models that say that their bulk savings from interconnect make this far from just a loss leader.

It's basically real world chaos monkeys that are stress testing their systems.

Combined with signal intelligence, those chaos monkeys are actively improving their systems.

Then, as a final bonus, absorbing the DDoS attacks aimed at those chaos monkeys (and their paid tier) provides a lot of globally diverse and distributed inbound traffic to them, favorably offsetting the outbound traffic they're serving from from their network. Improving their position during interconnect negotiations.

There are quite natural synergies that emerge as a product of their particular choices in structuring their business. Which is far more rare of a thing than you'd expect.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by craftyguy on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:05PM (#20707913)
> They list it as a key element of their business model:

And we all know public companies never change 'key elements' of their business models... (hint: they do)

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by davchana on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:26PM (#20709290)
This. I have about 20+ hobbyish domains total, & 13 of them are with free Cloudflare Plan, & 3 of them are with their Domain Registrar side. I am completely fine with their free tier & paying for Domain Reg/Renewal. But just in case if in future i need to paygor DNS hosting, I would fallback to regular domain registar's free dns.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by bufferoverflow on Thursday August 15, 2019 @06:02PM (#20710147)
I had one website that I was working on, basically zero traffic, besides me testing it. After a couple of months Cloudflare kicked me off the free tier, asked for money. No idea why. I didn't use much of their resources, well within the limits.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by therein on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:45PM (#20711152)
That's quite peculiar. I never had that happen and I have over 10 domains with them that I'd describe as basically zero traffic.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dkoston on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:07PM (#20711825)
Agree that this seems suspect. Have had free domains with plenty of traffic on them for years.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by mooreds on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:48PM (#20711173)
Domain reg/renewal, once you have the infrastructure, seems like it would be minting money.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by JorgeGT on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:46PM (#20708942)
You forgot the API! I have my own dynamic DNS with a raspberry and the cloudflare API for instance, it's very useful.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by apexalpha on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:21PM (#20709241)
Oh I didn't know you could do that. Do you move the Rpi around a lot? What do you use the dynamic dns for?
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by SXX on Thursday August 15, 2019 @05:25PM (#20709822)
Many ISPs around the world give you public IPs without NAT, but they're dynamic and change every once in a while.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by JorgeGT on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:09PM (#20710575)
Exactly my case! So I have a cronjob that compares the current IP with the previous one and, if different, sends an API request to update the DNS record.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by ollerac on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:18PM (#20711322)
Can you do a quick write up about how to do this? As a web developer, I feel like I should know how to host my own website from my own machine, but I've always struggled to get all the right steps in place. It'd be nice to hear from someone more experienced, so I can make sure to do it correctly!
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by icebraining on Friday August 16, 2019 @02:41AM (#20712722)
Essentially you write a script in any language that:

1) checks what's your current IP (an easy way is to do a GET request to http://icanhazip.com/, available thanks to Red Hat engineer Major Hayden)

2) checks what was the last IP you sent to Cloudflare (saved in a text file on your disk or something like data)

3) if they are different, send a PUT request to the Cloudflare API with the new IP: https://api.cloudflare.com/#dns-records-for-a-zone-update-dn...

4) Then save that new IP in the text file, so you can check next time

Finally, you edit your crontab to run that script every few hours or so.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by baud147258 on Friday August 16, 2019 @07:43AM (#20714140)
I've checked icanhazip.com and it's not returning the same ip as the one from ipconfig. What does it mean? Note I know nothing how networks work and that I'm in a corporate network
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by amdavidson on Friday August 16, 2019 @08:35AM (#20714497)
Your corporate network is using network address translation (NAT) to map an external address, shown on icanhazip.com, to a local network address, shown in ipconfig. You likely share this external address with many other users and mapping services to it will be challenging without having access to the routing/forwarding configuration.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_address_translation

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by baud147258 on Friday August 16, 2019 @08:55AM (#20714666)
Okay, thank you for this information.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by apexalpha on Friday August 16, 2019 @02:32AM (#20712680)
Oh I didn't know this, mine has always been static.

What's the reason for having such a low lease time on public IPs?

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by vasco on Friday August 16, 2019 @04:08AM (#20713089)
ISPs assign IPs depending on usage abd generally do not have a 1-1 userbase / IP pool.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by i_cant_speel on Thursday August 15, 2019 @05:50PM (#20710050)
I'd imagine there is significant value in capturing small customers with a free product who end up growing into their enterprise products.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by OrgNet on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:58PM (#20707091)
Cloudflare is getting too big so I'm all for anything that could possibly make it smaller
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by nannal on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:20PM (#20707362)
In defense of this user we have had a few system wide outages which have shut down major communications networks and news outlets.

Additionally they're less than friendly to users who strive for anonymity via forced captcha which further empowers google's massive machine learning/data classification efforts.

Cloudflare are big and competition is something they clearly lack.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by the_duke on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:27PM (#20707429)
Site owners can turn off the captcha by reducing the security level. I understand why it exists, I just wish they didn't use a Google service for it...

The lack of competition probably shows the difficulty of the task. A global CDN is complicated and expensive (physical infrastructure, all the interconnect agreements) and a big technical challenge.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by Ayesh on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:23PM (#20708724)
It is quite possible to setup a global CDN overnight. Spin nginx reverse proxies in all AWS, Digital Ocean, and Linode POSs, and you'd have a good enough network. Throw Inna control panel and you got yourself a contender in the budget CDN sector.

Cloudflare was rather innovative, with their authorative and recursive DNS, peering agreements with many ISPs including the ones that others didn't bother about, free SSL (Which they offered with Comodo even before Let's Encrypt), etc.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by manquer on Thursday August 15, 2019 @06:27PM (#20710328)
That is a fast way to burn a lot of money . Cloud Service Providers like the ones you mention heavily marked up sell metered bandwidth with no guaranteed allocation and are considerably more expensive than say a tier-2 player like hetzner/OVH or spinning your own servers in a Colo.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by ttsda on Saturday August 17, 2019 @10:24PM (#20727839)
Sure, but no cloud company offers the amount of locations you can get on Cloudflare. Now you've even got edge compute, bringing really low global latencies for some applications.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by alexnewman on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:00PM (#20707832)
hcaptcha.com
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by jorvi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:34PM (#20707511)
CloudFlare offers Privacy Pass where with 1 captcha completion you generate something like 20 tokens, meaning you can bypass 20 captchas after that. Sadly nearly every website just uses pure Google captcha which forces you to go through the ordeal every single time.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by alexnewman on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:00PM (#20707838)
hcaptcha.com also supports privacy pass, and we contribute to the standard
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dylz on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:08PM (#20708579)
Is this your product? If so, how can I cash this out into tangible currency rather than an ERC token, and is it possible to select the amount of labeling (ex: users I identify as bad have to go through 10+ pages, users I identify as OK go through 1)?
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by alexnewman on Thursday August 15, 2019 @06:45PM (#20710439)
It is. We support paying in paypal. We get users asking us to mainnet our token so they can be paid that way everyday, so expect news there.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by OrgNet on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:30PM (#20707468)
thanks a lot for articulating my point better then I did, but I don't really care about the downvotes because I know that my opinion will be accepted within 5-10 years if the trend keeps going the way it is... ;)
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by JohnAtCC on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:52PM (#20707013)
How so? If the service is WORTH paying for, then it SHOULD be paid for. The world of service, if proven magnetizable, should always be monetized. #FreeMarkets
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by rconti on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:15PM (#20707303)
The salami I try at Costco, as a free sample, is worth paying for. It is food, and it has value.

However, they give me a small sample as an inducement to buy; presumably to increase sales beyond a baseline, in quantities and at prices sufficient to cover the cost of not only the free food they give away, but the labor to do so.

Cloudflare can provide a free product that's WORTH paying for, if their paid product is so much better, and its sales increased by so much, that the free giveaway can be considered a marketing cost that pays for itself.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by squirrelicus on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:59PM (#20709044)
I'm a #freemarket guy and all, but freemium is a long standing monetization model that many companies have used to accelerate net profits in the long run. Not really anything anti free market about freemium. The problem with freemium has always been building the premium tier that someone wants to pay for :P
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by whatshisface on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:16PM (#20707320)
Markets don't equilibrate at the value to the customer any more than they equilibrate at the cost of production. They compromise between the two.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dragonwriter on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:21PM (#20707365)
> Markets don't equilibrate at the value to the customer any more than they equilibrate at the cost of production. They compromise between the two.

No, they don't compromise between them, nor do they reflect one more than the other: the basic law of supply and demand is that markets clear at the quantity and price where the marginal cost to produce equals the marginal value to customers which also equals the sale price.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by throwaway2048 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:19PM (#20709219)
assuming a huge number of perfect circumstances which is not how reality works. Assumptions made for what you said to play out include: perfect competition, perfect information, perfect rationality of actors, 0 barrier to entry, that value and cost is strongly bounded and defined on either end, and much more.

Common examples that violate each one in term: Facebook, Used cars, Veblen goods, Utilities, Healthcare.

A market that has one large player that completely dominates certain segment(s) is not likely to be a healthy one that is providing value at near cost, why would it be? The incentive is always to charge as much as possible.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dragonwriter on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:30PM (#20709333)
> assuming a huge number of perfect circumstances which is not how reality works.

I don't think there is actually an equilibrium price defined as some kind of compromise between supply and demand curves absent those circumstances, either; there's an actual price at any given time, but it's not an equilibrium (particularly, without rationality—which incorporates perfect information—you don't have any expectation of an equilibrium even if all the other factors are present, at any price.)

Once you are discussing equilibrium—as the post the grandparent addressed did—you are implicitly discussing at least some of the ideal circumstances you’d like to negate.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by throwaway2048 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:49PM (#20710835)
The market can still reach equilibrium even with non optimal conditions, just not the "efficient market" equilibrium.

Additionally, irrational does not mean unpredictable, after all advertising is extremely effective.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by empath75 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:36PM (#20707530)
It’s quite possible that cloudflare gains more value from the customers than they gain from cloudflare.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by lhill on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:08PM (#20708571)
For instance? (Honest question)
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by humblebee on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:16PM (#20708660)
> Free customer base—Free customers are an important part of our business. These customers sign up for our service through our self-serve portal and are typically individual developers, early stage startups, hobbyists, and other users. Our free customers create scale, serve as efficient brand marketing, and help us attract developers, customers, and potential employees. These free customers expose us to diverse traffic, threats, and problems, often allowing us to see potential security, performance, and reliability issues at the earliest stage. This knowledge allows us to improve our products and deliver more effective solutions to our paid customers. In addition, the added scale and diversity of this traffic makes us valuable to a diverse set of global ISPs, improving the breadth and economic terms of our interconnections, bandwidth costs, and co-location expenses. Finally, the enthusiastic engagement of our free customer base represents a “virtual quality assurance” function that allows us to maintain a high rate of product innovation, while ensuring products are extensively tested in real world environments before they are deployed to enterprise customers.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by tracker1 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:18PM (#20708684)
It adds latency to API services, it doesn't add value in conditions where you aren't under attack. It inhibits legitimate users with privacy controls (and/or Firefox) in place.

It may or may not be worth it, but it isn't a panacea.