Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by l0b0 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:10AM
(#20693099)
The "source" is just a list of almost 200 publications, with no indication of which numbers come from where. So it's effectively unsourced. That means it's either bullshit, terrible reporting, or both, and there's no reason to believe this over i-have-an-agenda.org.
I've got karma to burn, so bring it. But it really is time that reporters get their bloody act together. Without the research this is as worthless as an opinion piece, and it's not going to convince anybody who needs convincing.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by amirhirsch on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:29AM
(#20693177)
The fun part is seeing those ranges for silicon after having spent the last several weeks researching ways to decrease the energy costs of producing “solar grade” (one nine less than monocrystalline wafer) silicon from silica. There’s a paper showing 1.6kg of 6-nines silicon from rice hull ash in 6hours in a 50kw arc reactor (300kwh) (https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2015/gc/c5gc0...)
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by rosser on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:57AM
(#20693277)
> Furthermore, burning rice hulls to produce electricity and RHA, generates more energy than required for the overall process.
I don't have access to the paper, but assuming I'm reading that correctly, the notion of burning rice hulls to power the process and thereby source their ash is a fantastic efficiency.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:27AM
(#20693656)
The sourcing could definitely be better. The values smell about right to me (I've been exploring this space for a few years), and spot checks suggest they're reasonable.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by stewbrew on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:29AM
(#20693175)
The list is somewhat biased:
Iron (from iron ore)
[...]
Steel (from iron)
Paper (from standing timber)
Is the energy for digging up the ore or felling that tree + transport + machinery for production included? Steel should probably also include the numbers for iron.
The list would benefit from a common baseline. Without that these are just random numbers.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by londons_explore on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @03:05AM
(#20693310)
I'd prefer it said:
Steel (from the things Steel is typically made from in 2019 - 80% iron ore, 50% process X, 20% recycled)
That gets tricky, because many industrial processes use large amounts of energy, but only because that energy is effectively 'free' as waste heat from other processes.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:29AM
(#20693666)
The list is specifying clearly what the derived energy values are for. Not that they're necessarily typical (though I suspect these are).
There's a tremendous variability to industrial processes and material utilisation, including virgin vs. recycled materials. Listing from among options may help clarify engineering / manufacturing / consumption values and choices.
While these reports are in themselves reason for concern, they hugely underestimate the energy use of electronic equipment. To start with, electricity consumption does not equal energy consumption. In the US, utility stations have an average efficiency of about 35 percent. If a laptop is said to consume 60 watt-hours of electricity, it consumes almost three times as much energy (around 180 watt-hour, or 648 kilojoules).
So, let's start by multiplying all figures by 3 and we get a more realistic image of the energy consumption of our electronic equipment. Another thing that is too easily forgotten, is the energy use of the infrastructure that supports many technologies; most notably the mobile phone network and the internet (which consists of server farms, routers, switches, optical equipment and the like)."
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by londons_explore on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @03:08AM
(#20693312)
Gas turbine powerplants are easily in the 60% + efficiency band... Coal at 30% is dying out in most of the western world.
Granted every fossil fueled device ever has quoted efficiency with the Lower Heating Value, whereas the HHV is the fairest measure. The difference consists of if you should extract energy from the humidity in the exhaust, and the clear answer is yes.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @03:40AM
(#20693434)
AFAIR "easily" is a stretch -- there are highly efficient combined-cycle gas-turbine plants, and I think some of those actually get above 50% efficiency.
For most thermal generation, however, it's Carnot-cycle limits which get you down, and that's governed by hot vs. cold side efficiency.
Coal actually has some of the higher efficiencies, in some cases, exceeding 45%, though whether that's through high temps or combined cycle I'm not sure. (I'm not defending coal, just noting efficiency numbers I've encountered.)
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by dasd99 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:27AM
(#20693167)
> Another thing that is too easily forgotten, is the energy use of the infrastructure that supports many technologies; most notably the mobile phone network and the internet (which consists of server farms, routers, switches, optical equipment and the like)
While I agree with you, it's worth noting that the server farms of our tech giants are already powered by renewable energy (Google 100%, AWS 50%, Microsoft 50%, ...).
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by mikestew on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @12:21AM
(#20692688)
I'm going to have to cut down on my titanium addiction. OTOH, my nephew's grandchildren will be fighting over that double-walled coffee mug long after I die.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by BostonEnginerd on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:52AM
(#20693026)
It's both, I believe. Highly purified polysilicon is created using the Siemens CVD process. This is then broken up and used as feedstock for a CZ crystal puller.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by Gibbon1 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:05AM
(#20693553)
Yeah three really strong covalent bonds takes a lot of energy to break. And strong enough you can't use carbon alone to reduce it. Basically it's bottled electricity.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by hollerith on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:27AM
(#20693165)
I heard the same about the plants that refine the aluminum from ore. Also that those plants being there was a major reason a large airplane manufacturer (Boeing) is nearby.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:56AM
(#20693776)
It normalises the metric across all levels of production. Scale according to use.
A 5" iPhone weighs 138g. Much of that is probably battery, display, and case, so chips are on the order of 10% or less of the total. I'd estimate at <10g.
The core processor is the A10 Fusion SoC, 125mm^2, probably a few mm thick. Silicon has a density of 2.3290 g/cm^3. That adds up to about 20-30g, depending on thickness, though I'm not sure of the density or thickness of a silicon wafer. I suspect actual mass is less.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by philipkglass on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:26AM
(#20693162)
I did refer to figure 4 in that PDF. It shows aluminum around 16 kWh/kg for smelting. According to the accompanying pie chart, electricity used in smelting accounts for 75% of the energy used in aluminum production while bauxite mining, alumina refining, primary casting, and anode production account for another 25%. Starting from 16 kWh for smelting that would put the full energy intensity at 21 kWh per kg of aluminum.
Re:Embodied energy of digital technology
by hollerith on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:13AM
(#20693112)
Maybe 14 kWh/kg is just the electricity used in the refining process.
Maybe to get the 63 kWh/kg figure, you add to the 14 kWh/kg figure the energy needed to collect the cans (if recycled) and to mine the aluminum (if not) and the energy needed to build the refining or recyling plant and the energy used by the workers who mine, collect and operate the refining and recycling plants, including the energy used to feed, clothe, educate, entertain, transport, etc, the workers.
In other words, maybe one figure attempts to estimate the second- and third-order energy use, i.e., the "total carbon footprint", and the other does not.
I've got karma to burn, so bring it. But it really is time that reporters get their bloody act together. Without the research this is as worthless as an opinion piece, and it's not going to convince anybody who needs convincing.
I don't have access to the paper, but assuming I'm reading that correctly, the notion of burning rice hulls to power the process and thereby source their ash is a fantastic efficiency.
Rice hulls cost something to produce too, and I bet you need a lot more than a kilo of them to make a kilo of silicon...
Alternative sourcing: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/embodied-en...
(Hits: timber, recycled and stainless steel, aluminium, glass, plastics.)
Enough so that I'd be inclined to believe the values. Low Tech Magazine is generally reliable in my experience.
"smell about right"
"spot checks suggest they're reasonable"
"generally reliable in my experience"
The list would benefit from a common baseline. Without that these are just random numbers.
Steel (from the things Steel is typically made from in 2019 - 80% iron ore, 50% process X, 20% recycled)
That gets tricky, because many industrial processes use large amounts of energy, but only because that energy is effectively 'free' as waste heat from other processes.
There's a tremendous variability to industrial processes and material utilisation, including virgin vs. recycled materials. Listing from among options may help clarify engineering / manufacturing / consumption values and choices.
"The 180 watt laptop
While these reports are in themselves reason for concern, they hugely underestimate the energy use of electronic equipment. To start with, electricity consumption does not equal energy consumption. In the US, utility stations have an average efficiency of about 35 percent. If a laptop is said to consume 60 watt-hours of electricity, it consumes almost three times as much energy (around 180 watt-hour, or 648 kilojoules).
So, let's start by multiplying all figures by 3 and we get a more realistic image of the energy consumption of our electronic equipment. Another thing that is too easily forgotten, is the energy use of the infrastructure that supports many technologies; most notably the mobile phone network and the internet (which consists of server farms, routers, switches, optical equipment and the like)."
Granted every fossil fueled device ever has quoted efficiency with the Lower Heating Value, whereas the HHV is the fairest measure. The difference consists of if you should extract energy from the humidity in the exhaust, and the clear answer is yes.
For most thermal generation, however, it's Carnot-cycle limits which get you down, and that's governed by hot vs. cold side efficiency.
Coal actually has some of the higher efficiencies, in some cases, exceeding 45%, though whether that's through high temps or combined cycle I'm not sure. (I'm not defending coal, just noting efficiency numbers I've encountered.)
Update: Wikipedia's language is "possibly 62%" efficiency, FWIW: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle_power_plant
For example, [1] achieved 63.08% efficiency at the whole-site level (ie. including inefficiencies in startup, testing, etc. over a year)
[1]: http://interfaxenergy.com/article/30230/chubu-electric-plant...
While I agree with you, it's worth noting that the server farms of our tech giants are already powered by renewable energy (Google 100%, AWS 50%, Microsoft 50%, ...).
http://web.mit.edu/ebm/www/Publications/energy_required.pdf
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/222566309_Electrowi...
""High purity iron was produced, with a current yield of 85% and a power consumption of 4.25 kWh/kg iron.""
If you run numbers you get energy costs of about $400-$500/ton.
Wikiedia cites similar values referencing ICE.
http://www.circularecology.com/embodied-energy-and-carbon-fo...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embodied_energy
A 5" iPhone weighs 138g. Much of that is probably battery, display, and case, so chips are on the order of 10% or less of the total. I'd estimate at <10g.
The core processor is the A10 Fusion SoC, 125mm^2, probably a few mm thick. Silicon has a density of 2.3290 g/cm^3. That adds up to about 20-30g, depending on thickness, though I'm not sure of the density or thickness of a silicon wafer. I suspect actual mass is less.
https://www.iea.org/tcep/industry/aluminium/
http://web.mit.edu/ebm/www/publications.htm
After that URL it points back to a Low-Tech page called 'The monster footprint of digital technology'
https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2009/06/embodied-energy-of-d...
For a summary graphic, see figure 2 in this cited PDF (Gutowski et.al)
http://web.mit.edu/ebm/www/Publications/energy_required.pdf
On the whole, and prima facie, that graphic delivers much the same message, and rings true. Can't expect the L-T author to do -all- the work.
Maybe to get the 63 kWh/kg figure, you add to the 14 kWh/kg figure the energy needed to collect the cans (if recycled) and to mine the aluminum (if not) and the energy needed to build the refining or recyling plant and the energy used by the workers who mine, collect and operate the refining and recycling plants, including the energy used to feed, clothe, educate, entertain, transport, etc, the workers.
In other words, maybe one figure attempts to estimate the second- and third-order energy use, i.e., the "total carbon footprint", and the other does not.
As Sagan might not have Said:
If you want to make a kilo of virgin aluminium, you must first invent the global economy.
Paying it forward, here is the original clip so others can get a hit of the sweet sweet nostalgia...
https://youtu.be/BkHCO8f2TWs
The other paper posted by femto shows aluminum at ~16 kWh/kg. The slightly higher value is due to an earlier date cutoff around 2009. See figure 4(b):
http://web.mit.edu/ebm/www/Publications/energy_required.pdf
https://imgur.com/a/DYlT9GO