News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by lnsru on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:38AM (#20552612)
While reading your text I was thinking about Volkswagen, diesel cars and their defeat devices. This article (sorry for German only writing) https://www.auto-motor-und-sport.de/verkehr/audi-abgasskanda... states exactly opposite! The VW guys were writing poems for their clever defeat device! I am pretty sure, that some people at Boeing were also clapping hands about sales potential and cost savings of the new planes. There are more evil people in the corporate floors than you think. And top management plays with them!!! There is no way to build in defeat device in millions of cars without top management agreeing. I can guess, that Boeing’s management had enough clues, that their software wasn’t in the best shape.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by akerl_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:46AM (#20552648)
I don’t think anybody is arguing that Boeing execs hate money, or weren’t excited to make loads of money. And, as I wrote, the incentive structure the Boeing execs created has an incentive structure whose outcome was incredibly dangerous. Realizing those incentives required that the executives turn a blind eye to how the problems were being solved. But I think it’s pretty implausible to suggest that the “evil people” at Boeing we’re clapping their hands about savings with an understanding that they were trading human lives for those profits. It’s tempting to imagine that the executives of corporations are all comic villains, sitting in their offices plotting the demise of humanity, but to imagine them in that way is detrimental to the goal of actually avoiding these problems. If we treat corporations as if they’re comic villains, we ignore that they’re actually made up of normal people with a variety of social and economic incentives, and being aware of those incentives is crucial if we’d like to actually change corporate behavior.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by rectang on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:00AM (#20552701)
Why should Boeing and Wells Fargo executives be afforded sympathy and mercy routinely denied to people far less fortunate and whose actions have far fewer consequences?

Carrie Tolstedt of Wells Fargo is as close to a comic villain as you're going to get, designing a system which forced multitudes of employees into unethical actions. And even after clawbacks Tolstedt ended her career tens of millions of dollars ahead.

Executives are already so coddled and protected from failure that terrible actions are rewarded and inevitable.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by akerl_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:07AM (#20552734)
Speaking morally, I believe in having empathy for everybody. The fact that some people don’t behave that way doesn’t cause me to act in kind towards them. That said, empathy (which is what I’m suggesting above) is not “sympathy and mercy”. I haven’t suggested at any point in this thread that we should feel sympathy or mercy for anyone at Boeing (or Wells Fargo).

Speaking practically, treating execs as comic villains gets in the way of actually fixing their behavior. There are a variety of ways to force corporations to behave differently, but they all start with actually figuring out why they act this way in the first place. Otherwise we end up making the same mistake as Wells Fargo and Boeing: if we apply pressure on them to act better without clearly understanding why they’re doing what they’re doing, we’re just going to incentivize them to misbehave differently to get around the new rules.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by rectang on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:36AM (#20552877)
> Speaking morally, I believe in having empathy for everybody.

I take you at your word. It's just hilarious that a post urging empathy for executives floats to the top while it's bootstraps for everyone else. [EDIT: in other upvoted HN posts, not necessarily yours.]

> There are a variety of ways to force corporations to behave differently, but they all start with actually figuring out why they act this way in the first place.

It starts with whittling down the outrageous soft power enjoyed by corporations, their owners, and their agents — and which you are contributing to by delaying, denying, and softening accountability for the most outrageous of executive actions.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by NikolaNovak on Monday July 29, 2019 @07:45AM (#20553482)
Not the op, but this is a schism in attitude that I frequently face:

- I believe that "understanding your enemy" ("Empathy") is absolutely positively crucial in successfully fighting your enemy

- This frequently gets interpreted as "Sympathizing with your enemy", being too soft, making excuses,etc; by those who want simple action.

So for example, I think we need to understand what makes a terrorist, how they come to their beliefs and motivations, and what we can do to prevent that. Others interpret that as being 'soft on terrorism', and we just need to 'bomb them into oblivion'; whereas I fear that while actual physical fighting is definitely a critical part of the overall campaign, there's a tremendous danger it'll just create more terrorists because we haven't eradicated the actual root source.

To me, striving to understanding an enemy doesn't prevent direct, firm action, if that is then convincingly found to be the most effective and efficient way of fighting them. In turn, I feel understanding your enemy prevents random, ineffective, emotionally-satisfying but results-lacking action. Others, of course, will disagree.

So - to the point of the article and discussion: I agree with op, if that is their intention, that you have to look at incentives; I've worked in corporate world for decades and I fully agree that you can have whatever value pledges, official goals, mission statements, and even official rules you darn well want to; and they're completely irrelevant if actual incentives, when summed out, reward a different behaviour. External and internal rules, and power, and statements, and goals, are all factors in incentives; as are the more subtle, emergent incentives. Going for a blunt approach may shift those incentives insufficiently far, or in an incorrect direction.

...My 2.4 Canadian Pennies :-D

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by akerl_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:26AM (#20553801)
100% agreement with how you put it. I believe it’s crucial to empathize with everyone. Sympathy is fully separate, and not something that I have for the relevant management staff at Boeing/WellsFargo/etc. But empathy is what allows us to understand why somebody wants to do something, which is pretty necessary if we intend to alter that behavior.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by rectang on Monday July 29, 2019 @11:35AM (#20555656)
That Wells Fargo article you cite above vilifies low-level bankers as the true bad actors:

> “The real crime here is that low-level retail bankers set up fake accounts in order to scam Wells Fargo out of their modest paychecks” just doesn’t work as a story of the scandal, even if there is a certain partial truth to it as a mechanical matter.

Meanwhile, the upper managers who put in place the incentives that guaranteed fraud would occur by low-level bankers are only guilty of "mismanagement":

> In the case of Wells Fargo, though, I suppose it’s possible that the attorney general thinks the shareholders really were the victims. They didn’t benefit from the fake accounts, and it is not crazy to say that they were harmed by Wells Fargo’s mismanagement.

Carrie Tolstedt took home tens of millions of dollars for inducing fraud, but only the scapegoats who did the dirty work for her are held morally culpable. The author doesn't even notice that just like those low-level retail bankers, Tolstedt scammed shareholders out of her (enormous) paycheck.

It's a perfect example of extending excessive empathy to executives while hypocritically withholding it from others.

And that is exactly what's happening in this thread. Executive malfeasance gets endlessly excused away as the product of poor incentives, because in your quest to humanize executives, you succumb to the perfectly natural human foible of "to know all is to forgive all".

Now, I'm not saying you're a mustache-twirling villain. But people who are unable to apply their principles when the chips are down and hold executives accountable are at the root of the problem.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by akerl_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @12:37PM (#20556448)
Even the quote you cited doesn’t “vilify” anybody. It points out exactly what I described above: Wells Fargo execs created a situation with perverse incentives, no oversight, and reckless disregard for both, which led to low-level bankers predictably misusing the system. It’s not in dispute that the low-level bankers were the ones creating the fake accounts, and as the article notes, this wasn’t even desirable for the execs: they wanted the accounts because accounts lead to income, but faked accounts do not lead to income.

Your comment again points to some perceived inability on my part to “hold executives accountable”, citing some flaw with my principles. I’d invite you to review the site guidelines and my comments: at no point have I suggested that the executives aren’t culpable in both the Boeing and Wells Fargo examples. You seem to be inferring that empathy is incompatible with judgement, and that misconception is basically the heart of what I’m trying to call attention to in this exchange.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by rectang on Monday July 29, 2019 @01:02PM (#20556774)
> they wanted the accounts because accounts lead to income

Why is it a given that low-level retail bankers wanted faked accounts for the sake of their income, yet it is outside the realm of possibility that Carrie Tolstedt wanted faked accounts because they led to income for her — to the tune of tens of millions of dollars?

Why is it utterly inconceivable that Carrie Tolstedt is corrupt?

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by akerl_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:17PM (#20559554)
You seem pretty dead set on imagining that the only options are cartoon villainy or total innocence. I’m not sure how else I can frame the above points, given the continued selective quoting and misreading of the cited articles (notably, the Wells Fargo incident was not net-profitable for Wells Fargo, and was barely profitable at all even before all the government-imposed penalties).

I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree about the strength of my principles.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by AznHisoka on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:49AM (#20555152)
I love this, and 100% agree with this. People are just so impulsive and immediately flame you if you dare to say you emphathize with terrorists, or gun shooters. It's that impulsiveness that leads us to never make any progress in solving the root cause. Reactionary judgements accomplish absolutely nothing.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by Majromax on Monday July 29, 2019 @09:12AM (#20554236)
> I take you at your word. It's just hilarious that a post urging empathy for executives floats to the top while it's bootstraps for everyone else. [EDIT: in other upvoted HN posts, not necessarily yours.]

In some ways, having empathy (or even sympathy) for executives in situations such as this is a more damning call to action.

If a problem is a result of evil people doing evil things, then the obvious solution is to punish the evil people. If instead a problem is a result of good-natured people following a system with broken incentives, then the only effective response would be large-scale, systematic change.

Unfortunately, we don't often see things this way as a society. Our drive to action seems directly correlated to our sense of moral outrage, and we skip over the "broken system" step between "freak accident" and "mustache-twirling villain."

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday July 29, 2019 @11:01AM (#20555278)
They're not mutually exclusive. Broken incentives reward broken individuals and punish those who act in more ethical ways.

The legal system distinguishes between deliberate premeditated murder and accidental or negligent manslaughter.

Corporate ethics seems oddly resistant to understanding the distinction. If your actions cause significant harm the profit motive gives you very strong legal protection - a literal get out of jail free card. While it's not completely reliable, it's certainly more powerful than any non-corporate defence where culpability is obvious.

You're far more likely to go to jail for corporate fraud - which is an outrage against the profit motive - than for life-terminating harm inflicted on innocent bystanders.

This has the predictable effect of selecting executives who either don't understand that their actions cause harm, or don't care.

The system selects the people, and the people propagate its values. Neither is wholly innocent.

Every so often someone with a genuine ethical sense says "I'm not doing this." And they often lose their job when they do.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by ljm on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:02AM (#20552711)
Maybe I'm wrong but it feels a bit simpler than people being evil or malevolent. It's more like squeezing a juice out of a lemon: at first, it only requires light pressure to get the juice, but as you want more and more juice, your grip must get increasingly tighter. At some point it becomes clear you need a new lemon to get more juice, but for some reason it seems cheaper/more effective to keep squeezing the one that has nothing left to give.

So it is with businesses extracting value (/making as much money as possible).

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by akerl_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:17AM (#20552765)
The tricky part is figuring out the “for some reason” in your metaphor, and then designing a system that causes them to rethink that calculus instead of just finding a different way to keep squeezing the same lemon.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by Majromax on Monday July 29, 2019 @09:18AM (#20554280)
> Maybe I'm wrong but it feels a bit simpler than people being evil or malevolent. It's more like squeezing a juice out of a lemon: at first, it only requires light pressure to get the juice, but as you want more and more juice, your grip must get increasingly tighter.

It's like the idea of "pot odds" in poker: Boeing here wasn't just looking at the marginal return on investment, it was looking at the cost of essentially deprecating an entire line of aircraft. It would lose value from its entire "installed base" of customers, as competition from Airbus would become more viable.

In economic terms, the marginal value of the investment was probably close to nil, but it protected profitable infra-marginal investments. Interestingly, this seems like a problem that large companies face far more often than startups, which is perhaps why conventional wisdom thinks the latter are far more 'agile'.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by mlang23 on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:20AM (#20552780)
I dont believe your point at all. Do you know how high the psychopath rate amongst managers is? You would be shocked.

I really dont believe that someone having fought their way up to a job that pays a 7 figure number per year actually cares about normal human people anymore. I just dont.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by mcv on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:19AM (#20554846)
> Do you know how high the psychopath rate amongst managers is?

What I've always wanted to know is: do psychopaths make better managers? Do they somehow gravitate towards management positions in some other way? Or is it the management position that brings out the psychopath in people?

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by tempguy9999 on Monday July 29, 2019 @12:27PM (#20556324)
This is my opinion, from experience.

> do psychopaths make better managers?

I've had 2. No, they're horrible to work for. Indifferent to you as a human, bullying, lying, destructive (edit: and manipulative). The best bosses I've had, the ones that got the most out of me, were humane and decent (Also 2 of them).

> Do they somehow gravitate towards management positions in some other way?

I guess so. Power, control, money (all of these really boil down to power).

> Or is it the management position that brings out the psychopath in people?

No. A psychopath is a definite mental phenomenon that AFAIK is something you're born with. It is thought to be perhaps made worse by bad childhoods, but it certainly isn't something you develop if you weren't born with it.

What I do see in those psychopaths that I recognise as such is that they often really driven for money/power. They're often great fun to be with because they're so impulsive, but wear you down with constant demands.

Above is just my personal understanding and experiences.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by acqq on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:57AM (#20552694)
> being aware of those incentives is crucial if we’d like to actually change corporate behavior.

We are aware how the hierarchies function: "I was just following the orders"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superior_orders#Nuremberg_Tria...

I agree with you that it doesn't have sense trying to discuss about the abstract evilness, but I claim that the Boeing's top brass should be brought to the court!

If those who make decisions aren't held accountable, the results are provably terrible.

"I was ''just'' securing the profit for my shareholders" shouldn't be an excuse.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by msiyer on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:43AM (#20552910)
The executives in any corporation are in no way normal people. More so in a behemoth like Boeing. They have nothing in common with common people.

They might not be clapping hands at the death of few humans, but they would not be crying either.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by mcv on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:53AM (#20554059)
They were probably not thinking about human lives at all, merely about how to game the regulations they had to meet. It's not mere negligence, but intentional short-sightedness. Forget that this is about human lives, it's merely about red tape you need to get past.

That's the real corporate evil: losing sight of the big picture of what your product is supposed to accomplish in the world, and see it merely as a vehicle for profit, where the regulations are merely obstacles you need to bypass, rather than a necessary good that ensures your product is safe and provides real value to the world.

And I fear this kind of thinking is incredible common in large corporations. It doesn't always lead to disasters like the 737 Max, the VW emission scandal, or the Fukushima or Deepwater disasters, but losing sight of the larger context of what you're doing does enable those kind of disasters.

After the mortgage crisis and other banking misbehaviours, all people working at Dutch banks (including developers like me) are required (and trained, to some extent) to always keep this big picture in mind: what does this decision mean for the company, the customers, the shareholders and also society in general. All 4 need to be balanced. Maybe this should be more common among all industries.

Corporations certainly do need to be held accountable for their actions, and for the corporate culture they create, because that will impact the actions of the corporation as a whole. If everybody just focuses on the immediate requirements (passing that emissions test no matter how, making the plane pretend to be the same in order to pass certification) without considering the larger picture, that is a result of the corporate culture and the way performance of employees is measured. The corporation is absolutely responsible for that, and yes, maybe it should be considered evil when upper management fosters or allows a culture of this kind of short-sightedness.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by sokoloff on Monday July 29, 2019 @09:35AM (#20554419)
While I don't mean to defend the multi-step process that led to the 2 737 Max crashes, I think this is a case where many actors combined, with most every individual action apparently seeming fairly reasonable, to achieve an outcome that was unreasonable in aggregate. (This excludes a high-level systems engineering oversight function, of course.)

The airplane needs more efficient engines.

The new engines are physically larger and the space underwing too low.

Let's move the engines forward.

That causes the stick force curve in an uncommon region of the envelope seen mostly only when hand flying and out of normal envelope.

We could fix the stick force curve by actively displacing the horizontal stabilizer under those conditions.

We can limit the authority of the stab under MCAS to 0.6°, a figure which would only be a slight hazard to flight as pilots could easily override.

We can prevent the need to retrain pilots (even if only differences training), but this requires us to use only a single angle-of-attack sensor to drive the system. That's OK, because the 0.6° limit is safe.

Later, someone else decides to give MCAS a little more control authority. It's not clear (to me) that the 0.6° prior limit was documented as something that was being relied on by regulators or not. A "safe" system being given a little more authority in the name of safety doesn't sound so bad, after all.

No analysis appears to be done for the case of multiply resetting the MCAS system, allowing for progressively more authority.

No analysis appears to be done for the fact that line pilots were relying on the "control breakaway" to interrupt automated trim motion on legacy 737s. Pilots using this undocumented technique may have become overly accustomed to it and assumed the plane was designed that way. Of course, MCAS, being a system to protect the stick force curve during manual flight, could not reasonably be disabled by a control column breakout switch, because it's designed to protect the aircraft exactly during hand flying situations where the pilot had the column in an aircraft nose up attitude (where the column breakout switches would be activated).

I agree with your overall point that the holistic outcome was bad, that it's a systems problem, but want to amplify the fact that a great many people were working diligently to accomplish their goal(s) in the face of their constraints. Very few (to perhaps none of them), pilots included, likely realized that they were acting in a short-sighted way.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by mcv on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:15AM (#20554792)
I think those individual actions only seem reasonable because we're so used to this corporate short-sightedness. People should be taking responsibility for the whole, and not just their little cog in the big machine.

For the 737 Max, moving the engines forward meant changing the aerodynamic balance. That alone should mean recertification, and every attempt to cover that up in order to save money, is part of the problem.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by sokoloff on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:58AM (#20555247)
The 737-700 is ~10 feet longer and ~20 foot wider wingspan than the -200. Surely that has a greater impact on aerodynamics than the -Max engine change. It’s not that there is no certification but rather that they are built on a common type certificate (and flown by a common type rating).

Everything that adds cost to aviation has a safety balance. Why do we allow 0 and 1 year olds to fly as lap children (without buying a seat)? Because displacing the fraction of families who would substitute a car trip if forced to buy more tickets would mean greater overall injuries and fatalities. Saving money has its own real safety benefit that needs to be balanced holistically.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by jeroen on Thursday August 01, 2019 @10:19AM (#20583854)
> But I think it’s pretty implausible to suggest that the “evil people” at Boeing we’re clapping their hands about savings with an understanding that they were trading human lives for those profits.

Yet it's entirely plausible that they were consciously making that trade off. I see a lot of similarities to cases like these:

> Ford (..) Pinto became a subject of controversy after Mother Jones magazine exposed that it was prone to deadly fires in rear-end collisions; Ford’s internal documents showed the company knew of the potential problem but chose not to fix it, calculating that it would be cheaper to pay out possible injury claims.

> The Japanese manufacturer of airbags has recalled airbags in some 19.2 million vehicles in the U.S. due to a tendency of the device to deploy with too much force, sending metal scraps flying into the passenger cabin. Eight deaths and about 100 injuries in the U.S. have been attributed to the defect. According to a New York Times report, Honda, one of the companies using the bags, and Takata knew about the dangerous airbags for years before disclosing it to the public and issuing recalls.

-- https://fortune.com/2015/09/26/auto-industry-scandals/

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by breatheoften on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:54AM (#20555205)
Just to take things to another extreme — our society seems to believe the death penalty works as a deterrent — so why shouldn’t we seek the death penalty for executives when their neglect kills people ...?
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by rightbyte on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:09PM (#20560856)
Making being in charge riskier will probably not make more risk aware people being in charge.

If I could get prosecuted for accidents my code coused I would never work which such tasks.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by ahartmetz on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:15AM (#20552758)
Haha, thanks for the poem link. It's fairly funny and indicates that a) they knew exactly what they were doing and b) that they knew it was somewhat likely that they'd get caught. Actually it says they already got a slap on the wrist from TÜV but could somehow carry on?

I mean it was pretty clear that everybody who really wanted to know could discover the cheating, but somehow it was covered up for a long time. Everybody knew about gas mileage results drifting further and further away from reality, too... And finally we got WLTP, which is somewhat less bad but still pretty bad.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by nguoi on Monday July 29, 2019 @12:06PM (#20556035)
It reminds me of the reaction to the Five Eyes reveal. If someone had presented it as a conspiracy theory beforehand and asked me if I thought it was happening, I'd have said it probably was.

It's probably quite easy to justify to yourself if you see everyone else doing it, even though it has abhorrent consequences[1]. Like people dropping cigarette butts.

[1] Which they should have known existed - the oligarchy of car companies ensures a huge impact from just one company playing unfairly.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by Glawen on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:52AM (#20555192)
The competitors must have known as well. They all buy competitors cars and disassemble them to reverse engineer the car. They probably also spotted the cheating device, and thought: ok the leading company is cheating, so do I.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by mrguyorama on Monday July 29, 2019 @03:45PM (#20558596)
The "cheating device" was just a feature flag that could be enabled on the engine computer made by Bosch, who also makes engine computers with similar software for most other car companies. Bosch told them about the feature, educated them about what it would do, what it would mean, how it's not really legal etc, and then Volkswagen decided to turn it on.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by Glawen on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:58PM (#20559904)
You're totally off here.

Bosch sells engine hardware (ECU, pump, injectors etc..), but the software is custom made. The automaker pays Bosch to implement the SW they want, as a lot of features differentiating automakers are SW features that they do not want their competitors to have.

Hence it doesn't mean that every diesel engine with a bosch ECU had the cheating device from VW.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by sam_lowry_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:38AM (#20553919)
Those clever enough to discover the cheating were clever enough to understand that regulations are rather inadequate, and should not be followed à la lettre.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by keyme on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:44AM (#20552645)
There is always at least one guy that really does understand the implications, is in the position to make changes, but proceeds anyway.
Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by nguoi on Monday July 29, 2019 @12:09PM (#20556082)
To be picky, that is unfalsifiable.

I think you're probably correct but shaming the engineers in the hopes they'll stop it has repeatedly failed to work: that's why this isn't a thread about VW. IMHO it's because actions from a single individual carry too much risk for enough to accept. It needs collective bargaining.

Re:Work on production line of Boeing 737 Max ‘not adequately... by _pmf_ on Monday July 29, 2019 @07:28AM (#20553382)
> The VW guys were writing poems for their clever defeat device!

Didn't know that one; nice.