If we assume that different kinds of life based on different nucleic acids can co-exist, then it seems unlikely that a single kind would have happened to be carried to Earth by a natural process.
If we assume DNA has some inherent fitness advantage (so that only DNA-based life survived the journey), than we don't need the additional assumption of panspermia: perhaps only the DNA-based life survived some early period in Earth's history.
Also, for abiogenesis, given that we still can't reliably reproduce something like that, and that we have never seen new kinds of life spontaneously appearing on Earth, we do have some circumstantial evidence for the possibility that it is an incredibly unlikely event, such that it might have only happened once in Earth's history.
Edit: There is also another simple possibility: perhaps given the resources available on Earth, either forever or in the period where abiogenesis was possible, perhaps DNA(+RNA) is the only molecule with the right properties to act as genetic material. Perhaps there is no common ancestor to all life on Earth, but a "forest" of inter-breeding, spotnaneously arisen original organisms, but they were all DNA/RNA-based simply because of the available resources.
And I agree that RNA and DNA are pretty good molecules and probably close to some notion of 'optimal'. The ribosome, however, is big and complicated and there are probably millions of different ways something like that could have come about and that would affect the 3-base codon, protein structures, etc.
Also, look at the contortions DNA has to go through to copy what's called the "lagging strand". Clearly duplicating double-stranded DNA did not come early or easily; it's pretty obvious a system bolted on top of some other, older system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_replication#Lagging_strand
Maybe it's around, but too small and isolated a population to be discovered.
The closest we got is with Threose Nucleic Acids. Managed to get a working hemoglobin binder with this. But it is a relatively obvious analog.
There is a theory that early life was RNA based. The mechanims are simpler, and it's easier to create "spontaneously appearing" RNA "life".
But as soon as this RNA life evolved and produced DNA based encoding system, the DNA based life evolved to wiped them out. Right now earth is full of RNAses, which are proteins that destroy RNA, made by DNA based life.
Evolution works in non-intuitive (mysterious) ways.
Edit: with reflection I think I understand what you were getting at, that the memes contained in the Nag Hamadi corpus had been successfully suppressed by their memetic cousins which for whatever reason came to be the dominant 'version' of that information, until an accident of history reintroduced the different versions that had been all but extincted in the memepool.
A very well encapsulated and protected DNA will land on earth and create the most adaptable life-form there through mutation and competition. All of these life-forms have the trait of wanting to pass their genes, multiply as much as possible and then spread around.
So the engineers probably had that in mind:
1- Extremely small: Probably so that they can propel it through space at very high speed + propel lots of it.
2- No maintenance required.
3- Will create a life-form if possible that is adaptable to the target country.
4- The life-form has the property of multiplication, and spreading.
5- The new superior life-form will propel more of these DNA.
No, it won't. DNA alone without cellular machinery (that is, without a “life form”) doesn't produce anything. That's why viruses need hosts.
Not necessarily, many organisms can undergo cryptobiosis, where all metabolic activity ceases, and then restarts when conditions are appropriate (sometimes decades later).
“the epoch”? Apex, maybe?
DNA is useless without the cellular machinery to translate it into proteins and new cells. To do that, you basically need cells.
Maybe DNA is simply geared well compared to other mechanisms for the timescales we're interested in.
My thoughts exactly.
Also, the emergence of an intelligent, technologically capable species (i.e. humans) is a relatively very recent occurrence in Earth's history. It's as if it just suddenly happened, even though there was a long history of dynamic evolution for many hundreds of millions of years. But the sudden emergence of humans doesn't mean there had to have been an external cause.
But the variation is in the one place you could possibly have it - by changing the interpretation of one or two of the three available STOP codons.
Citaton needed.
https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.03748
https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/04/are-we-e...
But the evidence we have (as per prior comments) is that a human-level intelligence civilisation has arisen only once on Earth.
With that out of the way, when we're having these kinds of discussions, it's not really productive to bring up an infinite number of possibilities that we can't rule out. Which one should we choose to support? Without some criteria, we will just talk about it forever -- which might be fun, but it's not productive.
This is where science comes in. I'm going to say something a bit controversial. Science doesn't really talk about absolute truth. We can't know what that is -- because there are an infinite number of possibilities that we can't rule out. Instead it talks about things that are "productive" (my term).
In a very hand-wavy way, science is about making observations and building a model that explains those observation. There are a couple of other important things. The model should also make predictions about thing we haven't observed that we can test. We try it and if it also fulfills those predictions, we thing it's a "productive" model (again, my term). Why is it productive? Because it allows us to reason about things and make conclusions that are likely to work out for us. However, we shouldn't mistake that for the absolute truth. There really is a possibility that things appear one way to us, but are very different in ways that we can't see. The key is that from the perspective of science that's fine -- as long as we can keep making predictions and they keep working out for use, we can use our model.
But what if we have 2 models that are both equivalent? For example, let's say they both explain the observations we see and they make predictions that work out. Which should we pick? By convention, we pick the simplest one. In truth, the simplest one might not be correct, but it's always easier to work with a simpler model... because it's simpler ;-)
So while there may truly be advanced civilizations out there -- we can't rule it out, there is no test we can currently do that would show that advanced civilizations exist. Our models without advanced civilizations (except our own) explain everything we can currently observe and everything we can currently test. So we choose the model with no other advanced civilizations.
You really don't have to believe that, but when discussing with others we have to set some rules. If we keep in mind other advanced civilizations, it's just as reasonable to keep in mind an infinite number of other possibilities -- some of which would be truly bizarre. In order to keep the conversation on track, we have to choose somehow and the scientific method is a good, proven way to narrow the discussion down to something that is productive. However, if you find people who want to talk about the kinds of things you want to talk about, I think there is nothing at all wrong with that. You should do what makes you happy.
I hope that makes things a bit clearer. I often meet people who make comments like you did and I think it's really mystifying to those people why science oriented people act this way.
On the other hand, I believe the very core of science is to use our imagination and creativity to look for things that don't fit any models, that are not accounted for by any of them, for higher-order structures that might explain the current models better and so on.
For example, our civilization is more or less built on energy, with the electric current as its main medium, so we are totally dependent on external energy sources - and that's currently the main problem of our civilization. It's not impossible other civilizations might exist (in other space-time environments) that somewhat learned to achieve similar results we do (transportation, healing, distant communication) without using external energy sources. This would at least account for lack of artefacts we currently identify an advanced civilization with.
We have evidence that it is extremely unlikely under current conditions, but then we know that current conditions are unlike the conditions when life emerged on Earth (whatever it's origin), in part due to effects of life itself (such as the Oxygen Catastrophe).
Abiogenesis could be very likely under a combination of conditions that existed in the Hadean or Eoarchean Earth.
The problem is that we can't see through survivor bias. Maybe life has lots of possible configurations and only DNA-based life was highly successful on Earth. It's also possible that non-DNA-based life exists, we just haven't noticed it because it is too small, too slow, or too something-else that we missed it.
Maybe Earth is just a big petri-dish for a very advanced alien species trying to reconstruct their own evolutionary history?
It's something I've thought about since I've been a kid (I've been a weird kid).
The time-scales make this kinda implausible, but there's still Clarke's third law, so who knows if properly advanced technology might even allow for artificial time dilation to facilitate such an experiment in a useful way.
When I was in like 3rd or 4th grade we were each given a petri dish and told to swab different surfaces (bathroom door handle, water fountain spout, etc.) and then we would learn about bacteria while we watched ours grow. Well the teacher told us our petri dish would grow “it’s own little world” and I (fellow weird kid) had just seen Men In Black so I was fascinated by the idea of an entire world so tiny that it could exist on a cat’s collar. Of course I asked what would happen to our worlds after the experiment (I thought we’d get to keep them!) and when I found out it would go in the trash I refused to participate. (Weird and stubborn - my poor parents.)
And I had completely forgotten about that for 20+ years until today, when you’ve got me laughing at the thought that we could be the petri dish of some clueless 4th grader of an advanced alien species.
Possibly genetic drift. The odds of life making a successful journey to earth seem very poor, so maybe it was a small population that only made it here once, and then began to speciate.
Once the life really started going, it changed the chemistry of the earth rapidly. Similar chemical evolution starting from scratch was not possible once the life started. Eventually when photosynthesis started, biologically induced molecular oxygen caused so called Oxygen Catastrophe where Earth's chemistry turned from reducing into oxidizing. Oxygen also changed the chemistry in the seas and rocks. Molecular oxygen is great disinfectant.
> You can find less efficient photosynthetic pathways dominating their environment (see c4 rice project).
It's not absolute advantage. c4 has advantage in warm and low CO2, low water conditions. In colder climates and with more CO2 and water c3 plants gain more carbon.
Btw. Mirror chiralities are not exactly symmetric. There are tiny asymmetries between chirality due to weak interactions and electron interactions. Weak interactions might affect long hydrocarbon chains. Electrons from beta decay interact with molecules of different centrality with slightly different speeds (difference is something like 0.01%).
Yes, but horses and cows also compete for the same building blocks. And yet, we have horses and cows.
Your argument could be right if there wasn't an abundance of these building blocks.
I think you're just failing to grasp the sheer numbers involved here: there are probably around 10^9 cow-like critters and they interact with other, competing critters every, let's say, 10^4 seconds, with the odds of any one of these interactions being fatal being, again, let's say 1 in 10^4. By comparison, there were probably something like 10^37 (if I counted my orders of magnitude right) biomolecules interacting every 10^-6 seconds where every time some new chemical "A-ha!" moment occurred, that reaction now became 1000x more favorable than any other competing reaction. That's like, what, 41 orders of magnitude; even if I'm off by 10+ orders of magnitude, there was just a whole lot more selective pressure going on during the pre-biotic era. Less favorable chemical pathways were outcompeted on scales so vast you'd need trillions of cow-years to approximate how de-de-de-deselected-for they were.
Nature might be slightly biased due to the asymmetry of the weak force.
The more I read about DNA and RNA, the more it seems to me they're somewhat fundamentally grounded in chemistry - you can't just make codons mean arbitrary things by messing with the replication mechanisms. There's less path dependence, and more of "one optimal way of doing things".
That said, I think it's reasonable to assume we all have common lineage[0] - it's arguably a winner-takes-all scenario, as there's a huge first-mover advantage for the first self-replicating family of things that got loose on the world.
--
[0] - causally, not genetically; the history of life is not a tree structure due to constant lateral gene transfer that bacteria and archaea engage in.
Scientists have discovered that the animal with the most genes--about 31,000--is the near-microscopic freshwater crustacean Daphnia pulex, or water flea. By comparison, humans have about 23,000 genes.
One of the most astonishing features of the D. pulex genome is its compactness: despite being around 200 Mb in size (around 16-fold smaller than the human genome which is 3,200 Mb in size); its 12 chromosomes contain a minimum set of 30,907 predicted protein-coding genes, more than the 20,000–25,000 contained in the human counterpart.
The unexpected complexity of the water flea genome compared with a human genome illustrates unknown dimensions of complexity that we cannot fully comprehend.
What this means is this. You do not know how complicated the original template of life is... the complexity for the first genome to produce instructions that allow for self replication to kick off evolution may be so complex that it could only happen once on our planet, once in this galaxy or once in the universe.
We simply do not have the knowledge to know the probability space of life on earth or life as we know it.
Although most (all?) of the variability is in the one place you can make it without almost-certainly killing your host organism - in repurposing the STOP codons. There are usually three (and likely UGG was a fourth before it got hijacked by Tryptophan in the before time) and all you need is one.
Or that the same self replicating systems were the most (or only) stable systems that could be forged from the locally available inorganic molecules.
If a large asteroid hit the Earth today it might be only a few subterranean extremophile microorganisms that survive. Asteroids were more frequent during the early history of the solar system.
The counterpoint is that the fossil record is very incomplete when going that far back, seeing as tectonic subduction literally wipes the slate clean.
My understanding is that life visible to the naked eye is a minority of life forms on the planet. Maybe other forms of genetic coding than DNA are more prevalent than we anthropocentrists think.
() This is the whole appeal of the "RNA world" hypothesis, you have one molecule that can serve both as "code" and catalyst for other chemical reactions.
A posituve thing is that in Miller experiment, he found out that those conditions create aminate acids. That also indicate that panspermia theory is unlikely (not impossible, but not Occam's razor choice at least).
Evolution of eyes and abiogenesis aren't obviously similar enough for this analogy to be compelling without some narrative as to why what occurred with one should shape expectations of the other. The conditions in which life first emerged in either the Hadean or Eoarchean eons weren't around for much more of the history of the Earth; if the average expected frequency of abiogenesis under the conditions it actually emerged was once every quarter billion years or so, then—no matter which point in the possible range of time it first occurred—conditions wouldn't have been right for more than one to a very few instances, and if there were more than one, still one would likely be much more established by time available to spread alone, and then there were be massive environmental changes likely producing extinctions. Only one lineage surviving that bottleneck isn't surprising even if there were more before, and while we have evidence of early life it's far from complete either in coverage or ability to determine biochemistry and lineage.
It's really not necessary to invoke extraterrestrial origin to explain only one lineage on Earth (and it actually may make the problem worse: because then you have to explain why we haven't gotten alternate lineages from the same or other extraplanetary sources.)
If life came from outside our planet via an asteroid or something, then it had to be a LOT of DNA that came over. More exotic theories can be concieved, but the jist is that it is really really hard for DNA to travel the stars and between planets intact.
The simplier explination is that it started here.
[0] https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rspb.201...
When people talk about DNA-based-panspermia, I've always assumed that they meant either a living or dormant organism (with the potential for DNA replication/error-correction), rather than a completely inert blob of DNA.
I'll have to ponder on the idea that anything could get past all those 'gates'. If it did, woah, what a hardy little thing!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_life
xkcd just ran a strip with a joke about this theory last week
I think it's unlikely because it seems hard to imagine no interaction between the kinds of life ever after billions of years of coevolution. On the other hand, there are tons of microorganisms that do share our biochemistry that we haven't noticed or identified yet, so maybe it's not impossible to imagine some that don't that we also haven't noticed or identified (since it would be more difficult for us to recognize them).
Not that just because a hypothesis is not scientific, it doesn't mean that people can not research or fine-tune it until it become a scientific theory, but in this state, spending public research credit on it is not a very good choice (especially in the current state of funding for biology).
(it can be read wrong, my command of english is not great: i'm just adding thing to your comment, this is not a critisism of you or what you said)
Having said that, it is neither unscientific nor against Popper to postulate something for which there is currently no evidence (the search for exoplanets was started before there was evidence of them) - you would have to postulate something that cannot, in principle, be empirically determined (such as p-zombies) to violate the falsifiability principle (if that's what your specific issue is here.) Such hypotheses are not outside of science; they are an essential part of it, and some unspecified part of scientific spending is effectively spent on generating them.
On the other hand, as Hossenfelder has pointed out [1], falsifiability is a low bar. In the case of shadow life, it is reasonable to ask both how it could remain isolated and why have we not noticed it yet.
[1] https://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/01/just-because-its-f...
Not quite. Simple life forms probably existed for far longer than DNA. The fact that we see convergent evolution in complex life forms, which emerged very late in the history of life, only suggests that there are recurring patterns in the system that enabled the formation of higher life. It doesn't suggest anything about the origin of cellular life itself, which existed for hundreds of millions of years before eyes or lungs.
But what would the advantage look like? Isn't successfully surviving and propagating for billions of years, the ultimate advantage? It would seem like our current state is the best one then..
Or a (local) optimum.
The notion of abiogenesis occurring only once on earth seems improbable considering complex organs like eyes have evolved independently several different times. Or the fact that convergent evolution "reinvents" similar species in response to similar selective pressures. Selective pressures constantly "push" life in the same directions, so it would seem that whatever forces gave rise to life would have happened so repeatedly, but there doesn't seem to be any evidence for that.
A clean explanation for this would be that life didn't start on earth, and earth may have never had the right conditions to originate life, hence no competing genetic codes. But it was still hospitable enough to maintain life, so one universal genetic code flourishes with no emergent competition.