News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by tsimionescu on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:49AM (#20399439)
Doesn't that just beg the question? If life originated on some other planet and made it to Earth, why did only the DNA-based lifeform(s) make it here?

If we assume that different kinds of life based on different nucleic acids can co-exist, then it seems unlikely that a single kind would have happened to be carried to Earth by a natural process.

If we assume DNA has some inherent fitness advantage (so that only DNA-based life survived the journey), than we don't need the additional assumption of panspermia: perhaps only the DNA-based life survived some early period in Earth's history.

Also, for abiogenesis, given that we still can't reliably reproduce something like that, and that we have never seen new kinds of life spontaneously appearing on Earth, we do have some circumstantial evidence for the possibility that it is an incredibly unlikely event, such that it might have only happened once in Earth's history.

Edit: There is also another simple possibility: perhaps given the resources available on Earth, either forever or in the period where abiogenesis was possible, perhaps DNA(+RNA) is the only molecule with the right properties to act as genetic material. Perhaps there is no common ancestor to all life on Earth, but a "forest" of inter-breeding, spotnaneously arisen original organisms, but they were all DNA/RNA-based simply because of the available resources.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gomijacogeo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @05:14AM (#20400356)
I think the most likely reason is simply that they were first. And whatever managed to close some metabolic or reproductive cycle first got, and I mean this quite literally, an exponential boost over everything else. So think of early proto-life on Earth not as some single thread doggedly proceeding up an evolutionary ladder, but rather a series of epochs where there's great diversity until BOOM some set of molecules manage to close some metabolic or reproductive loop and then outcompetes everything else in essentially a blink of an eye.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by peteradio on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @07:57AM (#20401075)
Couldn't that be the same explanation in the case where it originated here? It was first and dominated?
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gomijacogeo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:26AM (#20401266)
That's what I was trying to say; I'm in no way a panspermia fan. I was responding primarily to the line "perhaps DNA(+RNA) is the only molecule with the right properties to act as genetic material" with the notion that it was probably more special because it was first rather than something intrinsic about the DNA->RNA->ribosome system that made it inevitable. If we could roll the clock back 4.mumble billion years, we'd probably still get life that had a separation between code and structure, but what that code was and what that structure looked like might have been pretty different.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:29AM (#20401293)
I'm not sure there is anything else with the flexibility of D/RNA. Its self-replicating property is fundamental. Is there something else known to work anything like this?
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gomijacogeo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @09:45AM (#20401868)
Some possible alternatives are covered here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nucleic_acid_analogue

And I agree that RNA and DNA are pretty good molecules and probably close to some notion of 'optimal'. The ribosome, however, is big and complicated and there are probably millions of different ways something like that could have come about and that would affect the 3-base codon, protein structures, etc.

Also, look at the contortions DNA has to go through to copy what's called the "lagging strand". Clearly duplicating double-stranded DNA did not come early or easily; it's pretty obvious a system bolted on top of some other, older system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_replication#Lagging_strand

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by bluGill on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @09:33AM (#20401764)
But that doesn't explain why DNA/RNA is the only. If DNA got a large boost I'll believe it is dominate, but why isn't there anything else somewhere still struggling along.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gomijacogeo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @10:16AM (#20402133)
There is a very (very!) small chance that there are isolated biomes that split from life's tree before what we call the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) and are still plugging along. But it's pretty much impossible that some sister-metabolism from the pre-DNA days could just 'struggle along' side-by-side what we consider 'biology'. When something out-competes another by factors of 1000x or 1000000x, extinction is the only outcome. It's not like elephants and ants finding different niches for billions of years; we're talking about systems of molecules where most of the building blocks are at most a dozen or two atoms and most of the feedstocks are less than 5 (CH4, NH2, O2, H2S, CO, CO2, etc). What's this poor, struggling cousin that we outcompete by a factor of a million going to eat that we can't eat better? Similarly, how does it adapt and evolve against its peers when 999999/1000000 interactions aren't against peers but against us and our self-contained, portable, self-replicating, weaponized Krebs cycle machines?
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by bluGill on Thursday July 11, 2019 @09:10AM (#20411199)
I don't see why 100000x better means extinction must happen. There are "fish" that have copper blood even though iron is significantly better, they are out competed, but that isn't enough to make them extinct: there is still enough oxygen for them to compete.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by tabtab on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @11:29AM (#20402893)
Re: When something out-competes another by factors of 1000x or 1000000x, extinction is the only outcome.

Maybe it's around, but too small and isolated a population to be discovered.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by AstralStorm on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @12:48PM (#20403762)
Or not alive, but fossilized. Speculation gets us nowhere - unless you happen to construct outside alternative life with modern nanotechnology and chemistry, it is bootless to even argue for other forms.

The closest we got is with Threose Nucleic Acids. Managed to get a working hemoglobin binder with this. But it is a relatively obvious analog.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by 1kGarand on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @09:33AM (#20401761)
> perhaps only the DNA-based life survived some early period in Earth's history.

There is a theory that early life was RNA based. The mechanims are simpler, and it's easier to create "spontaneously appearing" RNA "life".

But as soon as this RNA life evolved and produced DNA based encoding system, the DNA based life evolved to wiped them out. Right now earth is full of RNAses, which are proteins that destroy RNA, made by DNA based life.

Evolution works in non-intuitive (mysterious) ways.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by lisper on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @09:48AM (#20401892)
This is a very plausible theory. An analogous phenomenon happens in the world of memes, where some ideas produce "phenotypes" that wipe out other, competing ideas. c.f. Tienanmen Square in China or the Nag Hamadi scrolls.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by taylorfinley on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:21PM (#20404117)
Can you elaborate on your examples?
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by lisper on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @03:10PM (#20405340)
Yes, but have you read "The Selfish Gene"? If not, you need to do that first.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by taylorfinley on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @03:26PM (#20405520)
I have, I'm interested in memes as Dawkins defined them then. I've also read many translations of Nag Hamadi scrolls, so your example sparked my curiosity. Perhaps I need to re-read The Selfish Gene, it's been more than a decade now.

Edit: with reflection I think I understand what you were getting at, that the memes contained in the Nag Hamadi corpus had been successfully suppressed by their memetic cousins which for whatever reason came to be the dominant 'version' of that information, until an accident of history reintroduced the different versions that had been all but extincted in the memepool.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by lisper on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @06:30PM (#20407271)
Exactly right.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by csomar on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:38AM (#20399637)
It'll be easier to send a DNA without a life-form. A life-form is very expensive (need to eat and breath) and not necessarily adaptable to earth conditions.

A very well encapsulated and protected DNA will land on earth and create the most adaptable life-form there through mutation and competition. All of these life-forms have the trait of wanting to pass their genes, multiply as much as possible and then spread around.

So the engineers probably had that in mind:

1- Extremely small: Probably so that they can propel it through space at very high speed + propel lots of it.

2- No maintenance required.

3- Will create a life-form if possible that is adaptable to the target country.

4- The life-form has the property of multiplication, and spreading.

5- The new superior life-form will propel more of these DNA.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:05PM (#20403936)
> A very well encapsulated and protected DNA will land on earth and create the most adaptable life-form there through mutation and competition.

No, it won't. DNA alone without cellular machinery (that is, without a “life form”) doesn't produce anything. That's why viruses need hosts.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by rectangletangle on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:47AM (#20399680)
>A life-form is very expensive (need to eat and breath)

Not necessarily, many organisms can undergo cryptobiosis, where all metabolic activity ceases, and then restarts when conditions are appropriate (sometimes decades later).

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by andai on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:08AM (#20400070)
Fungi & bacteria can turn into spores & travel through space. There was also recent article about fungus growing on the outside (!) of the space station.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by rjf72 on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:25AM (#20400140)
There are also things like tardigrades [1] which are pretty much the epoch of survival evolution. And this is all just stuff on our little planet. It's hard to say anything about life on a large scale, since we are basing everything we know on a sample of one. But it's probably safe to say that we have not even scratched the surface of what's possibility through just plain old evolution alone.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tardigrade

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by imtringued on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @07:16AM (#20400865)
There are still a few billion years left for earth to shine.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dragonwriter on Thursday July 11, 2019 @10:58AM (#20411996)
> There are also things like tardigrades [1] which are pretty much the epoch of survival evolution

“the epoch”? Apex, maybe?

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by guelo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @06:18AM (#20400615)
Nematode worms have been brought back to life after having been frozen in tundra for 40,000 years.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by titzer on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:38AM (#20400194)
> It'll be easier to send a DNA without a life-form.

DNA is useless without the cellular machinery to translate it into proteins and new cells. To do that, you basically need cells.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by npongratz on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:27AM (#20401269)
Would a virus meet this project's specifications?
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by rkagerer on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:54AM (#20399462)
Another possibility often overlooked is that there's life out there on completely different timescales than we can recognize. We're only likely to notice those within a few orders of magnitude to our own.

Maybe DNA is simply geared well compared to other mechanisms for the timescales we're interested in.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by rectangletangle on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:01AM (#20399492)
This is an interesting thought. Plants are actually very animated at their own timescale, adapting to their environment through phenotypic plasticity. However this happens far too slow for humans to notice without a time lapse.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gremlinsinc on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:45AM (#20399674)
This is why it takes so long to hold a meeting of the Ents.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by Angostura on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @05:36AM (#20400449)
That's a moot point.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by guelo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @06:21AM (#20400631)
But plants are really obviously complex life forms when we examine them at human timescale. I don't see how a complex life from escapes our noticing it by moving really slowly.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by on_and_off on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @03:22AM (#20399842)
Sundiver is a recommended read in that regard ;)
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gricardo99 on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:18AM (#20399544)
> perhaps only the DNA-based life survived some early period in Earth's history.

My thoughts exactly.

Also, the emergence of an intelligent, technologically capable species (i.e. humans) is a relatively very recent occurrence in Earth's history. It's as if it just suddenly happened, even though there was a long history of dynamic evolution for many hundreds of millions of years. But the sudden emergence of humans doesn't mean there had to have been an external cause.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by H8crilA on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:35AM (#20399617)
What is surprising to me is not just that it's always DNA, but that it's always translated in the same way (codons to aminoacids, and the mapping function is fixed). Is there any simple reason for that?
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gomijacogeo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:59AM (#20400313)
The simplest reason is that the ribosome evolved very early on (and is probably the best preserved remnant of whatever the earlier "RNA world" looked like) and it was always easier to leverage that machinery than to evolve another whole system from scratch. Once you have a world populated by any form of proto-life that can self-reproduce, even with crappy fidelity, it's basically game-over for any of the other semi-closed metabolic pathways that might have been competitors up until that point - they're now just food. There's no opportunity for another system to arise because all the raw materials are being scooped up by the new superpredator on the scene - the ribosome & whatever associated machinery it drags along. The competition now heats up between different ribosome-equipped complexes - improve metabolism, increase independence, increase reproduction rate, improve reproductive fidelity, etc.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dtech on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:23AM (#20400127)
Changing it makes the organism non-viable, so a change there never enters a population. In contract DNA/RNA-mutations can be viable so happen all the time.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by gomijacogeo on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @05:54AM (#20400521)
There's a tiny bit of variation across the tree-of-life, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_code#Alternative_genet...

But the variation is in the one place you could possibly have it - by changing the interpretation of one or two of the three available STOP codons.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dvfjsdhgfv on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:31AM (#20399597)
> the emergence of an intelligent, technologically capable species (i.e. humans) is a relatively very recent occurrence in Earth's history.

Citaton needed.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by H8crilA on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:36AM (#20399622)
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dvfjsdhgfv on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @02:44AM (#20399667)
That's what we currently know based on what we discovered so far. You can't really rule out the existence of a relatively advanced civilization - although it might advance in a completely different way than ours - whose remains lie buried somewhere under the Mariana Trench for example.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by mellosouls on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @08:52AM (#20401463)
Yes, this has been investigated before - e.g.

https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.03748

https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/04/are-we-e...

But the evidence we have (as per prior comments) is that a human-level intelligence civilisation has arisen only once on Earth.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by throwaway2048 on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @03:47AM (#20399958)
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by andai on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:06AM (#20400060)
Sure, but we aren't trying to prove or disprove anything here, we're speculating for enjoyment.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by mikekchar on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @09:35AM (#20401780)
There are actually an infinite number of possible things that could have happened which we can't rule out. Let me preface what I'm going to say with I don't mind what anyone believes. If it makes you happy to believe one thing over another thing, then I think that's great.

With that out of the way, when we're having these kinds of discussions, it's not really productive to bring up an infinite number of possibilities that we can't rule out. Which one should we choose to support? Without some criteria, we will just talk about it forever -- which might be fun, but it's not productive.

This is where science comes in. I'm going to say something a bit controversial. Science doesn't really talk about absolute truth. We can't know what that is -- because there are an infinite number of possibilities that we can't rule out. Instead it talks about things that are "productive" (my term).

In a very hand-wavy way, science is about making observations and building a model that explains those observation. There are a couple of other important things. The model should also make predictions about thing we haven't observed that we can test. We try it and if it also fulfills those predictions, we thing it's a "productive" model (again, my term). Why is it productive? Because it allows us to reason about things and make conclusions that are likely to work out for us. However, we shouldn't mistake that for the absolute truth. There really is a possibility that things appear one way to us, but are very different in ways that we can't see. The key is that from the perspective of science that's fine -- as long as we can keep making predictions and they keep working out for use, we can use our model.

But what if we have 2 models that are both equivalent? For example, let's say they both explain the observations we see and they make predictions that work out. Which should we pick? By convention, we pick the simplest one. In truth, the simplest one might not be correct, but it's always easier to work with a simpler model... because it's simpler ;-)

So while there may truly be advanced civilizations out there -- we can't rule it out, there is no test we can currently do that would show that advanced civilizations exist. Our models without advanced civilizations (except our own) explain everything we can currently observe and everything we can currently test. So we choose the model with no other advanced civilizations.

You really don't have to believe that, but when discussing with others we have to set some rules. If we keep in mind other advanced civilizations, it's just as reasonable to keep in mind an infinite number of other possibilities -- some of which would be truly bizarre. In order to keep the conversation on track, we have to choose somehow and the scientific method is a good, proven way to narrow the discussion down to something that is productive. However, if you find people who want to talk about the kinds of things you want to talk about, I think there is nothing at all wrong with that. You should do what makes you happy.

I hope that makes things a bit clearer. I often meet people who make comments like you did and I think it's really mystifying to those people why science oriented people act this way.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dvfjsdhgfv on Thursday July 11, 2019 @01:57AM (#20409453)
Yes, it's very clear, thank you.

On the other hand, I believe the very core of science is to use our imagination and creativity to look for things that don't fit any models, that are not accounted for by any of them, for higher-order structures that might explain the current models better and so on.

For example, our civilization is more or less built on energy, with the electric current as its main medium, so we are totally dependent on external energy sources - and that's currently the main problem of our civilization. It's not impossible other civilizations might exist (in other space-time environments) that somewhat learned to achieve similar results we do (transportation, healing, distant communication) without using external energy sources. This would at least account for lack of artefacts we currently identify an advanced civilization with.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by kitd on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:17AM (#20400102)
I think the emphasis was, tongue-in-cheekily, on "intelligent".
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @12:54PM (#20403811)
> Also, for abiogenesis, given that we still can't reliably reproduce something like that, and that we have never seen new kinds of life spontaneously appearing on Earth, we do have some circumstantial evidence for the possibility that it is an incredibly unlikely event,

We have evidence that it is extremely unlikely under current conditions, but then we know that current conditions are unlike the conditions when life emerged on Earth (whatever it's origin), in part due to effects of life itself (such as the Oxygen Catastrophe).

Abiogenesis could be very likely under a combination of conditions that existed in the Hadean or Eoarchean Earth.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by titzer on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:47AM (#20400250)
> If life originated on some other planet and made it to Earth, why did only the DNA-based lifeform(s) make it here?

The problem is that we can't see through survivor bias. Maybe life has lots of possible configurations and only DNA-based life was highly successful on Earth. It's also possible that non-DNA-based life exists, we just haven't noticed it because it is too small, too slow, or too something-else that we missed it.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by freeflight on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @05:59AM (#20400541)
> Doesn't that just beg the question? If life originated on some other planet and made it to Earth, why did only the DNA-based lifeform(s) make it here?

Maybe Earth is just a big petri-dish for a very advanced alien species trying to reconstruct their own evolutionary history?

It's something I've thought about since I've been a kid (I've been a weird kid).

The time-scales make this kinda implausible, but there's still Clarke's third law, so who knows if properly advanced technology might even allow for artificial time dilation to facilitate such an experiment in a useful way.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by elliekelly on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @10:04AM (#20402032)
> Maybe Earth is just a big petri-dish for a very advanced alien species trying to reconstruct their own evolutionary history?

When I was in like 3rd or 4th grade we were each given a petri dish and told to swab different surfaces (bathroom door handle, water fountain spout, etc.) and then we would learn about bacteria while we watched ours grow. Well the teacher told us our petri dish would grow “it’s own little world” and I (fellow weird kid) had just seen Men In Black so I was fascinated by the idea of an entire world so tiny that it could exist on a cat’s collar. Of course I asked what would happen to our worlds after the experiment (I thought we’d get to keep them!) and when I found out it would go in the trash I refused to participate. (Weird and stubborn - my poor parents.)

And I had completely forgotten about that for 20+ years until today, when you’ve got me laughing at the thought that we could be the petri dish of some clueless 4th grader of an advanced alien species.

Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by minkzilla on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @10:28AM (#20402253)
I used to joke with my friends that earth was the equivalent of a baking soda volcano at a science fair. Some alien made us and we are completely uninspiring common.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by rectangletangle on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:55AM (#20399464)
>why did only the DNA-based lifeform(s) make it here?

Possibly genetic drift. The odds of life making a successful journey to earth seem very poor, so maybe it was a small population that only made it here once, and then began to speciate.