News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What If Life Did Not Originate on Earth? by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @01:22PM (#20404124)
> The notion of abiogenesis occurring only once on earth seems improbable considering complex organs like eyes have evolved independently several different times.

Evolution of eyes and abiogenesis aren't obviously similar enough for this analogy to be compelling without some narrative as to why what occurred with one should shape expectations of the other. The conditions in which life first emerged in either the Hadean or Eoarchean eons weren't around for much more of the history of the Earth; if the average expected frequency of abiogenesis under the conditions it actually emerged was once every quarter billion years or so, then—no matter which point in the possible range of time it first occurred—conditions wouldn't have been right for more than one to a very few instances, and if there were more than one, still one would likely be much more established by time available to spread alone, and then there were be massive environmental changes likely producing extinctions. Only one lineage surviving that bottleneck isn't surprising even if there were more before, and while we have evidence of early life it's far from complete either in coverage or ability to determine biochemistry and lineage.

It's really not necessary to invoke extraterrestrial origin to explain only one lineage on Earth (and it actually may make the problem worse: because then you have to explain why we haven't gotten alternate lineages from the same or other extraplanetary sources.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.