News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by KaiserPro on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:34AM (#19988790)
This is interesting

I would be very surprised if this could happen in central london.

1) the tubes are packed and the cabs locked.

2) they would have be murdered by the other commuters.

3) you can't get in or out of the station without being seen on CCTV

4) each train has CCTV coverage.

5) its almost impossible to get out of the tube via the tunnels, without being electrocuted or run over (All but the cut and cover tunnels are <1' bigger than the trains)

For point 2, even in legitimate cases where someone has keeled over, you get death stares. The only time its seen as acceptable is when someone falls inbetween the gap between the train and the platform edge.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by frereubu on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:26AM (#19989662)
From memory, the NYC subway has a lot more space in tunnels, making this much easier to do. The London underground has very tight tunnels and you'd probably be turned into mince if you tried this there (that is, if the commuters didn't get to you first).

Fun fact - the tunnels are so tight in the Underground that there's not much room for much airflow around the trains and the clay surrounding the tunnels has absorbed so much heat that it can't take in any more, which is why it gets so stifling in summer. People used to go down to the Central Line to cool off in summer! https://www.ianvisits.co.uk/blog/2017/06/10/cooling-the-tube...

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by masklinn on Thursday May 23, 2019 @06:49AM (#19990457)
> The London underground has very tight tunnels

That's an understatement. IIRC in some of the tube stock you have/had to duck to enter the carriage if you're more than 5'5.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by londons_explore on Thursday May 23, 2019 @06:57AM (#19990490)
Probably 25% of men now can't stand upright anywhere in the train. It's like playing sardines in a wardrobe!
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by attilakun on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:17AM (#19990615)
I'm 6'2'' and can stand upright in the middle of the carriage on Central line. The doors however have this annoying curvature so I do have to hunch when I'm standing close to them - which is quite often if you get on at a busy station.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by deadbunny on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:07AM (#19991338)
Preach brother, 6"4' here and if I can't get a seat (so always) or am able to stand in the middle of the carriage I'm doing my best hunchback impression.

That said I rarely use the tube these days as it's quicker to get an Uber/Taxi (by a good 15 mins) between Waterloo and my office.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by Ntrails on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:32AM (#19990689)
Yup, the roof curves but in the middle it's perfectly fine to stand straight at 6'4" and with some leeway. The time you get stuck by the door, well it's going to be a sad 20 minutes
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by masklinn on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:14AM (#19990599)
That matches my recollection of being just barely able to stand straight in the middle of the car, I can't imagine the neck/back/knees of 6'5 londoners. For starters I assume they wear a helmet with a face shield so they don't eat the lintel every time they step into the carriage.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by yaleman on Saturday May 25, 2019 @07:38PM (#20012191)
6'9" guy checking in, thankfully just a tourist to the town for a week - it was always leg day when I was on the tube.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by zeristor on Thursday May 23, 2019 @08:46AM (#19991158)
All the more horrific when people can’t get on a train, but get their clothes caught in the doors, get dragged along the platform and then slammed into the wall at the tunnel entrance.

That would leave about a thousand people traumatised. I hope they can retrofit platform doors into the stations soon.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by zeristor on Thursday May 23, 2019 @08:42AM (#19991122)
The Glasgow tube is even smaller, or should that be wee.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by tempguy9999 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @11:04AM (#19992401)
Interesting fact that maybe I'm the last person to discover, but...

I'd long wondered why underground trains came in 2 obviously different sizes, ie. the central line AKA the sardines express vs the district line, the carriages thereof being properly capacious.

Was talking to a TFL'er who said it annoyed him that all tube trains were collectively referred to by the public as 'underground trains' when there were actually sub-surface trains (the big ones) and proper underground trains (like the central and northern). I really hadn't known.

Edit: he could also tell the line a (proper) underground train was on by the metallic shriek it made. I asked him what caused that and he thought it was the wheel flanges rubbing on the sides of the rails during tighter turns.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by masklinn on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:36PM (#19993927)
> I'd long wondered why underground trains came in 2 obviously different sizes, ie. the central line AKA the sardines express vs the district line, the carriages thereof being properly capacious.

Because the original lines were opened in the mid (sub-surface) to late (deep) 19th century. The sub-surface lines were built cut-and-cover and thus easy to make roomy with the technology of the times, digging from up and covering was well within easy means, however the deep lines were built using pre-TBM tunnelling shields, limiting their diameter due to effort and sheer technology. The deepest station in the underground was opened in 1907, remains one of the deepest stations in the world, and pretty much all the deeper ones opened after WWII.

Later deep lines (Victoria and Jubilee) I'm guessing were kept at the same diameter for convenience (of sharing structure, infrastructure and rolling stock), and possibly existing sections being "moved" from one line to an other.

> Was talking to a TFL'er who said it annoyed him that all tube trains were collectively referred to by the public as 'underground trains' when there were actually sub-surface trains (the big ones) and proper underground trains (like the central and northern). I really hadn't known.

Technically they're all underground trains, as in trains which are part of the London Underground. The sardine express ones are "deep-level" or "deep-tube" (they used to be the actual tube lines but the term has expanded to basically be the same thing as the Underground).

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by dx034 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:59AM (#19988899)
Regarding 5, emergency brakes in London won't stop the train in the tunnel. They just send a signal to the driver to wait at the next station and inform staff at that station and/or emergency services.

Pulling the emergency brake therefore isn't necessarily a bad idea. If someone has fallen ill on the train (esp. common in summer), it's the best way to ensure that help will be available as soon as possible.

As you said, evacuating trains in the tunnel is dangerous so it's only done if trains physically can't move to the station (e.g. another train blocks the tracks). And even then, evacuation is only done after electricity has been switched off via the end of the train.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by zuminator on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:16AM (#19990611)
Maybe you're thinking about the emergency "brake" cord ? That works the same way in NY subways. They alert the driver and conductor to a possible problem in a train car so that they can get police assistance and/or bring the train to a controlled stop.

The emergency brake that is discussed here is different. It's inside the operator's locked cab, and releases air brakes that stop the train with maximal acceleration to the extent that the wheels can be damaged by grinding against the rails. They are only used in a last resort but they have to be available and functional in the event that the human operator finds itself unable to make a controlled stop. The same subsystem activates when the train incorrectly passes a red signal or hits a large obstruction in the tracks.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by mhb on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:21AM (#19991484)
Thanks. If only there had been a way to divine that from TFA.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by zuminator on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:33AM (#19991596)
I can only imagine transit authorities are being vague on purpose so as not to popularize this particular vector of attack.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by astura on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:18PM (#19993719)
TFA explains the break is located an area that should only be accessible to MTA personnel

>He climbs aboard the rear of the train as it departs a station, unlocks the safety chains, somehow gets into the rear cab, and triggers the emergency brakes.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by mprev on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:49AM (#19989165)
As for pulling the emergency brake for someone who is unwell, there are frequent announcements on the tube telling you not to do that. The advice from TfL is to wait until the next station and help the person get off.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by mcv on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:44AM (#19989450)
I find it weird that there's so much confusion about the way emergency brakes work and when to use them on the London Underground. If people on HN can't agree on it, how can the general public? Confusion about this sort of thing can be dangerous.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by JaimeThompson on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:36AM (#19990709)
That is because people on HN are the general public in a lot of ways. Just because most are specialized knowledge workers doesn't mean they are inherently more intelligent in other areas of life.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by darkpuma on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:18AM (#19991444)
Intelligence isn't the right word. There are some sort of jobs that do select for high intelligence. Any sort of work that requires abstract reasoning and novel problem solving is going to be inaccessible to people with lower intelligence.

Rather, it should be said that tech workers are not inherently more knowledgeable in matters unrelating to tech than the general public. In this case, knowledge of train function and etiquette is in question, not intelligence.

(Note also that intelligence does not confer knowledge (although it makes knowledge easier to acquire) and that it's quite easy to find examples of people with modest intelligence but exceptional knowledge. Furthermore the work/intelligence selection process only really applies in one direction; there are a lot of high intelligence people who choose jobs they find undemanding because they have different priorities or have had different opportunities in life.)

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by Angostura on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:24AM (#19989650)
Part part of the issue is that it changed about 20 years ago. The emergency brakes used to actually apply the brake, rather than signal the driver. But even when I was a lad, there were signs on the trains saying 'if someone is unwell, don't apply the brake until the station - help will get to them faster'.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by userbinator on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:54AM (#19990815)
Makes a lot of sense and is very logical --- that person still has to get off the train somehow, and better at a station which the train is already going to, than to stop and wait somewhere between stations for help to arrive. Perhaps the reason people pull the brake is more of a panic reaction.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by dx034 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:35AM (#19989407)
That's true if someone is still able to walk. For people who need medical assistance you need to alert the driver to ensure the train won't continue.

I think they started these announcements because people considered someone feeling dizzy a medical emergency.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by mprev on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:01AM (#19989824)
I can see that it could be wise to pull the emergency handle at the station to prevent the train moving if, say, someone were having a heart attack and couldn't easily be moved to the platform.

But pulling it between stations would only prolong the time it took for the person to get help.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by dx034 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @08:52AM (#19991205)
It won't as there are no emergency brakes on Tubes, they're just called emergency brake. The train continues to the station and will then remain there.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by mprev on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:02AM (#19991291)
Regardless of whether the emergency handle is connected to a physical brake or if it sounds a alarm, there is an emergency brake. If the driver removes their hand from the dead man's switch, the emergency brake engages. But that's a side-road to this discussion.

Unless you can point to official advice from TfL that states otherwise, I'm just gonna come out and say that I think it's best to stick to the advice TfL give at stations which is not to pull the emergency handle if someone is unwell. Whatever the precise action that results from pulling the handle (whether that's sounding an alarm, engaging a brake, or whatever), I don't see what it would achieve between stations and especially when TfL say not to do it.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by bobthepanda on Thursday May 23, 2019 @10:52AM (#19992285)
There are very limited scenarios where you want to pull the brake; e.g. the door has closes on a passenger and is dragging them along.

But of course these are very limited and you almost never actually want to do that.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by rightbyte on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:06AM (#19989856)
In the Stockholm metro there is a intercom to the driver for talking from the wagons. Is there one in London?
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by lmm on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:26AM (#19991529)
Yes, but the audio quality is not very good. There was a recent incident that was exacerbated by a driver mishearing "there's a fire" as "there's a fight".
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by londons_explore on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:02AM (#19990532)
The process to reset the brake can easily take 30 minutes or more, delaying 20,000 people or more (all people on the train, plus the trains behind, and the trains which can't start their journey because they're stuck in the wrong place, and the trains which have to be cancelled because it's now the end of the drivers shift).

The real solution is to practice till the time to reset an emergency brake is 1 minute or less. It should be simple - someone in a control room checks all CCTV cameras to see the situation, and presses a button to restart the train.

TFL's cameras mostly aren't digital and can't be watched remotely, so they're miles off ever being able to do this.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by baud147258 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:59AM (#19989529)
Last time I was in a tube when the emergency brake was pulled (not in NY or London), it was by a mom who had left her kid behind at the last station. All it did was stop the tube between two station, the driver had to go check what happened then go back and restart the tube.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by djmobley on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:17AM (#19989318)
At least on certain lines, if you lean on the doors, emergency brakes will be applied, regardless of whether the train is in a tunnel or not.

This often happens when a train is particularly crowded and people are crammed in near the doors.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by pledg on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:39AM (#19989425)
This slows the train down it doesn’t stop it.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by djmobley on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:32AM (#19990691)
Happens quite often on the Jubilee line, and whether it’s the brakes being applied or motors cutting out, the upshot is the train comes to a very abrupt stop, seemingly with no action from the driver.

This is usually followed by a frustrated driver coming over the PA system to implore people to stop leaning on the doors, because they are unable to move the train until they do so.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by dx034 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:31AM (#19989389)
In deep underground lines? I never experienced that, and in rush hour central line or Northern line it's basically impossible not to lean on the door.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by nothrabannosir on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:58AM (#19989803)
I take the central line regularly and this happens once a week. Big yank, followed by a "Please don't lean on the doors, it will slow down the train", it's par for the course.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by pledg on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:43AM (#19989448)
The old district line stock used to do it, but they’ve all been replaced now. It didn’t stop the train it would limit the maximum speed. The driver would keep announcing to stop leaning but in heavy traffic that wasn’t always easy.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by Angostura on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:25AM (#19989653)
I think the Central Line still does it.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by tfolbrecht on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:04AM (#19989839)
Are you sure there aren't emergency brakes in the cab that would stop the train on the tracks?
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by dx034 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @08:52AM (#19991210)
I'm sure there are but those would be hard to misuse by passengers.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by krisoft on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:59AM (#19988897)
> For point 2, even in legitimate cases where someone has keeled over, you get death stares.

And with good reason, because that is not a legitimate case. It is displayed on signs on many routes that the emergency services can best help/reach you on the platforms. Pulling the emergency brakes in the tunnel is actually counter productive if someone keels over.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by dx034 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:01AM (#19988909)
I wrote it in the other comments, but emergency brakes on London tubes are not brakes, they just alert the driver. It therefore is a legitimate way to inform the driver of any unusual activity that warrants a longer stop at the next station.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by morpheuskafka on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:00AM (#19988904)
I've always heard never to use the emergency brakes for a medical emergency because then you'd just stop the train in the middle of a tunnel and greatly delay responses.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by SilasX on Thursday May 23, 2019 @10:08AM (#19991920)
>they would have be murdered by the other commuters

Oh, I'm sure 99% of the NYC-area ridership is planning exactly this.

My immediate reaction to this story was, "Prankster, go into hiding now if you want to survive the week."

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by faissaloo on Thursday May 23, 2019 @06:29AM (#19990339)
>the tubes are packed and the cabs locked.

Not during the middle of the day, which would have a knock on effect

>each train has CCTV coverage.

You could always keep a change of clothes

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by din-9 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:48AM (#19989160)
Is point 5 true for the newest tunnels like the Jubilee Line Extension? I think the DLR has an emergency walkway in the tunnels to Bank. I am expecting Crossrail will too.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by luckylion on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:29AM (#19989054)
> 4) each train has CCTV coverage.

With my tinfoil hat adjusted: maybe this is a plan to push for CCTV acceptance in NYC. Annoy commuters enough, present surveillance as a solution, get agreement.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by insulanian on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:47AM (#19989156)
There's a conspiracy theory guy (David Ike) who claims there's always the same pattern here: problem - reaction - solution. You create a problem to provoke people reaction and then offer them a solution, which ultimately results in taking more and more control over them.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by Brakenshire on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:24AM (#19989347)
He also thinks the British royal family are lizards.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by Gibbon1 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:45AM (#19989738)
Well obviously. There hasn't been a bastard child out of that family line in five generations.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by dr_dshiv on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:31AM (#19989388)
And I suppose you have empirical evidence that proves they are not lizards? (Adjusts hat)
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by NeedMoreTea on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:35AM (#19989406)
Far more than there is for Icke self-identifying as the son of god. Apparently he learnt his status as new messiah in a dream or something.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by whenchamenia on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:30PM (#19996202)
Still, neither side is posting any proof of their lizard or not-lizard assertions.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by acct1771 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @11:42AM (#19992747)
RIP Di
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by RaceWon on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:45PM (#19995721)
> 2) they would have be murdered by the other commuters

In the spirt of HN's policy of not being snarky I will attempt to temper my reply. As a native NYer: I find it Laughable that a Nation which, in effect, gave up its Sovereign Government to the EU and, outlawed Free Speech by banning "hate speech" (which is in fact--Anything that your Overlords say it is), would attemp to draw the line at someone pulling the EBrake on a train.

Sorry, but that is as Non-Snarky as I could make my reply.

Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi... by RugnirViking on Thursday May 23, 2019 @06:08PM (#19996515)
Was this bizzare unprovoked statement really necessary? I simply don't see how 'free speech', which is a concept almost entirely unique to the USA, is related to being annoyed that your hypothetical commute was interrupted.

If you dispute the idea, I suggest you try pulling the emergency brake as a joke and see how fellow commuters treat you.