Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi...
by mcv on Thursday May 23, 2019 @03:44AM
(#19989450)
I find it weird that there's so much confusion about the way emergency brakes work and when to use them on the London Underground. If people on HN can't agree on it, how can the general public? Confusion about this sort of thing can be dangerous.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi...
by JaimeThompson on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:36AM
(#19990709)
That is because people on HN are the general public in a lot of ways. Just because most are specialized knowledge workers doesn't mean they are inherently more intelligent in other areas of life.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi...
by darkpuma on Thursday May 23, 2019 @09:18AM
(#19991444)
Intelligence isn't the right word. There are some sort of jobs that do select for high intelligence. Any sort of work that requires abstract reasoning and novel problem solving is going to be inaccessible to people with lower intelligence.
Rather, it should be said that tech workers are not inherently more knowledgeable in matters unrelating to tech than the general public. In this case, knowledge of train function and etiquette is in question, not intelligence.
(Note also that intelligence does not confer knowledge (although it makes knowledge easier to acquire) and that it's quite easy to find examples of people with modest intelligence but exceptional knowledge. Furthermore the work/intelligence selection process only really applies in one direction; there are a lot of high intelligence people who choose jobs they find undemanding because they have different priorities or have had different opportunities in life.)
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi...
by Angostura on Thursday May 23, 2019 @04:24AM
(#19989650)
Part part of the issue is that it changed about 20 years ago. The emergency brakes used to actually apply the brake, rather than signal the driver. But even when I was a lad, there were signs on the trains saying 'if someone is unwell, don't apply the brake until the station - help will get to them faster'.
Re:Someone in New York is pulling emergency brakes, destroyi...
by userbinator on Thursday May 23, 2019 @07:54AM
(#19990815)
Makes a lot of sense and is very logical --- that person still has to get off the train somehow, and better at a station which the train is already going to, than to stop and wait somewhere between stations for help to arrive. Perhaps the reason people pull the brake is more of a panic reaction.